The dwelling reflects the employment situation of its occupants and enables them to engage in a particular level and combination of types of work (‘work strategy’). The growth of suburban homeownership in Toronto demonstrates the point. Ownership levels increased rapidly among all social classes. More middle-class women were doing their own housework. As a result they came to value smaller and more affordable homes. Many working-class men built their own homes. Some of these homes were in unserviced districts at the suburban fringe, where household tasks were more arduous. In both cases the growth in owner-occupation depended upon an increasing amount of unpaid work within and upon the home. Toronto's experience is exemplary and challenges the belief that, in the early 20th century, suburban homeownership was a middle-class phenomenon. The prevailing model of the city in this period must be revised to incorporate the fact that unpaid labour played a vital role in determining people's housing situation and standard of living.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ArmstrongCNellesH V, 1986, “Suburban street railway strategies in Montreal, Toronto and Vancouver, 1896–1930”, in Power and Place Eds StelterGArtibiseA F J, (University of British Columbia Press, Vancouver) pp 187–218
2.
BarberM, 1980, “The women Ontario welcomed: Immigrant domestics for Ontario homes, 1870–1930”, in The Neglected Majority: Essays in Canadian Women's History, Volume 2 Eds PrenticeATrofimenkoffS M, (McClelland and Stewart, Toronto) pp 187–218
3.
BarrowsR G, 1983, “Beyond the tenement: Patterns of American urban housing, 1870–1930”Journal of Urban History9395–400
4.
BatorJ, 1979, “The struggle to raise the lower classes': Public health reform and the problem of poverty in Toronto, 1910 to 1921”Journal of Canadian Studies1443–48
5.
BeebyD, 1984, “Industrial strategy and manufacturing growth in Toronto, 1880–1910”Ontario History76199–232
6.
BensonJ, 1983, “Working-class capitalism in Great Britain and Canada, 1867–1914”Labour/Le Travailleur12145–154
7.
BordessaK, 1980, “A corporate suburb for Toronto: Lawrence Park 1905–1930”, unpublished MA thesis, Department of Geography, York University, North York, Ontario
8.
BradburyB, 1984, “Pigs, cows and boarders: Non-wage forms of survival among Montreal families, 1861–1891”Labour/Le Travail149–46
9.
BradburyB, 1987, “Women's history and working-class history”Labour/Le Travail1923–44
10.
BridleA, 1909, “A shacktown Christmas”The Canadian Magazine34129–134
11.
BryceP, 1915, “At the service of the people”, Earlscourt Methodist Churches, Toronto
12.
BurgessE W, 1925, “The growth of the city”, in The City Eds ParkR EBurgessE WMacKenzieR E, (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL) pp 47–62
13.
ByersC, 1912, “The ideal bungalow”Macleans Magazine25 (June) 59–60
14.
ChambersE J, 1984, “A new measure of the rental cost of housing in Toronto, 1890–1914”Histoire Sociale/Social History17165–174
15.
ChambersE J, 1985, “New evidence on the living standards of Toronto blue collar workers in the pre-1914 era”Histoire Sociale/Social History18285–314
16.
ChokoMHarrisR, 1990, “The culture of property: A comparative history of housing tenure in Montreal and Toronto since 1862”Annals of the Association of American Geographers (forthcoming)
17.
City of Toronto, 1906–15, “Annual report of the Assessment Commissioner for the City of Toronto”, various years; City of Toronto Archives, New City Hall, Toronto
18.
City of Toronto, 1911, “Report of the Medical Health Officer dealing with the recent investigation of slum conditions in Toronto”, Department of Health; City of Toronto Archives, New City Hall, Toronto
19.
City of Toronto, 1918, “Report of the Housing Commission”; City of Toronto Archives, New City Hall, Toronto
20.
ClarkC E, 1986The American Family Home, 1800–1960 (University of North Carolina Press, Chapel Hill, NC)
21.
ClarkeM J, 1917, “Report of the Standing Committee on Neighborhood Work”, reprinted 1974 in Saving the Canadian City Ed. RutherfordP, (University of Toronto Press, Toronto) pp 171–193
22.
Construction, 1907, “Sociological and economic advantages of the apartment house”1(2) 44
23.
CookeR R, 1907, “A visit to shackland in Toronto's suburbs”The Globe 9 November, page 13
24.
CowanR, 1983More Work for Mother: The Ironies of Household Technology from the Open Hearth to the Microwave (Basic Books, New York)
25.
CurryJ S, 1918Manufacturing and Wholesale Industries of Chicago, Volume 1 (Thomas B Poole Company, Chicago, IL)
26.
DarrochA G, 1983a, “Early industrialisation and inequality in Toronto, 1869–1899”Labour/Le Travailleur1131–61
27.
DarrochA G, 1983b, “Occupational structure, assessed wealth and homeowning during Toronto's early industrialisation, 1861–1899”Histoire Sociale/Social History32381–410
28.
DavisD F, 1978, “Mass transit and private ownership: An alternative perspective on the case of Toronto”Urban History Review360–98
29.
DeLuceF J, 1912, “How we built our bungalow for $450”Country Life in America21 (February) 53–54
30.
DennisR, 1987, “Landlords and rental housing in Toronto, 1885–1914”, RP-162, Centre for Urban and Community Services, University of Toronto, Toronto
31.
DennisR, 1989, “Toronto's first apartment-house boom; an historical geography, 1900–1920”, unpublished manuscript, Department of Geography, University College London, London
32.
Dinnick Papers, Archives of Ontario, Toronto
33.
DoucetM J, 1977, “Mass transit and the failure of private ownership: The case of Toronto”Urban History Review33–33; a revised version was printed in 1982 as “Politics, space and trolleys; mass transit in early twentieth century Toronto”, in Shaping the Urban Landscape Eds StelterGArtibiseA F J, (Carleton University Press, Ottawa) pp 356–381
34.
DoucetM JWeaverJ, 1985, “Material culture and the North American house; the era of the common man, 1870–1920”The Journal of American History72560–587
35.
DouglassH P, 1925The Suburban Trend (Appleton, New York)
36.
Dovercourt Land, Building and Savings Company, c1910, “Who gets your wages?”, Subdivision Prospectus; Dinnick Papers, MV9/9, Miscellaneous Envelope, Archives of Ontario, Toronto
FavaS, 1981, “Women's place in the new suburbia”, in New Space for Women Eds. WekerleGPetersonRMorleyD, (Westview Press, Boulder, CO) pp 129–149
39.
GameAPringleR, 1979, “Sexuality and the suburban dream”Australian and New Zealand Journal of Sociology15(2) 4–15
40.
GarlandG, 1978, “Suburbanization and the transition to monopoly capitalism”, MA thesis, Department of Geography, University of Toronto, Toronto
41.
GoheenP G, 1970, “Victorian Toronto, 1850–1900: Pattern and process of growth”, RP-127, Department of Geography, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL
42.
GowansA, 1986The Comfortable House: North American Suburban Architecture 1890–1930 (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
43.
GreenbergS W, 1980, “The relationship between work and residence in an industrializing city; Philadelphia, 1880”, in The Divided Metropolis Eds CutlerWGiletteH, (Greenwood Press, Westport, CT) pp 141–168
44.
HaigR M, 1927Major Economic Factors in Metropolitan Growth and Arrangement (Regional Plan of New York and its Environs, New York)
45.
HarrisR, 1986, “The unnoticed home ownership boom in Toronto, 1899–1911”Histoire Sociale/Social History18433–437
46.
HarrisR, 1988, “American suburbs: The sketch of a new interpretation”Journal of Urban History1598–103
47.
HarrisR, 1989, “The family home in working-class life”, RP-171, Centre for Urban and Community Studies, University of Toronto, Toronto
48.
HarrisR, 1990, “Working-class home ownership in the American metropolis”Journal of Urban History (forthcoming)
49.
HarrisRHamnettC, 1987, “The myth of the promised land. The social diffusion of home ownership in Britain and North America”Annals of the Association of American Geographers77173–190
50.
HarrisRMoffatB, 1986, “How reliable is the modern city directory?”The Canadian Geographer30154–158
51.
HarrisR CGabyF HCousinsE L, 1915Report of the Civic Transportation Committee on
52.
Radial Entrances and Rapid Transit for the City of Toronto2 volumes; Map Library, Robarts Library, University of Toronto, Toronto
53.
HaydenD, 1981, “What would a non-sexist city be like? Speculations on housing, urban design, and human work”, in Women and the American City Eds StimpsonC RDexterENelsonM JYattakisK B, (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL) pp 167–184
54.
HelliwellM M, 1904, “Woman's sphere: Domestic rocks. Paper 1”The Canadian Magazine23469–470
55.
HoldsworthD, 1986, “Cottages and castles for Vancouver's home seekers”BC Studiesnumber 69–70, pp 11–32
56.
HooverE MVernonR, 1962Anatomy of a Metropolis (Anchor Books, Garden City, NY)
57.
HurlL F, 1984, “The Toronto Housing Company 1912–1923: The pitfalls of painless philanthropy”Canadian Historical Review6528–53
58.
JacksonK T, 1985Crabgrass Frontier: The Suburbanisation of the United States (Oxford University Press, New York)
59.
James Mavor Papers, Rare Book Archives, University of Toronto, Toronto
60.
KatzmanD M, 1978Seven Days a Week: Women and Domestic Service in Industrializing America (Oxford University Press, New York)
61.
KealeyG, 1973Working Class Toronto at the Turn of the Century (New Hogtown Press, Toronto)
62.
KingA D, 1984The Bungalow: The Production of a Global Culture (Routledge and Kegan Paul, Andover, Hants)
63.
KnightsP, 1971The Plain People of Boston, 1830–1860 (Oxford University Press, New York)
64.
Labour Gazette, 1904–05, volumes V and VI, various issues, Department of Labour, Canada
65.
LancasterC, 1985The American Bungalow 1880–1930 (Abbeville Press, New York)
66.
LemonJSimmonsJ, 1977, “A guide to data on nineteenth century Toronto”, Class Notes Series, Department of Geography, University of Toronto, Toronto
67.
LevineG, 1984, “Criticising the assessment: Views of the property assessment process in Montreal 1870–1920”The Canadian Geographer28276–284
68.
LewisV, 1920, “Earlscourt”, unpublished MA thesis, Department of Sociology, University of Toronto, Toronto
69.
LoweG, 1980, “Women, work and the office: The feminization of clerical occupations in Canada 1901–1931”Canadian Journal of Sociology5361–381
70.
LuymesM, 1986, “The building of ‘Greater Toronto’: Annexations, 1903 to 1914”, unpublished MA research paper, Department of Geography, University of Toronto, Toronto
71.
MacKenzieSRoseD, 1983, “Industrial change, the domestic economy and home life”, in Redundant Space in Cities and Regions Eds AndersonJDuncanSHudsonR, (Academic Books, London) pp 155–201
72.
Macleans Magazine, 1912, “Housewives need drudge no longer”25159–160
73.
MarkusenA, 1981, “City spatial structure, women's household work, and national urban policy”, in Women and the American City Eds StimpsonCDexlerENelsonM JYatrakisK B, (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL) pp 20–41
74.
MarshM, 1988, “Suburban men and masculine domesticity, 1870–1915”American Quarterly40165–186
75.
MasseyD BMeeganR A, 1978, “Industrial restructuring versus the cities”Urban Studies15273–288
76.
MavorJ, 1923My Window on the Street of the World, Volume 1 (Dent, London)
77.
MayM, 1984, “The good managers—married working class women and family budget studies, 1895–1915”Labor History25351–372
78.
MillerR, 1983, “The Hoover® in the garden: Middle-class women and suburbanization, 1850–1920”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space173–87
79.
PahlR E, 1984Divisions of Labour (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
80.
PahlR E, 1988, “Some remarks on informal work, social polarisation and the social structure”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research12247–267
81.
PivaM J, 1979The Condition of the Working Class in Toronto—1900–1921 (University of Ottawa Press, Ottawa)
82.
PleckE H, 1976, “Two worlds in one: Work and family”Journal of Social History10178–195
83.
PopenoeD, 1977The Suburban Environment: Sweden and the United States (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
84.
PredA, 1964, “The intrametropolitan location of American manufacturing”Annals of the Association of American Geographers54165–180
85.
PughC, 1986, “Housing theory and policy”International Journal of Social Economics13(4/5) 1–104
86.
RandleA, 1914, “Suburban settlement”Saturday Night 3 January, page 9
87.
RobertsW, c1976Honest Womanhood: Feminism, Femininity and Class Consciousness among Toronto Working Women, 1893–1914 (New Hogtown Press, Toronto)
88.
RobertsW, 1979, “‘Rocking the cradle for the world’: The new woman and maternal feminism, Toronto, 1877–1914”, in A Not Unreasonable Claim: Women and Reform in Canada, 1880's–1920's Ed. KealeyL, (The Women's Press, Toronto) pp 15–45
89.
RoseD, 1987, “Home-ownership, subsistence and historical change: The mining district of West Cornwall in the late nineteenth century”, in Class and Space: The Making of Urban Society Eds ThriftNWilliamsP, (Routledge and Kegan Paul, New York) pp 108–153
90.
RoseDLeBourdaisC, 1986, “The changing conditions of female single-parenthood in Montreal's inner city and suburban neighborhoods”Urban Resources3(2) 45–52
91.
RossiP, 1955Why Families Move (The Free Press, New York)
92.
RussellM, 1984, ‘“Canadian Ways’: An introduction to comparative studies of housework, stoves and diet in Great Britain and Canada”Material History Bulletin191–12
93.
SaywellJ T, 1975, “Housing Canadians: Essays on the history of residential construction in Canada” DP-24, Economic Council of Canada, Ottawa
94.
ScottA J, 1982, “Production system dynamics and metropolitan development”Annals of the Association of American Geographers72185–201
95.
ScottA J, 1988Metropolis: From the Division of Labor to Urban Form (University of California Press, Los Angeles, CA)
96.
SeidlJ, 1983, “Consumers' choices: A study of household furnishings, 1880–1920”Minnesota History48183–197
97.
SiftonC, 1915, “Address of welcome to the City Planning Conference”Proceedings of the Sixth National Conference on City Planning, Toronto, 25–27 May; reprinted 1974 in Saving the Canadian City Ed. RutherfordP, (University of Toronto Press, Toronto) pp 213–219
98.
SimonR, 1976, “Housing and services in an immigrants neighborhood: Milwaukee's Ward 14”Journal of Urban History2435–458
99.
SpraggeS, 1974, “Provision of workingmen's housing: Attempts in Toronto 1904–1920”, unpublished MA thesis, Department of History, Queen's University, Kingston, Ontario
100.
SpraggeS, 1979, “A confluence of interests: Housing reform in Toronto, 1900–1920”, in The Usable Urban Past Eds ArtibiseA F JStelterG, (Macmillan, Toronto) pp 247–267
101.
StephensonH EMcNaughtC, 1940The Story of Advertising in Canada: A Chronicle of Fifty Years (Ryerson Press, Toronto)
102.
StrasserS, 1982Never Done: A History of American Housework (Pantheon, New York)
103.
TarrJ, 1973, “From city to suburb: The ‘moral’ influence of transportation technology”, in American Urban History Ed. CallowA B, (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 202–212
104.
TaylorG R, 1915Satellite Cities: A Study of Industrial Suburbs (Appleton, New York)
105.
The Globe, 1910, “Rearranging rooms” 4 October, page 5
106.
The News, 1907a, “House scarcity at junction compels numerous workmen to travel long distances” 8 May, page 7
107.
The News, 1907b, “City of homes on the outskirts” 9 May, page 7
108.
ThernstromS, 1973The Other Bostonians (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
109.
ThomasS M, 1973, “Railway satellite: West Toronto Junction 1884–1909”, MA thesis, Department of Geography, York University, Toronto
110.
Toronto Sunday World, 1908, “High rents in Toronto force many people to build their own homes on city outskirts”, illustrated section, 27 December
111.
VanceJ, 1966, “Housing the worker: The employment linkage as a force in urban structure”Economic Geography42294–325
112.
VieheF W, 1981, “Black gold suburbs: The influence of the extractive industry on the suburbanization of Los Angeles, 1890–1930”Journal of Urban History83–26
113.
WalkerR A, 1981, “A theory of suburbanisation: Capitalism and the construction of urban space in the United States”, in Urbanization and Urban Planning in Capitalist Society Eds DearMScottA J, (Methuen, New York) pp 383–429
114.
WarnerS B, 1962Streetcar Suburbs: The Process of Growth in Boston, 1870–1900 (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
115.
WeaverJ C, 1979, “The modern ciy realised: Toronto civic affairs, 1880–1915”, in The Usable Urban Past Eds ArtibiseA F JStelterG, (McClelland and Stewart, Toronto) pp 39–72
116.
WekerleG, 1981, “Women in the urban environment”, in Women and the American City Eds StimpsonCDexlerENelsonM JYatrakisK B, (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL) pp 185–211
117.
WekerleG, 1984, “Women's place is in the city”Antipode16(3) 11–19
118.
WrightG, 1980Moralism and the Model Home: Domestic Architecture and Cultural Conflict in Chicago, 1873–1913 (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
119.
ZunzO, 1982The Changing Face of Inequality (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
