The number of books and papers bearing the terms ‘sustainable development’ and ‘governance’ in their titles has grown exponentially in the last decade or so. The main purpose of this paper is to explore what meanings have been attached to these two essentially contested terms and to assess the extent to which the material on them constitutes an important, coherent, and cumulative body of scholarship. The first half explores the existing literatures on the two terms, and draws out some of the main similarities and differences. Drawing on papers that have been published in this journal over the last decade or so, the second half focuses on the attempts that have been made to build empirical and/or theoretical bridges between the two terms. The concluding section identifies a number of key themes and explores future research needs in what is evidently a vibrant and highly policy-relevant area of environmental social science research.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AyreGCallwayR (Eds), 2005Governance for Sustainable Development (Earthscan, London)
2.
BacheIFlindersM (Eds) 2004Multi-level Governance (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
3.
BakerS, 2005Sustainable Development (Routledge, London)
4.
BeierleT CKoniskyD M, 2001, “What are we gaining from stakeholder involvement? Observations from environmental planning in the Great Lakes”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy19515–527
5.
BiermannF, 2006, “Global governance and the environment”, in Palgrave Advances in International Environmental Politics Eds BetsillMHochstetlerKStevisD (Palgrave, Basingstoke, Hants) pp 237–264
6.
BiermannF, 2007, “‘Earth system governance’ as a cross cutting theme of global change research”Global Environmental Change17326–337
7.
BloomfieldDCollinsKFryCMuntonR, 2001, “Deliberation and inclusion: Vehicles for increasing trust in UK public governance?”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy19501–513
8.
BlühdornIWelshI (Eds), 2007, “The politics of unsustainability: Eco-politics in the post-ecologist era”, special issueEnvironmental Politics16(1) 185–375
9.
BrackeRAlbrechtJ, 2007, “Competing environmental management standards: How ISO 14001 outnumbered EMAS in Germany, the UK, France, and Sweden”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy25611–627
10.
BučekJSmithB, 2000, “New approaches to local democracy: Direct democracy, participation and the ‘third sector’”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy183–16
11.
CarterN, 2007The Politics of the Environment2nd edition (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
12.
CherpAGeorgeCKirkpatrickC, 2004, “A methodology for assessing national sustainable development strategies”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy22913–926
13.
ClappJDauvergneP, 2005Paths to a Green World: The Political Economy of the Global Environment (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
14.
Commission on Global Governance, 1995Our Global Neighbourhood (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
15.
CounsellDHaughtonG, 2003, “Regional planning tensions: Planning for economic growth and sustainable development in two contrasting English regions”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy21225–239
16.
CowellROwensS, 2006, “Governing space: Planning reform and the politics of sustainability”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy24403–421
17.
DingwerthKPattbergP, 2006, “Global governance as a perspective on word politics”Global Governance12185–203
18.
DobsonA, 2000Green Political Thought3rd edition (Routledge, London)
19.
DresnerS, 2002The Principles of Sustainability (Earthscan, London)
20.
DryzekJ, 2005The Politics of the Earth2nd edition (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
21.
ECFESD, 2000Sustainable GovernanceEuropean Consultative Forum on the Environment and Sustainable Development (European Commission, Brussels)
22.
EckersleyR, 2004The Green State (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
23.
FarrellKKempRHinterbergerFRammelCZieglerR, 2005, “From *for* to governance for sustainable development in Europe”International Journal of Sustainable Development8127–150
24.
FlindersM, 2002, “Governance in Whitehall”Public Administration80(1) 51–76
25.
GambleG, 2000Politics and Fate (Polity Press, Cambridge)
26.
GibbsDJonasA E G, 2001, “Rescaling and regional governance: The English Regional Development Agencies and the environment”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy19269–288
27.
GibsonRHassanSHoltzSTanseyJWhitelawG, 2005Sustainability Assessment: Criteria, Processes and Applications (Earthscan, London)
28.
GissendannerS, 2003, “Methodology problems in urban governance studies”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy21663–685
29.
GlasbergenPBiermannFMolA (Eds), 2007Partnerships, Governance, and Sustainable Development (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos)
30.
GuptaJ, 2002, “Global sustainable development governance”International Environmental Agreements2361–388
31.
HajerM, 1995The Politics of Environmental Discourse (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
32.
HansjürgensB, 1998, “The sulfur dioxide allowance-trading program in the USA: Recent developments and lessons to be learned”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy16341–361
33.
HansenKJohanssenK SLarsenA, 2002, “Recommendations for negotiated agreements”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy2019–37
34.
HelmsingA H J, 2002, “Decentralisation, enablement, and local governance in low-income countries”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy20317–340
35.
HewsonMSinclairT (Eds), 1999Approaches to Global Governance Theory (University of New York Press, New York)
36.
JasanoffSMartelloM (Eds), 2004Earth Politics: Local and Global in Environmental Governance (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
37.
JordanA, 1999, “The construction of a multilevel environmental governance system”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy171–17
38.
JordanALenschowA (Eds), 2008Innovation in Environmental Policy? Integrating the Environment for Sustainability (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos)
39.
JordanASchoutA, 2006The Coordination of the European Union (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
40.
JordanAWurzelRZitoA, 2005, “The rise of ‘new’ policy instruments in comparative perspective”Political Studies53477–496
41.
KallisGVideiraNAntunesPPereiraGuimarães ASpashC LCoccossisHQuintanaCorral Sdel MoralLHatzilacouDLoboGMexaAPanequePMateosPedregal BSantosR, 2006, “Participatory methods for water resources planning”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy24215–234
42.
KatesRParrisTLeisorowitzA, 2005, “What is sustainable development?”Environment478–21
43.
KiddSFischerT B, 2007, “Towards sustainability: Is integrated appraisal a step in the right direction?”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy25233–249
44.
Kohler-KochBRittbergerB, 2006, “The ‘governance turn’ in EU studies”Journal of Common Market Studies44 (annual review) 27–49
45.
KooimanJ (Ed.), 1993Modern Governance (Sage, Newbury Park, CA)
46.
KooimanJ, 2003Governing as Governance (Sage, London)
47.
LabattSMaclarenV W, 1998, “Voluntary corporate environmental initiatives: A typology and preliminary investigation”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy16191–209
48.
LaffertyW (Ed.), 2001Sustainable Communities in Europe (Earthscan, London)
49.
LaffertyW (Ed.), 2004Governance for Sustainable Development (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos)
50.
LaffertyWEckerbergK (Eds), 1998From the Earth Summit to Local Agenda 21 (Earthscan, London)
51.
LaffertyWMeadowcroftJ (Eds), 2000Implementing Sustainable Development (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
52.
LehtonenM, 2007, “Environmental policy integration through OECD peer reviews”Environmental Politics1615–35
53.
LeleS, 1991, “Sustainable development: A critical review”World Development19607–621
54.
LemosMAgrawalA, 2006, “Environmental governance”Annual Review of Environmental Resources31297–325
LevyDNewellP (Eds) 2004The Business of Global Environmental Governance (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
57.
MannM, 1997, “Has globalization ended the rise and rise of the nation state?”Review of International Political Economy4472–496
58.
MarksGHoogheLBlankK, 1996, “European integration from the 1980s: State centric versus multi-level governance”Journal of Common Market Studies34341–378
59.
MeadowcroftJ, 2000, “Sustainable development: A new(ish) idea for a new century?”Political Studies48370–387
60.
MeadowcroftJ, 2007, “National sustainable development strategies: Features, challenges and reflexivity”European Environment17152–163
61.
MeadowcroftJFarrellK NSpangenbergJ, 2005, “Developing a framework for sustainability governance in the EU”International Journal of Sustainable Development83–11
62.
MeadowsD HMeadowsD LRandersJBehrensW W, 1972The Limits to Growth (Universe Books, New York)
63.
Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, 2005Ecosystems and Human Well-being: Synthesis (Island Press, Washington, DC)
64.
MolA, 2006, “Environmental governance in the Information Age: The emergence of informational governance”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy24497–514
65.
NewigJVoßJ-PMonstadtJ (Eds), 2008Governance for Sustainable Development: Steering in Contexts of Ambivalence, Uncertainty and Power (Routledge, London)
66.
NilssonM, 2005, “Learning, frames, and environmental policy integration: The case of Swedish energy policy”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy23207–226
67.
O'DohertyRBaileyICollinsA, 2003, “Regulatory failure via market evolution: The case of UK packaging recycling”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy21579–595
68.
OECD, 2001Sustainable Development: Critical IssuesOrganisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD, Paris)
69.
OECD, 2002Improving Policy Coherence and Integration for Sustainable Development: A ChecklistOrganisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD, Paris)
70.
O'RiordanT (Ed.), 1998Transition to Sustainability: The Politics of Agenda 21 in Europe (Earthscan, London)
71.
O'RiordanT, 2004, “Environmental science, sustainability and politics”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series29234–247
72.
O'RiordanTVoiseyH (Eds), 1997Sustainable Development in Western Europe: Coming to Terms with Agenda 21 (Frank Cass, London)
73.
ParkJConcaKFingerM (Eds), 2008The Crisis of Global Environmental Governance: Towards a New Political Economy of Global Environmental Governance (Routledge, London)
74.
PatersonMHumphreysDPettifordL, 2003, “Conceptualizing environmental governance: From interstate regimes to counter-hegemonic struggles”Global Environmental Politics3(2) 1–10
75.
PerkinsRNeumeyerE, 2004, “Europeanisation and the uneven convergence of environmental policy: Explaining the geography of EMAS”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy22881–897
76.
PierreJPetersB, 2000Governance, Politics and the State (Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants)
RedcliftM, 2005Sustainability: Critical Concepts in the Social Sciencesfour volumes (Routledge, London)
79.
RhodesR, 1996, “The new governance: Governing without governance”Political Studies44652–667
80.
RhodesR, 1997Understanding Governance (Open University Press, Milton Keynes, Bucks)
81.
RichardsDSmithM, 2002Governance and Public Policy (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
82.
Rodriguez-PoseAGillN, 2003, “The global trend towards devolution and its implications”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy21333–351
83.
RosenauJ, 1992, “Governance, order and change in world politics”, in Governance without Government Eds RosenauJCzempielE-O (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 1–29
84.
SbragiaA, 2000, “Governance, the state and the market: What is going on?”Governance13243–250
85.
SchoutAJordanA J, 2005, “Coordinated European governance: Self-organizing or centrally steered?”Public Administration83(1) 201–220
86.
ScraseJSheateW, 2002, “Integration and integrated approaches to assessment: What do they mean for the environment?”Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning4275–294
87.
SmithB C, 2007Good Governance and Development (Palgrave, Basingstoke, Hants)
88.
SpashC, 2001, “Broadening democracy in environmental policy processes”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy19475–481
SteurerR, 2007, “From government strategies to strategic public management”European Environment17201–214
91.
SteurerRMartinuzziA, 2005, “Towards a new pattern of strategy formation in the public sector: First experiences with national strategies for sustainable development in Europe”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy23455–472
92.
StirlingA, 1999, “The appraisal of sustainability”Local Environment4111–135
93.
StokerG, 1998, “Governance as theory”International Social Science Journal15517–28
94.
SunnevågK, 2000, “Voluntary agreements and the incentives for innovation”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy18555–573
95.
ThompsonG, 2003Between Hierarchies and Markets: The Logic and Limits of Network Forms of Organisation (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
96.
TokeD, 2005, “Are green electricity certificates the way forward for renewable energy? An evaluation of the United Kingdom's Renewables Obligation in the Context of International Companies”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy23361–374
97.
TömmelI, 1997, “The EU and the regions: Towards a three tier system or new modes of regulation?”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy15413–436
98.
TreibOBahrHFalknerG, 2007, “Modes of governance”Journal of European Public Policy141–20
99.
United Nations, 1992Agenda 21 (United Nations, New York)
100.
United Nations, 2002Report of the World Summit on Sustainable Development A/CONF.199/20 and A/CONF.199/20/corr.1 (United Nations, New York)
van KersbergenKvan WaardenF, 2004, “‘Governance’ as a bridge between disciplines”European Journal of Political Research43143–171
103.
VoßJ-PBauknechtDKempR (Eds) 2006Reflexive Governance for Sustainable Development (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos)
104.
WCED, 1987Our Common FutureWorld Commission on Environment and Development (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
105.
World Bank, 2002Governance and Development (World Bank, Washington, DC)
106.
YearleyS, 2006, “Bridging the science-policy divide in urban air-quality management: Evaluating ways to make models more robust through public engagement”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy24701–714
107.
YoungO, 2005, “Why is there no unified theory of environmental governance?”, in Handbook of Global Environmental Politics Ed. DauvergneP (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) pp 170–186
108.
ZhangZ, 2000, “The design and implementation of an international trading scheme for greenhouse gas emissions”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy18321–337
