The Governance of British Public-Housing Investment in the Late-1970s: Central Encouragement of Comparative Local Diversity

Abstract

The thesis of this paper is that in the latter 1970s central government encouraged diversity in housing investment by English and Welsh local authorities. This was so particularly in Wales. This diversity was encouraged on the basis of local performance, rather than on the basis of measured local needs. Was this diversity encouraged to further local ‘autonomy’, or simply to achieve expenditure targets when local authorities were underspending in the central government's view? This thesis raises questions as to the role of consensus between central departments and local authorities, and about the constitutional location of public-housing provision in Britain.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ADC, 1980, Association of District Councils circular 1980/72 (Association of District Councils, London)

Bennett

R J

, 1982, “The financial health of local authorities in England and Wales: Resource and expenditure position 1974/1975–1980/1981” Environment and Planning A 14 997–1022

Boaden

, 1971 Urban Policy-making (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)

Bozeman

, 1976, “An investigation of some hypotheses related to programme funding” Policy and Politics 4 73–90

Bramley

Leather

Murie

, 1980, “Housing strategies and investment programmes” WP-7, School of Advanced Urban Studies, University of Bristol, Bristol BS8 1TH, England

Burgess

Travers

, 1980 Ten Billion Pounds (Grant McIntyre, London)

Butler

Oldman

Greve

, 1983 Sheltered Housing for the Elderly (George Allen and Unwin, Hemel Hempstead, Herts)

•CDC, 1976a, letter from the WO of 27 February; reference H208/75

•CDC, 1976b, letter from the WO of 11 August

10.

•CDC, 1976c, letter from the WO of 24 August

11.

•CDC, 1976d, letter from the DoE of 22 December

12.

•CDC, 1976e, letter from the WO of 23 December; reference Hl/35/4

13.

•CDC, 1977a, letter from the WO of 25 March; reference H261/75

14.

•CDC, 1977b, letter from the WO of 24 May; reference H35/55/8

15.

•CDC, 1977c, letter from the WO of 26 August; reference H43/1/6

16.

•CDC, 1977d, letter from the WO of 16 December; reference H43/1/10

17.

•CDC, 1978a, letter from the WO of 17 November

18.

•CDC, 1978b, letter from the WO of 29 November

19.

•CDC, 1979, letter from the WO of 23 July

20.

•CDC, 1980a, letter from the WO of 14 March; reference HS1/93/lHsg/2/80

21.

•CDC, 1980b, letter from the WO of 18 June; reference H83/35/1Hsg

22.

•CDC, 1980c, letter from the WO of 22 December; reference H43/l/33/Hsg.22/80

23.

Da vies

A O

Dempster

M A H

Widovsky

, 1966, “A theory of the budgetary process” American Political Science Review 60 529–547

24.

Davies

B D

, 1968 Social Needs and Resources in Local Services (Michael Joseph, London)

25.

Danziger

J N

, 1978 Making Budgets (Sage, London)

26.

DoE, 1972 New Local Authorities: Management and Structure Bains

M A

, Chairman; Department of the Environment (HMSO, London)

27.

DoE, 1977 Housing Policy: A Consultative Document Cmnd 6851; Department of the Environment (HMSO, London)

28.

•DoE, 1978a, Department of the Environment Circular 38/78 (HMSO, London)

29.

•DoE, 1978b, DoE note on the Housing Strategies and Investment Programmes meeting of 24 May at Bletchley

30.

•DoE, 1979, press notice of 6 July, reference 233

31.

•DoE/WO, 1974, Department of the Environment circular 70/74 and Welsh Office Circular 111/74; 19 April (HMSO, London)

32.

Eddison

, 1975 Local Government: Management and Corporate Planning (Leonard Hill, London)

33.

Else

P K

Marshall

G P

, 1981, “The unplanning of public expenditure” Public Administration 59 253–278

34.

Gibson

J G

Crame

C H

Stewart

J D

, 1981, “The measurement of central control in England and Wales” Political Studies 30 432–436

35.

HA, 1957 Housing Act Public General Acts chapter 56 (HMSO, London)

36.

HA, 1974 Housing Act Public General Acts chapter 44 (HMSO, London)

37.

Hepworth

N P

, 1976, “Public expenditure controls and local government” Local Government Studies new series 2 1–14

38.

HFA, 1972 Housing Finance Act Public General Acts chapter 47 (HMSO, London)

39.

HM Treasury, 1980 The Government's Expenditure Plans, 1980–81 to 1983–84 Cmnd 7841 (HMSO, London)

40.

HM Treasury, 1984 The Government's Expenditure Plans, 1984–85 to 1986–87 Cmnd 9143–1 (HMSO, London)

41.

Hocking

W E

, 1926 Men and the State (Archon Books, The Shoe String Press, Hamden, CT)

42.

Jackman

Sellers

, 1978, “Local expenditure and local discretion” Centre for Environmental Studies Review 3 63–73

43.

Lansley

, 1979 Housing and Public Policy (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent)

44.

Leather

, 1983, “Housing need and housing investment” Housing Review 32 202–204

45.

Leather

, 1984, “Housing allocations and the GNI” Housing Review 33 9–13

46.

LGPLA, 1980 Local Government Planning and Land Act Public General Acts chapter 65 (HMSO, London)

47.

McCulloch

, 1983, “Capital investment in local authority housing” Housing Review 32 149–151

48.

Martineau

, 1956 Local Government and Central Control (Routledge and Kegan Paul, Henley-on-Thames, Oxon)

49.

Matthews

, 1982, “Housing investment—a programme in search of a policy” Roof 7 11–13

50.

Midwinter

, 1980, “The Scottish Office and local authority financial planning” Public Administration Bulletin 34 21–43

51.

Miliband

, 1969 The State in Capitalist Society (Weidenfeld and Nicholson, London)

52.

Morris

, 1980, “The rise and fall of local housing strategies” Housing Review 29 50–53

53.

NBBC, 1976, DoE resume of topics raised at a seminar at Milton Keynes with the Minister for Housing and Construction, 18 February

54.

•NBBC, 1977a, letter from the DoE of 25 February

55.

•NBBC, 1977b, letter from the DoE of 29 March

56.

•NBBC, 1977c, letter from the DoE of 5 August

57.

•NBBC, 1977d, letter from the DoE of 15 August; reference E4/1725/1

58.

•NBBC, 1978a, letter from the DoE of 3 January; reference E4/5122/27/2

59.

•NBBC, 1978b, letter from the DoE of 27 May; reference E4/5122/27

60.

•NBBC, 1978c, letter from the DoE of 29 November; reference E4/5122/27/3

61.

•NBBC, 1978d, letter from the DoE of 14 December; reference E4/5122/27/3

62.

•NBBC, 1978e, DoE notes of a meeting at Bletchley on 24 May

63.

•NBBC, 1979a, letter from the DoE of 7 March; reference E4/5122/27/3

64.

•NBBC, 1979b, letter from the DoE of 6 August; reference E4/5122/27/3

65.

•NBBC, 1979c, letter from the DoE of 8 October; reference E4/5122/27/4

66.

•NBBC, 1980a, internal note of 2 September; reference FIN/FOLD/1

67.

•NBBC, 1980b, letter from the DoE of 21 February; reference E4/5122/27/4

68.

Paris

, 1979a, “HIPs and housing need: The Oxford experience” Centre for Environmental Studies Review 5 19–27

69.

Paris

, 1979b, “HIPs and underspending: The case of Oxford” Centre for Environmental Studies Review 6 43–49

70.

Partridge

P H

, 1971 Consent and Consensus (Pall Mall Press, London)

71.

Platt

Pinkham

, 1979, “The housing investment programme allocations for London in 1979–80” Housing and Planning Review 35 (3) 13–17

72.

Prentice

R C

, 1981, “Appraising the comparative effectiveness of local intentions in public sector housing investment in Wales” in PTRC Proceedings, Policy Analysis for Housing and Planning Planning and Transport Research and Computation, 110 Strand, London WC2, England; pp 43–52

73.

Prentice

R C

, 1982, “The measurement of performance and housing needs in Welsh strategy statements” Housing Review 31 167–171

74.

Prentice

R C

, 1983, “The assumption of aspatial housing markets locally in public housing investment planning” Cambria 10 41–46

75.

Prentice

R C

, 1984a, “Comparability and incomparability in housing programmes in Wales” Urban Studies 21 forthcoming (November)

76.

Prentice

R C

, 1984b, “Housing in Wales” Social Policy and Administration 18 3–26

77.

Prentice

R C

, 1984c, “Stability and change in the views of representatives: Some evidence from Southeast England” Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 2 79–92

78.

Regan

D E

Stewart

, 1982, “An essay in the government of health” Social Policy and Administration 16 19–43

79.

Robinson

, 1978 Parliament and Public Spending (Heinemann Educational Books, London)

80.

•SCP, 1976, letters from the WO of 30 September

81.

SWCHOG, 1982 A Report on the Housing Financial Allocation to Local Authorities 1981/1982 South Wales Chief Housing Officers Group, Newport Borough Council, Civic Centre, Newport NPT 4UR, Gwent, Wales

82.

SWCHOG, 1984 A Report on the Capital Investment in Housing in Wales South Wales Chief Housing Officers Group, Newport Borough Council, Civic Centre, Newport NPT 4UR, Gwent, Wales

83.

Webb

Wistow

, 1980, “Implementation, central-local relations and the personal social services” in New Approaches to the Study of Central-Local Government Relationships Ed. Jones

, (Gower, Aldershot, Hants) pp 69–83

84.

•WO, 1980, press notice of 17 November; reference HGN/AC

85.

Wright

, 1977, “Public expenditure in Britain: The crisis of control” Public Administration 55 143–167

86.

•These sources of information are not published documents, but are available in the files of the respective Councils or Offices at the addresses listed below:.

87.

CDC (Carmarthen District Council) references

88.

Director of Public Health and Housing, Carmarthen District Council, District Council Offices, 3 Stilman Street, Carmarthen, Dyfed SA31 1WE, Wales

89.

DoE (Department of the Environment) references

90.

2 Marsham Street, London SW1P 3EB, England

91.

NBBC (North Bedfordshire Borough Council) references

92.

Director of Housing and Environmental Health, North Bedfordshire Borough Council, Town Hall, Bedford MK40 1SJ, England

93.

SCP (Secretary of the Council for the Principality) references

94.

Jones

, Chief Executive and Town Clerk, Merthyr Tydfil Borough Council, Town Hall, Merthyr Tydfil CF47 8AN, Wales

95.

WO (Welsh Office) reference

96.

Crown Building, Cathay Park, Cardiff CF1 3NQ, Wales