Water is not only a valuable substance, but is also valued in different ways dependent on substantive social, ecological, and historical conditions. The concept of water value positionality is introduced to describe the dynamic ensemble of meanings forged from cooperation and competition in the allocation, use, and conservation of water. Positionality helps us to understand water conflicts as individuals and groups struggling to legitimise their valuation of water. The explanatory function of positionality is demonstrated with an empirical case study in the metropolitan region of Rio de Janeiro. Hegemonic positionality depicts water as an economic resource required for regional development and urban growth. This has been increasingly challenged by sectors of the state apparatus who call for the monetary valuation of water. Beyond these two perspectives, there exists a vast range of water values articulated by the local communities in their struggle for survival and political affirmation. The conclusion is that, in the process of constantly revaluing water, there are temporary ‘positions of value’ that last and change with sociocultural and politicoecological experiences.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbreuM, 1988Evolução Urbana do Rio de Janeiro (IplanRio, Rio de Janeiro)
2.
AmadorE, 1992, “Baia de Guanabara: Urn balanço histórico”, inNatureza e Sociedade no Rio de Janeiro Ed. AbreuM, (Secretaria Municipal de Cultura, Turismo e Transporte, Rio de Janeiro), pp 201–257
3.
AnandaJHerathG, 2003, “Incorporating stakeholder values into regional forest planning: A value function approach”Ecological Economics4575–90
4.
AppaduraiA, 1986, “Introduction: Commodities and the politics of value”, inThe Social Life of Things: Commodities in Cultural Perspective Ed. AppaduraiA, (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge), pp 3–64
5.
BachelardG, 1942L'Eau et les Rêves (Librarie José Corti, Paris)
6.
BrennanT, 1997, “Economy for the Earth: The labour theory of value without the subject/object distinction”Ecological Economics20175–185
7.
BrownTBergstromJLoomisJ, 2007, “Defining, valuing, and providing ecosystem goods and services”Natural Resources Journal47329–376
8.
ButlerJ, 1997Excitable Speech: A Politics of Performative (Routledge, New York)
9.
ChackoE, 2004, “Positionality and praxis: Fieldwork experiences in rural India”Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography2551–63
10.
CIDE, 2005Baixada em Dados (Centro de Informações e Dados, Rio de Janeiro)
11.
DaniereA GTakahashiL M, 1997, “Environmental policy in Thailand: Values, attitudes, and behavior among the slum dwellers of Bangkok”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy15305–327
12.
Darling-WolfF, 2004, “On the possibility of communicating: Feminism and social position”Journal of Communication Inquiry2829–46
13.
DermanBFergusonA, 2003, “Value of water: Political ecology and water reform in Southern Africa”Human Organization62277–288
14.
DeutschN L, 2004, “Positionality and the pen: Reflections on the process of becoming a feminist researcher and writer”Qualitative Inquiry10885–902
15.
EkersMLoftusA, 2008, “The power of water: Developing dialogues between Foucault and Gramsci”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space26698–718
16.
FadelS, 2009Meio Ambiente, Saneamento e Engenharia no Império e na Primeira República (Garamond, Rio de Janeiro)
17.
FreireP, 1996Pedagogy of the Oppressed (Penguin, London)
18.
GhoshNBandyopadhyayJ, 2009, “A scarcity value based explanation of trans-boundary water disputes: The case of the Cauvery River Basin in India”Water Policy11141–167
19.
GibbsL, 2006, “Valuing water: Variability and the Lake Eyre Basin, central Australia”Australian Geographer3773–85
20.
GibbsL M, 2010, “‘A beautiful soaking rain’: Environmental value and water beyond Eurocentrism”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space28363–378
21.
GoesH, 1934Relatório Apresentado pelo Engenheiro Chefe da Comissão de Saneamento da Baixada Fluminense (MVOP, Rio de Janeiro)
22.
Government of the State of Rio de Janeiro, 2005Piano Diretor de Recursos Hídricos da Região Hidrográfica da Baía de Guanabara (Consórcio Ecologus-Agrar, Rio de Janeiro)
23.
GraeberD, 2001Toward an Anthropological Theory of Value: The False Coins of our Own Dreams (Palgrave, New York)
24.
GramachoA, 2006, “A ponte da discórdia: Uma disputa entre os barqueiros do Rio Iguaçu e a Ferrovia no final do Século XIX”Revista Eletrónica do Instituto Históricohttp://www.cmdc.rj.gov.br/base.asp?area=revista
25.
GregoryRSlovicP, 1997, “A constructive approach to environmental valuation”Ecological Economics21175–181
26.
GruenL, 2002, “Refocusing environmental ethics: From intrinsic value to endorsable valuations”Philosophy and Geography5153–164
27.
HarawayD, 1991Simians, Cyborgs, and Women: The Reinvention of Nature (Free Association Books, London)
28.
HarribeyJ-M, 2005, “Richesse et valeur: Un couple qui ne fait pas bon ménage”Homme et la Société156–15727–46
29.
HarveyD, 1996Justice, Nature and the Geography of Difference (Blackwell, Oxford)
30.
HarveyD, 2006The Limits to CapitalNew edition (Verso, London)
31.
HuberM, 2009, “The use of gasoline: Value, oil, and the ‘American way of life’”Antipode41465–486
32.
IorisA A R, 2007, “The troubled waters of Brazil: Nature commodification and social exclusion”Capitalism Nature Socialism1828–50
33.
IorisA A R, 2009, “Desenvolvimento nacional e gestão de recursos hídricos no Brasil”Revista Crítica de Ciências Sociais8523–41
34.
IorisA A R, 2010, “The political nexus between water and economics in Brazil: A critique of recent policy reforms”Review of Radical Political Economics42231–250
35.
IorisA A RCostaM A M, 2009, “The challenge to revert unsustainable trends: Uneven development and water degradation in the Rio de Janeiro Metropolitan Area”Sustainability1133–160
36.
JacksonS, 2006, “Compartmentalising culture: The articulation and consideration of indigenous values in water resource management”Australian Geographer3719–31
37.
KingR, 2003, “Toward an ethics of the domesticated environment”Philosophy and Geography63–14
38.
LefebvreH, 1972The Sociology of Marx (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx)
39.
LintonJ, 2010What is Water? The History of a Modern Abstraction (University of British Columbia Press, Vancouver, BC)
40.
LovettJ C, 2001, “Ownership of environmental values and opportunity costs”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy19681–693
41.
McAfeeK, 1999, “Selling nature to save it? Biodiversity and green developmentalism”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space17133–154
42.
MarquesE, 1999, “Social networks and institutions in the construction of the state and its permeability”Revista Brasileira de Ciências Sociais14(41) 45–67
43.
MarxK, 1976Capital: A Critique of Political Economyvolume 1 (Vintage, New York)
44.
MiltonK, 1997“Ecologies: Anthropology, culture and the environment”International Social Science Journal49(154) 476–495
45.
MoserS, 2008, “Personality: A new positionality?”Area40383–392
46.
NortonBSteinmannA, 2001, “Environmental values and adaptive management”Environmental Values10473–506
47.
O'ConnorJ, 1998Natural Causes: Essays in Ecological Marxism (Guilford, New York)
48.
PaavolaJ, 2007, “Institutions and environmental governance: A reconceptualization”Ecological Economics6393–103
49.
PérardE, 2009, “Water supply: Public or private? An approach based on cost of funds, transaction costs, efficiency and political costs”Policy and Society27193–219
50.
RenoJ, 2009, “Your trash is someone's treasure: The politics of value at a Michigan landfill”Journal of Material Culture1429–46
51.
RobertsA, 2008, “Privatizing social reproduction: The primitive accumulation of water in an era of neoliberalism”Antipode40535–560
52.
RobertsonM, 2007, “Discovering price in all the wrong places: The work of commodity definition and price under neoliberal environmental policy”Antipode39500–526
53.
RoseG, 1997, “Situating knowledges: Positionality, reflexivity and other tactics”Progress in Human Geography21305–320
54.
RowlandsM, 2005, “Value and the cultural transmission of things”, inCommodification: Things, Agency, and Identities Eds van BinsbergenWGeschiereP, (Lit, Münster) pp 267–281
55.
ScruggsL, 1998, “Political and economic inequality and the environment”Ecological Economics26259–275
56.
SheehanJ, 2005, “The commodification of the Asian commons: Water as a property right”Asia Pacific Journal of Environmental Law987–104
57.
SpashC L, 2008, “Contingent valuation design and data treatment: If you can't shoot the messenger, change the message”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy2634–53
58.
SwyngedouwE, 2004Social Power and the Urbanization of Water: Flows of Power (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
59.
van HoutvenGPowersJPattanayakS K, 2007, “Valuing water quality improvements in the United States using meta-analysis: Is the glass half-full or half-empty for national policy analysis?”Resource and Energy Economics29206–228
