Urban informality has been the subject of renewed attention in recent years, with a resurgence of interest from architecture and planning. A focus on informality has however been criticised as reviving colonial hierarchies, characterising entire cities in terms of lack and rendering them perpetually inferior to Western cities. The call to postcolonialise urban studies has been answered by an emerging literature which has neglected Latin America. This paper therefore examines recent work on urban informality in the region that resonates with other scholarship at the intersection of postcolonial and urban studies. The Latin American work is characterised by an emphasis on informality as resistance and by challenges to the formal/informal binary. Its ‘favela-isation’ of the continent can however perpetuate dualistic interpretations, entrenching or inverting stereotypes rather than disrupting them. The paper also asks what postcolonial readings of informality from elsewhere can contribute to understanding Latin American experience.
AbramoP (Ed.), 2003A Cidade da Informalidade: O Desafio das Cidades Latino-Americanas (Sette Letras/FAPERJ, Rio de Janeiro)
2.
AlegríaT, 2008, “The solution is not architectural: Housing problems of the poor in Tijuana”Harvard Design Magazine28(spring/summer) 64–66
3.
AlexanderE R, 1988, “Informal settlement in Latin America and its policy implications”, in Spontaneous Shelter: International Perspectives and Prospects Ed. PattonC V (Temple University Press, Philadelphia, PA) pp 125–146
4.
AlSayyadN, 2004, “Urban informality as a ‘new’ way of life”, in Urban Informality: Transnational Perspectives from the Middle East, Latin America, and South Asia Eds RoyAAlSayyadN (Lexington Books, Lanham, MD) pp 7–30
5.
AlSayyadNRoyA, 2004, “Urban informality: Crossing borders”, in Urban Informality: Transnational Perspectives from the Middle East, Latin America, and South Asia Eds RoyAAlSayyadN (Lexington Books, Lanham, MD) pp 1–6
6.
AngottiT, 2006, “Apocalyptic anti-urbanism: Mike Davis and his planet of slums”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research30961–967
7.
AngottiT, 2009, “Apartheid in postcolonial Latin American cities”, paper presented at the XXVIII International Congress of the Latin American Studies Association, Rio de Janeiro
8.
AppaduraiA, 2001, “Deep democracy: Urban governmentality and the horizon of politics”Environment and Urbanization13(2) 23–42
9.
ArabindooP, 2011, “Rhetoric of the ‘slum’: Rethinking urban poverty”City15636–646
10.
AzuelaA, 1987, “Low income settlements and the law in Mexico City”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research11522–542
11.
AzuelaA, 1989La Ciudad, la Propiedad Privada y el Derecho (El Colegio de México, Mexico City)
12.
AzuelaA, 1993, “La propiedad de la vivienda en los barrios populares y la construcción del orden urbano”, in La Urbanización Popular y el Orden Jurídico en América Latina Ed. AzuelaA (Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Mexico City) pp 3–17
13.
BancilhonNPadrónA, 2005, “Caracas invisible(s)”, in Informal City: Caracas Case Eds BrillembourgAFeireissKKlumpnerH (Prestel, Munich) pp 149–155
14.
BayatA, 2004, “Globalization and the politics of the informals in the Global South”, in Urban Informality: Transnational Perspectives from the Middle East, Latin America, and South Asia Eds RoyAAlSayyadN (Lexington Books, Lanham, MD) pp 79–102
BeardsleyJWerthmannC, 2008, “Improving informal settlements: Ideas from Latin America”Harvard Design Magazine28(spring/summer) 31–34
17.
Berenstein-JacquesP, 2001aLes Favelas de Rio: Un Enjeu Culturel (L'Harmattan, Paris)
18.
Berenstein-JacquesP, 2001b, “The aesthetics of the favela: The case of an extreme”, in Transforming Cities: Design in the Favelas of Rio de Janeiro Eds FioriJHinsleyHPascoloEThorntonK (Architectural Association, London) pp 28–30
19.
Berenstein-JacquesP, 2002Esthétique des Favelas: Les favelas de Rio à Travers l'Œuvre de Hélio Oiticica (L'Harmattan, Paris)
20.
BhabhaH, 1994The Location of Culture (Routledge, London)
BitterSWeberH, 2005, “Caracas—hecho en Venezuela”, in Informal City: Caracas Case Eds BrillembourgAFeireissKKlumpnerH (Prestel, Munich) pp 113–121
23.
BrandS, 2006, “City planet”Strategy and Business42(spring) 78–91
24.
BrillembourgAKlumpnerH, 2005a, “Imagine the new city”, in Informal City: Caracas Case Eds BrillembourgAFeireissKKlumpnerH (Prestel, Munich) pp 248–259
25.
BrillembourgAKlumpnerH, 2005b, “Introduction”, in Informal City: Caracas Case Eds BrillembourgAFeireissKKlumpnerH (Prestel, Munich) pp 16–23
26.
BrillembourgAKlumpnerH, 2005c, “The simple and the complex”, in Informal City: Caracas Case Eds BrillembourgAFeireissKKlumpnerH (Prestel, Munich) pp 216–225
27.
BrillembourgAKlumpnerH, 2005d, “Towards an informal city”, in Informal City: Caracas Case Eds BrillembourgAFeireissKKlumpnerH (Prestel, Munich) pp 38–45
28.
BrillembourgC, 2004, “The new slum urbanism of Caracas, invasions and settlements, colonialism, democracy, capitalism and devil worship”AD: Architectural Design74(2) 77–81
Brissac-PeixotoN, 2009, “Latin American cities: The new urban formlessness”, in City/Art: The Urban Scene in Latin America Ed. BironR E (Duke University Press, Durham, NC) pp 233–250
31.
BurianE R, 2007, “Contemporary Mexico City: Recycled sites, regenerative landscapes, and revalued post-industrial enclaves”Perspecta: The Yale Architectural Journal39121–135
32.
CastilloJ, 2001, “Urbanisms of the informal: Transformations in the urban fringe of Mexico City”Praxis: Journal of Writing and Building2(1) 102–111
33.
CastilloM (Ed.), 2009Procesos Urbanos Informales y Territorio: Ensayos en Torno a la Construcción de Sociedad, Territorio y Ciudad (Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Bogotá)
34.
CavalcantiM, 2008, “The politics of concrete and cocaine in favela consolidation”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research32989–1027
35.
ConnollyP, 1976Análisis del Comportamiento del Mercado de Bienes Raíces en la Zona Metropolitana de la Ciudad de México (COPEVI, Mexico City)
36.
ConnollyP, 2008, “Urbanizaciones irregulares como forma dominante de ciudad”, in Irregularidad y Suelo Urbano: Memorias del II Congreso Nacional de Suelo Urbano Eds IrachetaAXMedinaS (El Colegio Mexiquense, Zinacantepec, Mexico) pp 143–170
37.
CoronilF, 1992, “Can postcoloniality be decolonized? Imperial banality and postcolonial power”Public Culture589–108
38.
CoronilF, 1998, “Más allá del occidentalismo: Hacia categorías geohistóricas no-imperialistas”, in Teorías sin Disciplina: Latinoamericanismo, Postcolonialidad y Globalización en Debate Eds Castro-GómezSMendietaE (Porrúa, Mexico City) pp 121–146
39.
CoronilF, 2008, “Elephants in the Americas? Latin American postcolonial studies and global decolonization”, in Coloniality at Large: Latin America and the Postcolonial Debate Eds MorañaMDusselEJáureguiC A (Duke University Press, Durham, NC) pp 396–416
40.
CruzT, 2007, “Border postcards: Chronicles from the edge/Postales fronterizas: Crónicas desde el borde”, in A Dynamic Equilibrium: In Pursuit of Public Terrain Ed. YardS (InSite/University of California, San Diego/Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, San Diego, CA) pp 68–91
41.
DavisM, 2006Planet of Slums (Verso, London)
42.
De la CampaR, 2008, “Postcolonial sensibility, Latin America, and the question of literature”, in Coloniality at Large: Latin America and the Postcolonial Debate Eds MorañaMDusselEJáureguiC A (Duke University Press, Durham, NC) pp 435–458
43.
de SotoH, 2000The Mystery of Capital: Why Capitalism Triumphs in the West and Fails Everywhere Else (Bantam Press, London
44.
de ToroF, 1999, “The postcolonial question: Alterity, identity, and the other(s)”, in El Debate de la Postcolonialidad en Latinoamérica: Una Postmodernidad Periférica o Cambio de Paradigma en el Pensamiento Latinoamericano Eds de ToroFde ToroA (Iberoamericana, Madrid)pp 101–136
45.
DeleuzeGGuattariF, 1987A Thousand Plateaus: Capitalism and Schizophrenia translated by MassumiB (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)
46.
DezeuzeA, 2006, “Thriving on adversity: The art of precariousness”Mute2(3) 74–87
47.
FabriciusD, 2008, “Resisting representation: The informal geographies of Rio de Janeiro”Harvard Design Magazine28(spring/summer) pp 4–17
48.
FioriJ, 2001, “Why Favela-Bairro?”, in Transforming Cities: Design in the Favelas of Rio de Janeiro Eds FioriJHinsleyHPascoloEThorntonK (Architectural Association, London) pp 9–12
49.
FoscariG, 2005Della Favela (INU Edizioni, Rome)
50.
FrancoJ, 1995, “Un retrato”Revista de Crítica Cultural11(November) 18–21
51.
CancliniGarcía N, 2005aImaginarios Urbanos3rd edition (Eudeba, Buenos Aires)
52.
CancliniGarcía N, 2005b, “The megalopolis and its informal order”, in Informal City: Caracas Case Eds BrillembourgAFeireissKKlumpnerH (Prestel, Munich) pp 265–269
53.
GendallJ, 2008, “Co-designing productive parks with the poorest of Kibera, Kenya”Harvard Design Magazine28(spring/summer) 67–69
54.
GilbertA G, 2007, “The return of the slum: Does language matter?”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research31697–713
55.
GilbertA GWardP M, 1985Housing, the State and the Poor: Policy and Practice in Three Latin American Cities (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
56.
Golda-PongratzK, 2004, “The barriadas of Lima: Utopian city of self-organisation?”AD: Architectural Design74(4) 38–45
57.
GoldsteinA, 2012Vivir en la Tierra: Asentamientos en Latinoamérica (Edhasa, Buenos Aires)
58.
GouverneurDGrauerO, 2008, “Urban connectors: Fostering a non-hierarchical integration of formal and informal settlements”Harvard Design Magazine28(spring/summer) 24–30
59.
GunnS, 2006, “From hegemony to governmentality: Changing conceptions of power in social history”Journal of Social History39705–720
60.
HernándezF, 2010Bhabha for Architects (Routledge, London)
61.
HernándezFKellettP, 2010, “Introduction: Reimagining the informal in Latin America”, in Rethinking the Informal City: Critical Perspectives from Latin America Eds HernándezFKellettPAllenL K (Berghahn, New York) pp 1–19
62.
HiernauxDLindónA, 1997, “Producción del espacio y regularización de la tenencia de la tierra en el valle de Chalco”, in El Acceso de los Pobres al Suelo Urbano Eds AzuelaATomasF (CEMCA/UNAM, Mexico City) pp 249–276
63.
HimmelfarbG, 1971, “Mayhew's poor: A problem of identity”Victorian Studies14307–320
64.
HolstonJCaldeiraT, 2008, “Urban peripheries and the invention of citizenship”Harvard Design Magazine28(spring/summer) 18–23
65.
HugoV, 1987Les Misérables translated by FahnestockLMacAfeeN (Penguin, New York)
66.
IrachetaA XMedinaS (Eds), 2008Irregularidad y Suelo Urbano: Memorias del II Congreso Nacional de Suelo Urbano (El Colegio Mexiquense: Zinacantepec, Mexico)
67.
JáureguiJ M, 2003Estrategias de Articulación Urbana. Proyecto y Gestión de Asentamientos Periféricos en América Latina: Un Enfoque Transdisciplinario (Ediciones FADU, Facultad de Arquitectura, Diseño y Urbanismo, Universidad de Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires)
68.
JáureguiJ M, 2004, “Traumas urbanos: Urbanización fuera de control, urbanismo explosivo en América Latina”, in Traumes Urbans: La Ciutat i els Desastres Ed. Centre de Cultura Contemporània de Barcelona (Col·lecció Urbanitats Digitals, Barcelona) pp 125–137
69.
JáureguiJ M, 2010, “Urban and social articulation: Megacities, exclusion and urbanity”, in Rethinking the Informal City: Critical Perspectives from Latin America Eds HernándezFKellettPAllenL K (Berghahn, New York) pp 207–223
70.
KellettPNapierM, 1995, “Squatter architecture? A critical examination of vernacular theory and spontaneous settlement with reference to South America and South Africa”Traditional Dwellings and Settlements Review6(2) 7–24
71.
KlumpnerHBrillembourgA, 2010, “On the road again: Alfredo Brillembourg and Hubert Klumpner in conversation”, in New Towns for the 21st Century: The Planned vs. the Unplanned City Ed. International New Town Institute (SUN, Amsterdam) pp 210–219
72.
LeggSMcFarlaneC, 2008, “Ordinary urban spaces: Between postcolonialism and development”Environment and Planning A406–14
73.
MbembeANuttallS, 2004, “Writing the world from an African metropolis”Public Culture16347–372
74.
MehrotraR, 2010, “Foreword”, in Rethinking the Informal City: Critical Perspectives from Latin America Eds HernándezFKellettPAllenL K (Berghahn, New York), pp xi–xiv
75.
MendietaE, 2001, “Invisible cities: A phenomenology of globalization from below”City5(1) 7–26
76.
MignoloW D, 1993, “Colonial and postcolonial discourse: Cultural critique or academic colonialism?”Latin American Research Review28(3) 120–134
77.
MignoloW D, 1998, “Posoccidentalismo: El argumento desde América Latina”, in Teorías sin Disciplina: Latinoamericanismo, Postcolonialidad y Globalización en Debate Eds Castro-GómezSMendietaE (Porrúa, Mexico City) pp 31–58
78.
MignoloW D, 2000Local Histories/Global Designs: Coloniality, Subaltern Knowledges, and Border Thinking (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
79.
MorañaMDusselEJáureguiC A, 2008, “Colonialism and its replicants”, in Coloniality at Large: Latin America and the Postcolonial Debate Eds MorañaMDusselEJáureguiC A (Duke University Press, Durham, NC) pp 1–20
80.
NuttallSMbembeA, 2005, “A blasé attitude: A response to Michael Watts”Public Culture17193–201
81.
PayneG K, 1973, “Functions of informality: Squatter settlements in Delhi”Architectural Design43494–503
82.
PerlmanJ E, 1976The Myth of Marginality: Urban Poverty and Politics in Rio de Janeiro (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
83.
PerlmanJ E, 2009Favela: Four Decades of Living on the Edge in Rio de Janeiro (Oxford University Press, New York)
84.
PotrčMEsakovL, 2005, “Growing house—growing city”, in Informal City: Caracas Case Eds BrillembourgAFeireissKKlumpnerH (Prestel, Munich) pp 178–186
85.
RaoV, 2006, “Slum as theory: The South/Asian city and globalization”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research30225–232
86.
RedfordK H, 1991, “The ecologically noble savage”Cultural Survival Quarterly15(1) 46–48
87.
RibbeckEPadillaS, 2002Die Informelle Moderne: Spontanes Bauen in Mexico-Stadt/Informal Modernism: Spontaneous Building in Mexico City (Architektur und Wirtschaftsförderungs-Verlag/Universität Stuttgart, Heidelberg/Stuttgart)
88.
RichardN, 1998, “Intersectando Latinoamérica con el latinoamericanismo: Discurso académico y crítica cultural”, in Teorías sin Disciplina: Latinoamericanismo, Postcolonialidad y Globalización en Debate Eds Castro-GómezSMendietaE (Porrúa, Mexico City), pp 245–270
89.
RobinsonJ, 2006a, “Inventions and interventions: Transforming cities—an introduction”Urban Studies43251–258
90.
RobinsonJ, 2006bOrdinary Cities: Between Modernity and Development (Routledge, London)
91.
RolnikR, 1997A Cidade e a Lei: Legislacão, Política Urbana e Territórios na Cidade de São Paulo (Studio Nobel, São Paulo)
92.
RoyA, 2005, “Urban informality: Toward an epistemology of planning”Journal of the American Planning Association71147–158
93.
RoyA, 2009a, “The 21st-century metropolis: New geographies of theory”Regional Studies43819–830
94.
RoyA, 2009b, “Why India cannot plan its cities: Informality, insurgence and the idiom of urbanization”Planning Theory876–87
95.
RoyA, 2011, “Slumdog cities: Rethinking subaltern urbanism”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research35223–238
96.
RoyAAlSayyadN, 2004, “Preface”, in Urban Informality: Transnational Perspectives from the Middle East, Latin America, and South Asia Eds RoyAAlSayyadN (Lexington Books, Lanham, MD) pp vii–viii
97.
SalazarC E (Ed.), 2012Irregular: Suelo y Mercado en América Latina (El Colegio de México, Mexico City)
98.
SantosB de S, 1977, “The law of the oppressed: The construction and reproduction of legality in Pasargada”Law and Society Review125–126
99.
SassenS, 2005, “Fragmented urban topographies and their underlying interconnections”, in Informal City: Caracas Case Eds BrillembourgAFeireissKKlumpnerH (Prestel, Munich) pp 83–87
SeedP, 1991, “Colonial and postcolonial discourse”Latin American Research Review26(3) 181–200
102.
TaussigM T, 1980The Devil and Commodity Fetishism in South America (University of North Carolina Press, Chapel Hill, NC)
103.
TerryT, 2001, “Reflections on the workshop”, in Transforming Cities: Design in the Favelas of Rio de Janeiro Eds FioriJHinsleyHPascoloEThorntonK (Architectural Association/PROURB, London/Rio de Janeiro) pp 26–27
104.
ThurnerM, 1996, “Historicizing ‘the postcolonial’ from nineteenth-century Peru”Journal of Historical Sociology91–18
105.
TurnerJ F C, 1968, “The squatter settlement: An architecture that works”Architectural Design38355–360
106.
TurnerJ F C, 1978, “Housing in three dimensions: Terms of reference for the housing question redefined”World Development61135–1145
107.
UN-Habitat, 2003The Challenge of Slums: Global Report on Human SettlementsUnited Nations Human Settlement Programme (Earthscan, London)
108.
ValladaresL do P, 2005A Invencão da Favela: Do Mito de Origem a Favela.com (Editora FGV, Rio de Janeiro)
109.
VarleyA, 1985a, “Urbanization and agrarian law: The case of Mexico City”Bulletin of Latin American Research41–16
110.
VarleyA, 1985b, Ya somos dueños: Ejido land development and regularisation in Mexico City PhD thesis, Department of Geography, University College London
111.
VarleyA, 1998, “The political uses of illegality: Evidence from urban Mexico”, in Illegal Cities: Law and Urban Change in Developing Countries Eds FernandesEVarleyA (Zed Books, London) pp 172–190
112.
VarleyA, 2002, “Public or private: Debating the meaning of tenure legalization”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research26449–461
113.
VazL FBerenstein-JacquesP, 2004, “Morphological diversity in the squatter settlements of Rio de Janeiro”, in Suburban Form: An International Perspective Eds StanilovKScheerB C (Routledge, New York) pp 61–72
114.
WattsM, 2005, “Baudelaire over Berea, Simmel over Sandton?”Public Culture17181–192
115.
YiftachelO, 2009, “Theoretical notes on ‘gray cities’: The coming of urban apartheid?”Planning Theory888–100
116.
YúdiceG, 1989, “Marginality and the ethics of survival”Social Text21214–236
