The high level of receipt of disability benefits in the UK was until the 1990s a problem predominantly affecting men. However, the number of women claiming—1.1 million—is now on a similar scale. The decline of heavy industry produced large numbers of men with ill health and limited alternative employment prospects who claimed disability benefits. However, this explanation is problematic for women, who have seen an expansion in employment. We set out a framework that reconciles the central importance of the level of labour demand in explaining worklessness with the paradoxical simultaneous rise of women's employment and receipt of disability benefits. Women claiming disability benefits are overwhelmingly located alongside male claimants in areas where heavy industry has declined, pointing towards linkages between the ‘male’ and ‘female’ sides of the labour market. Additionally, there may be raised knowledge and local acceptance of disability benefits in these locations.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AassveABurgessSPropperCDicksonM, 2006, “Employment, family union and childbearing decisions in Great Britain”Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series A169781–804.
2.
AdkinsL, 1995Gendered Work: Sexuality, Family and the Labour Market (Open University Press, Buckingham, Bucks).
3.
AlcockPBeattyCFothergillSMacmillanRYeandleS, 2003Work to Welfare: How Men Become Detached from the Labour Market (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
4.
BeattyCFothergillS, 2007, “Changes in the profile of men claiming in incapacity benefit: A case study”People, Place and Politics1http://extra/shu.ac.uk/ppp-online/.
5.
BeattyCFothergillSMacmillanR, 2000, “A theory of employment, unemployment and sickness”Regional Studies34617–630.
6.
BeattyCFothergillSGoreTPowellR, 2007a, “The real level of unemployment 2007”, Centre for Regional Economic and Social Research, Sheffield Hallam University, Sheffield.
7.
BeattyCFothergillSPowellR, 2007b, “Twenty years on; has the economy of the UK coalfields recovered?Environment and Planning A391654–1675.
8.
BeattyCFothergillSPowellR, 2008, “Women on incapacity benefits: New survey evidence”, Centre for Regional Economic and Social Research, Sheffield Hallam University; available at http:///www.geographyandgender.org.
9.
BeecheyV, 1987Unequal Work (Verso, London).
10.
BeggIMooreB CRhodesJ, 1986, “Economic and social change in urban Britain and the inner cities”, in Critical Issues in Urban Economic Developmentvolume 1, Ed. HausnerV, (Clarendon Press, Oxford) pp 10–49.
BerthoudR, 2007Work-rich and Work-poor: Three Decades of Change (Policy Press, Bristol).
13.
BerthoudR, 2008, “Disability employment penalties in Britain”Work, Employment and Society22129–148.
14.
BivandP, 2005, “Who are the economically inactive?”, Working Brief 160, Centre for Economic and Social Inclusion, Albert Embankment, London.
15.
BlackBTrainorMSpencerJ E, 1999, “Wage protection systems, segregation and gender pay inequalities: West Germany, the Netherlands and Great Britain”Cambridge Journal of Economics23449–464.
16.
BlackwellL, 2001, “Occupational sex segregation and part-time work in modern Britain”Gender, Work and Organization8160–163.
17.
BradleyH, 1989Men's Work Women's Work: A Sociological History of the Sexual Division of Labour in Employment (Polity Press, Oxford).
18.
BurchellBRuberyJ, 1994, “Divided women: Labour market segmentation and gender segregation”, in Gender Segregation and Social Change Ed. ScottA MacEwen (Oxford University Press, Oxford pp 80–120.
19.
CraigCRuberyJTarlingRWilkinsonF, 1982Labour Market Structure, Industrial Organisation and Low Pay (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
20.
DoeringerP BPioreM J, 1971Internal Labour Markets and Manpower Analaysis (Heath Lexington, Lexington, MA).
21.
DorlingDReesP, 2003, “A nation still dividing: The British census and social polarisation 1971–2001”Environment and Planning A351287–1313.
22.
DWP, 2008Raising Expectations and Increasing Support Reforming Welfare for the FutureDepartment for Work and Pensions (The Stationery Office, London).
23.
FletcherD RGoreTReeveKRobinsonDBashirNGoudieRO'TooleS, 2008Social Housing and Worklessness: Qualitative Research Findings (The Stationery Office, London).
24.
GreenAOwenD, 1991, “Local labour supply and demand interactions in Britain during the 1980s”Regional Studies25295–314.
25.
GreggPWadsworthJ, 1998Unemployment and Non-Employment: Unpacking Economic InactivityEmployment Policy Institute, London.
26.
Gutiérrez-DomènechMBellB, 2004, “Female labour force participation in the United Kingdom: Evolving characteristics or changing behaviour?”, WP 221, Bank of England, London.
27.
HakimC, 1979, “Occupational segregation: A comparative study of the degree and pattern of the differential between men and women's work in Britain and the United States”, RP 9, Department of Employment, London.
HudsonR, 1988, “Labour market changes and new forms of work in ‘old’ industrial regions”, in Uneven Re-development: Cities and Regions in Transition: A Reader Eds MasseyDAllenJ, (Hodder and Stoughton, London) pp 147–166.
30.
KeebleD, 1980, “Industrial decline, regional policy and the urban–rural manufacturing shift in the United Kingdom”Environment and Planning A12945–962.
31.
KempP, 2006, “Comparing trends in disability benefit receipt”, in Sick Societies? Trends in Disability Benefits in Post-industrial Welfare States Eds KempPSundenATauritzB Bakker (International Social Security Association, Geneva) pp 7–22.
32.
McDowellL, 1989, “Gender divisions”, in The Changing Social Structure Eds HamnettCMcDowellLSarreP, (Sage, London) pp 158–198.
33.
McDowellL, 2003Redundant Masculinities: Employment Change and White Working Class Youth (Blackwell, Oxford).
34.
ScottA MacEwen, 1994, “Gender segregation and the SCELI research”, in Gender Segregation and Social Change Ed. ScottA MacEwen (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 1–38.
35.
MacKayR, 1999, “Work and nonwork: A more difficult labour market”Environment and Planning A311919–1934.
36.
MumfordKSmithP N, 2007, “The gender earnings gap in Britain: Including the workplace”Manchester School75653–672.
37.
PowerM, 1983, “From home production to wage labour: Women as a reserve army of labour”Review of Radical Political EconomicsXV71–91.
38.
RobinsonH, 2002, “Wrong side of the track? The impact of the minimum wage on gender pay gaps in Britain”Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics64417–448.
39.
RowthornRWebsterD, 2008, “Male worklessness and the rise of lone parenthood in Britain”Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society169–88.
40.
RuberyJHorrellSBurchellB, 1994, “Part-time work and gender inequality in the labour market”, in Gender Segregation and Social Change Ed. MacEwen ScottA, (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 205–234.
41.
RuberyJSmithMFaganC, 1996Trends and Prospects for Women's Employment in the 1990s (European Commission, Brussels).
42.
SyrettSNorthD, 2008Renewing Neighbourhoods: Work, Enterprise and Governance (Policy Press, Bristol).
TurokIEdgeN, 1999The Jobs Gap in Britain's Cities (Policy Press, Bristol).
45.
WadsworthJ, 1998, “Eyes down for a full house: Labour market polarisation and the housing market in Britain”Scottish Journal of Political Economy45376–392.
46.
WarrenT, 2001, “Divergent female part-time employment in Britain and Denmark and the implications for gender equity”Sociological Review49548–567.
47.
WarrenTWaltersP, 1998, “Appraising a dichotomy: A review of part-time/full-time in the study of women's employment in Britain”Gender Work and Organization5102–118.
