Cultural geographers have for too long ignored the association between the ‘religious' and the ‘political’, concentrating instead on separating the ‘religious' from the sociopolitical and economic forces in society, The challenge is taken up in this paper in an analysts of the contemporary meanings and values of religious buildings in Singapore as invested by the state. Attention is paid to the state's conceptions of religion and religious space and the roles it plays in influencing such space, The ways in which, through its various roles, the state in Singapore plays a significant part in influencing context and hence in shaping the constraints to the construction of meanings are demonstrated. Also discussed are the ways in which religious groups respond to state policies which have direct and indirect implications for their space.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Administration of Muslim Law Act, 1985The Statutes of the Republic of Singaporerevised edition, chapter 3 (Act 27 of 1966) (Government Printing Office, Singapore)
2.
AgnewJ ADuncanJ S, 1989, “Introduction”, in The Power of Place: Bringing Together Geographical and Sociological Imaginations Eds AgnewJ ADuncanJ S (Unwin Hyman, Winchester, MA) pp 1–8
3.
Ahmad Mattar, 1977a, “Speech delivered at the opening ceremony of the Muhajidin Mosque”, 9 October, in Ministry of Social Affairs: Speeches, Statements, Press Conferences and Interviews, 1977–1979 (Information Division, Ministry of Culture, Singapore)
4.
Ahmad Mattar, 1977b, “Speech delivered at a tea party to welcome new members of the Majlis Ugama Islam Singapura”, 17 October, in Ministry of Social Affairs: Speeches, Statements, Press Conferences and Interviews, 1977–1979 (Information Division, Ministry of Culture, Singapore)
5.
Ahmad Mattar, 1987, “Speech delivered at the Islamic Fellowship Association's Idulfitre Night”, 21 June, Singapore Government press release: May-June 1987 (Information Division, Ministry of Communications and Information, Singapore)
6.
Ahmad Mattar, 1988, “Speech delivered at the Dawoodi Bohra's Prophet Muhammad's Birth Celebrations”, 13 November, Singapore Government press release: November-December 1988 (Information Division, Ministry of Communications and Information, Singapore)
7.
AndersonK J, 1987, “The idea of Chinatown: The power of place and institutional practice in the making of a racial category”Annals of the Association of American Geographers77580–598
8.
AndersonK J, 1991Vancouver's Chinatown: Racial Discourse in Canada, 1875–1980 (McGill-Queen's University Press, Montreal)
9.
BenjaminG, 1976, “The cultural logic of Singapore's ‘multiracialism’”, in Singapore: Society in Transition Ed. HassanR (Oxford University Press, Kuala Lumpur) pp 115–133
10.
BiswasL, 1984, “Evolution of Hindu temples in Calcutta”Journal of Cultural Geography473–85
11.
BurgessJGoldJ, 1982, “On the significance of valued environments”, in Valued Environments Eds GoldJBurgessJ (Allen and Unwin, Hemel Hempstead, Herts) pp 1–9
12.
Chan Chee Seng, 1975, “Speech delivered at the Vesak Celebrations of the Singapore Buddhists Vesak Celebration Committee”, 25 May, in Ministry of Social Affairs: Speeches, Statements, Press Conferences and Interviews, 1974- 1976 (Information Division, Ministry of Culture, Singapore)
13.
ChanH C, 1985, “Legislature and legislators”, in Government and Politics in Singapore Eds QuahJ S TChanH CSeahC M (Oxford University Press, Singapore) pp 71–91
14.
Chin Harn Tong, 1988, “Speech delivered at the Hari Raya gathering at Aljunied Community Centre”, 28 May, Singapore Government press release: May-June 1988 (Information Division, Ministry of Communications and Information, Singapore)
15.
ChuaB H, 1983, “Re-opening ideological discussion in Singapore: A New theoretical direction”Southeast Asian Journal of Social Science1131–45
16.
ClarkG LDearM J, 1984State Apparatus: Structures and Language of Legitimacy (Allen and Unwin, London)
17.
Constitution, 1985The Constitution of the Republic of Singaporerevised editionGovernment Printing Office, Singapore)
18.
CosgroveD, 1986, “The geographical study of environmental symbolism: Review and prospect”, Paper presented at XXIV Congresso Italiano, Torino; available from the author, Department of Geography, University of Technology, Loughborough, Leics
19.
CurtisJ R, 1980, “Miami's Little Havana: Yard shrines, cult religion and landscape”Journal of Cultural Geography11–15
20.
DardenJ T, 1972. “Factors in the location of Pittsburgh's cemeteries”The Virginia Geographer73–8
21.
DearM J, 1983. “Society and space: An introduction”Environment and Planning!): Society and Space11–2
22.
DearM J, 1986. “State”, in The Dictionary of Human Geography Eds JohnstonR JGregoryDSmithD M (Basil Blackwell, Oxford) pp 456–457
23.
Drakakis-SmithD WYeungY M, 1977, “Public housing in the city states of Hong Kong and Singapore”, OP-8, Development Studies Centre, Australian National University, Canberra
24.
DuncanJ, 1990The City as Text: The Politics of Landscape Interpretation in the Kandyan Kingdom (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
25.
DuncanJDuncanN, 1988, “(Re)reading the landscape”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space6117–126
26.
EylesJ, 1988, “The geography of everyday life”, in Horizons in Human Geography Eds GregoryDWalfordR (Macmillan, London) pp 102–117
27.
FrancavigliaR V, 1970, “The Mormon landscape: Definition of an image in the American West”Proceedings of the Association of American Geographers259–61
28.
FrancavigliaR V, 1979The Mormon Landscape (AMS Press, New York)
29.
GilsenanM.1982Recognizing Islam: An Anthropologist's Introduction (Croom Helm, Andover, Hants)
30.
Goh Chok Tong, 1985, “Speech delivered at the twentieth anniversary of the Prophet Muhammad Birthday Memorial Scholarship Fund Board's dinner”, 24 August, Singapore Government press release: August 1985 (Information Division, Ministry of Communications and Information, Singapore)
31.
GPO, 1978First Session of the Fourth Parliament, Part II 27 May 1977–31 July 1978, Volume 37 16 March, column 978 (Government Printing Office, Singapore)
32.
GPO, 1984 in First Session of the Fifth Parliament, Part IV, 30 August 1983–20 March 1984, Volume 43 19 March, column 1301 (Government Printing Office, Singapore)
33.
GramsciA, 1973Letters from Prison (Harper and Row, New York)
34.
GregoryD, 1981, “Human agency and human geography”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers: New Series61–18
35.
GregsonN, 1987, “Structuration theory: Some thoughts on the possibilities for empirical research”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space573–91
36.
GriffithJ S, 1975, “The folk-Catholic chapels of the Papagueria”Pioneer America721–36
37.
HallS, 1984, “The state in question”, in The Idea of the Modern State Eds McLennanGHeldDHallS (Open University Press, Milton Keynes) pp 1–28
38.
HarrisonM, 1988, “Symbolism, ‘ritualism’ and the location of crowds in early nineteenth century English towns”, in The Iconography of Landscape Eds CosgrovcDDanielsS (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 194–213
39.
HoA P, 1990, “The Maintenance of Religious Harmony Bill”Mirror 15 April, pages 1–4
40.
Ho Kah Leong, 1987, “Speech delivered at the opening of the fund raising food fair at Assyakirin Mosque”, 17 April, Singapore Government press release: March-April 1987 (Information Division, Ministry of Communications and Information, Singapore)
41.
IsaacE, 1959–60, “Religion, landscape and space”Landscape914–18
42.
IsaacE, 1961–62, “The act and the covenant: The impact of religion on the landscape”Landscape1112–17
43.
JacksonP, 1988, “Street life: The politics of Carnival”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space6213–227
44.
JacksonP, 1989Maps of Meaning: An Introduction to Cultural Geography (Unwin Hyman, London)
45.
JayakumarS, 1982, “Speech delivered at the Hindu Centre Youth Rally and Cultural Show”, 13 February, Singapore Government press release: January-February 1982 (Information Division, Ministry of Culture, Singapore)
46.
JohnsonH B, 1967, “The location of Christian missions in Africa”The Geographical Review57168–202
47.
KhoE M, 1979–80, “Religion and State in Singapore, 1959–1978”, unpublished academic exercise, Department of History, University of Singapore
48.
KongL, 1992, “The sacred on the secular: Exploring contemporary meanings and values for religious buildings in Singapore”Southeast Asian Journal of Social Science2018–42
49.
KuoE C YQuahJ S T, 1988Religion in Singapore: Report of a National Survey (Ministry of Community Development, Singapore)
50.
LaatschW GCalkinsC F, 1986, “The Belgian roadside chapels of Wisconsin's Door Peninsula”Journal of Cultural Geography7117–128
51.
Land Acquisition Act, 1966The Statutes of the Republic of Singapore chapter 41 (Government Printing Office, Singapore)
52.
Lee Boon Yang, 1985, “Speech delivered at Montfort Secondary School's Founder's Day cum Speech Day”, 26 April, Singapore Government press release: March-April 1985 (Information Division, Ministry of Culture, Singapore)
53.
Lee Kuan Yew, 1988, “Speech delivered at the First Ritual for the Observance of the Five Precepts cum the Buddhisattva Precepts by the Singapore Buddhist Federation”, 13 December, Singapore Government press release: November-December 1988 (Information Division, Ministry of Communications and Information, Singapore)
54.
Lee Yiok Seng, 1988, “Speech delivered at the Variety Show organised by the Sra Siva-Krishna Temple Management Committee”, 30 July, Singapore Government press release: November-December 1988 (Information Division, Ministry of Communications and Information, Singapore)
55.
LehrJ, 1972, “Mormon settlement morphology in Southern Alberta”The Alberta Geographer86–13
56.
LewandowskiS J, 1984, “The built environment and cultural symbolism in post-colonial Madras”, in The City in Cultural Context Eds AgnewJ AMercerJSopherD E (Allen and Unwin, Winchester, MA) pp 237–254
57.
LeyD, 1988, “Culture's geographies”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space6115–116
58.
LeyD, 1989, “Modernism, post-modernism, and the struggle for place”, in The Power of Place: Bringing Together Geographical and Sociological Imaginations Eds AgnewJ ADuncanJ S (Unwin Hyman, Winchester, MA) pp 44–65
59.
Maintenance of Religious Harmony Bill, 1991The Statutes of the Republic of Singaporerevised edition, chapter 167a (Government Printing Office, Singapore)
60.
MeinigD W, 1965, “The Mormon culture region: Strategies and patterns in the geography of the American West, 1874–1964”Annals of the Association of American Geographers55191–220
61.
MeyerJ W, 1975, “Ethnicity, theology and immigrant church expansion”The Geographical Review65180–197
62.
MilibandR, 1969The State in Capitalist Society (Quartet Books, London)
63.
Minor Offences Act, 1985The Statutes of the Republic of Singaporerevised edition, chapter 184 (ordinance 13 of 1906) (Government Printing Office, Singapore)
64.
Miscellaneous Offences (Public Order and Nuisance) (Assemblies and Processions) Rules, 1989, Government Gazette Subsidiary Legislation Supplement, Republic of Singapore (Government Printing Office, Singapore)
65.
MoC, 1973, “Singapore Government press release”, 25 November (Information Division, Ministry of Culture, Singapore)
66.
MoC, 1987, “Singapore Government press release”, 3 October (Information Division, Ministry of Culture, Singapore)
67.
MuirEWiessmanF E, 1989, “Social and symbolic places in Renaissance Venice and Florence”, in The Power of Place: Bringing Together Geographical and Sociological Imaginations Eds AgnewJ ADuncanJ S (Unwin Hyman, Winchester, MA) pp 81–104
68.
MukerjiA B, 1972, “Distribution aspects of Muslim population in Uttar Pradesh, 1961”The Geographer1916–29
69.
Othrnan Wok, 1971, “Speech delivered at a Hari Raya gathering organised by the Toa Payoh Mosque Building Committee”, 11 December, in Ministry of Social Affairs: Speeches, Statements, Press Conferences and Interviews, 1971–1973 (Information Division, Ministry of Culture, Singapore)
70.
Othrnan Wok, 1974a, “Speech delivered at the Pasir Panjang Koran Reading Competition”, 17 July, in Ministry of Social Affairs: Speeches, Statements, Press Conferences and Interviews, 1971–1973 (Information Division, Ministry of Culture, Singapore)
71.
Othman Wok, 1974b, “Speech delivered at a meeting with new members of the Majlis Ugama Islam Singapura”, 25 October, in Ministry of Social Affairs: Speeches, Statements, Press Conferences and Interviews, 1974–1976 (Information Division, Ministry of Culture, Singapore)
72.
Othrnan Wok, 1974c, “Speech delivered at a children's Hari Raya party”, 3 November, in Ministry of Social Affairs: Speeches, Statements, Press Conferences and Interviews, 1974–1976 (Information Division, Ministry of Culture, Singapore)
73.
PattisonW D, 1955, “The cemeteries of Chicago: A Phase of land utilization”Annals of the Association of American Geographers45245–257
74.
Preservation of Monuments (Amendment) Act, 1985The Statutes of the Republic of Singapore chapter 239 (Act 45 of 1970) (Government Printing Oftice, Singapore)
75.
Rahim Ishak, 1979, “Speech delivered at the Prophet Mohamed's Birthday Celebration at Oueenstown Mujahidin Mosque”, 25 February, Singapore Government press release: January-February 1979 (Information Division, Ministry of Culture, Singapore)
76.
RajaratnamS, 1981, “Speech delivered at a seminar organised by the Hindu Centre”, 21 March, Singapore Government press release: March-April 1981 (Information Division, Ministry of Culture, Singapore)
77.
ShearesH B, 1972, “Speech delivered at the Opening of the seminar organised by the Inter-Religious Organisation and the Society for Spiritual Culture”, 30 October, in President: Speeches, Statements, Press Conferences and Interviews, 1967–1979 (Information Division, Ministry of Culture, Singapore)
78.
ShortridgeJ R, 1976, “Patterns of religion in the United States”Geographical Review66420–434
79.
SiddiqueS, 1989, “Singaporean identity”, in Management of Success: The Moulding of Modern Singapore Eds SandhuK SWheatleyP (Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, Singapore) pp 563–577
80.
Sidek Saniff, 1985, “Speech delivered at the World Assembly of Muslim Youth Camp”, 23 December, Singapore Government press release: December 1985 (Information Division, Ministry of Communications and Information, Singapore)
81.
SimmieJ, 1974Citizens in Conflict: The Sociology of Town Planning (Hutchinson Education, London)
82.
STPB, 1989Singapore: Official Guide (Singapore Tourist Promotion Board, Singapore)
83.
STPB, 1990Singapore: Official Guide (Singapore Tourist Promotion Board, Singapore)
84.
TehC W, 1969, “Public housing”, in Modern Singapore Hds J B Ooi, H D Chiang (University of Singapore Press, Singapore) pp 171–180
85.
The Business Times1987, “The enlightened religious path”, 12 May, page 8
86.
The Straits Times1977, “When religious buildings make way for progress”, 11 November, page 27
87.
1978a, “HDB to offer new site for Sikh temple”, 17 January, page 5
88.
1978b, “Sikhs turn down offer of alternative site for temple”, 9 February, page 19
89.
1978c, “Lee tells Sikh leaders: all religious groups treated equally”, 18 May, page 9
90.
1979, “Temple bell will toll no more”, 15 June, page 22
91.
1984a, “Denominations' rivalry causing competition for church sites”, 29 July, page 12
VasilR, 1988Governing Singapore: Interviews with the New Leaders (Times Books International, Singapore)
98.
Wong Kan Seng, 1985, “Speech delivered at the Singapore Buddhist Federation Vesak Day Celebrations”, 3 June, Singapore Government press release: May-June 1985 (Information Division, Ministry of Culture, Singapore)
99.
YoungK, 1975, “Urban politics: An overview”, in Essays on the Study of Urban Politics Ed. YoungK (Macmillan, London) pp 185–201
