In this paper the dynamic relations between the state, society, and metropolitan planning are explored. The changing role and function of the state in the context of rapid restructuring of economic and social relations in Australia during the past decade are discussed, along with the impact of processes such as globalisation, cyclic recessions, and the growing assertion of local communities on the state. The influence of these processes on metropolitan planning, as an arm of the state which mediates between development interests and local communities, is then assessed from a theoretical perspective. Given the identified processes and changes, it is argued that metropolitan planning has become increasingly constrained in its ability to influence the nature and location of urban development in 1990s Australia.
The validity of this argument is examined against the case of metropolitan planning in Perth during the past decade. Three key aspects of the changing nature of planning in Perth are studied in detail: A 1987 proposal for a new metropolitan strategy; a 1990 adopted metropolitan plan which derived from the 1987 proposal; and several redevelopment initiatives currently under consideration. It is concluded that the Western Australian state—and subsequently metropolitan planning—have experienced significant challenges to their ability to influence urban change. The constraints imposed on metropolitan planning are simultaneously due to economic pressures ‘from above’ and community pressures ‘from below’. Finally, it is observed that this process possesses a regresive potential, and that metropolitan planning should restructure in order to respond effectively and equitably to recent economic and social changes.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlbrechtL, 1991, “Changing roles and positions of planners”Urban Studies28123–137
2.
AlexanderE RAltermanRYoneH Law, 1983, “Evaluating plan implementation: The National Statutory Planning System in Israel”Progress in Planning2097–172
3.
AlexanderI C, 1981, “Post war metropolitan planning: Goals and realities”, in Equity in the City Ed. TroyP, (Allen and Unwin, Sydney) pp 145–171
4.
AlexanderI C, 1987, “Land use and transport planning in Australian metropolitan areas”, in Urban Planning in Australia: Critical Readings Eds McLoughlinBHuxleyM, (Longman Cheshire, Melbourne) pp 116–132
5.
AlexanderI C, 1991, “The political difficulties of urban consolidation”, in Urban Consolidation: Myths and Realities conference proceedings (Australian Institute of Urban Studies, Perth) pp 78–81
6.
AlexanderI C, 1992, “City centre planning: For public or private interest?”, in Urban and Regional Planning in Western Australia: Historical and Critical Perspectives Eds HedgcockDYiftachelO, (Paradigm Press, Perth) pp 79–92
7.
BarryP, 1990The Rise and Fall of Alan Bond (Bantam/ABC Books, Sydney)
8.
BerryMHuxleyM, 1992, “Big build: Property capital, the state and urban change in Australia”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research16(1) 35–69
9.
BollensS, 1993, “Restructuring land use governance”Journal of Planning Literature7(3) 211–226
10.
BunkerR, 1983, “Urban consolidation: The experience of Sydney”, Australian Institute of Urban Affairs, Canberra
11.
CARRA, 1992, “The Constitution of the Confederation of Allied Residents and Ratepayers Associations of W.A. (Inc.), Perth”, mimeograph, 11 August, Confederation of Affiliated Residents' and Ratepayers' Associations, PO Box 909, Victoria Park, WA 6100
12.
CastellsM, 1983The City and the Grassroots (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
13.
CastellsM, 1990The Informational City (Basil Blackwell, Oxford)
14.
CCWA, 1993, “Alkimos rezoning criticised”, Conservation council of Western Australia The Greener Times (October) page 3
15.
ClarkeSKirbyA, 1990, “In search of the corpse: The mysterious case of local politics”Urban Affairs Quarterly25389–412
16.
ClokePLittleJ, 1990The Rural State: Limits to Planning in Rural Society (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
17.
CostelloLDunnK, 1993, “Residential action groups in Sydney: Reformers or ratbags?”Australian Geographer241–28
18.
DearM, 1992, “Understanding and overcoming the NIMBY syndrome”Journal of the American Planning Association58288–299
19.
DPUD, 1990, “Metroplan: A planning strategy for the Perth Metropolitan Region”, Department of Planning and Urban Development, Perth
20.
DPUD, 1992a, “Metropolitan Region residential density: Policy statement”, Department of Planning and Urban Development, Perth
21.
DPUD, 1992b, “Metropolitan regional residential density: Policy background report”, Department of Planning and Urban Development, Perth
22.
FainsteinS, 1991, “Promoting economic development: Urban planning in the United States and Great Britain”Journal of the American Planning Association5722–33
23.
ForesterJKrumbholtzN, 1990Making Equity Planning Work (Temple University Press, Philadelphia, PA)
24.
FriedmannJ, 1987Planning in the Public Domain: From Knowledge to Action (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
25.
FriedmannJ, 1992Empowerment: The Politics of Alternative Development (Basil Blackwell, Oxford)
26.
GansH J, 1991People, Plans and Politics (Columbia University Press, New York)
27.
GilchristJ, 1990, “Demographic and housing characteristics in East Fremantle”, report prepared for Fielman Planning Consultants, Colin Street, West Perth, October 1990
28.
GlassonJ, 1992, “The fall and rise of regional planning in economically advanced nations”Urban Studies29505–531
29.
GoodwinMDuncanSHalfordS, 1993, “Regulation theory, the local state, and the transition of urban politics”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space1167–88
30.
GottdeinerM, 1987The Decline of Urban Politics: Political Theory and the Crisis of the Local State (Sage, Newbury Park, CA)
31.
GrahamL, 1985, “The Corridor Plan and Metropolitan Region Scheme”, in Review of the Corridor Plan for Perth conference proceedings, State Planning Commission, Forrest Square, Perth, pp 11–24
32.
GurrT, 1993Minorities at Risk: The Global View of Ethnopolitical Conflict (Institute of Peace Press, Arlington, TX)
33.
HallP, 1988Cities of Tomorrow (Basil Blackwell, Oxford)
34.
HallS, 1993, “Policy paradigms, social learning, and the state: The case of economic policymaking in Britain”Comparative Politics25275–293
35.
HallSJacquesM, (Eds), 1990New Times: The Changing Face of Politics in the 1990s (Lawrence and Wishart, London)
36.
HarmanE, 1981, “Ideology and mineral development in Western Australia”, in State, Capital and Resources in the North and West of Australia Eds HarmanEHeadB, (University of Western Australia Press, Nedlands, Western Australia) pp 167–196
37.
HarveyD, 1989The Condition of Postmodernism (Basil Blackwell, Oxford)
38.
HarveyD, 1992, “Social justice, postmodernism and the city”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research16588–601
39.
HayIBellJ, 1990, “Small spaces and big states: Changing state relations in a new global environment”Tijdschrift voor Economische et Sociale Geografie81322–331
40.
HealeyP, 1992, “The reorganisations of state and markets in planning”Urban Studies29411–434
41.
HedgcockDYiftachelO, (Eds), 1992Urban and Regional Planning in Western Australia: Historical and Critical Perspectives (Paradigm Press, Perth) pp 79–92
42.
HedgcockDYiftachelO, 1993, “Planning and planners in Western Australia: An historical perspective”, Papers in Architecture and Planning Research Number 19, Centre for Architecture and Planning Research, Curtin University of Technology, Perth
43.
HeldD, 1990, “The decline of the nation state”, in New Times: The Changing Face of Politics in the 1990s Eds HallSJacquesM, (Lawrence and Wishart, London) pp 191–204
44.
HillierJ, 1993, “To boldly go where no planner …”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space10377–392
45.
HRSCLTF, 1992Patterns of Urban Settlement: Consolidating the Future?House of Representatives Standing Committee on Long Term Futures (Australian Government Publishing Services, Canberra)
46.
HuxleyM, 1993, “Private affluence and public squalor?”Urban Policy and Research11(1) 44–46
47.
JarmanA M GKouzminA, 1993, “Australian metropolitan development: Local government reform and urban growth into the 1990s”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy11143–160
48.
KreukelsASpitT, 1993, “Public–private partnership in the Netherlands”Tijdschrift voor Economische et Sociale Geografie85388–392
49.
LakeR, 1993, “Rethinking NIMBY”Journal of the American Planning Association5987–93
50.
LoganB, 1987, “The shape of Melbourne: A political geography of Melbourne's planning in the 1970s and 1980s”, in Urban Planning in Australia: Critical Readings Eds McLoughlinB JHuxleyM, (Longman, Melbourne)
51.
LoveringJ, 1989, “The restructuring debate”, in New Models in Geography (Unwin Hyman, London) pp 198–223
52.
LowN P, 1991Planning, Politics and the State: Political Foundation of Planning Thought (Unwin Hyman, London)
53.
McLoughlinJ B, 1991, “Urban consolidation and urban sprawl: A question of density”Urban Policy and Research9(3) 148–156
54.
McLoughlinJ B, 1992aShaping Melbourne's Future: Town Planning, the State and Civil Society (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
55.
McLoughlinJ B, 1992b, “The case for a legal basis for land use planning systems”Built Environment18214–220
56.
MRPA, 1970, “The Corridor Plan for Perth”, Metropolitan Region Planning Authority, Forrest Square, Perth
57.
National Housing Strategy, 1992National Housing Strategy: Agenda for ActionCommonwealth of Australia (Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra)
58.
PaddisonR, 1983The Fragmented State: The Political Geography of Power (Basil Blackwell, Oxford)
59.
ParisC, 1990, “The changing urban and regional system in Australia”Australian Planner28(1) 25–30
60.
ReynoldsD, 1992, “Political geography: Thinking globally and locally”Progress in Human Geography16393–405
61.
Royal Commission, 1992A Report of the Royal Commission for Government 1980–1990volumes 2 and 5 (Government Printers, Perth)
62.
RumleyD, 1991, “The political organisation of space: A reformist perspective”Australian Geographical Studies29329–336
63.
SandercockL, 1990Property, Politics and Planning: A History of Australian City Planning 1890–1990 (Transaction Books, New Brunswick, NJ)
64.
ScottA, 1988Metropolis: From Division of Labour to Urban Form (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
65.
ShawBHoughtonS, 1991, “Urban consolidation: Beyond the rhetoric”Urban Policy and Research9(2) 85–91
66.
SmithA, 1992, “Ethnicity and nationalism”International Journal of Contemporary Sociology331–5
67.
SmithS, 1989, “Society, space and citizenship: A human geography for the ‘new times’?”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers: New Series14144–156
68.
SPC, 1987, “Planning for the future of the Perth Metropolitan Region”, State Planning Commission, Forrest Square, Perth
69.
StephensonGHepburnA, 1955Plan for the Metropolitan Region, Perth and Fremantle (Government Printers, Perth)
70.
StilwellF, 1992Understanding Cities and Regions (Pluto Press, Sydney)
71.
StokesRHillR, 1992, “The evolution of metropolitan planning in Western Australia”, in Urban and Regional Planning in Western Australia: Historical and Critical Perspectives Eds HedgcockDYiftachelO, (Paradigm Press, Perth) pp 111–130
TaylorP, 1984, “Accumulation, legitimation and electoral geographies within liberal democracies”, in Political Geography: Recent Advances and Future Directions Eds TaylorPHouseJ, (Croom Helm, Andover, Hants) pp 117–132
74.
TaylorP, 1992, “Changing political relations”, in Policy and Change in Thatcher's Britain Ed. ClokeP, (Pergamon Press, Oxford) pp 33–54
75.
ThriftN, 1992, “Light out of darkness? Critical social theory in 1980s”, in Policy and Change in Thatcher's Britain Ed. ClokeP, (Pergamon Press, Oxford) pp 1–32
76.
TofflerA, 1980The Third Wave (Pan Books, London)
77.
TofflerA, 1990Powershift: Knowledge, Wealth and Violence at the Edge of the 21st Century (Bantam Books, New York)
78.
TroyP, 1992, “The new feudalism”Urban Futures2(2) 36–44
79.
TurnerR S, 1992, “Growth politics and downtown development: The economic imperative in sunbelt cities”Urban Affairs Quarterly28(1) 3–21
80.
UrryJ, 1990, “The end of organised capitalism”, in New Times: The Changing Face of Politics in the 1990s Eds HallSJacquesM, (Lawrence and Wishart, London) pp 94–102
81.
WebbM, 1983, “The evolution of regional planning in Metropolitan Perth 1911–1981”, paper presented to the 18th RAPI Congress: “Resonances '83”, Perth; copy available from the author, 102 Circe Circle, Dalkeith, WA 6009
82.
WinterI, 1993, “Urban planning and the entrepreneurial state”Urban Policy and Research11(1) 46–48
83.
WinterIBrookeT, 1993, “Urban planning and the entrepeneurial state: The view from Victoria, Australia”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy11263–278
84.
YiftachelO, 1991, “Theory and practice in metropolitan planning: The case of Perth”, Centre for Architecture and Planning Research, Curtin University of Technology, Perth
85.
YiftachelO, 1992Planning a Mixed Region in Israel: The Political Geography of Arab–Jewish Relations in the Galilee (Avebury, Aldershot, Hants)
86.
YiftachelOBenthamM, 1991, “Urban consolidation: Beyond the stereo-types”Urban Policy and Research9(2) 92–95
87.
YiftachelOHedgcockD, 1993, “Urban social sustainability and the planning of an Australian city”Cities11139–157
88.
YiftachelOKenworthyJ, 1992, “The planning of metropolitan Perth: Some critical observations”, in Urban and Regional Planning in Western Australia: Historical and Critical Perspectives Eds HedgcockDYiftachelO, (Paradigm Press, Perth) pp 131–149
89.
YoungI M, 1990Justice and the Politics of Difference (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
