Shrimp are harvested in two different ways. They are fished in the sea (sometimes to the cost of turtles) or they are ‘farmed’ in ponds in coastal areas. Such aquaculture is increasing around the world as shrimp become a valuable item of world trade. Mangrove forests are sacrificed for commercial shrimp farming. The author considers the conflict between mangrove conservation and shrimp exports in different countries. Who has title to the mangroves, who wins and who loses in this tragedy of enclosures? Which languages of valuation are used by different actors in order to compare the increase in shrimp exports and the losses in livelihoods and in environmental services? The economic valuation of damages is only one of the possible languages of valuation which are relevant in practice. Who has the power to impose a particular language of valuation?
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AgarwalB, 1992, “The gender and environment debate: Lessons from India”Feminist Studies18(1) 119–158
2.
AhmedF, 1997, “In defence of land and livelihood. Coastal communities and the shrimp industry in Asia”, Consumers' Association of Penang, CUSO, InterPares, Sierra Club of Canada, Ottawa and Penang
3.
BroadRCavanaghJ, 1993Plundering Paradise; The Struggle for the Environment in the Philippines (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
4.
CIEL, IUCN, WWF, 1996, “Protecting marine and coastal biodiversity under the Convention on Biological Diversity”, Center for International Environmental Law, International Union for the Conservation of Nature, Worldwide Fund for Nature
5.
FallaP, 2000, “Estado actual y tendencias en el manej o del ecosistema manglar por comunidades del Pacífico colombiano”, master's thesis, Universitat Autónoma de Barcelona, Barcelona
6.
FrenchH, 2000Vanishing Borders: Protecting the Planet in the Age of Globalization (Norton, New York)
7.
GibbonP, 1997, “Prawns and piranhas: The political economy of a Tanzanian private sector marketing chain”Journal of Peasant Studies24(4) 1–86
8.
GilbertA JJanssenR, 1998, “Use of environmental functions to communicate the values of a mangrove ecosystem under different management regimes”Ecological Economics25323–346
9.
GopinathNGabrielP, 1997, “Management of living resources in the Matang Reserve, Perak, Malaysia”, in Harvesting Wild Species. Implications for Biodiversity Conservation Ed. FreeseC H (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD) pp 167–216
10.
GruesoLRoseroCEscobarA, 1997, “El proceso organizativo de comunidades negras en Colombia”Ecologia Politica1447–64
11.
GuhaRMartinez-AlierJ, 1997Varieties of Environmentalism: Essays North and South (Earthscan, London, Oxford University Press, Delhi)
12.
HallK G, 1997, “Shrimp farms harvest aquaculture clash”Journal of Commerce 24 October
13.
HandbergH, 1998, “A study of people's conception of the social consequences of the shrimp farming industry in two local communities in coastal Ecuador”, Department of Anthropology, University of Oslo, Oslo
14.
Human Rights Watch, 1999The Price of Oil: Corporate Responsibility and Human Rights Violations in Nigeria's Oil Producing Communities (Human Rights Watch, New York)
LarssonJFolkeCKaustkyN, 1994, “Ecological limitations and appropriation of ecosystem support by shrimp farming in Colombia”Environmental Management18663–676
17.
Martinez-AlierJO'ConnorM, 1996, “Ecological and economic distribution conflicts”, in Getting Down to Earth: Practical Applications of Ecological Economics Eds CostanzaRSeguraOMartinez-AlierJ (Island Press, Washington, DC) pp 153–183
18.
Martinez-AlierJMundaGO'NeilJ, 1998, “Weak comparability of values as a foundation for ecological economics”Ecological Economics26277–286
19.
MydansS, 1996, “Thai shrimp farmers facing ecologists' fury”New York Times 28 April
20.
OdumH TArdingJ E, 1991, “Emergy analysis of shrimp mariculture in Ecuador”, WP, Coastal Resources Center, University of Rhode Island, Kingston, RI
21.
PrimaveraJ H, 1991, “Intensive prawn farming in the Philippines: Ecological, social and economic implications”Ambio20(1) 28–33
22.
RoyA, 1999The Cost of Living (Modern Library, New York)
23.
SathirathaiS, 1999, “Economic valuation of mangroves and the role of local communities in the conservation of natural resources”, Centre for Ecological Economics, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok
24.
ShabecoffP, 2000Earth Rising, American Environmentalism in the 21st Century (Island Press, Washington DC)
25.
SiregarR, 1999, “Indonesia to intensify shrimp farming”Linknumber 90, page 6
26.
SiregarRHafildE, 1999, “Global shrimp trade and Indonesian shrimp farming policies”, report, Friends of the Earth International/WALHI, Jakarta
27.
StonichS, 1991, “The promotion of nontraditional exports in Honduras: Issues of equity, environment, and natural resource management”Development and Change22725–755
28.
SwardsonA, 1998, “Turtle protection law overturned by WTO”Washington Post 13 October, page C2
