In recent work on collaborative planning arguments have been made for the land-use planning system and local government to be considered within a broader context of local systems of governance and institutional capacity building. We consider the impact of the planning system upon a major inward-investment project within a system of governance in Wales which is unique in the sense that there is a vacuum of formal strategic planning. The investment by the Korean company LG, at Newport, South Wales, has prompted a degree of strategic collaboration between some of the institutions and organisations of local governance in South Wales. However, the LG case reveals some important limits to such strategic collaboration. The extreme flexibility required of the planning system by major inward investors promotes a rather impoverished form of strategic collaboration which is hierarchical in nature and select in its coverage both of the relevant institutions and organisations of governance and of the planning issues involved. In conclusion we identify some of the implications of the rather limited way in which the planning system currently impinges on inward investors through local systems of governance.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdburghamR, 1996, “Survey—inward investment into the UK: Springboard into Europe”Financial Times 18 July, page 6
2.
AminABradleyDHowellsJTomaneyJGentleC, 1994, “Regional incentives and the quality of mobile investment in the less favoured regions of the EC”Progress in Planning411–112
3.
AminAThriftN, 1995, “Globalisation, institutional ‘thickness’ and the local economy”, in Managing Cities: The New Urban Context Eds HealeyPCameronSDavoudiSGrahamSMadani-PourA (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex) pp 91–108
4.
BoyneGGriffithsPLawtonALawJ, 1991, “Local government in Wales: Its role and functions”, report prepared by the Welsh Unit of Local Government, Polytechnic of Wales, Joseph Rowntree Foundation, The Homestead, 40 Water End, York Y03 6LP
5.
BuckinghamM, 1997, “Fury as planners ‘jump gun’ over LG homes”South Wales Argus 16 June, page 8
6.
CCW, not dated Nature Conservation and Physical Development on the Gwent LevelsCountryside Commission for Wales, Ladywell House, Newtown, Powys SY16 1RD
7.
CrowtherSGarrahanP, 1988, “Invitation to Sunderland—corporate power and the local economy”Industrial Relations Journal1951–59
8.
CWD, 1991The Structure of Local Government in Wales: Response to the Welsh OfficeCouncil of Welsh Districts, 10–11 Raleigh Walk, Atlantic Wharf, Cardiff CF1 5LN
9.
EnnisFHealeyPPurdueM, 1995Negotiating Planning (E & F N Spon, London)
10.
EvansA, 1997, “Wildlife on the run”South Wales Argus 13 June, page 1
11.
EvansRHardingA, 1997, “Regionalisation, regional institutions and economic development”Policy and Politics2519–30
GCC, 1992Gwent Structure Plan 1991–2006Gwent County Council, Newport, Gwent
14.
GeorgeKMainwaringL (Eds), 1988The Welsh Economy (University of Wales Press, Cardiff)
15.
HambletonRMillsL, 1993, “Local government reform in Wales”Local Government Policy Making1945–55
16.
HarrisNTewdwr-JonesM, 1995, “The implications for planning of local government reorganisation in Wales: Purpose, process and practice”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy1347–66
17.
HarveyD, 1989, “From managerialism to entrepreneurialism: The transformation of urban governance in late capitalism”Geografiska Annaler B713–17
18.
HealeyP, 1997Collaborative Planning: Shaping Places in Fragmented Societies (Macmillan, London)
19.
HealeyPKhakeeAMotteANeedhamB, 1997, “Strategic plan-making and building institutional capacity”, in Making Strategic Spatial Plans: Innovation in Europe Eds HealeyPKhakeeAMotteANeedhamB (UCL Press, London) pp 283–295
20.
HoodNYoungS, 1988, “Inward investment and the EC: UK evidence on corporate integration strategies”, in Multinationals and the European Community Eds DunningJ HRobsonP (Basil Blackwell, Oxford) pp 91–104
21.
House of Commons Welsh Affairs Committee, 1995Wales in EuropeVolume 2 (The Stationery Office, London)
22.
HughesC, 1996, “Old tinplate site needs polish”Western Mail 17 October, page 8
23.
JessopB, 1997, “The future of the national state: erosion or reorganisation? General reflections on the West European Case”, mimeo, Department of Sociology, University of Lancaster, Lancaster
24.
LeyshonAThriftNTwomeyJ, 1989, “The rise of the provincial financial centre”Progress in Planning31151–229
25.
Local Government (Wales) Act1994Public General Acts—Elizabeth II chapter 19 (The Stationery Office, London)
26.
LoughlinJ, 1997, “Wales in Europe: Welsh regional actors and European integration”, Papers in Planning Research 164, Department of City and Regional Planning, University of Wales, Cardiff
27.
LoveringJ, 1978, “The theory of the internal colony and the political economy of Wales”Review of Radical Political Economics1055–67
28.
LoveringJ, 1997, “Misreading and misleading the Welsh economy: the ‘new regionalism’ ”, Papers in Planning Research 166, Department of City and Regional Planning, University of Wales, Cardiff
29.
MarksGHoogheLBlankK, 1996, “European integration in the 1980s: State-centric v. multi-level governance”Journal of Common Market Studies34341–378
30.
MorganKRobertsE, 1993, “The democratic deficit: a guide to quangoland”, Papers in Planning Research 144, Department of City and Regional Planning, University of Wales, Cardiff
31.
MorganKSaycrA, 1985, “A ‘modern’ industry in a ‘mature’ region: The remaking of management labour relations”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research9383–404
32.
MorrisJ, 1987, “Industrial restructuring, foreign direct investment and uneven development: The case of Wales”Environment and Planning A19205–224
33.
NCBC, 1993Local Plan (Consultation Draft)Newport County Borough Council, Civic Centre, Newport NP9 4UR
34.
NCBC, 1996, “Director of Development and Transportations' report to the Highways, Transportation and Planning Committee”, 3 September, Newport County Borough Council, Civic Centre, Newport NP9 4UR
35.
PainterJGoodwinM, 1996, “Local governance, the crises of Fordism and the changing geographies of regulation”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series21635–648
36.
PeckF W, 1996, “Regional development and the production of space: The role of infrastructure in the attraction of new inward investment”Environment and Planning A28327–339
37.
PhelpsN A, 1997Multinationals and European Integration: Trade, Investment and Regional Development (Jessica Kingsley, London)
38.
ReadeE, 1997British Town and Country Planning (Open University Press, Milton Keynes, Bucks)
39.
ReesG, 1980, “Uneven development, state intervention and the generation of inequality: The case of industrial South Wales”, in Poverty and Social Inequality in Wales Eds RecsGReesT (Croom Helm, London) pp 185–205
40.
ReesGThomasM, 1994, “Inward investment, labour market adjustment and skills development: Recent experiences in South Wales”Local Economy948–61
41.
RydinY, 1993The British Planning System: An Introduction (Macmillan, London)
42.
Tewdwr-JonesM, 1997, “Green belts or green wedges for Wales? A flexible approach to planning in the urban periphery”Regional Studies3173–77
43.
ThomsonR, 1996, “Valleys gear up to cope with jobs problems”Western Mail 2 September, page 6
44.
UNCTAD, 1996World Investment Report: Trade and Investment Policy (United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, Geneva)
45.
WagstaffJ, 1997, “Going, going, gone—our fine countryside”South Wales Argus 24 June, page 6
Western Mail1996, “Industrial villages idea for Valleys” 25 July, page 9
48.
YannopoulosG, 1990, “Foreign direct investment and European integration: The evidence from the formative years of the European Community”Journal of Common Market Studies28235–260
