Taxation and Small Firms: Creating Incentives for the Reinvestment of Profits

Abstract

In this paper we examine, using the NatWest/Manchester Business School (MBS) tax models, the impact of taxation on the small business sector over the last few years. Because it is known that a small number of growth businesses provide most of the new wealth and additional employment created by the small firms sector, consideration is given to the combined effect of the different elements of the tax regime on small firms, with particular reference to the tax implications of business growth. The NatWest/MBS tax models, for incorporated and unincorporated small businesses, contain accounting data for a stratified random sample of almost 4000 small UK firms. These data are employed to estimate the total tax burden borne by small firms in the United Kingdom, including the total value of taxes collected from this sector by the Exchequer and the aggregate value of compliance costs borne by small businesses. Unincorporated firms employing fewer than 20 staff contribute just 5% of government revenues, and small limited companies with fewer than 100 employees provide 15% of total taxes collected. These figures of total tax revenues together with estimates of the compliance costs borne by small firms are assembled into tax indices for incorporated and unincorporated firms, set at 100 in 1994/95. Changes to the total tax burden are traced from 1994/95 (the base year in the models) up to 1996/97 in the light of the changes introduced in successive budgets. Although the index for small companies falls by 2.5 points across this period the position of unincorporated firms remains virtually unchanged. The reasons for these differential effects are considered and explained. We identify three important areas in which the growth and development of small business is restrained by the tax regulations currently in force: sales growth, employment generation, and investment for the future, We conclude that the fiscal barriers in these areas could be reduced by raising the VAT registration limit (initially to £100 000), by compensating small businesses for the cost of collecting tax on behalf of government and by reducing the level of taxation on profits reinvested in small businesses.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bannock

Daly

, 1994 Small Business Statistics (Paul Chapman, London)

Bannock

Peacock

, 1989 Governments and Small Business (Paul Chapman, London)

BCC, 1998, “Budget '98: A submission to the Chancellor of the Exchequer”, British Chambers of Commerce, Manning House, 22 Carlisle Place, Victoria, London SW1P 1JA

Bolton

J E

, 1971 Report of the Committee of Inquiry on Small Firms Chairman J E Bolton, Department of Trade and Industry (HMSO, London)

Chittenden

, 1991, “Taxation”, in Bolton 20 Years On: The Small Firm in the 1990s Eds Stanworth

Gray

(Paul Chapman, London) pp 76–111

Chittenden

, 1994

A Study to Determine the Effects of Introducing a Cash Flow Base for the Corporate Taxation of Small Limited Companies

PhD thesis, Faculty of Economic and Social Studies, University of Manchester, Manchester

Chittenden

Hall

Hutchinson

, 1996, “Small firm growth, access to capital markets and financial structure: Review of issues and empirical investigation” Small Business Economics 8 59–67

Cosh

Hughes

, 1994, “Size, financial structure and profitability”, in Finance and the Small Firm Eds Hughes

Storey

D J

(Routledge, London) pp 18–63

Davies

Dilnot

Giles

Walton

, 1996, “Options for 1997: The green budget”, Institute for Fiscal Studies, 7 Ridgmount Street, London WC1E 7AE

10.

DeAngelo

Masulis

R W

, 1980, “Optimal capital structure under corporate and personal taxation” Journal of Financial Economics 8 3–29

11.

Devereux

, 1988, “Corporation tax: The effect of the 1984 reforms on incentives to invest” Fiscal Studies 9(1) 62–79

12.

DTI, 1995 Small Firms in Britain 1995 Department of Trade and Industry (The Stationery Office, London)

13.

Gray

, 1992, “Stages of growth and entrepreneurial career motivation”, paper presented to the 15th National Small Firms Policy and Research Conference, Southampton; copy available from the author, School of Management, Open University Business School, Milton Keynes

14.

Inland Revenue, 1995 Inland Revenue Statistics 1995 Board of Inland Revenue, Statistics and Economics Office (The Stationery Office, London)

15.

Meade

, 1978 The Structure and Reform of Direct Taxation (George Allen and Unwin, London)

16.

Mian

S L

Smith

C W

, 1992, “Accounts receivable management policy: Theory and evidence” Journal of Finance 47(1) 169–200

17.

Michaelas

Chittenden

Poutziouris

, 1996, “Determinants of capital structure in small privately held firms”, Research Monograph Series 2, Institute for Small Business Affairs, 39 Lane Street, Leeds LS8 1AP

18.

Myers

, 1977, “Determinants of corporate borrowing” Journal of Financial Economics 4 147–176

19.

Neeley

, 1992, “Small business capital investment and tax reform” Journal of Small Business Management 30(3) 30–34

20.

Noteboom

, 1987, “Basic income as a basis for small businesses” International Small Business Journal 5(3) 10–18

21.

Parrington

, 1996 Whillans's Tax Tables 1996/7 (Butterworths, Sevenoaks, Kent)

22.

Pointon

Spratley

, 1988 Principles of Business Taxation (Clarendon Press, Oxford)

23.

Rees

Shah

, 1993, “The characteristics of the self-employed: The supply of labour”, in Employment the Small Firm and the Labour Market Eds Atkinson

Storey

D J

(Routledge, London) pp 317–327

24.

Rosa

Scott

, 1997, “Growing through cluster formation: Insights from Scottish case studies”, in Proceedings of the 20th ISBA National Small Firms Policy and Research Conference The Institute of Small Business Affairs, 39 Street Lane, Leeds LS8 1AP, pp 117–148

25.

Sandford

C T

Godwin

Hardwick

, 1989 Administrative and Compliance Costs of Taxation (Fiscal Publications, Bath)

26.

SBRT, 1996 NatWest Quarterly Survey No 1 Small Business Research Trust, 45 Clydesdale Close, Isleworth, Middx TW7 6ST

27.

Smallbone

North

, 1995, “Targeting established SMEs: Does their age matter?” International Small Business Journal 13(3) 47–64

28.

Stanworth

Gray

(Eds), 1991 Bolton 20 Years On: The Small Firm in the 1990s (Paul Chapman, London)

29.

Storey

, 1994 Understanding the Small Business Sector (Routledge, London)

30.

van Hilten

Kort

P M

Loon

P J J M

, 1993 Dynamic Policies and the Firm: An Optimal Control Approach (Springer, Berlin)

31.

Watson

, 1990, “Employment change, profits and directors' remuneration in small closely held UK companies” Scottish Journal of Political Economy 37 259–274

32.

Welsh

J A

White

J F

, 1981, “A small business is not a little big business” Harvard Business Review 59 (July/August) 18–33