Societies in the Middle Ages underwent a fundamental change in their mode of organisation as they moved from being organised around concepts of kin rule to being ordered around the power exercised by kings over defined territories. Even though this state-making process led to the creation of a landscape that was inherently impersonal in nature, kings strove to legitimise and justify the existence of the new state to their subjects. Their principal method of engendering a sense of loyalty towards their kingdom or early state was through the promotion of certain group ideologies. A variety of these legitimising ideologies were utilised by societal leaders, including foundation legends of kingdoms, origin legends of people, and the promotion of senses of ethnic identity. By drawing on evidence from two Celtic societies in the British Isles, namely Wales and Ireland, it is argued that legitimising ideologies experienced a general increase in their geographical scale throughout the Middle Ages. It is suggested that the main reason for this general trend was the increasing use, and subsequent increasing maturity, of state institutions within medieval society. Such institutions enabled medieval rulers to govern larger territories in a more efficient manner and, as a consequence, legitimising ideologies of an ever-increasing geographical scale were needed in order to justify the rule of those particular political units. It is concluded that these legitimising ideologies were principally political constructs, which were manipulated by medieval rulers in order to justify their rule of an evolving state landscape.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AndersonB, 1983Imagined Communities (New Left Books, London)
2.
BarrowG W S, 1980The Anglo-Norman Era in Scottish History (Clarendon Press, Oxford)
3.
BartlettR, 1993The Making of Europe: Conquest, Colonisation and Cultural Change 950-1350 (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx)
4.
BinchyD A, 1970Celtic and Anglo-Saxon Kingship (Clarendon Press, Oxford)
5.
ByrneF J, 1971, “Tribes and tribalism in early Ireland”Ériu22128–164
6.
ByrneF J, 1973Irish Kings and High-Kings (Batsford, London)
7.
ChadwickN K, 1958, “Early culture and learning in North Wales”, in Studies in the Early British Church Ed. ChadwickN K, (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 29–120
8.
Charles-EdwardsT M, 1971, “Some Celtic kinship terms”Bulletin of the Board of Celtic Studies24105–122
9.
Charles-EdwardsT M, 1993Early Irish and Welsh Kinship (Clarendon Press, Oxford)
10.
ClaessenH J MSkalnikP, 1978, “The early state: Theories and hypotheses”, in The Early State Eds ClaessenH J MSkalnikP, (Mouton, The Hague) pp 3–29
11.
ConversiD, 1995, “Reassessing current theories of nationalism: Nationalism and boundary maintenance and creation”Nationalism and Ethnic Politics173–85
12.
DaviesJ C, 1940The Welsh Assize Roll 1277–1284 (University of Wales Press, Cardiff)
13.
DaviesR R, 1984, “Law and national identity in thirteenth-century Wales”, in Welsh Society and Nationhood. Essays to Glanmor Williams Ed. DaviesR R, (University of Wales Press, Cardiff) p 51–69
14.
DaviesR R, 1992The Age of Conquest: Wales 1093–1415 (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
15.
DaviesW EFouracreP, 1986The Settlement of Disputes in Early Medieval Europe (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
16.
DeneckeD, 1992, “Ideology in the planned order upon the land: The example of Germany”, in Ideology and Landscape in Historical Perspective Eds BakerA R HBigerG, (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 303–329
17.
DodgshonR A, 1987The European Past: Social Evolution and Spatial Order (Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants)
18.
DriverF, 1991, “Political geography and state formation: Disputed territory”Progress in Human Geography15268–280
19.
DuffyS, 1997Ireland in the Middle Ages (Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants)
20.
DumvilleD, 1977, “Sub-Roman Britain: History and legend”History52173–192
21.
FrameR, 1990The Political Development of the British Isles 1100–1400 (Clarendon Press, Oxford)
22.
GellnerE, 1983Nations and Nationalism (Basil Blackwell, Oxford)
23.
GledhillJ, 1988, “Introduction: The comparative analysis of social and political transitions”, in State and Society: The Emergence and Development of Social Hierarchy and Political Centralisation Eds GledhillJBenderBLarsenM T, (Unwin Hyman, London) pp 1–29
24.
HenigeD P, 1971, “Oral tradition and chronology”Journal of African Studies12371–389
25.
HobsbawmE J, 1990Nations and Nationalism Since 1780 (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
26.
HobsbawmE JRangerT O, (Eds), 1992The Invention of Tradition (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
27.
JenkinsD, 1970Cyfraith Hywel: Rhagarweiniad i Gyfraith Gynhenid Cymru'r Oesau Canol [The Laws of Hywel: An introduction to medieval Welsh indigenous law] (Gomer Press, Llandysul, Wales)
28.
JonesG R J, 1992, “The models for organisation in Llyfr Iorwerth and Llyfr Cyfnerth“Bulletin of the Board of Celtic Studies3995–118
29.
JonesR, 1998, “Early state formation in native medieval Wales”Political Geography17667–682
30.
JonesT, (Ed.), 1955Brut y Tywysogyon [Chronicles of the princes]: Red Book of Hergest Version (University of Wales Press, Cardiff)
31.
KohnH, 1944The Idea of Nationalism (Macmillan, New York)
32.
KohtH, 1947, “The dawn of nationalism in Europe”American Historical Review52265–280
33.
LloberaJ R, 1994The God of Modernity: The Development of Nationalism in Western Europe (Berg, Oxford)
34.
LloydNOwenM E, (Eds), 1986Drych yr Oesoedd Canol [A mirror of the Middle Ages] (University of Wales Press, Cardiff)
35.
LotF, 1934Nennius et l'Historia Brittonum [Nennius and the history of the Britons] (H Champion, Paris)
36.
LowenthalD, 1985The Past is a Foreign Country (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
37.
Mac NeillE, 1935Early Irish Laws and Institutions (Burns, Oates and Washbourne, Dublin)
38.
MartinC T, (Ed.), 1884Registrum Epistolarum Fratris Johannis Peckham, Archiepiscopi Canticariensis [Register of the letters of Brother John Peckham, Archbishop of Canterbury] (Longman, London)
39.
MillerM, 1978, “The foundation legends of Gwynedd in the Latin texts”Bulletin of the Board of Celtic Studies27515–532
40.
Ó CorráinD, 1971, “Irish regnal succession: A reappraisal”Studia Hibernica111–35
41.
Ó CorráinD, 1978, “Nationality and kingship in pre-Norman Ireland”, in Nationality and the Pursuit of National Independence Ed. MoodyT W, (Appletree Press, Belfast)
42.
Ó CróinínD, 1995Early Medieval Ireland 400–1200 (Longman, Harlow, Essex)
43.
O'DonovanJ, 1847The Book of Rights: Ancient Laws of Ireland, Published Under the Direction of the Commissioners for Publishing the Ancient Laws and Institute of Ireland (Alexander Thorn, Dublin)
44.
OwenA, (Ed.), 1841Ancient Laws and Institutes of Walesvolume 1 (Record Commissioners, London)
45.
O'RahillyT F, 1946Early Irish History and MythologyInstitute for Advanced Studies, School of Celtic Studies, 10 Burlington Road, Dublin, Ireland
46.
PocockJ G A, 1962, “The origins of the study of the past: A comparative approach”Comparative Studies in Society and History4209–246
47.
ReynoldsS, 1981, “Law and communities in Western Europe c.900–1300”American Journal of Legal History25205–224
48.
ReynoldsS, 1983. “Medieval Origines Gentium and the community of the realm”History68375–390
49.
ReynoldsS, 1984Kingdoms and Communities in Western Europe, 900–1300 (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
50.
RichterM, 1978, “The political and institutional background to national consciousness in medieval Wales”, in Nationalism and the Pursuit of National Independence Ed. MoodyT W, (Appletree Press, Belfast)
SmithJ B, 1986Llywelyn ap Gruffudd; Tywysog Cymru [Llywelyn ap Gruffudd: Prince of Wales] (University of Wales Press, Cardiff)
55.
SmythA P, 1982Celtic Leinster: Towards an Historical Geography of Early Irish Civilisation AD 500–1600 (Irish Academic Press, Dublin)
56.
StubbsW, (Ed.), 1913Select Charters and Other Illustrations of English Constitutional History: From the Earliest Times to the Reign of Edward the First (Clarendon Press, Oxford)
57.
VansinaJ, 1985Oral Tradition as History (University of Wisconsin Press, Madison, WI)
58.
Wade-EvansA W, 1906, “The Brychan documents”Y Cymmrodor1928–50
59.
WhiteM, 1997, “History delivers a faint cry of yes”The Guardian20 September, page 8
60.
WhiteR, 1978, “New light on the origins of the kingdom of Gwynedd”, in Astudiaethau yn yr Hengerdd Eds BromwichRJonesR B, (University of Wales Press, Cardiff) pp 350–355
