Despite the fact that mainstreaming of climate change into existing EU sectoral policies is a key aim, empirical knowledge of how it works in practice remains scarce. With this paper we explore the degree to which climate considerations are taken into account in the implementation of one of the most influential pieces of European water legislation, the Water Framework Directive and, more importantly, we assess possible explanations for the geographical variability in levels of mainstreaming observed. Our empirical research is based on an analysis of both EU and local policy documents, as well as more than forty in-depth interviews, and shows that, for various reasons, the degree of mainstreaming that has taken place differs widely. We conclude that timely incentives and clear guidance will be necessary to ensure progress is made by all, but that a residual fear that the adaptation agenda is open to abuse by those seeking to rationalise failures to fully implement the Water Framework Directive has put a brake on the mainstreaming agenda.
Agenda Catalana de l'Aigua, Department de Medi Ambient i Habitatge, Agènda Catalana de l'Aigua and Generalitat de Catalunya, Barcelona
2.
2008, “Water in Catalonia. Diagnosis and proposed actions: Significant water issues raised within the compilation of the River Basin Management Plan for Catalonia”
3.
2009aPla de gestió de l'aigua de Catalunya
4.
2009bAigua i Canvi Climàtic: Diagnosi dels inpactes previstos a Catalunya
5.
AhmadI H, 2009, “Climate policy integration: Towards operationalization”, DESA WP73ST/ESA/2009/DWP/73, United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs, http://www.un.org/esa/desa/papers/2009/wp73_2009.pdf
6.
Autorità di bacino del fiume Po, 2010Piano di Gestione del Distretto Idrografico del Fiume Po, Relazione GenerateParma
7.
BazzaniG MGalleraniVViaggiDRaggiMBartoliniF, 2004, “The sustainability of irrigated agriculture in Italy under water and agricultural policy scenarios”, paper presented at the 9th Joint Conference on Food, Agriculture, and the Environment, University of Padua, Conegliano, http://www.tesaf.unipd.it/minnesota/It/Bazzani-et-al.pdf
8.
BlackstockK LDunglinsonJMatthewsK BDilleyRFutterM, 2009, “Climate proofing Scottish river basin planning: A future challenge”Environmental Policy and Governance19374–387
9.
BlomquistWTonderskiADinarA, 2005, “Institutional and policy analysis of river basin management: The Warta river basin, Poland”, WP WPS 3528, World Bank, Washington, DC
CollierU, 1994Energy and Environment in the European Union: The Challenge of Integration (Avebury, Aldershot, Hants)
12.
Deloitte, IEEP, 2011Support to Fitness Check Water Policy Deloitte Consulting and Institute for European Environmental Policy (European Commission—General Directorate Environment, Brussels)
2000, “Directive 2000/60/EC of the European Parliament and of the council of 23 October 2000 establishing a framework for Community action in the field of water policy (Water Framework Directive)”Official Journal of the European CommunitiesL3271–72, 22 December
16.
2007, “Directive 2007/60/EC of the European Parliament and of the council of 23 October 2007 on the assessment and management of flood risks (Floods Directive)”Official Journal of the European CommunitiesL28827–34, 6 November
2009b, “Commission staff working document accompanying the white paper: Adapting to Climate Change: Towards a European Framework for Action” [COM(2009) 147 final]Commission of the European Communities, Brussels, http://www.eurosfaire.prd.fr/7pc/doc/1264761288_sec_2009_386_en.pdf
EEA, 2009, “Report on good practice measures for climate change adaptation in river basin management plans”, EEA/ADS/06/001: Version 3.0, European Environment Agency, Copenhagen
21.
HammerMBalforsBMörtbergUPeterssonMQuinA, 2011, “Governance of water resources in the phase of change: A case study of the implementation of the EU Water Framework Directive in Sweden”AMBIO: A Journal of the Human Environment40210–220
22.
HendryS, 2008, “River basin management and the Water Framework Directive: In need of a little help?”Water Law19150–156
23.
HeyC, 2002, “Why does environmental policy integration fail? The case of environmental taxation for heavy goods vehicles”, in Environmental Policy Integration: Greening Sectoral Policies in Europe Ed. LenschowA (Earthscan, London) pp 127–152
24.
HopkinJ, 2002, “Comparative methods”, in Theory and Methods in Political Science Eds MarshDStokerG (Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants) pp 249–270
25.
JordanALenschowA, 2010, “Environmental policy integration: A state of the art review”Environmental Policy and Governance20147–158
26.
JordanAHuitemaDVan AsseltHRaynerTBerkhoutF, (Eds) 2010Climate Change Policy in the European Union: Confronting the Dilemmas of Mitigation and Adaptation (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
27.
KaikaM, 2003, “The Water Framework Directive: A new directive for a changing social, political and economic European framework”European Planning Studies11299–316
28.
KeskitaloE C H, 2010, “Introduction. Adaptation to climate change in Europe: Theoretical framework and study design”, in Developing Adaptation Policy and Practice in Europe: Multi-level Governance of Climate Change Eds CarinaEKeskitaloH (Springer, Dordrecht) pp 1–38
29.
KleinR J TSchipperE LDessaiS, 2005, “Integrating mitigation and adaptation into climate and development policy: Three research questions”Environmental Science and Policy8579–588
30.
KrysanovaVKundzewiczZ WPińskwarIHabeckAHattermannF, 2006, “Regional socioeconomic and environmental changes and their impacts on water resources on example of Odra and Elbe basins”Water Resource Management20607–641
31.
KundzewiczZ W, 2007, “Climate change impacts on water management and adaptation needs in Europe”, in Proceedings of the Workshop on Climate Change Impacts on Water Cycle, Resources and QualityBrussels, 25–26 September 2006, pp 106–110
32.
KundzewiczZ W, 2011, “Nonstationarity in water resources: Central European perspective”Journal of the American Water Resources Association47550–562
33.
Länsstyrelsen Västmanlands Iän, 2009Förvaltningsplan för Norra Östersjöns vattendistrikt 2009–2015 Västerås
34.
LindblomP, 2007, “Poland”, in The Water Framework Directive in the Baltic Sea Region Countries: Vertical Implementation, Horizontal Integration and Transnational Cooperation Eds HedinSDuboisAIkonenRLindblomPNilssonSTynkkynenVViehhauserMLeiskUVeidemaneK (Nordregio, Stockholm) pp 121–129
35.
MasseyEHuitemaDJordanARaynerT, 2010, “Adaptation in the water sector: Will mainstreaming be sufficient?”, in Climate Change Policy in the European Union: Confronting the Dilemmas of Mitigation and Adaptation Eds JordanAHuitemaDVan AsseltHRaynerTBerkhoutF (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 167–185
36.
MeijerinkSHuitemaD, 2010, “Policy entrepreneurs and change strategies: Lessons from sixteen case studies of water transitions around the globs”Ecology and Society15(2) 1–19
37.
MeijerinkSWieringM, 2009, “River basin management in Europe: The ‘up- and downloading’ of a new policy discourse”, in The Disoriented State: Shifts in Governmentality Territoriality and Governance Eds ArtsBLagendijkAVan HoutumH (Springer, Dordrecht) pp 181–200
38.
MickwitzPAixFBeckSCarssDFerrandNGörgCJensenAKivimaaPKuhlickeCKuindersmaWMáñezMMelanenMMonniSPedersenA BReinertHVan BommelS, 2009, “Climate policy integration, coherence and governance, RR2, Partnership for European Environmental Research Report, http://edepot.wur.nl/3987
39.
OlhoffASchaerC, 2010“Screening tools and guidelines to support the mainstreaming of climate change adaptation into development assistance: A stocktaking report”, United Nations Development Program, New York
40.
PageB, 2003, “The Water Framework Directive: A new directive for a changing social, political and economic European framework”European Planning11299–316
41.
PageBKaikaM, 2003, “The EU water framework directive: Part 2. Policy innovation and the shifting choreography of governance”European Environment13328–343
PerssonAKleinR J T, 2009, “Mainstreaming adaptation to climate change in official development assistance: Challenges to foreign policy integration”, in Climate Change and Foreign Policy: Case Studies from East to West Ed. HarrisP (Routledge, London) 162–177
44.
PollackMAHafner-BurtonE M, 2010, “Mainstreaming international governance: The environment, gender, and IO performance in the European Union”Review of International Organizations5285–313
45.
RaynerTJordanA, 2010, “Adapting to a changing climate: An emerging European Union policy?”, in A J Jordan, D Huitema, H van Asselt, T Rayner, F BerkhoutClimate Change Policy in the European Union (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 145–166
SEPA, 2009bThe River Basin Management Plan for the Scotland River Basin District 2009–2015: Strategic Environmental Assessment StatementScottish Environment Protection Agency, http://www.sepa.org.uk/water/river_basin_planning.aspx
50.
SwartRRaesF, 2007, “Making integration of adaptation and mitigation work: Mainstreaming into sustainable development policies?”Climate Policy7288–303
UrwinKJordanA, 2008, “Does public policy support or undermine climate change adaptation? Exploring policy interplay across different scales of governance”Global Environmental Change18180–191
53.
UNESCO, 2009, “The Po iver basin: Italy”, in Facing the Challenges: Case Study Volume (United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization, Paris) pp 51–54
54.
Van BommelSKuindersmaW, 2008Policy Integration, Coherence and Governance in Dutch Climate Policy: A Multi-level Analysis of Mitigation and Adaptation Policy report 1799, Alterra, Wageningen
55.
VeraartJWesteinE, 2005De klimaatdimensie van de Kaderrichtlijn WaterAlterra, Wageningen
56.
WilbyR LOrrH GHedgerMForrowDBlackmoreM, 2006, “Risks posed by climate change to the delivery of Water Framework Directive objectives in the UK”Environment International321043–1055
57.
WrightJHorvathBWilbyR, 2011, “River basin management in a changing climate”, in The Water Framework Directive, Action Programmes and Adaptation to Climate Change Eds QuevauvillerPBorchersUThompsonK CSimonartT (Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge) pp 17–33
