The evaluation of industrial policy interventions has attracted increasing policy and academic attention in recent years. Despite the widespread consensus regarding the need for evaluation, the issue of how to evaluate, and the associated methodological considerations, continue to be issues of considerable debate. The authors develop an approach to estimate the net additionally of financial assistance from Enterprise Ireland to indigenously owned firms in Ireland for the period 2000 to 2002. With a sample of Enterprise Ireland assisted firms, an innovative, self-assessment, in-depth, face-to-face, interview methodology was adopted. The authors also explore a way of incorporating the indirect benefits of assistance into derived deadweight estimates—an issue which is seldom discussed in the context of deadweight estimates. They conclude by reflecting on the key methodological lessons learned from the evaluation process, and highlight some pertinent evaluation issues which should form the focus of much future discussion in this field of research.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AshcroftBTaylorJ, 1977, “The movement of manufacturing industry and the effects of regional economic policy”Oxford Economic Papers2984–101
2.
BartikT J, 1990, “The market failure approach to regional economic development policy”Economic Development Quarterly4361–370
3.
BorooahV K, 1996Growth, Unemployment, Distribution and Government: Essays on Current Economic Issues (Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants)
4.
ConnollySMonroeA, 1999Economics of the Public Sector (Pearson Education, Harlow, Essex)
Fitzpatrick Associates, 2002, “Review of Enterprise Ireland's world class manufacturing support”, Fitzpatrick Associates, 10 Lad Lane, Dublin 2
8.
FoleyA, 2002, “Finance for new ventures”, in New Venture Creation in Ireland Eds CooneyTHillS (Oak Tree Press, Dublin) pp 175–202
9.
Forfás, 2003The Economic Appraisal System for Projects Seeking Support from the Industrial Development AgenciesForfás, Wilton Park House, Wilton Place, Dublin 2
10.
FraserS, 2003, “The impact of Investors in People on small business growth: Who benefits?”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy21793–812
11.
GrantR M, 1983, “Appraising selective financial assistance to industry: A review of institutions and methodologies in the United Kingdom, Sweden and West Germany”Journal of Public Policy3369–395
12.
HartMScottR, 1994, “Measuring the effectiveness of small firm policy: Some lessons from Northern Ireland”Regional Studies28849–858
13.
HartMScottRGudginGKeeganR, 1993, “Job creation in small firms—an economic evaluation of job creation in small firms assisted by the Northern Ireland Local Economic Development Unit (LEDU)”, Northern Ireland Economic Research Centre, Queen's University, Belfast
14.
HeijsJ, 2003, “Freerider behaviour and the public finance of R&D activities in enterprises: The case of the Spanish low interest credits for R&D”Research Policy32445–461
15.
HonohanP, 1998, “Key issues of cost–benefit methodology for Irish industrial policy”, General Research Series 172, The Economic and Social Research Institute, 4 Burlington Road, Dublin 4
16.
HughesAStoreyD J (Eds), 1994Finance and the Small Firm (Routledge, London)
17.
IEU, 1996, “Marketing sub programme” (Industrial Evaluation Unit, Dublin)
18.
IEU, 1998, “Review of graduate placement programmes” (Industrial Evaluation Unit, Dublin)
19.
IEU, 1999, “Meta-evaluation of STI policies and interventions. Models for future investment” (Industrial Evaluation Unit, Dublin)
20.
KingJ, 1990, “Regional selective assistance 1980–84: An evaluation by the Department of Trade and Industry, the Industry Department for Scotland, and the Welsh Office Industry Department” (The Stationery Office, London)
21.
LenihanH, 1999, “An evaluation of a regional development agency's grants in terms of deadweight and displacement”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy17303–318
22.
LenihanH, 2001Industrial Policy in Ireland: Developing Appropriate Evaluative Frameworks PhD thesis, School of Public Policy, Economics, and Law, University of Ulster, Jordonstown, Newtownabbey, Co.Antrim
23.
LenihanH, 2004, “Evaluating Irish industrial policy in terms of deadweight and displacement: A quantitative methodological approach”Applied Economics36229–252
24.
LenihanHHartMRoperS, 2003, “Developing methods to evaluate the impact of Enterprise Ireland assistance—deriving estimates of deadweight and displacement in Enterprise Ireland assisted companies”, Enterprise Ireland, Glasnevin, Dublin 9
25.
McEldowneyJ, 1997, “Policy evaluation and the concept of deadweight and additionality—a commentary”Evaluation3175–188
26.
MooreBRhodesJ, 1973, “Evaluating the effect of British regional economic policy”Economic Journal8387–110
27.
MooreBRhodesJTylerP, 1986, “The Effects of Regional Policy”, Department of Trade and Industry (The Stationery Office, London)
28.
PACEC, 1993, “Regional selective assistance 1985–88”, Department of Trade and Industry (The Stationery Office, London)
29.
PACEC, 2001, “Evaluation of SMART (including SPUR)”, Department of Trade and Industry Evaluation Report Series 3, (ref URN 01/1189), http://www.dti.gov.uk/about/evaluation
30.
RoperSHartM, 2003, “Modelling the effects of public support to small firms in the UK—paradise gained?”, presented to the European Regional Science Association Conference, Jyväskylä, Finland, November; copy available from Mark Hart, Small Business Research Centre, Kingston University, Kingston Hill, Kingston upon Thames, Surrey
31.
RoperSHewitt-DundasN, 2001, “Grant assistance and small firm development in Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland”Scottish Journal of Political Economy4899–117
32.
RoperSHartMBramleyGDaleIAndersonC, 2001, “Paradise gained—the Business Link Tracker Study”, presented to the 24th ISBA Conference, Leicester; copy available from Mark Hart, Small Business Research Centre, Kingston University, Kingston Hill, Kingston upon Thames, Surrey
33.
SheehanM, 1993, “Government financial assistance and manufacturing investment in Northern Ireland”Regional Studies27527–540
34.
StightzJ E, 1988Economics of the Public Sector (W W Norton, New York)
35.
SwalesJ K, 1997, “The ex post evaluation of regional selective assistance”Regional Studies31859–865
36.
TurokIRacoM, 2000, “Developing expertise in small and medium-sized enterprises: An evaluation of consultancy support”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy18409–427
37.
WrenCStoreyD, 2002, “Evaluating the effect of small business support upon small firm performance”Oxford Economic Papers54334–365
