Comparing Local Government Systems across Countries: Conceptual and Methodological Challenges to Building a Field of Comparative Local Government Studies
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online February, 2008
Comparing Local Government Systems across Countries: Conceptual and Methodological Challenges to Building a Field of Comparative Local Government Studies
Despite increasing research on comparative local government, the resulting literature remains disappointing in that it is difficult to generalize across the range of diffuse studies. The main problem is the lack of a common framework to conduct such research and into which results can be placed and built upon. Partly, this is a consequence of insufficient attention to the requirements of building a classification system that can serve as a framework. In the spirit of contributing to the conceptual and methodological development of the literature on comparative local government, I set forth criteria for a classification system, review and assess the literature with respect to these criteria, and suggest a possible approach for building an empirically based classification system for local government that can serve as a common framework.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BaileyK, 1994Typologies and Taxonomies: An Introduction to Classification Techniques (Sage, London)
2.
BaileyS, 1999Local Government Economics: Principles and Practice (Macmillan, London)
3.
BaldersheimHWolmannH, 2006, “Assessment of the field of comparative local government and a future research agenda”, in The Comparative Study of Local Government and Politics: Overview and Synthesis Eds BaldersheimHWolmanH (Barbara Budrich, Farmington Hills, MI) pp 109–131
4.
BaldersheimHIllnerMWolmannH (Eds), 2003Local Democracy in Post-communist Europe (Leske & Budrich, Leverkusen)
5.
BennettR, 1993“European local government systems”, in Local Government in the New Europe Ed. BennettR (Belhaven, London) pp 1–11
CaulfieldJLarsenH (Eds), 2002Local Government at the Millennium (Leske & Budrich, Leverkusen)
8.
ChandlerJ A, 1993Local Government in Liberal Democracies: An Introductory Survey (Routledge, London)
9.
ClarkG, 1984, “A theory of local autonomy”Annals of the Association of American Geographers74195–208
10.
DentersBMossbergerK, 2006, “Building blocks for a methodology for comparative urban political research”Urban Affairs Review41550–571
11.
DentersBRoseL, 2005, “Local governance in the third millennium: A brave new world?”, in Comparing Local governance Trends and Developments Eds DentersBRoseL (Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants) pp 1–11
12.
DiGaetanoAKlemanskiJ, 1999Power and City Governance: Comparative Perspectives on Urban Government (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)
13.
EldersveldSStrombergLDerksenW, 1995Local Elites in Western Democracies: A Comparative Analysis of Urban Political Leaders in the U.S., Sweden, and the Netherlands (Westview Press, Boulder, CO)
14.
GoldsmithM, 1990“Local autonomy: Theory and practice”, in Challenges to Local Government Eds KingDPierreJ (Sage, London) pp 15–36
GoldsmithM, 2006“From community to power and back again”, in The Comparative Study of Local Government and Politics: Overview and Synthesis Eds BaldersheimHWolmannH (Barbara Budrich, Farmington Hills, MI) pp 11–32
17.
GurrTKingD, 1987The State and the City (Macmillan, London)
18.
HeineltHHlepasN-K, 2006, “Typologies of local government systems”, in The European Mayor: Political Leaders in the Changing Context of Local Democracy Eds BäckHHeineltHMagnierA (VS Verlag, Wiesbaden) pp 21–42
19.
HesseJ JSharpeL J, 1991, “Local government in international perspective: Some comparative observations”, in Local Government and International Affairs in International Perspective Ed. HesseJ (Nomos, Baden-Baden)
20.
HumesS I V, 1991Local Governance and National Power (Harvester Wheatsheaf, Hemel Hempstead, Herts)
21.
JohnP, 2001Local Governance in Western Europe (Sage Publications, London)
22.
JohnP, 2006, “Methodologies and research methods in urban political science”, in The Comparative Study of Local Government and Politics: Overview and Synthesis Eds BaldersheimHWolmannH (Barbara Burdich, Farmington Hills, MI) pp 67–82
23.
JohnPColeA, 2001Local Governance in England and France (Routledge, London)
24.
Le GalèsP, 2002European Cities: Social Conflicts and Governance (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
25.
LidstromA, 1999“The comparative study of local government: A research agenda”Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis195–115
26.
MarradiA, 1990“Classification, typology, and taxonomy”Quality and Quantity24129–157
27.
MukherjeeR, 1983Classification in Social Research (State University of New York Press, Albany, NY)
28.
NortonA, 1994International Handbook of Local and Regional Government (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos)
29.
OECD, 1997Managing Across Levels of Local Government (OECD, Paris)
30.
OECD, 2006, “Fiscal autonomy of sub-central governments”, Network on Fiscal Relations Across Levels of Government, WP 2, Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/48/26/37159974.pdf
31.
PageE, 1991Localism and Centralism in Europe (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
32.
PageEGoldsmithM, 1987a, “Centre and locality: Functions, access and discretion”, in Central and Local Government Relations: A Comparative Analysis of West European Unitary States Eds PageEGoldsmithM (Sage, London) pp 1–11
33.
PageEGoldsmithM, 1987b, “Centre and locality: Explaining cross-national variation”, in Central and Local Government Relations: A Comparative Analysis of West European Unitary States Eds PageEGoldsmithM (Sage, London) pp 156–168
34.
PrzeworskiATeuneH, 1970The Logic of Comparative Political Inquiry (Wiley Interscience, New York)
35.
SavitchH VKantorP, 2002Cities in the International Marketplace (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
36.
SellersJ, 2004“Local government and the egalitarian welfare state”, paper prepared for the Biennial Conference of Europeanists, Chicago, IL, April 11; copy available from J M Sellers, Department of Political Science, University of Southern California, Los Angeles
37.
SellersJ, 2005, “Re-placing the nation: An agenda for comparative urban politics”Urban Affairs Review40419–445
38.
ShahAShahS, 2006“The new vision of local governance and the evolving roles of local governments”, in Local Governance in Developing Countries Ed. ShahA (World Bank, Washington, DC) pp 1–46
39.
StokerG, 2006“Comparative local governance”, in The Oxford Handbook of Political Institutions Eds RhodesR A WBinderS ARockmanB A (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 497–515
40.
SvaraJMouritzenP-E, 2002Leadership at the Apex (University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, PA)
41.
VetterA, 2007Local Politics: A Resource for Democracy in Western Europe (Lexington Books, Lanham, MD)
42.
VetterAKerstingN, 2003“Democracy vs efficiency”, in Reforming Local Government in Europe Eds KerstingNVetterA (Leske & Budrich, Leverkusen) pp 11–28
43.
WolmanHGoldsmithM, 1990“Local autonomy as a meaningful analytical concept: Comparing local government in the US and the UK”Urban Affairs Quarterly (September) 3–27
