This paper deals with two questions on the relations between the size of political systems and political trust. First, does citizens' trust in national elected officials differ from their trust in local elected officials? Second, what is the relationship between citizens' trust in elected local government officials and the size of local government units? These questions were answered on the basis of survey data from Denmark, the Netherlands, Norway and the United Kingdom. We found that trust in local officeholders is typically and often considerably higher than trust in national politicians. Moreover, the evidence from these four countries suggests that size of municipality has a modest negative effect on political trust. Further evidence suggests that this negative effect is the result of a tendency of citizens in small municipalities to be more satisfied with their local government than residents in large units. This further evidence also shows that whatever its origins (intensive personal relations or a dense network of civil organisations) social trust is not vital for an adequate understanding of political trust.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlmondG AVerbaS, 1989The Civic Culture: Political Attitudes and Democracy in Five Nations first published 1963 (Sage, Newbury Park, CA)
2.
BraithwaiteVLeviM (Ed.), 1998Trust and Governance (Russell Sage Foundation, New York)
3.
CitrinJMusteCh, 1999, “Trust in government”, in Measures of Political Attitudes Eds RobinsonJ PShaverP RWrightsmanL S (Academic Press, San Diego, CA) pp 465–532
4.
ColemanJ S, 1990Foundations of Social Theory (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
5.
DahlR ATufteE R, 1973Size and Democracy (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA)
6.
DearloveJ, 1973The Politics of Policy in Local Government (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
7.
DentersS A Hde JongH MThomassenJ J A, 1990Kwaliteit van gemeenten: een onderzoek naar de relatie tussen de omvang van gemeenten en de kwaliteit van het lokaal bestuur [Quality of municipalities: research into the relation between municipal size and the quality of local government] (VUGA, 's-Gravenhage)
8.
DentersS A HGeurtsP A Th M, 1998a, “Tevredenheid over het gemeentebestuur” [Satisfaction with municipal government], in Lokale democratie in Nederland: burgers en hun gemeentebestuur [Local democracy in the Netherlands: citizens and their local government] Eds DentersS A HGeurtsP A Th M (Coutinho, Bussum) pp 27–54
9.
DentersS A HGeurtsP A Th M, 1998b, “Opvattingen over politieke machteloosheid tegenover de gemeentelijke en de nationale overheid” [Views on political powerlessness with regard to municipal and national government], in Lokale democratie in Nederland: burgers en hun gemeentebestuur [Local democracy in the Netherlands: citizens and their local government] Eds DentersS A HGeurtsP A Th M (Coutinho, Bussum) pp 55–108
10.
EastonD, 1975, “A re-assessment of the concept of political support”British Journal of Political Science5435–451
11.
EcksteinH, 1996, “Culture as a foundation concept for the social sciences”Journal of Theoretical Politics8471–497
12.
GeurtsP A Th M, 1998, “Bijlagen”, in Lokale democratie in Nederland: burgers en hun gemeentebestuur [Local democracy in the Netherlands: citizens and their local government] Eds DentersS A HGeurtsP A Th M (Coutinho, Bussum) pp 243–273
13.
GoodinR EKlingemannH D (Eds), 1996A New Handbook of Political Science (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
14.
HamiltonAMadisonJJayJ, 1981The Federalist Papers: A Collection of Essays Written in Support of the Constitution of the United States2nd edition; first published 1787/88 (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD)
15.
HardinR, 1999, “Do we want trust in government”, in Democracy and Trust Ed. WarrenM E (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 22–41
KrosnickJ, 1991, “The stability of political preferences”American Journal of Political Science35547–576
18.
LeviMStokerL, 2000, “Political trust and trustworthiness”, in Annual Review of Political Sciencevolume 3, Ed. PolsbyN W (Annual Reviews, Palo Alto, CA) pp 475–508
19.
MansbridgeJ, 1999, “Altruistic trust”, in Democracy and Trust Ed. WarrenM E (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 290–309
20.
MouritzenP E, 1989, “City size and citizen satisfaction: Two competing theories revisited”European Journal of Political Research17661–688
21.
NewtonK, 1999, “Social and political trust in established democracies”, in Critical Citizens: Global Support for Democratic Governance Ed. NorrisP (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 169–187
22.
NewtonKNorrisP, 2000, “Confidence in public institutions: Faith, culture, or performance?”, in Disaffected Democracies: What's Troubling the Trilateral Countries? Eds PharrS JPutnamR D (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ) pp 52–73
23.
NielsenH J, 1981, “Size and evaluation of government: Danish attitudes towards politics at multiple levels of government”European Journal of Political Research947–60
24.
NorrisP (Ed.), 1999aCritical Citizens: Global Support for Democratic Governance (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
25.
NorrisP, 1999b, “Introduction: The growth of critical citizens?”, in Critical Citizens: Global Support for Democratic Governance Ed. NorrisP (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 1–27
26.
NyeJ SJrZelikowP DKingD C (Eds), 1997Why People Don't Trust Government (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
27.
OstromE, 1972, “Metropolitan reform: Propositions derived from two traditions”Social Science Quarterly53474–493
28.
PharrS JPutnamR D (Eds), 2000Disaffected Democracies: What's Troubling the Trilateral Countries? (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
29.
PitkinH F, 1967The Concept of Representation (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
30.
PutnamR D, 1993Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
31.
RoseL EPettersenP A, 1999, “Confidence in politicians and institutions: Comparing national and local levels”, in Challenges to Representative Democracy: Parties, Voters and Public Opinion Eds NarudH MAalbergT (Fagbokforlaget, Bergen) pp 93–126
32.
SnidermanP M, 1993, “The new look in public opinion research”, in Political Science: The State of the Discipline II Ed. FinifterA W (American Political Science Association, Washington, DC) pp 219–245
33.
StewartM CRombergAClarkeH DAcockA, 1992, “Arenas and attitudes: A Note on political efficacy in a federal system”The Journal of Politics54179–196
34.
TaageperaR, 1999, “Ignorance-based quantitative models and their practical implications”Journal of Theoretical Politics11421–431
