In this paper the question of tax assignment in multiple-level systems of government is addressed. Existing economic theory of fiscal federalism, which is the main source of information on tax assignment, is reviewed and various criticisms of this theory, as a normative theory, are outlined which indicate major difficulties in application to practice. Where a strong desire for decentralisation exists, such as in Spain, an alternative political-economic approach is suggested. This is then used to comment on developments in Spain where, it is concluded, the present assignment of taxing powers is insufficient to guarantee the autonomy of the regional governments. For Spain, regional access to a share of the VAT or personal income tax is suggested as the best option for tax reform in order to offer sufficient regional tax autonomy.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BennettR J, 1980The Geography of Public Finance: Welfare under Fiscal Federalism and Local Government Finance (Methuen, Andover, Hants)
2.
BennettR J, 1982Central Grants to Local Government: The Political and Economic Impacts of the Rate Support Grant (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
3.
BrennanH G, 1980, “Criteria for state and local taxes” in The Economics of Federalism Eds GrewalB SBrennanH GMathewsR L, (Australian National University Press, Canberra) pp 341–350
4.
BretonA, 1974The Economic Theory of Representative Government (Aldine, Chicago, IL)
5.
BricallJ MCastellsASicartF, 1984Estado Autónomico y Finanzas Públicas (Gabinete de Publicaciones, Diputación de Barcelona)
6.
BuchananJ M, 1950, “Federalism and fiscal equity”American Economic Review40583–597
7.
BuchananJ M, 1960Fiscal Theory and Political Economy (University of North Carolina Press, Chapel Hill, NC)
8.
BuchananJ M, 1965, “An economic theory of clubs”Economica321–14
9.
CastellsA, 1987, “Financing regional government in Spain: Main trends and a comparative perspective”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 5 pp 257–268
10.
CleggT, 1986, “Central-local relations in Spain” in Territorial Politics in Unitary States Eds GoldsmithMPageE, (Sage, London)
11.
DafflonB, 1977Federal Finance in Theory and Practice with Special Reference to Switzerland Schriftcnreihe Finanzwirtschaft und Finanzrecht reo. 21 (Paul Haupt, Bern)
12.
DavisD G, 1977, “An analysis of fiscal centralisation, decentralisation and the problems of federal and state-local taxes” in State and Local Taxation Ed. MathewsR L, (Australian National University Press, Canberra)
13.
DodgsonJ STophamN, 1986, “Cost-benefit criteria for urban transport subsidies”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy4177–186
14.
DoE, 1986Paying for Local Government Department of the Environment, Cmnd 9714 (HMSO, London)
15.
DunleavyP, 1980Urban Political Analysis (Macmillan, London)
16.
MaruganF Fernandas, 1984, “La financiación autonómica. Algunos comentarios sobre su generación y evolución”Economistas912–17
17.
FosterC DJackmanRPerlmanM, 1980Local Government Finance in a Unitary State (Allen and Unwin, Hemel Hempstead, Herts)
18.
de CataluñaGeneralidad, 1985Libro Blanco del Gobierno de la Generalidad de Cataluña Sobre la Finanziación AutonómicaDepartamento de Economía y Finanzas, Barcelona
19.
GrewalB SBrennanH GMathewsR L, (Eds), 1980The Economics of Federalism (Australian National University Press, Canberra)
20.
GrewalB SMathewsR L, 1983Federalism, Localional Surplus, and the Redistributive Role of Subnational Government Report 53, Centre for Research on Federal Financial Relations, Australian National University. Updated version published in 1986 in Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy4317–324
21.
HallerH, 1968, “Wandlungen in den Problemen föderativer Staatswirtschaften”Finanzarchiv249–270
22.
JonesG W, 1981New Approaches to the Study of Central-Local Relationships (ESRC-Gower, Aldershot, Hants)
23.
Kilbrandon, 1973Royal Commission on the Constitution 1969–1973 Chairman Lord Kilbrandon, Cmnd 5460 (HMSO, London)
24.
KingD, 1984Fiscal Tiers: The Economics of Multi-level Government (Allen and Unwin, Hemel Hempstead, Herts)
25.
SanchoJ R Lasuén, 1986El Estado Multi-regional España Descentrada (Alianza Editorial, Madrid)
26.
SanchoJ R Lasuén, 1987, “The autonomous communities: Political and economic”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy5 pp 251–256
27.
MathewsR L, 1977State and Local Taxation (Australian National University Press, Canberra)
28.
McLureC E, 1983Tax Assignment in Federal CountriesCentre for Research on Federal Financial Relations, Australian National University, Canberra
29.
McLureC EMieskowskiP, (Eds), 1983Fiscal Federalism and the Taxation of Natural Resources (D C Heath, Lexington, MA)
30.
MusgraveR A, 1959The Theory of Public Finance (McGraw-Hill, New York)
31.
MusgraveR A, 1961, “Approaches to a fiscal theory of political federalism” in Public Finances: Needs, Resources and UtilisationNational Bureau of Economic Research (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
32.
MusgraveR AMusgraveP B, 1980Public Finance in Theory and Practice3rd edition (McGraw-Hill, New York)
33.
NiskanenW A, 1971Bureaucracy and Representative Government (Aldine-Atherton, Chicago, IL)
34.
OatesW A, 1972Fiscal Federalism (Harcourt Brace Jovanowich, New York)
35.
OatesW A, (Ed.), 1977The Political Economy of Fiscal Federalism (D C Heath, Lexington, MA)
36.
PeacockA T, 1972, “Fiscal means and political ends” in Essays in Honour of Lionel Robbins Eds PestonMCorryB, (Weidenfeld and Nicholson, London)
37.
AbelloA Pedros, 1987, “Autonomous public finance in Spain: Reflections and propositions for reform”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy5 pp 301–307
38.
PennimanC, 1980State Income Taxation (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD)
39.
RhodesR A W, 1981Control and Power in Central-Local Relations (Gower, Aldershot, Hants)
40.
SandfordC T, 1983Tax Policy-making in the United Kingdom (Heinemann, London)
41.
SaundersP, 1979Urban Politics: A Sociological Interpretation (Hutchinson, London)
42.
SchmidtK, 1986, “The case for a local net value-added tax for German municipalities” in Local Business Taxes in Britain and Germany Eds BennettR JZimmermannH, (Anglo-German Foundation, London and Bonn)
43.
ScottA D, 1964, “The economic goals of federal finance”Public Finance19241–288
44.
SeguraJ V Sevilla, 1987, “Financial aspects of political decentralisation in Spain”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy5 pp 287–299
45.
ThirskW R, 1983, “Fiscal harmonization in the United States, Australia, West Germany, Switzerland, and the EEC” in Federalism and the Canadian Economic Union Eds TrebilcockM JPrichardJ R SCourcheneT JWhalleyJ, (University of Toronto Press for the Ontario Economic Council, Toronto)
46.
TieboutC M, 1956, “A pure theory of local expenditures”Journal of Political Economy64412–424
47.
TieboutC M, 1961, “An economic theory of fiscal decentralisation”, in Public Finances: Needs, Sources and UtilisationNational Bureau of Economic Research (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
48.
TophamN, 1982, “The incidence of grants-in-aids”Fiscal Studies3199–209
49.
TophamN, 1983, “Local government economics” in Public Sector Economics Eds MillwardRParkerDRosenthalLSumnerM TTophamN, (Longman, London) pp 129–198
50.
TreschR W, 1981Public Finance: The Normative Theory (Business Publications, Piano, TX)
51.
WisemanJ, 1964The Political Economy of Federalism: A Survey and a Proposal mimeo, prepared for Canadian Royal Commission on Taxation, to be published in revised form in Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy5
