Some 40% of the world's urban poor—living predominantly in informal settlements—lack access to legal electricity. Urban upgradation programmes, if they exist, prioritize water supply over electrification since water is nonsubstitutable and more essential for sustaining human life. Illegal electricity—albeit unreliable, expensive and dangerous—is also already widely available in informal settlements. I share the experiences of the Self-Employed Women's Association and Saath—two nongovermental organizations (NGOs) based in India—of participating in a multiple-stakeholder propoor electrification programme. By 2008 close to 100 000 homes had been electrified in the city of Ahmedabad and the programme is currently being replicated in smaller cities in Gujarat and in the neighbouring state of Rajasthan. I use academic literature on urban infrastructure provision and politics, project reports and evaluations, pricing surveys, and interviews with electricity utility and NGO staff to analyze the programme for its impacts upon access, tariffs, consumption patterns, quality of service, and security of land tenure. The findings indicate that NGOs can be very effective as intermediaries between utilities, municipalities, and urban poor communities. However, scaling up such programmes will require strong state involvement in developing a policy framework to facilitate NGO participation in the design and implementation of propoor electrification activities, and in the energy reform process in general.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AhluwaliaS, 2000, “Power tariff reform in India”Economic and Political Weekly353407–3419
2.
BaconR WBesant-JonesJ, 2001, “Global electric power reform, privatization and liberalization of the electric power industry in developing countries”Annual Review of Energy and the Environment26331–359
3.
BakkerK, 2007, “The ‘commons’ versus the ‘commodity’: Alter-globalization, anti-privatization and the human right to water in the Global South”Antipode39430–455
4.
BanerjeeB, 2002, “Security of tenure of irregular settlements in Visakhapatnam”, in Holding Their Ground: Secure Land Tenure for the Urban Poor in Developing Countries Eds Durand-LasserveARoystonL (Earthscan, London) pp 86–97
5.
BarnesD F, 1997, “Tackling the rural energy problem in developing countries”Finance and Development3411–15
6.
BarnesD FHalpernJ, 2000, “The role of energy subsidies”, in Energy Services for the World's Poor Energy Sector Management Assistance Programme (World Bank, Washington, DC) pp 60–66
7.
BaruahB, 2007a, “Assessment of public-private-NGO partnerships: Water and sanitation services in slums”Natural Resources Forum31226–237
8.
BaruahB, 2007b, “Gendered realities: Exploring property ownership and tenancy relationships in urban India”World Development352096–2109
9.
BatesonG, 1978Steps to an Ecology of Mind (Ballantine, New York)
10.
BaylissKHallD, 2000Privatisation of Water and Energy in AfricaPublic Services International Research Unit, University of Greenwich, London
11.
BhattE, 2006We Are Poor But So Many: The Story of Self-employed Women in India (Oxford University Press, New Delhi)
12.
BlackM, 2008The Last Taboo: Opening the Door on the Global Sanitation Crisis (Earthscan, London)
13.
DubashN K, 2002Power Politics: Equity and Environment in Electricity Reform (World Resources Institute, Washington, DC)
14.
FabriciusD, 2008, “Resisting representation: The informal geographies of Rio de Janeiro”Harvard Design Magazine285
15.
FergusonRWilkinsonWHillR, 2000, “Electricity use and economic development”Energy Policy28923–934
16.
FlavinCHull AeckM, 2006Energy for Development: The Potential Role for Renewable Energy in Meeting Millennium Development Goals (Worldwatch Institute, Washington, DC)
17.
GandyM, 2005, “Cyborg urbanization: Complexity and monstrosity in the contemporary city”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research2926–49
18.
GhanadanR, 2004, “Electricity reform in developing and transition countries: A Reappraisal”Energy31815–844
19.
GhanadanR, 2009, “Connected geographies and struggles over access: Electricity commercialization in Tanzania”, in Electric Capitalism: Recolonizing Africa on the Power Grided.McDonaldD A (Earthscan, London) pp 400–436
20.
GilbertA, 2007, “Water for all: How to combine public management with commercial practice to the benefit of the poor?”Urban Studies441574
21.
GrahamS, 2000, “Constructing premium networked spaces: Reflection on infrastructure networks and contemporary urban development”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research24183–200
22.
GrahamS, 2010, “When infrastructures fail”, in Disrupted Cities: When Infrastructure Fails Ed. GrahamS (Routledge, New York) pp 1–26
23.
GrahamSMarvinS, 2001Splintering Urbanism: Networked Infrastructure, Technological Mobilities and the Urban Condition (Routledge, London)
24.
GulyaniSBassettE M, 2007, “Retrieving the baby from the bathwater: Slum upgrading in Sub-Saharan Africa”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy25486–515
25.
GulyaniSBassettE M, 2008, “Revisiting… Retrieving the baby from the bathwater: Slum upgrading in Sub-Saharan Africa”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy26858–860
26.
HaPPorcaroJ, 2005, “Energy and the millennium development goals: The impact of rural energy services on development”Journal of International Affairs58193–209
27.
HallDLethbridgeJLobinaE, 2005Public – Public Partnerships in Health and Essential ServicesMunicipal Services Project, Cape Town
28.
HuntS, 2002Making Competition Work in Electricity (John Wiley, New York)
29.
KessidesI, 2004Reforming Infrastructure: Privatization, Regulation and Competition (World Bank, Washington, DC)
30.
KunduAMahadeviaD, 2002Poverty and Vulnerability in a Globalizing Metropolis: Ahmedabad (Manak Publications, New Delhi)
31.
McCarthyJ, 2005, “Commons as counter-hegemonic projects”Capitalism Nature Socialism169–24
32.
McDonaldD A, 2009a, “Electric capitalism: Conceptualizing electricity and capital accumulation in (South) Africa”, in Electric Capitalism: Recolonizing Africa on the Power Grid Ed. McDonaldD A (Earthscan, London) pp 1–49
33.
McDonaldD A, 2009b, “Conclusion: Alternative electricity paths for southern Africa”, in Electric Capitalism: Recolonizing Africa on the Power Grid Ed. McDonaldD A (Earthscan, London) pp 437–453
34.
McFarlaneC, 2010, “Infrastructure, interruption, and inequality: Urban life in the global South”, in Disrupted Cities: When Infrastructure Fails Ed. GrahamS (Routledge, New York) pp 131–144
RobbinsP, 2003, “Transnational corporations and the discourse of water privatization”Journal of International Development151073–1082
39.
RoseK, 1992Where Women are Leaders: The SEWA Movement in India (Zed Books, London)
40.
SEA, 2006State of Energy in South African Cities: Setting a BaselineSustainable Energy Africa, Cape Town
41.
UN Energy, 2005The Energy Challenge for Achieving the Millennium Development Goals (United Nations, New York)
42.
UN Habitat, 2007State of the World's Cities (UN Habitat, Nairobi, Kenya)
43.
USAID, 2004Innovative Approaches to Slum ElectrificationUnited States Agency for International Development, Washington, DC
44.
VeriavaANgwaneT, 2004, “Strategies and tactics: Movements in the neo-liberal transition”, in Development Update 5: Mobilizing for Change. The Rise of the New Social Movements in South Africa Eds McKinleyDNaidooP (Interfund, Johannesburg) pp 129–145
45.
Waddams PriceC, 2000, “Better energy services, better energy sectors—and links with the poor”, in Energy Services for the World's Poor Energy Sector Management Assistance Programme (World Bank, Washington DC) pp 26–32
