Beyond their educational function, schools are frequently a focal point for community life. We argue that this latter role was compromised in New Zealand by a decade of neoliberal realignments within education policy. During the 1990s the abolition of school zones, the commodification of education, and the drive for efficiency in the allocation of educational resources undermined the place of school in community life. In this paper we explore the impacts of a school closure on an urban neighbourhood in Invercargill, New Zealand. We present and interpret narratives gathered during an interview-based study of the closure of Surrey Park Primary School. Our analysis highlights parents' perspectives on the role of the educational bureaucracy in the closure debate, the ambiguous role assigned to ‘community’ within the restructured system, the impact of the closure for low-income families, and the place of schools in contributing to the neighbourhood social cohesion. Our analysis concurs with international research suggesting that breaking links between schools and communities has potentially significant educational impacts on children.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BarnettR, 2000, “Rationalising hospital services: reflections on hospital restructuring and its impacts in New Zealand”New Zealand Geographer565–22
2.
BatesR, 1990, “Educational policy and the new cult of efficiency”, New Zealand Education Policy Today: Critical Perspectives Eds MiddletonSCoddJJonesA (Allen and Unwin, Wellington) pp 40–52
3.
BondiL, 1987, “School closures and local politics: the negotiation of primary school rationalization in Manchester”Political Geography Quarterly6203–224
4.
BradfordM, 1995, “Diversification and division in the English education system: towards a post-Fordist model?”Environment and Planning A271595–1612
5.
BrehmJRahnW, 1997, “Individual level evidence for the causes and consequences of social capital”American Journal of Political Science41999–1023
6.
CollinsDKearnsR, 2001, “The safe journeys of an enterprising school: negotiating landscapes of opportunity and risk”Health and Place7293–306
7.
CorkeryM, 1995, “Summary/analysis of consultation meetings with principals and board chairs in Invercargill: Roll trends, accommodation”; copy from Ministry of Education, Dunedin Regional Office, Dunedin
8.
CosterH, 1999, “Community responses to change in rural health service delivery”, masters thesis, Department of New Zealand Studies, University of Auckland, Auckland
9.
DaviesWHerbertD T, 1993Communities Within Cities: An Urban Social Geography (Bellhaven Press, London)
EngEParkerE, 1994, “Measuring community competence in the Mississippi Delta: the interface between program evaluation and implementation”Health Education Quarterly21199–220
12.
EtzioniA, 1997The New Golden Rule: Community and Morality in a Democratic Society (Profile, London)
13.
FiskeELaddH, 2000When Schools Compete: A Cautionary Tale (Brookings Institution Press, Washington, DC)
14.
GibsonAAsthanaS, 2000, “Local markets and the polarization of public-sector schools in England and Wales”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series25303–319
15.
GodwinKSheardW, 2001, “Education reform and the politics of 2000”Publius31111–131
16.
GordonL, 1994, “‘Rich’ and ‘poor’ schools in Aotearoa”New Zealand Journal of Educational Studies29113–125
17.
HargreavesD, 1997, “School culture, school effectiveness and school improvement”, Organizational Effectiveness and Improvement in Education Eds HarrisABennettNPreedyM (Open University Press, Buckingham) pp 239–250
18.
HoganD, 1997, “The social economy of parent choice and the contract state”, The New Contractualism? Eds DavisGSullivanBYeatmanA (Macmillan Education, Melbourne) pp 119–136
19.
HsiehC-LJianpingS, 2001, “Is school choice a mechanism for sustaining change? Implications from a national survey”The Clearing House7588–91
20.
HughesDLauderHWatsonSHamlinJSimiyuI, 1996, “Markets in education: testing the polarisation thesis”, Ministry of Education, Wellington
21.
Infometrics Consulting, 2000, “Economic impact on Invercargill of SIT's proposed zero fees policy”, Southern Institute of Technology, 133 Tay Street, Invercargill, Southland
22.
JosephAKearnsR, 1996, “Deinstitutionalisation meets restructuring: the closure of a psychiatric hospital in New Zealand”Health and Place279–85
23.
KearnsR A, 1991, “The place of health in the health of place: the case of the Hokianga special medical area”Social Science and Medicine33519–530
24.
KearnsR, 1998, “Going it alone: community resistance to health reforms in Hokianga, New Zealand”, Putting Health into Place: Landscape, Identity and Wellbeing Eds KearnsRGeslerW (Syracuse University Press, Syracuse, NY) pp 226–247
25.
KearnsR, 1999, “Seeing the social in infrastructure”New Zealand Planning Quarterly13412–14
26.
KelseyJ, 1997The New Zealand Experiment: A World Model for Structural Adjustment? (Auckland University Press, Auckland)
27.
LefebvreH, 1991The Production of Space (Blackwell, Oxford)
28.
Le HeronRPawsonE, 1996Changing Places: New Zealand in the Nineties (Longman, Auckland)
29.
LewisN, 2000Restructuring Discourse in the New Zealand Restructuring Experience 1984–95: The Practices of the Education Review Officedoctoral thesis, School of Geography and Environmental Science, University of Auckland, Auckland
30.
LewisNMoranW, 1998, “Restructuring, democracy, and geography in New Zealand”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy16127–153
31.
Mac an GhaillM, 1996, “Sociology of education, state schooling and social class: beyond critiques of New Right hegemony”British Journal of Sociology of Education17163–176
32.
McCreanorT, 1996, “Why strengthen the city when the enemy has poisoned the well: an assay on anti-homosexual discourse in New Zealand”Journal of Homosexuality3175–105
33.
MarshallB, 2001, “Including the socially excluded: league tables and Labour's schools policy”Critical Quarterly4329–40
34.
Minister of Education, 1999a, “Final decision on the closure of Surrey Park School”, 17 February (released under the Official Information Act), Ministry of Education, Wellington, New Zealand
35.
Minister of Education, 1999b, “Final decision on the closure of Surrey Park School. Appendix 3—government response to report of the Education and Science Committee on Parliamentary Petition 1996/1403 of Jan Jordan and 5540 others”, 17 February (released under the Official Information Act), Ministry of Education, Wellington
36.
MOE, 1994, “Education development initiative policy framework: redesigning education at the community level”, Ministry of Education, Wellington
37.
MOE, 1997, “Socio-economic indicators for schools”, Ministry of Education, Wellington
38.
NashR, 1994, “Education”, New Zealand Society: A Sociological Introduction Eds SpoonleyPPearsonDShirleyI (Dunmore Press, Palmerston North) pp 161–176
39.
NZ Taskforce to Review Education Administration, 1988, “Administering for excellence: effective administration in education. Report of the Taskforce to Review Education Administration”, NZ Taskforce to Review Education Administration, Wellington
40.
PavlichG, 1999, “Preventing crime: ‘social’ versus ‘community’ governance in Aotearoa/New Zealand”, Governable Places: Readings on Governmentality and Crime Control Ed. SmandychR (Ashgate and Dartmouth, Sydney) pp 102–131
41.
PawsonEScottG, 1992, “The regional consequences of economic restructuring: the West Coast, New Zealand (1984–1991)”Journal of Rural Studies8373–386
42.
PetersM, 1996Poststructuralism, Politics and Education (Bergin and Garvey, Westport, CT)
43.
PetersMMarshallJ, 1996Individualism and Community: Education and Social Policy in the Postmodern Condition (Falmer, London)
44.
PetersMOlssenM, 1999, “Compulsory education in a competition state”, Redesigning the Welfare State in New Zealand: Problems, Policies, Prospects Eds BostonJDalzielPSt JohnS (Oxford University Press, Auckland) pp 177–196
45.
PostmanN, 1995The End of Education: Redefining the Value of School (Knopf, New York)
46.
PotterJWetherellM, 1987Discourse Analysis and Social Psychology: Beyond Attitudes and Behaviour (Sage, London)
47.
RibchesterCEdwardsB, 1999, “The centre and the local: policy and practice in rural education provision”Journal of Rural Studies1549–63
48.
RobertsonS, 1999, “‘Risky business’: market provision, community governance and the individualisation of risk in New Zealand education”International Studies in Sociology of Education9171–191
49.
RobertsonSDaleR, 2000, “Competitive contractualism—a new social settlement in New Zealand education”, World Yearbook of Education 2000: Education in Times of Transition Eds CoulbyDCowanRJonesC (Kogan Page, London) pp 116–131
50.
RoseN, 1999, “Inventiveness in politics”Economy and Society28467–493
51.
SampsonR JMorenoffJ DEarlsF, 1999, “Beyond social capital: Spatial dynamics of collective efficacy for children”Amercian Sociological Review64633–660
52.
SarasonS, 2001American Psychology and Schools: A Critique (Teachers College Press, New York and American Psychological Association, Washington, DC)
53.
SchickA, 1996, “The spirit of reform: managing the New Zealand state sector in a time of change. A report prepared for the State Services Commission and The Treasury, New Zealand”, State Services Commission, Wellington
54.
ScottKKearnsR, 2000, “Coming home: return migration of Maori to Maungakahia Valley, Northland”New Zealand Population Review2621–44
55.
SPPS, 1998, “Rationalisation submission to the Ministry of Education”, Surrey Park School, Invercargill; copy from Ministry of Education, Dunedin Regional Office, Dunedin
56.
Statistics New Zealand, 1997New Zealand Now Series 2: People and Places (Statistics New Zealand, Wellington)
57.
TeddlieCReynoldsD (Eds), 2000The International Handbook of School Effectiveness Research (Falmer Press, New York)
58.
ValenciaR, 1984, “The school closure issue and the Chicano community: a follow-up study of the Los Angeles case”Urban Review16145–163
59.
WatsonSHughesDLauderHStrathdeeRSimiyuI, 1998, “Ethnicity and school choice”New Zealand Annual Review of Education795–110
60.
WeinsteinR, 2001, “Overcoming inequality in schooling: a call to action for community psychology”American Journal of Community Psychology3021–42
61.
WilliamsR, 1961The Long Revolution (Chatto and Windus, London)
62.
WittenKMcCreanorTKearnsRRamasubramanianL, 2001, “The impacts of school closure on neighbourhood social cohesion: narratives from Invercargill, New Zealand”Health and Place7307–317
63.
YoungM, 1971, “On the politics of educational knowledge”, Knowledge and Control: New Directions for the Sociology of Education Ed. YoungM (Collier-Macmillan, London) pp 194–215
