In this paper I examine the process through which different claims to ‘development’ and ‘sustainability’ were made during a recent public inquiry into an application for a coastal superquarry at Lingerbay, Isle of Harris. On the one hand, a modernist discourse of sustainable development was claimed by a corporation which attempted to frame the debate in terms of jobs versus environment, exploiting rhetorically a difference between islander and incomer. Sustainable development here became the front for an extension of corporate interest and private property. On the other hand, members of the local community drew on historically resilient symbols of collective identity, crofting, the Gaidhealtacht, and observance of the Sabbath, to claim an alternative discourse of sustainability.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdkinL E, 1992, “Counter-hegemony and environmental politics in Canada”, in Organizing Dissent. Contemporary Social Movements in Theory and Practice Ed. CarrollW K, (Garamond Press, Toronto)
2.
BartonH, 1996, “The Isle of Harris superquarry: Concepts of the environment and sustainability”Environmental Values597–122
3.
BrydenJ, 1996, “Land tenure and rural development”, The John McEwan Lecture 1996, Perth, Scotland; copy available from Rural Forum Scotland, Highland House, St Catherine's Road, Perth PH1 5RY, Scotland
4.
CarneyJWattsM, 1990, “Manufacturing dissent: Work, gender and the politics of meaning in a peasant society”Africa60207–240
5.
CCS, 1974A Park System for Scotland Countryside Commission for Scotland (Scottish Natural Heritage, Edinburgh)
6.
CohenA P, 1985The Symbolic Construction of Community (Tavistock, London)
7.
CohenA P, 1993, “Culture as identity: An anthropologist's view”, New Literary History24(1) 195–209
8.
CooperD, 1977Hebridean Connection: A View of the Highlands and Islands (Routledge and Kegan Paul, London)
DarlingF F, 1955West Highland Survey: An Essay in Human Ecology (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
13.
DoE, 1994aThe Mineral Planning Guidance 6. Guidelines for Aggregates Provision in England and Wales (MPG6) Department of the Environment (The Stationery Office, London)
14.
DoE, 1994b, Sustainable Development. The UK Strategy Department of the Environment (The Stationery Office, London)
15.
DreyfusH LRabinowP, 1983Michel Foucault: Beyond Structuralism and Hermeneutics (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
16.
EscobarA, 1995, “Imagining a post-development era”, in Power of Development Ed. CrushJ, (Routledge, London) pp 211–227
17.
FergusonJ, 1994The Anti-Politics Machine. ‘Development’, Depoliticization, and Bureaucratic Power in Lesotho (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)
18.
Friends of the Earth Scotland, 1996Towards a Sustainable ScotlandFriends of the Earth, Edinburgh
19.
GiddensA, 1991Modernity and Self-identity: Self and Society in the Late Modern Age (Polity Press, Cambridge)
20.
HDL, 19973-Year Business Plan 1 April 1997 to March 2000Harris Development Limited, Old Hostel, Tarbert, Isle of Harris, Scotland, HS3 3BG
21.
HornborgA, 1994, “Environmentalism, ethnicity and sacred places: Reflections on modernity, discourse and power”Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology31245–267
22.
HunterJ, 1976The Making of the Crofting Community (John Donald, Edinburgh)
23.
HunterJ, 1995On the Other Side of Sorrow: Nature and People in the Scottish Highlands (Mainstream, Edinburgh)
24.
JedrejCNuttallM, 1996White Settlers: The Impact of Rural Repopulation in Scotland (Harwood Academic, Luxembourg)
25.
LawsonB, 1991St Clement's Church at Rodel (Bill Lawson Publications, Northton, Isle of Harris)
26.
LQG, 1996The Case Against the Harris SuperquarryLink Quarry Group, Friends of the Earth Scotland, Edinburgh
27.
MacAulayJ, 1993Silent Tower: A History and Description of St Clement's Church at Rodel (Pentland Press, Durham)
28.
MacCaigN, 1990Collected Poems (Chatto and Windus, London)
29.
McCroneD, 1992Understanding Scotland: The Sociology of Stateless Nation (Routledge, London)
30.
MacGill-Eain S/MacLeanS, 1991O Choille gu Bearradh/From Wood to Ridge: Collected Poems in Gaelic and English (Vintage, London)
31.
McGrathJ, 1981The Cheviot, The Stag and The Black, Black Oil (Eyre Methuen, London)
32.
McIntoshA, 1995a, “Lands and minds: Psychospiritual aspects of green consciousness”, Centre for Human Ecology, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh
33.
McIntoshA, (Ed.) 1995bTheology and the Isle of Harris Superquarry Public InquiryCentre for Human Ecology, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh
34.
McIntoshA, 1996, “Conscientisation in the community: The ‘French Revolution’ on Eigg and the ‘Gravel Pit of Europe’”, unpublished manuscript, Moray House Institute of Education, Heriot-Watt University, Edinburgh; copy available from A McIntosh, Centre for Human Ecology, Edinburgh, Scotland
35.
McIntoshAWightmanAMorganD, 1994, “Reclaiming the Scottish Highlands: Clearance, conflict and crofting”The Ecologist24(2) 64–70
36.
MacLennS, 1941, “The poetry of the Clearances”Transactions of the Gaelic Society of Inverness38293–324
37.
MaltzA, 1994–95, “Commentary on the Harris Superquarry Inquiry”Journal of Law and Religion11(2) 793–833
38.
MooreD S, 1993, “Contesting terrain in Zimbabwe's Eastern Highlands: Political ecology, ethnography, and peasant resource struggles”Economic Geography69380–401
39.
MooreD S, 1996, “Marxism, culture and political ecology: Environmental struggles in Zimbabwe's eastern highlands”, in Liberation Ecologies Eds PeetRWattsM, (Routledge, London)
40.
ParpartJ LMarchandM H, 1995, “Exploding the canon: An introduction/conclusion”, in Feminism, Postmodernism, Development Eds MarchandM HParpartJ L, (Routledge, London) pp 1–22
41.
Press and Journal1996, “Quarry Group denies it is ‘creature of Redland’”, 4 April, page 3
42.
Press and Journal1997, “Cash for quarry backers—claim”, 22 March
43.
QBG, 1997, press release, April; copy from The Harris Council for Voluntary Service, Room 5, Old Hostel, Tarbert, Isle of Harris, Scotland, HS3 3BG
44.
RAL, 1997, press release, 19 March; copy available from the author
45.
RennieF, 1993The Harris Integrated Development Programme prepared on behalf of the Harris Integrated Development Programme Steering Group
46.
SaidE W, 1993Culture and Imperialism (Alfred A Knopf, New York)
47.
ScottJ, 1985Weapons of the Weak, Everyday Forms of Peasant Resistance (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT)
48.
Scottish Crofters Union (Aonadh nan Croitearan) and the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (An Comann Rioghail Airson Dion nan Eun), 1992 Crofting and the Environment. A New Approach (Acair, Stornoway)
49.
Scottish Crofters Union (Aonadh nan Croitearan) and the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (An Comann Rioghail Airson Dion nan Eun), 1995 Rural Development and the Environment. Opportunities in the Highlands and Islands (Leasachadh duthchail agus an arainneachd. Cothroman air a'Ghaihealtachd agus na h-Eileanan) (SCU/RSPB, Edinburgh)
50.
Scottish Development Department, 1972Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1972 (The Stationery Office, London)
51.
Scottish Office, 1994National Planning Policy Guideline. Land for Mineral Working, Scottish Office (NPPG4) (Environment Department, Scottish Office, Edinburgh)
StephenI, 1994Providence II (Windfall Press, Gress, Isle of Lewis)
56.
Stornoway Gazette1995a, “Fishermen protest”, 4 May, page 6
57.
Stornoway Gazette1995b, “Quarry backers in last battle as protestors triumph”, 8 June, page 1
58.
Stornoway Gazette1996, Advertisement taken out by the CQLSN, pages 5–6
59.
Stornoway Gazette1997a, “Comment” and “Viewpoint”, and “Quarry group hit back”, 27 March
60.
Stornoway Gazette1997b, “Viewpoints”, “Riddle of ‘project’ for quarry network”, letter from Catherine MacDonald, 24 April
61.
ThomsonD, 1990An Introduction to Gaelic Poetry (Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh)
62.
ToogoodM, 1995, “Representing ecology and Highland tradition”Area27(2) 102–109
63.
United Kingdom Government, 1884Report of the Commissioners of Inquiry into the Condition of the Crofters and Cottars in the Highlands and Islands of Scotland parliamentary publication; copy available from the Public Information Office, House of Commons, London SW1A 2DG
64.
West Highland Free Press, 1993, “Quarry firm fined”, 7 October
WIIC, 1988Western Isles Structure Plan/Dealbh-Chruth nan Eilean SiarWestern Isles Island Council/Comhairle nan Eilean, Stornoway, Isle of Harris
70.
WIIC, 1995Statistical Area Content of Local Plan Areas 1991 Census Results, Western Isles Island Council, Stornoway, Isle of Harris
71.
WilsonC IGribbleC D, 1980, “Potential for a large coastal quarry in Scotland: Preliminary research report”, prepared for the Planning Services, Scottish Development Department, Scottish Office, Edinburgh; copy available from the author
72.
WithersC W J, 1988Gaelic Scotland: The Transformation of a Culture Region (Routledge, London)
73.
WithersC W J, 1996, “Place, memory, monument: Memorializing the past in contemporary Highland Scotland”Ecumene3325–344
