Networks have rapidly become the dominant trope in governance theory and practice. While scholarship highlights important benefits, there has been insufficient systematic interrogation of the potential pathologies in network governance. This paper addresses the lacuna. We begin by discussing different kinds of network analysis and distinguishing the specific claims of network governance theory. We then pull together the scattered critically oriented literatures on the topic, identifying major problems with network modes of governance: hypocrisy, distrust, marketization, subjugation, antiproceduralism, fragmentation, and ‘netsploitation’. We finally argue for a more agnostic approach to governance research, capable of taking account of these pathologies and thereby putting networks in their place. This means avoiding the fetishization of particular modes of governance and giving more careful attention to the settings in which they each can be useful.
AddicottRMcGivernGFerlieE, 2007, “The distortion of managerial technique: The case of UK cancer networks”British Journal of Management1893–105
2.
AlonsoL-E, 2001, “New myths and old practices: Postmodern management discourse and the decline of Fordist industrial relations”Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research7268–288
3.
AtkinsonW, 2007, “Beck, individualization and the death of class: A critique”British Journal of Sociology58349–366
4.
BangH, 2011, “The politics of threat: Late modern politics in the shadow of neoliberalism”Critical Policy Studies5434–448
5.
BaumanZ, 2002, “Foreword: Individually, together”, in Individualization: Institutionalized Individualism and its Social and Political Consequences Ed. BeckU, (Sage, London) pp xiv–xix
6.
BaumanZ, 2003Liquid Love: On the Frailty of Human Bonds (Polity Press, Cambridge)
7.
BeckU, 1992Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity (Polity Press, Cambridge)
8.
BensonJ K, 1977, “Organisations: A dialectical view”Administrative Science Quarterly22(1) 1–21
9.
BentleyTHalpernD, 2003, “21st century citizenship”, in The Progressive Manifesto Ed. GiddensA, (Policy Network, London) pp 73–96
10.
BevirMRhodesR A W, 2006Governance Stories (Routledge, London)
11.
BogasonPMussoJ A, 2006, “The democratic prospects of network governance”The American Review of Public Administration363–18
12.
BoltanskiLChiapelloE, 2006 [1999] The New Spirit of Capitalism (Verso, London)
13.
BorgattiS PMehraABrassD JLabiancaG, 2009, “Network analysis in the social sciences”Science323(5916) 892–895
14.
BrassD JGalaskiewiczJGreveH RTsaiW, 2004, “Taking stock of networks and organizations: A multi-level perspective”Academy of Management Journal47795–817
15.
BrunssonNAdlerN, 1989The Organization of Hypocrisy: Talk, Decisions and Actions (Wiley, New York)
CookKHardinRLeviM, 2007Cooperation without Trust? (Russell Sage Foundation, New York)
21.
CrouchC, 2005Capitalist Diversity and Change: Recombinant Governance and Institutional Entrepreneurs (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
22.
CrouchC, 2011The Strange Non-death of Neoliberalism (Polity Press, Cambridge)
23.
DaviesJ S, 2007, “The limits of partnership: An exit-action strategy for local democratic inclusion”Political Studies55779–800
24.
DaviesJ S, 2011Challenging Governance Theory: From Networks to Hegemony (Policy Press, Bristol)
25.
DaviesJ S, 2012, “Network governance theory: A Gramscian critique”Environment and Planning A442687–2704
26.
DaviesJ SPillM, 2012, “Hollowing out neighbourhood governance? Re-scaling revitalization in Baltimore and Bristol”Urban Studies492199–2217
27.
DeanJ, 2002Publicity's Secret (Cornell University Press, New York)
28.
Du GayP, 2000In Praise of Bureaucracy: Weber, Organization, Ethics (Sage, London)
29.
Du GayP, 2003, “The tyranny of the epochal: Change, epochalism and organizational reform”Organization10663–684
30.
FrancesJLevačićRMitchellJThompsonG F, 1991, “Introduction”, in Markets, Hierarchies and Networks: The Coordination of Social Life Eds ThompsonG FFrancesJLevačićRMitchellJ, (Open University Press, Milton Keynes, Bucks) pp 1–20
31.
FungAWrightE O, 2001, “Deepening democracy: Innovations in empowered participatory governance”Politics and Society295–41
32.
GiddensA, 1994Beyond Left and Right: The Future of Radical Politics (Polity Press, Cambridge)
33.
GilchristA, 2009A Networking Approach to Community Development2nd edition (Policy Press, Bristol)
34.
GroteJ R, 2012, “Horizontalism, vertical integration and vertices in governance networks”Stato e Mercato94103–134
35.
GuarnerosV, 2008, “Local governance in Mexico: The case of two historic-centre partnerships”Urban Studies451011–1035
36.
HardtMNegriA, 2000Empire (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
37.
HardtMNegriA, 2005Multitude: War and Democracy in the Age of Empire (Penguin, New York)
38.
HarveyD, 1978, “The urban process under capitalism: A framework for analysis”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research2101–131
IsettK RMergelI ALeRouxKMischenP ARethemeyerK, 2011, “Networks in public administration scholarship: Understanding where we are and where we need to go”Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory21i157–i173
41.
JessopB, 2007State Power (Polity Press, Cambridge)
42.
JonesCHesterlyW SBorgattiS P, 1997, “A general theory of network governance: Exchange conditions and social mechanisms”The Academy of Management Review22911–945
43.
KilduffMTsaiW, 2003Social Networks and Organizations (Sage, London)
44.
LaclauEMouffeC, 2001Hegemony and Socialist Strategy2nd edition (Verso, London)
45.
LawlessP, 2004, “Locating and explaining area-based urban initiatives: New deal for communities in England”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy22383–399
46.
MarshD, 2011, “The new orthodoxy: The differentiated polity model”Public Administration8932–48
47.
MarshDRhodesR A W, 1992Policy Networks in British Government (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
48.
MasonP, 2012Why it's Kicking Off Everywhere: The New Global Revolutions (Verso, London)
49.
MathurNSkelcherCSmithM, 2005, “The public governance of collaborative spaces: Discourse, design and democracy”Public Administration83573–596
50.
MessnerD, 1997The Network Society: Economic Development and International Competitiveness (Frank Cass, London)
51.
MoranM, 2010, “Policy-making in an interdependent world”, in New Directions in Political Science Ed. HayC, (Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants) pp 25–42
52.
NewmanJ, 2004, “Modernizing the state: A new style of governance?”, in Welfare State Change: Towards a Third Way? Eds LewisJSurenderR, (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 69–88
53.
OffeCKeaneJ, 1985Disorganised Capitalism: Contemporary Transformation of Work and Politics (MIT Press, Boston, MA)
54.
PedersenASehestedKSørensenE, 2011, “Emerging theoretical understandings of pluricentric coordination in public governance”American Review of Public Administration41375–394
55.
PioreM JSabelC F, 1984The Second Industrial Divide (Basic Books, New York)
56.
PodolnyJ MPageK L, 1998, “Network forms of organization”Annual Review of Sociology2457–76
57.
PolanyiK, 1944The Great Transformation (Beacon Press, Boston, MA)
58.
PowellW W, 1990, “Neither hierarchy nor market: Network forms of organization”Research in Organizational Behavior12295–336
59.
RhodesR A W, 1997aUnderstanding Governance: Policy Networks, Governance, Reflexivity and Accountability (Open University Press, Milton Keynes, Bucks)
60.
RhodesR, 1997b, “From marketisation to diplomacy: It's the mix that matters”Australian Journal of Public Administration5640–53
61.
RhodesR A W, 2000, “Governance and public administration”, in Debating Governance Ed. PierreJ, (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 54–90
62.
RhodesR A W, 2011, “Thinking on: A career in public administration”Public Administration89196–212
63.
RichardsonJ, 2000, “Government, interest groups and policy change”Political Studies481006–1025
64.
SørensenETorfingJ, 2009, “Making governance networks effective and democratic through metagovernance”Public Administration87234–258
65.
StokerG, 1998, “Governance as theory: Five propositions”International Social Science Journal15517–28
66.
StokerG, 2002, “Life is a lottery: New Labour's strategy for the reform of devolved governance”Public Administration80417–434
67.
StokerG, 2004Transforming Local Governance: From Thatcherism to New Labour (Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants)
68.
StokerG, 2011, “Was local governance such a good idea? A global comparative perspective”Public Administration8915–31
69.
ThompsonG F, 2003Between Hierarchies and Markets: The Logic and Limits of Network Forms of Organization (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
