The objective of this paper is to illustrate that concern over environmental pollution became a significant national issue in the United States during the late 1950s, many years earlier than is typically acknowledged by environmental historians and policy analysts. Kingdon's model of agenda development is used to document how air and water pollution was transformed from an issue of local concern and control to an issue of national significance during the 1950s. The analysis focuses on two case studies: the development of pollution as a political issue in the state of New Jersey; and the development of pollution as a significant policy issue in the national political arena. Political leaders both within New Jersey and nationwide linked pollution control to other contemporary concerns about urban decay and suburban growth in order to win the allegiance of undecided voters. Pollution control became part of the debate over the role of the federal government in addressing urban ills. Concern about pollution also became important in the general restructuring of the US political landscape in this period, helping to set the stage for Democratic Party activism on the environment and other issues after 1960.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AmbroseS, 1983Eisenhower: The President (Simon and Schuster, New York)
2.
BaroneM, 1990Our Country: The Shaping of America from Roosevelt to Reagan (The Free Press, New York)
3.
BaumgartnerF RJonesB D, 1993Agendas and Instability in American Politics (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
4.
BiemillerA, 1958, “Labor's stake in conservation”AFL–CIO American Federationist November, pages 12, 27
5.
BossoC J, 1987Pesticides and Politics: The Life Cycle of a Public Issue (University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, PA)
6.
BrownHShatkinJ A, 1994, “Historical developments in the awareness of the impacts of industrial waste disposal”, paper presented at the annual meeting of the Society for Risk Analysis, Baltimore, MD, December; copy available from the author, Center for Technology, Environment and Development, Clark University, Worcester, MA
7.
CallisonC H, 1959, “Conservation and jobs”AFL–CIO American Federationist June, pages 21–22
8.
CarsonR, 1962Silent Spring (Houghton Mifflin, Boston, MA)
9.
CobbR WElderC D, 1983Participation in American Politics: The Dynamics of Agenda Building (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD)
10.
ColtenC E, 1994, “Creating a toxic landscape: Chemical waste disposal policy and practice, 1900 – 1960”Environmental History Review1885–116
11.
EganL, 1957, “Governors vote state-U.S. study”New York Times 27 June, page 14
12.
FarbP, 1957, “Let's clean up all our poisoned rivers”Reader's Digest71133–136
13.
FelzenburgA S, 1982, “Alfred Eastlack Driscoll”, in The Governors of New Jersey, 1664–1974 Eds StellhornP ABerknerM J, (New Jersey Historical Commission, Trenton, NJ) pp 214–219
14.
FentonJ H, 1958, “Mayors told U.S. is imperiled by growth in urban problems”New York Times 2 December, page 39
15.
FurmanB, 1957, “Area unit urged on air pollution”New York Times 20 November, page 37
16.
FurmanB, 1958a, “Smog is termed a cancer cause”New York Times 19 November, page 39
17.
FurmanB, 1958b, “Flemming urges stream clean-up”New York Times 7 October, page 19
18.
GottliebR, 1993, Forcing the Spring: The Transformation of the American Environmental Movement (Island Press, Washington, DC)
19.
HaysS, 1987Beauty, Health and Permanence: Environmental Politics in the United States, 1955–1985 (Cambridge University Press, New York)
20.
HellerA NBensonD S, 1953, “New Jersey Governor's Conference on Atmospheric Pollution”Public Health News34(4) 145–150
21.
HofferbertR, 1974The Study of Public Policy (Bobbs-Merrill, Indianapolis, IN)
22.
HofferbertRUriceJ, 1985, “Small scale policy: The federal stimulus versus competing explanations for state funding of the arts”American Journal of Political Science29308–329
23.
HollisM D, 1958, “Fresh air getting scarce in the United States”U.S. News and World Report4570–72
24.
JansonD, 1957, “Civic gain linked to smog control”New York Times 5 June, page 37
25.
KingdonJ W, 1984Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies (HarperCollins, New York)
26.
KiserLOstromE, 1982, “The three worlds of action”, in Strategies of Political Inquiry Ed. OstromE, (Sage, Beverly Hills, CA) pp 179–222
27.
KleppnerP, 1987Continuity and Change in Electoral Politics, 1893–1928 (Greenwood Press, Westport, CT)
28.
KnowlesC, 1960, “Kennedy charges urban neglect by Republicans”New York Times 11 October, pages 1 and 25–26
29.
LemmeyW, 1982, “Robert Baumle Meyner”, in The Governors of New Jersey, 1664–1974 Eds StellhornP ABerknerM J, (New Jersey Historical Commission, Trenton, NJ) pp 219–223
30.
LindblomC E, 1959, “The science of muddling through”Public Administration Review1979–88
31.
LipfertF W, 1993Air Pollution and Community Health: A Critical Review and Data Sourcebook (Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York)
32.
MAPCC, 1957, “Text of the report on the major problems of metropolitan areas' growth”, Metropolitan Area Problems Conference Committee, New York Times 26 September, page 29 (Special to the New York Times)
33.
MeanyG, 1960, “The most momentous political decision of our time”AFL–CIO American Federationist November, pages 2, 7
34.
MelosiM V, (Ed.), 1980Pollution and Reform in American Cities, 1870–1930 (University of Texas Press, Austin, TX)
35.
MeynerR B, 1958, “Urban sprawl and public health”Public Health News39(6) 163–166
36.
MeynerR B, 1960, “How conservation helps business and industry”, Proceeding of the 29th North American Wildlife Conference, Dallas, Texas (Wildlife Management Institute, Washington, DC) pp 47–56
37.
New York Times1955, “U.S. set to study Staten Island air”, 18 February, page 19
38.
New York Times1957, “Air pollution move by U.S. is sought”, 4 June, page 17
39.
New York Times1960, “Nixon maps plan on conservation”, 30 October, page 42
40.
NicholsonA, 1959, “Los Angeles battles the murk”Saturday Evening Post23217–19
41.
NJDH, 1951, “Department of Health of the State of New Jersey, 1951”, New Jersey Department of Health (MacCrellish & Quigley, Trenton, NJ)
42.
NJHR, 1951Minutes of the House New Jersey House of Representatives Assembly Bill Number 411, Monday 26 March, page 572
43.
OstromE, 1990Governing the Commons (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
44.
PetullaJ M, 1977American Environmental History: The Exploitation and Conservation of Natural Resources (Boyd and Fraser, San Francisco, CA)
45.
RichardsonE, 1973Dams, Parks and Politics: Resource Development and Preservation in the Truman – Eisenhower Era (University Press of Kentucky, Lexington, KY)
46.
SabatierP A, 1988, “An advocacy coalition framework of policy change and the role of policy-oriented learning therein”Policy Sciences21129–168
47.
SabatierP A, 1991, “Toward better theories of the policy process”PS: Political Science & Politics24147–156
48.
ShelleyF MArcherJ C, 1989, “Sectionalism and presidential politics in America: A twentieth century reinvestigation of voting patterns in Illinois, Indiana and Ohio”Journal of Interdisciplinary History20227–255
49.
ShelleyF MArcherJ CDavidsonF MBrunnS D, 1996Discovering American's Political Geography (Guilford Press, New York)
50.
SheltonW, 1960, “The 1960 Elections: The Presidency”AFL – CIO American Federationist November, pages 3–7
51.
SnyderL P, 1994, “The death-dealing smog over Donora, Pennsylvania: Industrial air pollution, public health policy, and the politics of expertise, 1948–1949”Environmental History Review18(1) 117–140
52.
SoleckiW DMichaelsS, 1994, “Looking through the post-disaster policy window”Environmental Management18587–595
53.
SternA C, 1982, “History of air pollution legislation in the United States”Journal of Air Pollution Control Association3244–61
54.
SternsherB, 1987, “The Harding and Bricker Revolutions: Party systems and voter behavior in Northwest Ohio, 1860–1982”Northwest Ohio Quarterly5991–118
55.
SullivanR J, 1986, “Environmental policy”, in The Political State of New Jersey Ed. PomperG M, (Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, NJ) pp 216–227
56.
UdallS, 1963The Quiet Crisis (Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York)
57.
WalkerJ L, 1977, “Setting the agenda in the U.S. Senate”British Journal of Political Science7423–445
58.
WeaverWJr, 1957, “Mayors ask state for aid increase”New York Times 10 January, page 21
59.
WickerT, 1991One of Us: Richard Nixon and the American Dream (Random House, New York)
