The Geographies of Policy Translation: How Nudge Became the Default Policy Option

Abstract

This paper examines the emergence of libertarian paternalism or ‘nudge’ as a rationale of government in the UK and charts the way in which this development has been enabled by, and has enabled, a process of policy translation. We examine: the reasons for the emergence of libertarian paternalism in the UK; the processes that have enabled libertarian paternalism to become a significant way of framing policy in the UK for both the New Labour and the Coalition administrations; the way in which this set of policy initiatives has been predicated upon a process of social and spatial embedding that has seen it become interpreted as a meaningful and default solution to a whole host of social ills. We conclude by arguing that there is a need to appreciate both the political malleability of libertarian paternalism as a concept and the complex geographies that have enabled it to assume political significance in the UK.

Keywords

policy translation policy transfer libertarian paternalism UK

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bastagli

, 2008, “Conditionality in public policy targeted to the poor: Promoting resilience?” Social Policy and Society 8 127–140.

BIT, Behavioural Insights Team, London.

2010 Applying Behavioural Insight to Health Cabinet Office, London.

2011a Behaviour Change and Energy Use Cabinet Office, London.

2011b Better Choices: Better Deals. Consumers Powering Growth Cabinet Office and Department for Business, Innovation and Skills, London.

Cialdini

R B

, 2007 [1984] Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion (HarperCollins, New York).

Clarke

, 2009, “In what sense ‘spaces of neoliberalism’? The new localism, the new politics of scale, and town twinning” Political Geography 28 496–507.

Clarke

, 2012, “Urban policy mobility, anti-politics and the histories of the transnational municipal movement” Progress in Human Geography 31 25–43.

Czarniawska-Joerges

Sevón

, 1996 Translating Organizational Change (Walter de Gruyter, New York).

10.

Dean

, 2003, “The third way and social welfare: The myth of post-emotionalism” Social Policy and Administration 37 659–708.

11.

Defra, 2007 A Framework for Pro-environmental Behaviours Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, London.

12.

Devine

, 2007 Feel Bad Britain (Compass, London).

13.

DH, Department of Health, London.

14.

2004 Choosing Health: Making Healthy Choices Easier (The Stationery Office, London).

15.

2010a, “A new approach to public health”, speech by Andrew Lansley on 7 July 2010, http://www.dh.gov.uk/en/MediaCentre/Speeches/DH_117280.

16.

2010b Healthy Lives, Healthy People: Our Strategy for Public Health in England Cm 7985 (The Stationery Office, London).

17.

Dolan

Hallsworth

Halpern

King

Vlaev

, 2010 MINDSPACE: Influencing Behaviour Through Public Policy Institute for Government and Cabinet Office, London.

18.

Dolowitz

D P

Marsh

, 1996, “Who learns what from whom? A review of the policy transfer literature” Political Studies 44 343–357.

19.

Dolowitz

D P

Marsh

, 2000, “Learning from abroad: The role of policy transfer in contemporary policy-making” Governance: An International Journal of Policy and Administration 13 5–24.

20.

DoT, 2007 Manual for Streets Department of Transport (Thomas Telford, London).

21.

DWP, 2006 Personal Accounts: A New Way to Save Cm 6975, Department for Work and Pensions (The Stationery Office, London).

22.

Evans

Davies

, 1999, “Understanding policy transfer: A multi-level, multi-disciplinary perspective” Public Administration 77 361–385.

23.

Freeman

, 2009, “What is translation?” Evidence and Policy 5 429–447.

24.

Gilbert

, 2002 The Transformation of the Welfare State: The Silent Surrender of Public Responsibility (Oxford University Press, Oxford).

25.

Gordenker

Weiss

T G

, 1996, “Pluralising global governance: Analytical approaches and dimensions”, in NGOs, the UN, and Global Governance Eds Weiss

T G

Gordenker

(Lynne Rienner, Boulder, CO) pp 17–47.

26.

Haas

E B

, 1990 When Knowledge is Power: Three Models of Change in International Organizations (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA).

27.

Halpern

Bates

Mulgan

Aldridge

Beales

Heathfield

, 2004 Personal Responsibility and Changing Behaviour: The State of Knowledge and its Implications for Public Policy Cabinet Office, London.

28.

HoL, 2011 Report on the House of Lords' Inquiry into Behaviour Change HL paper 179, House of Lords, Science and Technology Select Committee (The Stationery Office, London).

29.

Hulme

, 2005, “Policy transfer and the internationalisation of social policy” Social Policy and Society 4 417–425.

30.

IEA, 2005 The Brit-irresponsibles Institute of Economic Affairs, London.

31.

IPPR, 2007 States of Reason: Freedom, Responsibility and the Governing of Behaviour Change Institute of Public and Policy Research, London.

32.

Jessop

, 1990 State Theory: Putting the Capitalist State in its Place (Polity Press, Cambridge).

33.

Jones

Pykett

Whitehead

, 2011, “Governing temptation: Changing behaviour in an age of libertarian paternalism” Progress in Human Geography 35 483–501.

34.

Kahneman

Slovic

Tversky

, 1982 Judgment Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases (Cambridge University Press, New York).

35.

Knott

Muers

Aldridge

, 2008 Achieving Culture Change: A Policy Framework Cabinet Office, London.

36.

Laclau

E J

, 1996, “Why do empty signifiers matter to politics?”, in Emancipation(s) Ed. Laclau

(Verso, London) pp 36–46.

37.

Lave

Wenger

, 1991 Situated Learning: Legitimate Peripheral Participation (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).

38.

McCann

, 2008, “Expertise, truth, and urban policy mobilities: Global circuits of knowledge in the development of Vancouver, Canada's ‘four pillar’ drug strategy” Environment and Planning A 40 885–904.

39.

McCann

E J

, 2011, “Urban policy mobilities and global circuits of knowledge: Toward a research agenda” Annals of the Association of American Geographers 101 107–130.

40.

McFarlane

, 2011 Learning the City: Knowledge and Translocal Assemblage (Wiley Blackwell, Oxford).

41.

Majone

Wildavsky

, 1984, “Implementation as Evolution”, in Implementation: How Great Expectations in Washington are Dashed in Oakland: Or, Why It's Amazing that Federal Programs Work at All, This Being a Saga of the Economic Development Administration as Told by Two Sympathetic Observers Who Seek to Build Morals on a Foundation of Ruined Hopes Eds Pressman

J L

Wildavsky

(University of California Press, Berkeley, CA) pp 163–180.

42.

Needham

, 2007, “Realising the potential of co-production: Negotiating improvements in public services” Social Policy and Society 7 221–231.

43.

NEF, 2005 Behavioural Economics: Seven Principles for Policy-makers New Economics Foundation, London.

44.

O'Leary

(Ed.), 2008, “The politics of public behaviour”, Demos, London.

45.

Oppenheimer

D M

, 2008, “The secret life of fluency” Trends in Cognitive Sciences 12 237–241.

46.

Peck

Theodore

, 2001, “Exporting workfare/importing welfare-to-work: Exploring the politics of Third Way policy transfer” Political Geography 20 427–460.

47.

Prince

, 2010, “Policy transfer as policy assemblage: Making policy for the creative industries in New Zealand” Environment and Planning A 42 169–186.

48.

Rose

, 1993 Lesson Drawing in Public Policy: A Guide to Learning Across Time and Space (Chatham House, Chatham, NJ).

49.

Shapiro

, 1992, “The European Court of Justice”, in Euro-politics: Institutions and Policy-making in the ‘New’ Europe Ed. Sbragia

A M

, (Brookings Institution, Washington, DC) pp 123–156.

50.

Stone

, 2000, “Non-governmental policy transfer: The strategies of independent policy institutes” Governance: An International Journal of Policy and Administration 13 45–62.

51.

Stone

, 2001, “Learning lessons, policy transfer and the international diffusion of ideas”, WP 69/01, Centre for the Studies in Globalisation and Regionalisation, University of Warwick, Coventry.

52.

Stone

, 2006, “Public policy analysts and think tanks”, in Handbook of Public Policy Analysis: Theory, Methods, and Politics Eds Fischer

Miller

G J

Sidney

M S

, (Marcel Dekker, New York) pp 149–157.

53.

Stone

Denham

, (Eds) 2004 Think Tank Traditions: Policy Research and the Politics of Ideas (Manchester University Press, Manchester).

54.

Thaler

R H

Sunstein

C R

, 2008 Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth and Happiness (Yale University Press, London).

55.

The Guardian, 2009, “Tory controlled borough of Barnet adopts budget airline model”, 27 August, page 7.

56.

WAG, 2008 Appetite for Life Action Plan Welsh Assembly Government, Cardiff.

57.

Ward

, 2007, “Business Improvement Districts: Policy origins, mobile policies and urban liveability” Geography Compass 1 657–672.

58.

Ward

, 2010, “Towards a relational comparative approach to the study of cities” Progress in Human Geography 34 471–487.

59.

Welsh Government, 2011 Proposals for Legislation on Organ and Tissue Donation: A Welsh Government White Paper Cardiff.

60.

Whitehead

Jones

Pykett

, 2011, “Governing irrationality, or a more than rational government: Reflections on the rescientisation of decision making in British public policy” Environment and Planning A 43 2819–2837.

61.

Wolman

, 1992, “Understanding cross-national policy transfers: The case of Britain and the US” Governance: An International Journal of Policy and Administration 5 27–45.