This paper questions the continued dominance of the network governance approach in public policy and administration and proposes an alternative framework. We find little evidence to support claims for a paradigmatic shift towards network governance in the English case. Neither does the evidence support claims for a weakening of vertical linkages or a strengthening of horizontal linkages within, or across, service delivery chains in England. Instead, bureaucratic and hierarchical structures remain pervasive and power remains highly centralised. The two case studies, of economic development and affordable housing provision, demonstrate how reforms are driven by elected politicians' political objectives and their support of various target groups in society. Nevertheless, policy making is constrained by conditions of ‘postdemocracy’—essentially, the exigencies of contemporary electoral politics and the pervasive influence of business. The study of public administration and management needs to refocus on the implications for the public services of postdemocracy and address critical questions of power, competing interests, mechanisms of exclusion and inclusion, and contested claims to knowledge and expertise within service delivery chains.
ChhotrayVStokerG, 2009Governance Theory and Practice: A Cross-disciplinary Approach (Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants)
8.
CochraneA, 2012, “Making up a region: the rise and fall of ‘the South East of England’ as a political territory”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy3095–108
9.
ConlanTPosnerP, 2011, “Pathways of policy making: the politics of intergovernmental lawmaking and reform in the United States”, in Policy, Performance and Management in Governance and Intergovernmental Relations Eds OngaroEMasseyAHolzerMWayenbergE (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) pp 7–33
CrouchC, 2011The Strange Non-death of Neoliberalism (Polity Press, Cambridge)
12.
DansonMLloydG, 2012, “Devolution, institutions, and organisations: changing models of regional development agencies”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy3078–94
13.
DaviesJ, 2009, “The limits of joined-up government: towards a political analysis”Public Administration8780–96
14.
DCLG, 2011Localism Bill: Summary Impact Assessment Department of Communities and Local Government (The Stationery Office, London)
15.
DearloveJ, 1973The Politics of Policy in Local Government (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
16.
DowneJMartinS, 2006, “Joined up policy in practice? The coherence and impacts of the Local Government Modernisation Agenda”Local Government Studies32456–488
17.
Du GayP, 2005, “The values of bureaucracy: an introduction”, in The Values of Bureaucracy Ed. Du GayP (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 1–13
18.
EntwistleT, 2010, “Organising intergovernmental relations: insights from cultural theory”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy28630–645
19.
FriendJ, 1977Regional Planning and Policy Change IOR/960R, Tavistock Institute, London
20.
FriendJPowerJYewlettC, 1974Public Planning: The Inter-corporate Dimension (Tavistock, London)
21.
GyfordJ, 1991Citizens, Consumers and Councils (Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants)
22.
HillCHupeP, 2011, “Talking about governance: the role of magic concepts”Public Management Review13641–658
23.
IngramHSchneiderAdeLeonP, 2007, “Social construction and policy design”, in Theories of the Policy Process Ed. SabatierP (Westview Press, Boulder, CO) 93–128
24.
JohnP, 1998Analysing Public Policy (Continuum, London)
25.
JohnPMussonSTickellA, 2002, “England's problem region: regionalism in the South East”Regional Studies36733–741
26.
KisbyB, 2010, “The Big Society: power to the people?”The Political Quarterly81484–490
27.
LaffinM, 2008, “Local government modernisation in England: a critical review of the LGMA evaluation studies”Local Government Studies34109–125
28.
LaffinM, 2012, “Policy networks versus political parties: Labour's reform of affordable and social housing delivery”, paper available from author
29.
LaffinM, 2013, “A new politics of governance or an old politics of central—local relations? Labour's reform of social housing tenancies in England”Public Administration91195–210
30.
LingT, 2002, “Delivering joined up government in the UK: dimensions, issues and problems”Public Administration80615–642
31.
LipskyM, 1980Street-level Bureaucracy: The Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services (Russell Sage Foundation, New York)
32.
LowndesVPratchettL, 2012, “Local governance under the Coalition government: austerity, localism and the ‘Big Society’”Local Government Studies3821–40
33.
McCarthyAPikeATomaneyJ, 2012“The governance of economic development in England”Town and Country Planning81126–130
34.
McMillanJMasseyA, 2001, “A regional future for the UK civil service?”Public Money and Management2125–31
35.
MarshD, 2008, “Understanding British government: analysing competing models”British Journal of Politics and International Relations10251–268
36.
MarshDRichardsDSmithM, 2003, “Unequal plurality: towards an asymmetric power model of British politics”Government and Opposition38306–332
37.
MawsonJ, 2007, “Regional governance in England: past experience, future directions?”International Journal of Public Sector Management20548–566
38.
NCVO, 2011Counting the Cuts. National Council for Voluntary Associations, London
39.
PearceGMawsonJAyresS, 2008, “Regional governance in England: a changing role for the government's regional offices?”Public Administration86443–463
40.
PikeATomaneyJ, 2009, “The state and uneven development: the governance of economic development in England in the post-devolution UK”Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society213–34
41.
PikeARodríguez-PoseATomaneyJTorrisiGTseliosV, 2012, “In search of the ‘economic dividend’ of devolution: special dispartities, spatial economic policy, and decentralisation in the UK”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy3010–28
42.
PivenFClowardR, 1971Regulating the Poor: The Functions of Public Relief (Pantheon Books, New York)
43.
PivenFClowardR, 1977Poor People's Movements Why They Succeed, How They Fail (Vintage Books, New York)
44.
PollittCHupeP, 2011, “Talking about government”Public Management Review13641–658
45.
PugalisLTownsendA, 2012, “Rebalancing England: sub-national development (once again) at the crossroads”Urban Research and Practice5157–174
46.
PurcellCChowD, 2011, “The reorganisation of children's social services in England”Public Money and Management31403–410
47.
RhodesR, 1996, “The new governance: governing without government”Political Studies44652–667
48.
RhodesR, 2007, “Understanding governance ten years on”Organization Studies281243–1264
49.
RichardsD, 2008New Labour and the Civil Service: Reconstituting the Westminster Model (Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants)
50.
RichardsonJ, 2000, “Government, interest groups and policy change”Political Studies481006–1025
51.
RichardsonJJordanG, 1979Governing under Pressure: The Policy Process in a Post-parliamentary Democracy (Robertson, Oxford)
52.
RydinY, 2011, “The promise of localism”Town and Country Planning8033–35
SorensenETorfingJ, 2009, “Making governance networks effective and democratic through metagovernance”Public Administration87234–258
60.
SpencerKMawsonJ, 1997, “The Government Offices for the English Regions: towards regional governance?”Policy and Politics2571–84
61.
SpencerKMawsonJ, 2000, “Transforming regional government offices in England: a new Whitehall agenda”, in Transforming British GovernmentVolume 2, Ed. RhodesR (Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants) pp 223–226
62.
Taylor-GoobyPStokerG, 2011, “The Coalition programme: a new vision for Britain or politics as usual?”The Political Quarterly824–15
63.
TomaneyJ, 2002, “The evolution of regionalism in England”Regional Studies36721–731
64.
WaltersW, 2004, “Some critical notes on ‘governance’”Studies in Political Economy7327–46
65.
WhiteSWastellDBroadhurstKHallC, 2010, “When policy o'erleaps itself: the ‘tragic tale’ of the Integrated Children's System”Critical Social Policy30405–428
66.
WilsonD, 2003, “Unravelling control-freakery: redefining central—local relations”British Journal of Politics and International Relations5317–346
67.
WoodinS, 2011, “The building blocks of neighbourhoods”Town and Country Planning8077–81
