It is argued that the regional level of the state in Britain has been neglected in recent work on intrastate relations. The aim in this paper is to develop, through the application, development, and amendment of a ‘dual politics’ thesis, a middle-range theory of the political processes which characterise the regional state level. On the basis of a review and discussion of primary and secondary research materials relating to English Regional Water Authorities and Regional Health Authorities, it is suggested that the ‘politics of production’ at regional level are characterised by class domination organised through corporatist forms, whereas the ‘politics of consumption’ at this level tend towards a pattern of bureaucratic and professional closure. Explanations for such a divergence are put forward and the implications for democracy of a growth of state functions at a regional level are briefly explored.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
CawsonA, 1982Corporatism and Welfare (Heinemann Educational Books, London)
2.
CawsonASaundersP, 1983, “Corporatism, competitive politics and class struggle” in Capital and Politics Ed. KingR, (Routledge and Kegan Paul, Henley-on-Thames, Oxon) pp 8–27
3.
CookeP, 1983, “The spatial dimension of urban politics: Local opposition to a regional coalition” paper presented at the Anglo Danish seminar on local state research, University of Copenhagen, September; copy available from the author at Department of Town Planning, UWIST, Cardiff, Wales
4.
DahlR, 1956A Preface to Democratic Theory (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
5.
DavidsonN, 1979, “Opening doors to meet the needs of the people served”Health and Social Services Journal89566–569
6.
DonaldB, 1975, “Volunteers retained as managers”Public Administration53299–320
7.
DraperPSmartT, 1974, “Social science and health policy in the United Kingdom”International Journal of Health Services4453–470
8.
DuncanSGoodwinM, 1982, “The local state and restructuring social relations”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research6157–186
9.
ElcockHHaywoodS, 1980The Buck Stops Where? Accountability and Control in the National Health ServiceInstitute for Health Studies, University of Hull, Hull, England
10.
EllisP, 1981Planning in an Inter-organisational Context: The Relationship between Planning and Water Authorities MA thesis, Department of Town and Country Planning, Trent Polytechnic, Nottingham, England
11.
GrayC, 1982, “Professional ideologies and planning in water authority-local authority relationships” paper presented at the Political Studies Association, Urban Politics Group, seminar on “Nonlocal urban services”, University of Birmingham, 4 December; copy available from the author at Department of Business Studies, Polytechnic of Wales, Pontypridd, Mid Glamorgan, Wales
12.
HogwoodBKeatingM, 1982Regional Government in England (Clarendon Press, Oxford)
13.
LevittR, 1976The Reorganised National Health Service (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent)
14.
LucasS, 1980, “Cooperative planning”Water3310–13
15.
MilibandR, 1969The State in Capitalist Society (Weidenfeld and Nicolson, London)
16.
NavarroV, 1978Class Struggle, the State and Medicine (Martin Robertson, Oxford)
ParkerDPenning-RowsellE, 1980Water Planning in Britain (George Allen and Unwin, Hemel Hempstead, Herts)
19.
PearceF, 1982Watershed: The Water Crisis in Britain (Junction Books, London)
20.
PickvanceC, 1983, “Spatial policy as territorial politics” paper presented at British Sociological Association Annual Conference, University College, Cardiff, April; copy available from the author at Urban and Regional Studies Unit, University of Kent at Canterbury, Canterbury, England
21.
ReganDStewartJ, 1982, “An essay in the government of health: The case for local authority control”Social Policy and Administration1619–42
22.
SaundersP, 1979Urban Politics: A Sociological Interpretation (Hutchinson, London)
23.
SaundersP, 1982, “Why study central-local relations?”Local Government Studies855–66
24.
SelfP, 1964, “Regional planning in Britain”Urban Studies155–70
25.
SewellWBarrL, 1978, “Water administration in England and Wales”Water Resources Bulletin14337–348
26.
StewartJ, 1980, “Inter-organisational relationships: An introduction”Town Planning Review51257–260
27.
TownsendATaylorC, 1975, “Regional culture and identity in industrialised societies”Regional Studies9379–393
28.
WA, 1973, Water Act Public General Acts-Elizabeth II chapter 37 (HMSO, London)
29.
WA, 1983, Water Act Public General Acts-Elizabeth II chapter 23 (HMSO, London)
30.
WilliamsA, 1977, “The relationship between Regional Water Authorities and local authorities” in Water Planning and the Regions Ed. DrudyP, (Regional Studies Association, London)
31.
WistowG, 1982, “Collaboration between health and local authorities”Social Policy and Administration1644–62
