Measuring urban sprawl is a controversial topic among scholars who investigate the urban landscape. This study attempts to measure sprawl from a landscape perspective. The measures and indices used are derived from various research disciplines, such as urban research, ecological research, and fractal geometry. The examination was based on an urban land-use survey performed in seventy-eight urban settlements in Israel over the course of fifteen years. Measures of sprawl were calculated at each settlement and were then weighted into one integrated sprawl index through factor analysis, thus enabling a description of sprawl rates and their dynamics over a time period of approximately two decades. The results reveal that urban sprawl is a multidimensional phenomenon that is best quantified by various measures.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlperovichG, 1995, “The effectiveness of spine urban density functions: An empirical investigation”Urban Studies321537–1548
2.
BattyMKimK S, 1992, “Form follows function: Reformulating urban population density functions”Urban Studies291043–1070
3.
BattyMLongleyP, 1994Fractal Cities: A Geometry of Form and Function (Academic Press, London)
4.
BattyMXieYZhanliS, 1999, “The dynamics of urban sprawl”, WP 15, Centre for Advanced Spatial Analysis, University College London, http://www.casa.ucl.ac.uk/sprawl.pdf
5.
BelserK, 1960, “Urban dispersal in perspective”, in The Nature and Control of Urban Dispersal Ed. EngelbertE A, California Chapter of the American Institute of Planners, Berkeley, CA, pp1–18
6.
BenguiguiL, 1995, “A fractal analysis of the public transportation system of Paris”Environment and Planning A271147–1161
7.
BenguiguiLMarinovMCzamznskiD, 1998City Growth as a Leap-frogging Process: An Application to the Tel-Aviv MetropolisCenter for Urban and Regional Studies, Technion—Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa
BurchellR WShadN AListokinDPhillipsHDownsASeskinSDavisJMooreTHeltonDGallM, 1998, “The cost of sprawl-revisited”, report 39, Transit Cooperative Research Program (TCRP) Transportation Research Board, National Research Council, Washington, DC, pp 83–125
10.
BurtonE, 1996, “The potential of the compact city for promoting social equity”, in The Compact City—A Sustainable Urban Form Eds JenksMBurtonEWilliamsK (Spon, London) pp 19–29
11.
BurtonE, 2000, “The compact city: Just or just compact? A preliminary analysis”Urban Studies371969–2001
12.
CBS, 1997Localities in Israel, Spatial Data publication number 1103, Central Bureau of Statistics, Jerusalem (in Hebrew)
13.
CBS, 2004, “Localities and population by municipal status and district”, in Statistical Annual of Israel Number 55, Central Bureau of Statistics, Jerusalem (in Hebrew)
14.
ChinN, 2002, “Unearthing the roots of urban sprawl: a critical analysis of form, function and methodology”, WP 47, Centre for Advanced Spatial Analysis, University College London, www.casa.ucl.ac.uk
15.
ChurchmanA, 1999, “Disentangling the concept of density”Journal of Planning Literature13389–411
16.
DownsA, 1998, “How America's cities are growing: The big picture”Brookings Review168–12
17.
EwingR, 1994, “Characteristics, causes, and effects of sprawl: A literature review”Environmental and Urban Issues211–15
18.
EwingR, 1997, “Is Los Angeles-style sprawl desirable?”Journal of the American Planning Association63107–126
19.
EwingRPendallRChenD, 2002, “Measuring sprawl and its impact”, volume 1, technical report, Smart Growth America, Washington, DC, http://www.smartgrowthamerica.org
20.
FrenkelA, 2004a, “Land-use patterns in the classification of cities: The Israeli case”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design31711–730
21.
FrenkelA, 2004b, “A land consumption model: Its application to Israel's development”Journal of the American Association70453–470
22.
FultonW, 1996The New Urbanism (Lincoln Institute of Land Policy, Cambridge, MA)
23.
GalsterGHansonRRatcliffeM RWolmanHColemanSFreihageJ, 2001, “Wrestling sprawl to the ground: Defining and measuring an elusive conceptHousing Policy Debate12681–717
24.
GansH J, 1967The Levittowners: Ways of Life and Politics in a New Suburban Community (Pantheon Books, New York)
25.
GarreauJ, 1991Edge City: Life on the New Frontier (Doubleday, New York)
26.
GibbsJ P, 1961, “A method for comparing the spatial shapes of urban units”, in Urban Research Methods Ed. GibbsJ P (D Van Nostrand, Princeton, NJ) pp 99–106
27.
GonenA, 1995, “Recent middle-class spread to suburbia”, in Between City and Suburb: Urban Residential Patterns and Processes in Israel Ed. GonenA (Avebury, Aldershot, Hants) pp 114–138
28.
GonenA, 1996, “Changing urban residential structure in Israel”, in The Mosaic of Israeli Geography Eds GradusYLipshitzG, The Negev Center for Regional Development (Ben-Gurion University of the Negev Press, Beer Sheva) pp 55–62
29.
GordonPRichardsonH W, 1997, “Are compact cities a desirable planning goal?”Journal of the American Planning Association6395–106
30.
GustafsonE J, 1998, “Quantifying landscape spatial pattern: What is the state of the art?”Ecosystems1143–156
HartshornT AMullerP O, 1992, “The suburban downtown and urban economic development today”, in Sources of Metropolitan Growth Eds MillsE SMcDonaldJ F, Center for Urban Policy Research, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ, pp 147–158
33.
HarveyR OClarkW A V, 1965, “The nature and economics of urban sprawl”Land Economics411–9
HeroldMMenzG, 2001, “Landscape metric signatures (LMS) to improve urban land use information derived from remotely sensed data”, in A Decade of Trans-European Remote Sensing Cooperation Ed. BuchroithnerM F (A A Balkema, Rotterdam) pp 251–256
36.
IngramG K, 1998, “Patterns of metropolitan development: What have we learned?Urban Studies351019–1035
37.
JacksonK T, 1985Crabgrass Frontier: The Suburbanization of the United States (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
38.
JenksMBurtonEWilliamsK, 1996The Compact City—A Sustainable Urban Form (Spon, London)
39.
JohnsonM P, 2001, “Environmental impacts of urban sprawl: A survey of the literature and proposed research agenda”Environment and Planning A33717–735
40.
KimJ OMuellerC W, 1978, “Introduction to factor analysis: What it is and how to do it”, Paper 13 Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences Series (Sage, London)
41.
KlaassenL HMolleW T NPaelinckJ H P, 1981The Dynamics of Urban Development (Gower, Aldershot, Hants)
42.
McGarigalKMarksB, 1995FRAGSTATS: Spatial Pattern Analysis Program for Quantifying Landscape Structure TR PNW-GTR-351, USDA Forest Service, Washington, DC
43.
MalpezziS, 1999, “Estimates of the measurements and determinants of urban sprawl in US metropolitan areas”, Wisconsin -Madison CULER WP 99–06, Center for Urban Land Economics Research, University of Wisconsin, Madison
44.
MalpezziSWen KaiG, 2001Measuring “Sprawl”: Alternative Measures of Urban Form in U.S. Metropolitan AreasCenter for Urban Land Economics Research, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI
45.
MaretI, 2002“Understanding the diversity of sprawl and the need for targeted policies”, paper presented at the 5th Congress on Environment and Planning, Oxford, 23–27 September, available from 922 North Lopez Street, New Orleans
46.
MillsE SHamiltonB W, 1989, “Trends in sizes and structure of urban areas”, in Urban Economics4th edition, Eds MillsE SHamiltonB W (Scott, Foresman and Company, Glenview, IL) pp 68–83
PeiserR B, 1989, “Density and urban sprawl”Land Economics65193–203
49.
PendallR, 1999, “Do land-use controls cause sprawl?”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design26555–571
50.
RazinERosentraubM, 2000, “Are fragmentation and sprawl interlinked? North American Evidence”Urban Affairs Review35821–836
51.
Real Estate Research Corporation, 1974, “The costs of sprawl: detailed cost analysis” (Government Printing Office, Washington, DC)
52.
SchiffmanI, 1999, “The limits of ideology: The first for open space in Israel”, in Handbook of Global Environment Policy and Administration Eds SodenD LSteelB S (Marcel Decker, New York) pp 559–578
53.
ShoshanyMGoldshlegerN, 2002, “Land-use and population density in Israel—1950 to 1990: Analysis of regional and local trends”Land Use Policy19123–133
54.
TorrensP MAlbertiM, 2000, “Measuring sprawl”, WP 27, Centre for Advanced Spatial Analysis, University College London, http://www.casa.ucl.ac.uk
55.
TurnerM G, 1989, “Landscape ecology: The effect of pattern on process”Annual Review of Ecological Systems20171–197
56.
Van Den BergLDrewettRKlaassenL HRossiAVijverbergC H T, 1982, “Stages of urban development”, in A Study of Growth and DeclineVolume 1, Eds Van Den BergLDrewettRKlaassenL HRossiAVijverbergC H T (Pergamon Press, New York) pp 24–45
57.
WeitzJ, 2000, “State programs that bust sprawl and measures that can be used in diagnosing sprawl”, paper presented at the 2000 APA National Planning Conference, http://www.asu.edu/caed/proceedings00/WEITZ/weitz.htm
58.
WolmanHGalsterGHansonRRatcliffeMFurdellKSarzynskiA, 2004, “The fundamental challenge in measuring sprawl: Which land should be considered?”The Professional Geographer5794–105
