The Prospects and Problems of Integrating Sketch Maps with Geographic Information Systems to Understand Environmental Perception: A Case Study of Mapping Youth Fear in Los Angeles Gang Neighborhoods
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online April, 2014
The Prospects and Problems of Integrating Sketch Maps with Geographic Information Systems to Understand Environmental Perception: A Case Study of Mapping Youth Fear in Los Angeles Gang Neighborhoods
How people feel about places matters, especially in their neighborhood. It matters for their health, the health of their children, and their social cohesion and use of local resources. A growing body of research in public health, planning, psychology, and sociology bears out this point. Recently, a new methodological tack has been taken to find out how people feel about places. The sketch map, a once popular tool of behavioral geographers and environmental psychologists to understand how people perceive the structural aspects of places, is now being used in concert with geographic information systems (GIS) to capture and spatially analyze the emotional side of urban environmental perception. This confluence is generating exciting prospects for what we can learn about the characteristics of the urban environment that elicit emotion. However, due to the uncritical way this approach has been employed to date, excitement about the prospects must be tempered by the acknowledgement of its potential problems. In this paper we review the extant research on integrating sketch maps with GIS and then employ a case study of mapping youth fear in Los Angeles gang neighborhoods to demonstrate these prospects and the problems, particularly in the areas of (1) representation of environmental perception in GIS and (2) spatial analysis of these data.
AcredoloL PPickH LOlsenM, 1975, “Environmental differentiation and familiarity as determinants of children's memory for spatial location”Developmental Psychology11495–501
2.
AnselinL, 1995, “Local indicators of spatial autocorrelation—LISA”Geographical Analysis2793–115
3.
AppleyardD, 1970, “Styles and methods of structuring a city”Environment and Behavior2100–117
4.
BladesM, 1990, “The reliability of data collected from sketch maps”Journal of Environmental Psychology10327–339
5.
CampbellEHenlyJ RElliottD SIrwinK, 2009, “Subjective constructions of neighborhood boundaries: Lessons from a qualitative study of four neighborhoods”Journal of Urban Affairs31461–490
6.
CeccatoV ASnickarsF, 2000, “Adapting GIS technology to the needs of local planning”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design27923–937
7.
CouclelisC, 2003, “The certainty of uncertainty: GIS and the limits of geographic knowledge”Transactions in GIS7165–175
8.
CoultonC JKorbinKChanTSuM, 2001, “Mapping residents' perceptions of neighborhood boundaries: A methodological note”American Journal of Community Psychology29371–383
9.
CraigW JHarrisT MWeinerD, 2002Community Participation and Geographic Information Systems (Taylor and Francis, London)
10.
CurtisJ W, 2012, “Integrating GIS with sketch maps to explore fear of crime in the urban environment: A review of the past and prospects for the future”Cartography and Geographic Information Science Journal39175–186
11.
CurtisALeitnerM, 2005Geographical Information Systems and Public Health: Eliminating Perinatal Disparity (IGI Press, Hershey, PA)
12.
CurtisADuval-DiopDNovakJ, 2010, “Identifying spatial patterns of recovery and abandonment in the post-Katrina Holy Cross neighborhood of New Orleans”Cartography and Geographic Information Science3745–56
13.
DennisS, 2006, “Prospects for GIS at the intersection of youth development and participatory planning”Environment and Planning A382039–2054
14.
DoranBLeesB, 2005, “Investigating the spatiotemporal links between disorder, crime, and the fear of crime”The Professional Geographer571–12
15.
DownsRSteaD, 1973Image and Environment (AVC, Chicago, IL)
16.
ElwoodS, 2006, “Critical issues in participatory GIS: Deconstructions, reconstructions, and new research directions”Transactions in GIS10693–708
17.
ElwoodSCopeM, 2009Qualitative GIS: A Mixed Methods Approach (Sage, London)
EvansG WMarreroD GButlerP A, 1981, “Environmental learning and cognitive mapping”Environment and Behavior1383–104
20.
GolledgeR, 1977, “Environmental cues, cognitive mapping, spatial behaviour”, in Behaviour–Environment Research Methods Eds BurkeD, (Institute for Environmental Studies, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI) pp 35–46
21.
GomezJ EJohnsonB ASelvaMSallisJ F, 2004, “Violent crime and outdoor physical activity among inner-city youth”Preventive Medicine39876–881
22.
GoodchildB, 1974, “Class differences in environmental perception: An exploratory study”Urban Studies11157–169
23.
GouldPWhiteR, 1974Mental Maps (Penguin, New York)
24.
HaneyW GKnowlesE S, 1978, “Perception of neighbourhoods by city and suburban residents”Human Ecology6201–214
25.
HarriesK, 2006, “Extreme spatial variation in crime density in Baltimore County, MD”Geoforum37404–416
26.
HawthorneTKrygierJKwanM-P, 2008, “Mapping ambivalence: Exploring the geographies of community change and rails-to-trails development using photo-based Q methods and PPGIS”Geoforum391058–1078
27.
JungJ-K, 2009, “Computer-aided qualitative GIS: A software-level integration of qualitative research and GIS” in Qualitative GIS: A Mixed Methods Approach Eds ElwoodSCopeM, (Sage, London)
28.
JungJ-KElwoodS, 2010“Extending the qualitative capabilities of GIS: Computer-aided qualitative GIS”Transactions in GIS1463–87
29.
KaplanRKaplanS, 1989The Experience of Nature: A Psychological Perspective (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
30.
KaranP PBladenW ASinghG, 1980, “Slum dwellers' and squatters' images of the city”Environment and Behavior1281–100
31.
KimY OPennA, 2004, “Linking the spatial syntax of cognitive maps to the spatial syntax of the environment”Environment and Behavior36483–504
32.
KitchinR M, 1994, “Cognitive maps: What are they and why study them?”Journal of Environmental Psychology141–19
33.
KitchinR M, 1996a, “Methodological convergence in cognitive mapping research: Investigating configurational knowledge”Journal of Environmental Psychology16163–185
34.
KitchinR M, 1996b, “Exploring approaches to computer cartography and spatial analysis in cognitive mapping research: CMAP and MiniGASP prototype packages”The Cartographic Journal3351–55
35.
KitchinR MFotheringhamA S, 1997, “Aggregation issues in cognitive mapping”The Professional Geographer49269–280
36.
KniggeLCopeM, 2006, “Grounded visualization: Integrating the analysis of qualitative and quantitative data through grounded theory and visualization”Environment and Planning A382021–2037
37.
KohmS A, 2009, “Spatial dimensions of fear in a high-crime community: Fear of crime or fear of disorder”Canadian Journal of Criminology and Criminal Justice511–30
38.
KwanM-P, 2002, “Feminist visualization: Re-envisionsing GIS as a method in feminist geographic research”Annals of the Association of American Geographers92645–661
39.
KwanM-PDingG, 2008, “Geo-narrative: Extending geographic information systems for narrative analysis in qualitative and mixed-method research”The Professional Geographer60443–465
40.
LaddF C, 1970, “Black youths view their environment–neighbourhood maps”Environment and Behavior274–99
41.
LaneG WSuiD Z, 2010, “Geographies of identity theft in the US: Understanding spatial and demographic patters, 2002–2006”GeoJournal7543–55
42.
LeeT, 1968, “Urban neighbourhood as socio-spatial schema”Human Relations21241–267
43.
LopezNLukinbealC, 2010, “Comparing police and residents' perceptions of crime in a Phoenix neighborhood using mental maps in GIS”Yearbook of the Association of Pacific Coast Geographers7233–55
44.
Loukaitou-SiderisA, 2006, “Is it safe to walk? Neighborhood safety and security considerations and their effects on walking”Journal of Planning Literature20219–232
45.
LynchK, 1960The Image of the City (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
46.
MacEachrenA M, 1992, “Visualizing uncertain information”Cartographic Perspectives1310–19
47.
MasonM JMennisJCoatsworthJ DValenteTLawrenceFPateP, 2009, “The relationship of place to substance use and perceptions of risk and safety in urban adolescents”Journal of Environmental Psychology29485–492
48.
MateiSBall-RokeachS JQiuJ L, 2001, “Fear and misperception of Los Angeles urban space: A spatial-statistical study of communication-shaped mental maps”Communication Research28429–463
49.
MathewsS ADetwilerJ EBurtonL M, 2005, “Geo-ethnography: Coupling geographic information analysis techniques with ethnographic methods in urban research”Cartographica4075–90
50.
MatthewsM H, 1980, “The mental maps of children”Geography65169–179
51.
MatthewsM H, 1987, “Gender, home range, and environmental cognition”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series1243–56
52.
MaurerRBaxterJ C, 1972, “Images of the neighborhood and city among Black-, Anglo-, and Mexican-American children”Environment and Behavior4351–388
53.
MennisJMasonM J, 2011, “People, places, and adolescent substance abuse: Integrating activity space and social network data for analyzing health behavior”Annals of the Association of American Geographers101272–291
54.
PavlovskayaM, 2002, “Mapping urban change and changing GIS: Other views of economic restructuring”Gender, Place and Culture9281–289
55.
PavlovskayaM, 2004, “Other transitions: Multiple economies of Moscow households in the 1990s”Annals of the Association of American Geographers94329–351
56.
PlattJ, 2005, “Capturing and integrating perception of change in neighbourhood GIS”, Master of City Planning Thesis, University of Manitoba
57.
PocockD C D, 1976, “Some characteristics of mental maps: An empirical study”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series1493–512
58.
RatcliffeJ H, 2010, “Crime mapping: Spatial and temporal challenges”, in Handbook of Quantitative Criminology Eds PiqueroRWeisbardD, (Springer: New York) pp 5–24
59.
RatcliffeJ HMcCullaghM J, 2001, “Chasing ghosts? Police perception of high crime areas”The British Journal of Criminology41330–341
60.
RomanC GChalfinA, 2008, “Fear of walking outdoors: A multilevel ecologic analysis of crime and disorder”American Journal of Preventive Medicine34306–312
61.
RossC E, 1993, “Fear of victimization and health”Journal of Quantitative Criminology9159–175
62.
SiegelA WSchadlerM, 1977, “Young children's cognitive maps of their classroom”Child Development48388–394
63.
SpencerCDixonJ, 1983, “Mapping the development of feelings about the city', a longitudinal study of new residents' affective maps”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series8373–383
StaffordMChandolaTMarmotM, 2007, “Association between fear of crime and mental health and physical functioning”American Journal of Public Health972076–2081
66.
TalenE, 1999, “Constructing neighborhoods from the bottom up: The case for resident-generated GIS”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design26533–554
67.
VeitchJSalmonJBallK, 2008, “Children's active free play in local neighborhoods: A behavioral mapping study”Health Education Research23870–879
68.
WhiteMKaslS VZahnerG E PWillJ C, 1987, “Perceived crime in the neighborhood and mental health of women and children”Environment Behavior19588–613
69.
WoodDBeckR, 1989, “Janine Eber maps London: Individual dimensions of cognitive imagery”Journal of Environmental Psychology91–26
70.
WridtP, 2010, “A qualitative GIS approach to mapping urban neighborhoods with children to promote physical activity and child-friendly community planning”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design37129–147
71.
YaoXJiangB, 2005, “Visualization of qualitative locations in Geographic Information Systems”Cartography and Geographic Information Science32219–229
