The idea of ‘graduated sovereignty’ has been used in economic geography and related fields to describe neoliberal capitalism and its negative implications for countries in the Global South. Scholars such as Aihwa Ong use the term primarily to reflect on how states and their elites in the Global South flexibly manage territories and populations at different spatial scales, including export-processing zones. In this paper, attention is given to how ‘graduated sovereignty’ is a useful lens to interrogate territorial claims (including the preservation of territorial integrity) and the spatially varied performance of state power. The Canadian government led by Prime Minister Stephen Harper and his government's Arctic policies and strategies are a case in point. Graduated sovereignty is only one element, however, as the paper considers how a form of paternal sovereignty plays a part in managing the normative ideas of territorial integrity, the presence of exceptional circumstances, and the role of future uncertainties. Using Operation Nanook 10 as a short case study, the paper considers how the government puts to work an uncertain future regarding the Canadian Arctic is materialised and then made actionable by invoking both graduated and paternal forms of sovereignty.
AbeleF, 2009, “The state and the northern social economy: Research prospects”The Northern Review3037–58
2.
Beyond the blue horizon: Northern development policy in the Mulroney years”, in Examining the Legacy: The Era of Prime Minister Brian Mulroney Ed. BlakeR (McGill-Queens University Press, Montreal and Kingston) pp 218–242
3.
AbeleF, 2011, “Use it or lose it? The Conservatives' Northern Strategy”, in How Ottawa Spends 2011–2012: Trimming Fat or Slicing Pork Eds StoneyCDoernB (McGill-Queens University Press, Montreal and Kingston) pp 218–242
4.
AgnewJ, 1994, “The territorial trap: The geographical assumptions of international relations theory”International Review of Political Economy153–80
5.
AgnewJ, 2005, “Sovereignty regimes: Territoriality and state authority in world politics”Annals of the Association of the American Geographers95437–461
6.
AgnewJ, 2009Globalization and Sovereignty (Rowman and Littlefield, Lanham, MD)
7.
AnahitaSMixT, 2006, “Retrofitting frontier masculinity for Alaska's war against wolves”Gender and Society20322–353
8.
AndersonA, 2009After the Ice: Life, Death and Politics in the New Arctic (HarperCollins, London)
9.
AndersonB, 2010a, “Security and the future: Anticipating the event of terror”Geoforum41227–235
10.
AndersonB, 2010b, “Preemption, precaution, preparedness: Anticipatory action and future geographies”Progress in Human Geography34777–798
BehielsM, 2010, “Stephen Harper's rise to power: Will his ‘new’ Conservative Party become Canada's ‘Natural Governing Party’ of the twenty-first century?”American Review of Canadian Studies40118–145
16.
BergLLonghurstR, 2004, “Placing masculinities and geography”Gender, Place and Culture10351–360
17.
BilligM, 1995Banal Nationalism (Sage, London)
18.
BirdKCharpentierR RGautierD LHouseknechtD WKlettT RPitmanJ KMooreT ESchenkC JTennysonM EWandreyC J, 2008Circum-Arctic Resource Appraisal: Estimates of Undiscovered Oil and Gas North of the Arctic Circle factsheet 2008–3049, http://pubs.usgs.gov/fs/2008/3049/.
19.
BorgersonS, 2008, “Arctic meltdown: The economic and security implication of global warming”Foreign Affairs8763–77
20.
BraddonC, 2009, “The true North strong and free for the taking? The need for Canada to apply the whole of government approach in the pursuit of Arctic security”Canadian Army Journal12(2) 62–74
21.
BraunB, 2000, “Producing vertical territory: Geology and governmentality in late Victorian Canada”Cultural Geographies77–46
CoatesKLackenbauerWPoelzerG, 2008Arctic Front: Defending Canada in the High North (Thomas Allen, Markham, Ontario)
35.
CohenA, 2004While Canada Slept (McClelland and Stewart, Toronto)
36.
ColemanM, 2009, “What counts as the politics and practice of security, and where? Devolution and immigrant insecurity after 9/11”Annals of the Association of American Geographers99904–913
37.
CollisC, 2004, “The Proclamation Island moment: Making Antarctica Australian”Law Text Culture81–18
38.
ConnellR, 1987Gender and Power (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA)
39.
ConnellR, 1993, “The big picture”Theory and Society22597–623
40.
CooperALackenbauerW, 2007, “The Achilles heel of Canadian good international citizenship: Indigenous diplomacies and state responses in the twentieth century”Canadian Foreign Policy1399–119
41.
CosgroveDDellaDora V (Eds), 2009High Places (I B Tauris, London)
42.
CraciunA, 2009, “The scramble for the Arctic”Interventions11103–114
43.
DavisT, 2007Stages of Emergency (Duke University Press, Durham NC)
44.
Department for Foreign Affairs and International Trade, 2000The Northern Dimension of Canada's Foreign Policy (Department for Foreign Affairs and International Trade, Ottawa)
DoddsK, 2008, “Icy geopolitics”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space341–6
51.
DoddsK, 2010a, “We are a northern country: Stephen Harper and the Canadian North”Polar Record47371–311
52.
DoddsK, 2010b, “A polar Mediterranean? Accessibility, resources and sovereignty in the Arctic Ocean”Global Policy1303–311
53.
DoddsK, 2010c, “Flag planting and finger pointing: The law of the sea, the Arctic and the political geographies of the outer continental shelf”Political Geography2963–73
54.
DoddsK, 2011, “Sovereignty watch: Claimant states, resources and territory in contemporary Antarctica”Polar Record in press
55.
DotyR, 2011, “Bare life: Border-crossing deaths and spaces of moral alibi”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space29599–612
56.
EbingerCZambetakisE, 2009, “The geopolitics of Arctic melt”International Affairs851215–1232
57.
EldenS, 2005, “Missing the point: Globalization, deterritorialization and the space of the world”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers30(1) 8–19
58.
EmelJHuberMMakeneM, 2011, “Extracting sovereignty: Capital, territory, and gold mining in Tanzania”Political Geography30(2) 70–79
59.
EmmersonC, 2010The Future History of the Arctic (Public Affairs, New York)
60.
FarishM, 2006, “Frontier engineering: From the globe to the body in the Cold War Arctic”The Canadian Geographer50177–196
FengeTPenikettT, 2010, “The Arctic vacuum in Canada's foreign policy”Policy Options April 6570
63.
FurnissE, 2000Colonialism and the Frontier Myth in a Rural Canadian Community (UBC Press, Vancouver)
64.
GerhardtHSteinbergPTaschJFabianoSShieldsR, 2010, “Contested sovereignty in a changing Arctic”Annals of the Association of American Geographers100992–1002
65.
GriffithsF (Ed.), 1987Politics of the Northwest Passage (McGill-Queens University Press, Montreal and Kingston)
66.
GunnJ, 2008, “Father trouble: Staging sovereignty in Spielberg's War of the Worlds”Critical Studies in Media Communication251–27
67.
HannahM, 2010, “(Mis)adventures in Rumsfeld space”GeoJournal75397–406
JohnsonL, 2010, “The fearful symmetry of Arctic climate change: Accumulation by degradation”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space28828–847
79.
JohnsonW, 2006Stephen Harper and the Future of Canada (McClelland and Steward, Toronto)
80.
JonesR, 2009, “Geopolitical boundary narratives, the global war on terror and border fencing in India”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series34290–304
81.
KeskitaloE, 2004Negotiating the Arctic (Routledge, London)
82.
KoivurovaT, 2009, “Limits and possibilities of the Arctic Council in a rapidly changing scene of Arctic governance”Polar Record451–11
83.
KollinS, 2007Nature's State: Imagining Alaska as the Last Frontier (University of North Carolina Press, Chapel Hill, NC)
84.
KristoffersenBYoungS, 2009, “Geographies of security and statehood in Norway's ‘Battle of the North’”Geoforum41577–584
85.
LackenbauerWFarishM, 2007, “The Cold War on Canadian soil: Militarizing a northern environment”Environmental History12921–950
86.
LesterADussartF, 2009, “Masculinity, ‘race’, and family in the colonies: Protecting Aborigines in the early nineteenth century”Gender, Place and Culture1663–75
87.
McConnellF, 2013, “Sovereignty”, in The Ashgate Research Companion to Critical Geopolitics Eds DoddsKKuusMSharpJ (Ashgate, Farnham, Surrey) in press
88.
MacDonaldFHughesRDoddsK (Eds), 2010Observant States: Geopolitics and Visual Cultures (I B Tauris, London)
NeilsonB, 2010, “Between governance and sovereignty: Remaking the borderscape to Australia's north”RMIT Local—Global Journal8124–140
98.
NeufeldM, 1995, “Hegemony and foreign policy analysis: The case of Canada as a middle power”Studies in Political Economy487–29
99.
NordD, 2007, “Searching for the north in North American foreign policies: Canada and the United States”American Review of Canadian Studies37207–217
100.
NuttallM, 2009, “Aboriginal participation, consultation and the Mackenzie Gas Project”Energy and Environment19617–634
101.
OngA, 2006Neo-liberalism as Exception (Duke University Press, Durham, NC)
102.
ParkB-G, 2005, “Spatially selective liberalization and graduated sovereignty: Politics of neoliberalism and ‘special economic zones’ in South Korea”Political Geography24850–874
103.
PetersonS, 1992Gendered States (Lynne Rienner, Boulder, CO)
104.
PharandD, 1988Canada's Arctic Waters in International Law (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
105.
PharandD, 2007, “The Arctic waters and the North West Passage: A final revisit”Ocean Development and International Law383–69
106.
PowellR, 2008a, “Configuring an ‘Arctic Commons’?”Political Geography27827–832
107.
PowellR, 2008b, “Science, sovereignty and nation: Canada and the legacy of the International Geophysical Year 1957–58”Journal of Historical Geography34618–638
108.
ReevesM, 2011, “Fixing the border: On the affective life of the state in southern Kyrgyzstan”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space29905–923
109.
RobinsonZ, 2005, “Storming the heights: Canadian frontier nationalism and the making of manhood in the conquest of Mount Robson 1906–13”International Journal of the History of Sport22415–433
110.
RoseG, 1993Geography and Feminism (Polity Press, Cambridge)
111.
ShepherdL, 2009Gender Matters in Global Politics (Routledge, London)
112.
SimonM, 2009, “Inuit and the Canadian Arctic: Sovereignty begins at home”, ‘State of the Union’ public address, University of Waterloo, 3 March, http://marysimonlecture.eventbrite.com
113.
SparkeM, 1995, “Between demythologising and deconstructing the map: Shawnadithit's New-found-land and the alienation of Canada”Cartographica321–21
114.
SparkeM, 1996, “Displacing the field in fieldwork: Masculinity, metaphor and space” in BodySpace: Destabilizing Geographies of Gender and Sexuality (Routledge, New York) pp 212–233
ThriftN, 2000, “It's the little things”, in Geopolitical Traditions Eds DoddsKAtkinsonD (Routledge, London) pp 380–388
121.
Van HamP, 2008, “Place branding: The state of the art”Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science616126–149
122.
Vaughan-WilliamsN, 2008, “Borderwork beyond inside/outside? Frontex, the citizen-detective and the war on terror”Space and Polity1263–79
123.
WhiteheadMJonesRPykettJWelshM, 2012, “Geography, libertarian paternalism and neuropolitics in the UK”The Geographical Journal first published online, doi:10.1111/j.1475-4959.2012.00469.x
124.
WilliamsM, 2003, “Words, images, enemies: Securitization and international politics”International Studies Quarterly47511–531
125.
YoungI, 2003, “The logic of masculinist protection”SIGNS291–25
126.
YoungO, 1985, “The age of the Arctic”Foreign Policy61160–179
127.
YoungO, 2009, “Whither the Arctic? Conflict or co-operation in the Circumpolar North”Polar Record4573–82
