The author provides an understanding of the concept of institutional innovations for local economic development in post-Mao China. With Kunshan, one of the most dramatically developed regions in Yangtze Delta, used as a case study, the aim is to understand how, under what circumstances, and by whom, locally initiated projects can be institutionalized and evolved in the context of China's transition. ‘Projects’ here refer to those reforms implemented by local governments initially without any permission from the centre. It is argued that the development of those projects can be understood as an evolutionary process, consisting of three mechanisms of local-central interactions: state's intention to connive; ex-post state endorsement, and ex-ante state adoption. Moreover, the innovations would be successful not only because of general contexts such as marketization, liberalization, and globalization, but also because of a particular process of economic decentralization to the local and political centralization under the party, or, as is proposed, asymmetric decentralization. Careerist local officials would like to utilize their decentralized resources to strive for more development opportunities, which could in turn become their ‘political capital’, enabling them to attract the attentions of upper level governments and hence gain promotion.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Almanac Office of KETZ, 2000Kunshan kai fa qu de xin cheng yu fa zhan [Formation and transformation of Kunshan Development Zone], in Kunshan kai fa qu shi wu nian [Fifteen Years of Kunshan Development Zone], Eds KETZ Administration Office, Party History Research Office of Kunshan CCP (Ting Lin, Kunshan) pp 15–57
2.
BahlRW, 1999Fiscal Policy in China: Taxation and Intergovernmental Fiscal Relations (1990 Institute, South San Francisco, CA)
3.
BaumRShevchenkoA, 1999, “State of the state”, in The Paradox of China's Post-Mao Reform Eds MacfarquharR, (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA) pp 333–360
4.
Beijing Institute of International City Development (Ed.), 2003zhong kuo shu zi huang pi shu [Yellow Book of Numbers in China] (Zhong Kuo Shi Dai Jin Ji, Beijing)
5.
BoZ, 2000a, Chinese Provincial Leaders: Economic Performance and Political Mobility Since 1949 (East Gate, London)
6.
BoZ, 2000b, “Economic development and corruption: Beijing beyond ‘Beijing’”Journal of Contemporary China9(25) 467–487
7.
BreanDJS, 1998, “Fiscal reform in modern China: An overview”, in Taxation in Modern China Ed. BreanDJS, (Routledge, New York) pp 1–30
8.
BreslinSG, 1996China in the 1980s: Centre-Province Relations in a Reforming Socialist State (Macmillan, London)
9.
BurnsJP, 1987, “China's nomenklatura system”Problems of Communism36 (September-October) pages 36–51
10.
CaoYQianYWeingastB, 1999, “From federalism, Chinese style, to privatization, Chinese style”Economics of Transition7(1) 103–131
11.
ChanHS, 2004, “Cadre personnel management in China: The nomenklatura system, 1990–1998”The China Quarterly issue 179, 703–734
12.
ChenT-J, 2004, “Living under the roof of WTO: Cross-Strait economic relations since WTO accession”, in Rising China and the East Asian Economy (Korea Institute for International Economic Policy, Seoul)
13.
CheungPTY, 1994, “Relations between the central government and Guangdong”, in Guangdong: Survey of a Province Undergoing Rapid Change Eds YeungY-MChuDKY, (The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong) pp 19–51
14.
CheungPTY, 1998a, “Introduction: Provincial leadership and economic reform in post-Mao China”, in Provincial Strategies of Economic Reforms in Post-Mao China—Leadership, Politics and Implementation Eds CheungPTYChugJHLinZ, (East Gate, New York) pp 3–46
15.
CheungPTY, 1998b, “The Guangdong advantage: Provincial leadership and strategy toward resource allocation since 1979”, in Provincial Strategies of Economic Reform in Post-Mao China—Leadership, Politics, and Implementation Eds CheungPTYChungJHLinZ, (East Gate, New York) pp 89–144
16.
ChungJH, 1997, “Shangdong: The political economy of development and inequality”, in China's Provinces in Reform—Class, Community and Political Culture Ed GoodmanD, (Routledge, London) pp 127–157
17.
ChungJH, 1999a, “Recipes for development in post-Mao Chinese cities”, in Cities in China—Recipes For Economic Development in the Reform Era Ed. ChungJH, (Hong Kong University Press, Hong Kong) pp 1–17
18.
ChungJH, 1999b, “Preferential policies, municipal leadership and development strategy—a comparative analysis of Qingdao and Dalian”, in Cities in China—Recipes for Economic Development in the Reform Era Ed. ChungJH, (Routledge, London), pp 105–140
19.
ChungJH, 2000Central Control and Local Discretion in China-Leadership and Implementation During Post-Mao Decollectivization (Oxford University Press, New York)
20.
DuckettJ, 1998The Entrepreneurial State in China: Real Estate and Commerce Departments in Reform Era Tianjin (Routledge, London)
21.
EdinM, 2000Market Forces and Communist Power—Local Political Institutions and Economic Development in China (University Printers, Uppsala)
22.
EdinM, 2003, “State capacity and local agent control in China: CCP cadre management from a township perspective”The China Quarterly number 173, 35–52
23.
FanCC, 1995, “Development from above, below, and outside: Spatial impacts of China's economic reforms in Jiangsu and Guangdong Provinces”Chinese Environment and Development6 (1&2) 85–116
24.
FanG, 1998, “Market-oriented economic reform and the growth of off-budget local public finance”, in Taxation in Modern China Ed. BreanDJS, (Routledge, New York) pp 209–227
25.
FeiX, (Ed.), 2000chong xiao cheng zhen dao ka fa qu [From Small Town to Development Zone] (Jiangsu ren ming chu ban shi, Nanjing)
26.
GaoX, 1999Xian Fu Guang Dong Bang [Taming of the Guangdong Gang] (Mirror Books, Hong Kong)
27.
GoreLLP, 1999, “The communist legacy in post-Mao economic growth”The China Journal4125–54
28.
HeilmannSKirchbergerS, 2000, “The Chinese nomenklatura in transition: A study based on internal cadre statistics of the Central Organization Department of the Chinese Communist Party”, Trier, China Analysis No 1, Center for East Asian and Pacific Studies, Trier University, Trier
29.
Herrmann-PillathCFengX, 2004, “Competitive governments, fiscal arrangements, and the provision of local public infrastructure in China”China Information18373–428
30.
HsingY, 1998Making Capitalism in China: The Taiwan Connection (Oxford University Press, New York)
31.
HsuH, (Ed.), 1998Kunshan shi tu di shi [Kunshan Gazette on Landuse] (Shanghai ke xuan ji shu wen xian chu ban she, Shanghai)
32.
HuangY, 1996Inflation and Investment Control in China—The Political Economy of Central—Local Relations During the Reform Era (Cambridge University Press, New York)
33.
HuangY, 2002, “Managing Chinese bureaucrats: An institutional economic perspective”Political Studies5061–79
34.
KETZ Administration Office, Party History Research Office of Kunshan CCP (Eds), 2000Kunshan kai fa qu si wu nei [Fifteen Years of Kunshan Development Zone] (Ting Lin, Kunshan)
35.
Kunshan EPZ Administrative Committee, 2000yin zi zhai ti de xin tan sou [New exploration of investment vehicle], in Kunshan kai fa qu shi wu nian [Fifteen Years of Kunshan Development Zone], Eds KETZ Administration Office, Party History Research Office of Kunshan CCP (Ting Lin, Kunshan) pp 213–220
36.
LaiH-CChiuYCLeuD-H, 2005, “Innovation capacity comparison of China's information technology industrial clusters: The case of Shanghai, Kunshan and Shenzhen and Dongguan”Technology Analysis and Strategic Management17293–315
37.
LamTC, 1999, “Institutional constraint, leadership, and development strategies—Panyu and Nahia under reform”, in Cities in China—Recipes for Economic Development in the Reform Era Ed. CheungJH, (Routledge, London) pp 256–295
38.
LeeB, 2003, kun tai jin ji hu don di su liang mo xing [Quantitative model of economic interaction between Kunshan and Taiwan], 3rd meeting of Kunshan—Taiwan Relationship Conference, 22–23 September 2003, Kunshan, Jiangsu, China; copy available from the author
39.
LiDD, 1998, “Changing incentives of the Chinese bureaucracy”The American Economic Review88393–397
40.
LiHZhouL-A, 2005, “Political turnover and economic performance: The incentive roles of personnel control in China”Journal of Public Economics891743–1762
41.
LiLC, 1997a, “Toward a non-zero-sum interactive framework of spatial politics: The case of central-province in contemporary China”Political Studies4549–65
42.
LiLC, 1997b, “Provincial discretion and national power: Investment policy in Guangdong and Shanghai, 1978–93”The China Quarterly number 152, 778–804
43.
LiQ, 2000Kunshan kai fa qu de cheng gong zhi dao [The reasons for success of Kunshan Development Zone] in Kunshan kai fa qu shi wu nian [Fifteen Years of Kunshan Development Zone], Ed. Party History Research Office of Kunshan CCP (Ting Lin, Kunshan) pp 148–154
44.
LinY-M, 2001Between Politics and Markets—Firms, Competition, and Institutional Change in Post-Mao China (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
45.
MaJ, 2000, “Off-budgetary activities of China governments since economic reform”, paper presented to the 12th Annual Conference of Association for Budgeting and Financial Management, Kansas City, http://www.use.cuhk.edu.hk/wk_wzdetails.asp7id=1356
46.
MaLJCWuF, 2005, “Restructuring the Chinese city: Diverse processes and reconstituted spaces”, in Restructuring the Chinese City: Changing Society, Economy, and Space Eds MaLJCWuF, (Routledge, London), pp 1–20
MartonAM, 2000China's Spatial Economic Development—Restless Landscapes in the Low Yangzi Delta (Routledge, London)
49.
Monash International Pty Ltd, 2003PRC: Foreign Capital Utilization (Final Report)Monash, Monash International Pty Ltd, 871 Dandenong Road, Caulfield East, Victoria 3145; submitted to Asian Development Bank (ADB TA 3806)
50.
MontinolaGQianYWeingastBR, 1995, “Federalism, Chinese style: The political basis for economic success in China”World Politics4850–81
51.
OiJC, 1995, “The role of the local state in China's transitional economy”The China Quarterly number 144, 1132–1149
52.
OiJC, 1998, “The evolution of local state corporatism”, in Zouping in Transition—The Process of Reforms in Rural North China Ed. WalderAG, (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA) pp 37–61
53.
PoLCPunN, 2003, “Making transborder governance: A case study of the role of Taiwanese capital in Kunshan's institutional change”, in Chinese, presented at the 3rd meeting of Kunshan—Taiwan Relationship Conference, 22–23 September 2003, Kunshan, Jiangsu, China; copy available from the author
54.
QianYRolandG, 1998, “Federalism and the soft budget constraint”American Economic Review881143–1162
55.
QianYStiglitzJ, 1996, “Institutional innovations and the role of learning government in transition economies: The case of Guangdong Province of China”, in Reforming Asian Socialism: The Growth of Market Institutions Eds McMillanJNaughtonB, (University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor, MI) pp 175–196
56.
QianYWeingastB, 1996, “China's transition to markets: Market-preserving federalism, Chinese style”Journal of Policy Reform1(1) 149–185
57.
Rodríguez-PoseAGillN, 2003, “The global trend towards devolution and its implications”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy21333–351
58.
SaichT, 2002, “The blind man and the elephant: Analysing the local state in China”, in East Asian Capitalism: Conflicts and the Roots of Growth and Crisis Ed. TombaL, (Annali della Fondazione Giangiacomo Feltrinelli, Milan) pp 75–99
59.
ShirkSL, 1993The Political Logic of Economic Reform in China (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
60.
SmartA, 1999, “Predatory rule and illegal economic practices”, in States and Illegal Practices Ed. HeymanJM, (Berg, New York) pp 99–128
61.
SmartAHsuJ-Y, 2004, “The Chinese diaspora, foreign investment and economic development in China”The Review of International Affairs3544–566
62.
SolnickSL, 1996, “The breakdown of hierarchies in the Soviet Union and China”World Politics48209–238
63.
SuFYangDL, 2000, “Political institutions, provincial interests, and resource allocation in reformist China”Journal of Contemporary China24(9) 215–230
64.
TanQ, 2002, “Growth disparity in China: Provincial causes”Journal of Contemporary China11(33) 735–759
65.
TungC-Y, 2002China's Economic Leverage and Taiwan's Security Concerns with Respect to Cross-Strait Economic Relations PhD thesis, Department of International Relations, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD
66.
UngerJChanA, 1995, “China, corporatism, and the East Asian model”The Australian Journal of Chinese Affairs3329–53
67.
WalderAG, 1995, “Local governments as industrial firms: An organizational analysis of China's transitional economy”American Journal of Sociology101263–301
68.
WeiYD, 2002, “Beyond the Sunan model: Trajectory and underlying factors of development in Kunshan, China”Environment and Planning A341725–1747
69.
WeiYDFanCC, 2000, “Regional inequality in China: A case study of Jiangsu Province”The Professional Geographer52455–469
70.
WhitingSH, 2001Power and Wealth in Rural China: The Political Economy of Institutional Change (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
71.
WongCPW, 1998, “Fiscal dualism in China: Gradualist reform and the growth of off budget finance”, in Taxation in Modern China Ed. BreanDJS, (Routledge, New York) pp 187–208
72.
WongCPWBhattasaliD, 2003China: National Development and Sub-National FinanceInternational Bank for Reconstruction and Development, The World Bank, Washington, DC
73.
WongCPWHeadyCWooWT, 1995Fiscal Management and Economic Reform in the People's Republic of China (Oxford University Press, Hong Kong)
74.
WooWT, 1999, “The economics and politics of transition to an open market economy: China” TP 153, CD/DOC (99)10, OECD, Paris
75.
World Bank, 1997China 2020 Development Challenges in the New Century (World Bank, Washington, DC)
76.
World Bank, 2001World Development Report 2000/2001 (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
77.
WuF, 2000, “The global and local dimensions of place-making: Remaking Shanghai as a world city”Urban Studies371359–1377
78.
WuF, 2003, “Transitional cities”Environment and Planning A351331–1338
79.
WuFMaLJC, 2005, “The Chinese city in transition—toward theorizing China's urban restructuring”, in Restructuring the Chinese City—Changing Society, Economy and Space Eds MaLJCWuF, (Routledge, London) pp 260–278
80.
WuK, 2000Fei jian she jin ji ji shu kai fa qu [Self-developing economic and technological development zone], in Kunshan kai fa qu shi wu nian [Fifteen Years of Kunshan Development Zone] Ed. Party History Research Office of Kunshan CCP (Ting Lin, Kunshan) pp 131–140
81.
YangMM-H, 2002, “The resilience of Guanxi and its new deployments: A critique of some new Guanxi scholarship”The China Quarterly number 170, 459–476
82.
YangSS, 1991Kunshan zhi lu [The Road of Kunshan] (Jiangsu People's Press, Nanjing)
YehAG-OWuF, 1999, “Urban planning system in China”Progress in Planning5167–252
85.
YeungHW-C, 2000, “Local politics and foreign ventures in China's transitional economy: The political economy of Singaporean investments in China”Political Geography19809–840
86.
ZhangL-Y, 1994, “Location-specific advantages and manufacturing direct foreign investment in South China”World Development2245–53
87.
ZhangL-Y, 1999, “Chinese central—provincial fiscal relationship, budgetary decline and the impact of the 1994 fiscal reform: An evaluation”The Chinese Quarterly number 157, 115–141
88.
ZhangL-Y, 2003, “Economic development in Shanghai and the role of the state”Urban Studies401549–1572
89.
ZhangS, (Ed.), 2004Kunshan fu ming zhi dao [Road to Restore Wealth in People in Kunshan] (Jiangsu Education Publishing House, Nanjing)
90.
ZhaoS, 1994, “China's central—local relationship: A historical perspective”, in Changing Central-Local Relationship in China-reform and State Capacity Eds HaoJLinZ, (Westview Press, Boulder, CO) pp 1–34
91.
ZhuD, 2005jin ji te qu yu zhong quo zheng zhi fa zhang [Special Economic Zone and Political Development in China] (Chongqing, Chongqing)
92.
ZhuJ, 1999, “Local growth coalition: The context and implications of China's gradualist urban land reforms”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research23(3) 1–11
