An important issue for the geography of health in urban areas concerns how urban change arising from renewal of inner-city areas relates to health of urban populations. In this paper we examine ways in which urban regeneration schemes in Britain are attempting to incorporate consideration of health impact into their planning and development. It concentrates especially on diverse ways that different stakeholders perceive the outcomes of these schemes and the significance for health. The paper is based on two case studies of urban development projects, focusing on housing improvement and training for unemployed people, in a London borough where levels of deprivation are high and various forms of social exclusion affect large numbers of people. The methods used aimed to represent the views of different types of stakeholders, by means of interviews and focus groups with a range of stakeholders in these schemes. Health impact assessment needs to be evidence based. We discuss the evidence for potential health impact of regeneration projects through effects on housing and employment as determinants of health. We focus especially on the ways in which this evidence can be viewed and used by different stakeholders, and how far their perceptions seemed to match with research findings from public health. We consider the potential and the limitations for health improvement associated with urban regeneration in view of the case studies presented here.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AllenT, 2000, “Housing renewal—doesn't it make you sick?”Housing Studies15443–461
2.
ArgyrisC, 1993Knowledge for Action: A Guide to Overcoming Barriers to Organizational Change (Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA)
3.
AtkinsonR, 1999, “Discourses of partnership and empowerment in contemporary British urban regeneration”Urban Studies3659–72
4.
AtkinsonRMoonG, 1994Urban Policy in Britain: The City, the State and the Market (Macmillan, London)
5.
BaileyNTurokI, 2000, “Adjustment to job loss in Britain's major cities”Regional Studies34631–653
6.
BardsleyMCaveBJacobsonB, “Monitoring regeneration and health: a health indicators toolbox for practitioners”, Health of Londoners Programme2001, London, http://www.holp.org.uk
7.
BardsleyMJonesI RKempVDodhiaHAspinallPBevanP, 1998Housing and Health in London: A Review by the Health of Londoners ProjectHealth of Londoners Project and East London and City Health Authority; available from Health of Londoners programme, 11–13 Cavendish Square, London W1G 0AN
8.
BarnettP, 1995, “Unemployment, work and health: Opportunities for healthy public policy”New Zealand Medical Journal108(998) 138–140
9.
BartleyM J, 1994, “Unemployment and ill health: Understanding the relationship”Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health48333–377
10.
BartleyM JFerrieJMontgomeryS M, 1999, “Living in a high-unemployment economy: Understanding the health consequences”, in Social Determinants of Health Eds MarmotMWilkinsonR G (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 81–104
11.
BenzevalMJudgeK, 2000, “Income and health: The time dimension”Social Science and Medicine521371–1390
12.
BenzevalMJudgeKWhiteheadM, 1995Tackling Inequalities in Health: An Agenda for Action (King's Fund Publishing, London)
13.
BestR, 1995, “The housing dimension”, in Tackling Inequalities in Health: An Agenda for Action Eds BenzevalMJudgeKWhiteheadM (King's Fund, London) pp 53–68
14.
BestR, 1999, “Health inequalities, the place of housing”, in Inequalities in Health: The Evidence Presented to the Independent Inquiry into Inequalities in Health, Chaired by Sir Donald Acheson Eds GordonDShawMDorlingDDavey-SmithG (The Policy Press, Bristol) pp 45–67
15.
BranthwaiteAGarciaS, 1985, “Depression in the young unemployed and those on Youth Opportunities Schemes”British Journal of Medical Psychology5867–74
16.
British Medical Association, 1987, “Deprivation and ill-health”, discussion paper, British Medical Association Board of Science and Education, Tavistock Square, London WC1H 9JP
17.
British Medical Association, 1998Health and Environmental Impact Assessment: An Integrated Approach (Earthscan, London)
18.
BrownillS, 1990Developing London's Docklands: Another Great Planning Disaster (Paul Chapman, London)
19.
BurchellB J, 1994, “The effects of labour market position, job insecurity and unemployment on psychological health”, in Social Change and the Experience of Unemployment Eds GallieDMarshCVoglerC (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 188–212
20.
BurridgeROrmandyD, 1993Unhealthy Housing: Research, Remedies, and Reform (E & F N Spon, London)
21.
CattellV, 2001, “Poor people, poor places, and poor health: The mediating role of social networks and social capital”Social Science and Medicine521501–1516
22.
CaveBCurtisS, 2001a, “Developing a practical guide to assess the potential health impact of urban regeneration schemes”Promotion and Education812–16
23.
CaveBCurtisS, 2001bHealth Impact Assessment for Regeneration Projects. Volume I: A Practical GuideQueen Mary, University of London and East London and the City Health Action Zone, http://www.geog.qmul.ac.uk/health/guide.html
24.
CaveBCurtisS, 2001cHealth Impact Assessment for Regeneration Projects. Volume III: PrinciplesQueen Mary, University of London and East London and the City Health Action Zone, http://www.geog.qmul.ac.uk/health/guide.html
25.
CaveBCurtisSCouttsAAvilesM, 2001Health Impact Assessment for Regeneration Projects. Volume II: Selected Evidence BaseQueen Mary, University of London and East London and the City Health Action Zone, http://www.geog.qmul.ac.uk/health/guide.html
26.
CollardA, 1997, “Settling up: towards a strategy for resettling homeless families”, London Homelessness Forum, c/o Kings Cross Homeless Project, 48 Mecklenburgh Square, London WC1N 2NU
27.
CreedP AMachinM AHicksR E, 1999, “Improving mental health status and coping abilities for long-term unemployed youth using cognitive behavioural therapy based training interventions”Journal of Organizational Behavior20963–978
28.
DalgardOTambsK, 1997, “Urban environment and mental health: A Longitudinal study”Journal of Psychiatry171530–536
29.
Department of Health, 1998Independent Inquiry into Inequalities in Health: ReportChairman Sir Donald Acheson (The Stationery Office, London)
30.
Department of Health, 1999Saving Lives: Our Healthier Nation Cm 4386 (The Stationery Office, London)
EdenDAviramA, 1993, “Self-efficacy training to speed reemployment: Helping people to help themselves”Journal of Applied Psychology78352–360
33.
FoleyPMartinS, 2000, “A new deal for community? Public participation in regeneration and local service delivery”Policy and Politics28479–491
34.
ForrestMMurieA, 1988Selling the Welfare State: The Privatisation of Public Housing (Routledge, London)
35.
FrankishC JGreenL WRatnerP AChomickTLarsenC, 1996Health Impact Assessment as a Tool for Population Health Promotion and Public Policy report submitted to the Health Promotion Development Division of Health Canada Institute of Health Promotion Research, University of British Columbia, http://www.hcsc.gc.ca/hppb/healthpromotiondevelopment/pube/impact/impact.htm
36.
GabeJWilliamsP, 1993, “Women, crowding and mental health”, in Unhealthy Housing: Research, Remedies and Reform Eds BurridgeROrmandyD (E & F N Spon, London) pp 191–208
37.
GlennLBeckRBurkettG, 1998, “Effect of a transient, geographically localised economic recovery on community health and income studied with longitudinal household cohort method”Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health52749–757
38.
GraetzB, 1993, “Health consequences of employment and unemployment: Longitudinal evidence for young men and women”Social Science and Medicine36715–724
39.
HagquistCStarrinB, 1996, “Youth unemployment and mental health-gender differences and economic stress”Scandinavian Journal of Social Welfare5(4) 215–228
40.
HalpernD, 1995Mental Health and the Built Environment: More than Bricks and Mortar (Taylor and Francis, London)
41.
HalvorsenK, 1998, “Impact of re-employment on psychological distress among long-term unemployed”Acta Sociologica41227–242
42.
HammerT, 1993, “Unemployment and mental health among young people: A Longitudinal study”Journal of Adolescence16407–420
43.
HamnettC, 2001, “London's housing”Area33(1) 80–84
44.
HaylettC, 2001, “Modernization, welfare and ‘third way’ politics: Limits to theorizing in ‘thirds’?”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series2643–56
45.
HendleyJBarnesRHirschfieldAScott-SamuelA, 1999, “What is HIA and how can it be applied to regeneration programmes?”, WP 1, Departments of Civic Design and Public Health, University of Liverpool, Liverpool
46.
HillD, 2000Urban Policy and Politics in Britain (Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants)
47.
HoggettPStewartMRazzaqueKBarkerI, 1999Urban Regeneration and Mental Health in London (King's Fund, London)
48.
IversenLSabroeS, 1988, “Hospital admissions before and after shipyard closure”British Medical Journal2991073–1076
49.
JahodaM, 1982Employment and Unemployment (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
50.
JoelsonLWahlquistL, 1987, “The psychological meaning of job insecurity and job loss: Results of a longitudinal study”Social Science and Medicine25179–182
51.
KarasekRTheorellT, 1990Healthy Work: Stress, Productivity, and the Reconstruction of Working Life (Basic Books, New York)
MartikainenP T, 1990, “Unemployment and mortality among Finnish men 1981–1985”British Medical Journal301407–411
56.
MattiassonILindgardeFNilssonJ ATheorellT, 1990, “The threat of unemployment and cardiovascular risk factors longitudinal study of quality of sleep and serum cholesterol concentrations in men threatened with redundancy”British Medical Journal301461–466
57.
MeadL, 1997From Welfare to Work: Lessons from America (Institute of Economic Affairs, London)
58.
MorrellSTaylorR JQuineSKerrCWesternJ, 1994, “A cohort study of unemployment as a cause of psychological disturbance in Australian youth”Social Science and Medicine381553–1563
59.
MoserK AGoldblattP OFoxA JJonesD, 1987, “Unemployment and mortality: Comparison of the 1971 and 1981 Longitudinal Study census sample”British Medical Journal29487–90
60.
MurrayC, 1990The Emerging British Underclass (Institute of Economic Affairs, London)
61.
OddyMDonovanAPardoeR, 1984, ‘“Do government training schemes for unemployed school leavers achieve their objectives? A psychological perspective”Journal of Adolescence7377–385
62.
OstermanP, 1991, “Welfare participation in a full employment economy: The impact of neighbourhood”Social Problems38475–489
63.
PainterCClarenceE, 2001, “UK local action zones and changing urban governance”Urban Studies381215–1232
PowellMMoonG, 2001, “Health Action Zones: The ‘third way’ of a new area-based policy?”Health and Social Care in the Community9(1) 43–50
66.
ReasonP, 1994, “Three approaches to participative inquiry”, in Handbook of Qualitative Research Eds DenzinNLincolnY (Sage, London) pp 324–339
67.
RogersAHuxleyPThomasRRobsonBEvansSStordyJGatelyC, 2001, “Evaluating the impact of a locality based social policy intervention on mental health: Conceptual and methodological issues”International Journal of Social Psychiatry47(4) 41–55
68.
RussellHKilloranA, 1999, “Public health and regeneration: making the links: summary bulletin”, Health Education Authority; now Health Development Agency, 30 Great Peter Street, London SW1
69.
SchwefelD, 1996, “Unemployment, health and health services in German-speaking countries”Social Science and Medicine22409–430
70.
Scott-SamuelABirleyMArdernK, 1998, “The Merseyside guidelines for health impact assessment”, Merseyside Health Impact Assessment Steering Group, Liverpool Public Health Observatory, University of Liverpool, Liverpool
71.
ShawMDorlingDBrimblecombeN, 1999, “Life chances in Britain by housing wealth and for the homeless and vulnerably housed”Environment and Planning A312239–2248
72.
SmithSEasterlowD, 2001, “Housing, wealth and health inequalities”, paper presented to the Association of American Geographers, Annual meeting, 27 February-3 March, New York
73.
SmithS JAlexanderAEasterlowD, 1997, “Rehousing as a health intervention: Miracle or mirage?”Health and Place3203–216
74.
StansfeldS A, 1999, “Social support and social cohesion”, in Social Determinants of Health Eds MarmotMWilkinsonR G (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 155–178
75.
StokerGMossbergerK, 1994, “Urban regime theory in comparative perspective”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy12195–212
76.
StrandhM, 2000, “Different exit routes from unemployment and their impact on mental well-being: The role of the economic situation and the predictability of the life course”Work, Employment and Society14459–479
77.
TurokIWebsterD, 1998, “The New Deal: Jeopardised by the geography of unemployment?”Local Economy12309–328
78.
VahteraJKivimakiMPenttiJTheorellT, 2000, “Effect of change in the psychosocial work environment on sickness absence: A Seven year follow up of initially healthy employees”Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health54484–493
79.
VictorC, 1997, “The health of homeless people: A Review”European Journal of Public Health7398–404
80.
VinokurASchulYVuoriJPriceR, 2001, “Two years after a job loss: Long term impact of the JOBS program on reemployment and mental health”Journal of Occupational Health Psychology5(1) 32–47
81.
VuoriJVersalainen, 1999, “Labour market interventions as predictors of re-employment, job seeking activity and psychological distress among the unemployed”Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology72532–538
82.
WallaceM, 2001, “A new approach to neighbourhood renewal in England”Urban Studies382163–2166
83.
WarrP B, 1987Work, Unemployment and Mental Health (Clarendon Press, Oxford)
84.
WesterlundHTheorellTBergströmA, 2001, “Psychophysiological effects of temporary alternative employment”Social Science and Medicine52405–415
85.
WestinS, 1990, “The structure of factory closure: Individual response to job loss and unemployment in a 10 year controlled follow up study”Social Science and Medicine311301–1311
86.
WHO, 1999, “Health impact assessment: main concepts and suggested approach”, Gothenburg consensus paper 1–10, European Centre for Health Policy, WHO Regional Office for Europe, Brussels, http://www.who.dk/hs/ECHP/index.htm
