This paper explores the possibility of learning through listening; it is about the way space is made through sound as well as sight. I begin by suggesting that music—precariously positioned between the myth of silence and the threat of noise—offers one means of accessing the soundworld. Then, in order to develop an approach to music that prioritises its sonic qualities, I turn to ideas about performance. This also draws attention away from musical texts and towards the physicality involved in making and listening to music. With reference to some exploratory case studies, I try to appreciate how music—through its embodiment in performance—works as a powerful way of knowing and being. Most of the paper is therefore devoted to a discussion of the intersecting political, economic, and emotional spaces which are made through musical performance (and listening) practices. Like the performances they draw from, the conclusions are incomplete. But they do confirm the importance of imagining—of creating, of engaging with—a world in the doing, shaped by senses other than sight.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AckermanD, 1990A Natural History of 6 Senses (Pheonix, London).
2.
AdornoT, 1992Quasi una Fantasia: Essays on Modern Music (Verso, London).
3.
AdornoT W, 1993, “Music, language and composition” translated by GillespieS, The Musical quarterly77401–414; first published 1953–56.
4.
AhlbergL-O, 1994, “Susanne Langer on representation and emotion in music”British Journal of Aesthetics34(1) 69–80.
5.
AllsopP, 1984, “Gabrieli to Vivaldi”, in Programme Book for A Festival of Venetian Music 1500–1700' Ed. BartlettC, (Peterhouse Press, London) pp 15–17.
6.
ArnoldD, 1979Giovanni Gabrieli and the Music of the Venetian High Renaissance (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
7.
AttaliJ, 1985Noise: The Political Economy of Music (originally published in French in 1977) translated by MassumiB, (Manchester University Press, Manchester).
8.
BarthesR. 1986The Responsibility of Forms (Basil Blackwell, Oxford).
9.
BarthesR, 1996, “The grain of the voice”, in The Twentieth-century Performance Reader Eds HuxleyMWittsN, (Routledge, London) pp 44–52.
10.
BartlettC, 1984, “Ceremonial music for St. Mark's”, in Programme Book for A Festival of Venetian Music 1500–1700' Ed. BartlettC, (Peterhouse Press, London) pp 11–13.
11.
BashfordC, 1999, “Learning to listen: Audiences for chamber music in early-Victorian London”Journal of Victorian Culture4(1) 25–51.
12.
BrechtB, 1996, “Short description of a new technique of acting which produces an alienation effect”, in The Twentieth-century performance Reader Eds HuxleyMWittsN, (Routledge, London) pp 99–111.
13.
BrownP, 1997Art and Life in Renaissance Venice (Abrams, New York).
14.
BryanJ, 1999, “Performing Renaissance music today: A survey of changing positions in the late twentieth century”Bulletin of the Society for Renaissance Studies16(2) 18–23.
15.
BurkeP, 1994Venice and Amsterdam: A Study of Seventeenth Century Elites2nd edition (Polity Press, Cambridge).
16.
BurstynS, 1997, “In quest of the period ear”Early Music25693–701.
17.
CageJ, 1973Silence: Lectures and Writings (Wesleyan University Press, Middletown, CT).
18.
CarlsonM, 1996Performance: A Critical Introduction (Routledge, London).
19.
CarterT, 1992Music in Late Renaissance and Early Baroque Italy (B T Batsford, London).
20.
CarterT, 1999, “From the outside looking in: Musicology and the Renaissance”Bulletin of the Society for Renaissance Studies16(2) 1–7.
CosgroveD, 1984Social Formation and Symbolic Landscape (Croom Helm, London).
23.
CosgroveD, 1985, “Prospect, perspective and the evolution of the landscape idea”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series1045–62.
24.
CosgroveDDanielsS, (Eds), 1988The Iconography of Landscape (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
25.
CummingsA M, 1992The Politicized Muse: Music for Medici Festivals 1512–1537 (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ).
26.
DaviesS, 1987, “Authenticity in musical performance”British Journal of Aesthetics27(1) 39–50.
27.
DeleuzeGGuattariF, 1987A Thousand Plateaus (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN).
28.
DoningtonR, 1977String Playing in Baroque Music (Faber and Faber, London).
29.
DuffyM, no date, “The performance of identity”, unpublished manuscript, Department of Geography and Environmental Studies, University of Melbourne, Parkville, Vic..
DuffyM, 2000, “Lines of drift: The community music festival and a sense of place”Popular Music in press.
32.
FenlonI, 1984, “Music and the myth of Venice”, in Programme Book for A Festival of Venetian Music 1500–1700' Ed. BartlettC, (Peterhouse Press, London) pp 7–9.
33.
FenlonI, (Ed.), 1999Early Music27(1) special issue on music and spectacle.
34.
FrithS, 1996, “Music and identity”, in Questions of Cultural Identity Eds HallSDuGayP, (Sage, London) pp 100–127.
35.
GrossbergL, 1984, “Another boring day in paradise: Rock and roll and the empowerment of everyday life”Popular Music4225–258.
36.
HandelS, 1989Listening: An Introduction to the Perception of Auditory Events (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA).
37.
hooksb, 1995Art on My Mind (The New Press, New York).
38.
InghamJPurvisMClarkeD B, 1999, “Hearing places, making spaces: Sonorous geographies, ephemeral rhythms, and the Blackburn warehouse parties”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space17283–305.
39.
JohnsonJ, 1995Listening in Paris (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA).
40.
KoenigsbergerH G, 1986Politicians and Virtuosi: Essays in Early Modern History (Hambledon Press, London).
41.
KoskelaH, 2000, “The gaze without eyes: Video surveillance and the changing nature of urban space”Progress in Human Geography24(2) in press.
42.
KreitnerK, 1998, “Bad news or not? Thoughts on Renaissance performance practice”Early Music26323–333.
43.
LangerS K, 1942Philosophy in a New Key (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA).
44.
LaszloE, 1967, “Aesthetics of live musical performance”, British Journal of Aesthetics7261–273.
45.
Lawrence-KingA, 1997, “Emotional logic: On Renaissance instrumental music and improvisation”, in Inside Early Music: Conversations with Performers Ed. ShermanB D, (Oxford University Press, New York) pp 157–170.
46.
Leech-WilkinsonD, 1999, Review of Inside Early Music (Ed. ShermanB) 27319–320.
47.
LeppertR, 1988Music and Image: Domesticity, Ideology and Socio-cultural Formation in Eighteenth-century England (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
48.
LeppertR, 1993The Sight of Sound: Music, Representation and the History of the Body (University of California Press, Berkely, CA).
LeyshonAMatlessDRevillG, 1998, “Introduction: Music, space and the production of place”, in The Place of Music Eds LeyshonAMatlessDRevillG, (Guilford Press, New York) pp 1–30.
51.
McClaryS, 1985, “The politics of silence and sound”, afterword in Noise: The Political Economy of Music Ed. AttaliJ, (Manchester University Press, Manchester) pp 149–158.
52.
McClaryS, 1991Feminine Endings: Music, Gender and Sexuality (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN).
53.
McDowellL, 1996, “Spatializing feminism: Geographic perspective”, in Body Space Ed. DuncanN, (Routledge, London) pp 28–44.
54.
McKinneyT, 1998, “Hearing in the sixth sense”The Musical Quarterly82(3–4) 517–536.
55.
PageC, (Ed.), 1997Early Music25(4) special issue on listening practices.
56.
PoirierR, 1971The Performing Self (Oxford University Press, New York).
57.
PutmanD, 1990, “The aesthetic relation of musical performer and audience”British Journal of Aesthetics7261–273.
58.
Roman-ValazquezP, 1999, “The embodiment of salsa: Musicians, instruments and the performance of a Latin style and identity”Popular Music18(1) 115–131.
RoseG, 1996, “Teaching visualised geographies: Towards a methodology for the interpretation of visual materials”Journal of Geography in Higher Education20281–294.
61.
RoseG, 1999, “Performing space”, in Human Geography Today Eds MasseyDAllenJSarreP, (Polity Press, Cambridge) pp 247–259.
62.
SaidE W, 1991Musical Elaborations (Chatto and Windus, London).
63.
SharpeR A, 1995, “Music, platonism and performance: Some ontological strains”British Journal of Aesthetics35(1) 38–48.
64.
ShepherdJ, 1991Music as Social Text (Polity Press, Cambridge).
65.
SmithB R, 1999The Acoustic World of Early Modern England (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL).
66.
SmithS J, 1993, “Bounding the borders: Claiming space and making place in rural Scotland”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series18291–308.
67.
SmithS J, 1995, “Where to draw the line?”, in The Urban Context Eds RogersAVertovecS, (Berg, Oxford) pp 141–163.
68.
SmithS J, 1996, “Bordering on identity”Scotlands3(1) 18–31.
69.
SmithS J, 1997, “Beyond geography's visible worlds: A cultural politics of music”Progress in Human Geography21502–529.
70.
SmithS J, 1999a, “The cultural politics of difference”, in Human Geography Today Eds MasseyDAllenJSarreP, (Polity Press, Cambridge) pp 129–150.
71.
SmithS J, 1999b, “Early brass on the map: An interview with Robert King, Paul McCreesh and Andrew Parrott”Historic Brass Society Newsletter123–9.
72.
StokesM, (Ed.), 1994Ethnicity Identity and Music (Berg, Oxford).
73.
ThriftN, 2000a, “Performance”, in Dictionary of Human Geography4th edition, Eds JohnstonR JGregoryDPrattGWattsM, (Blackwell, Oxford) page 577.
74.
ThriftN, 2000b, “Afterwords”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space18213–255.
75.
WalkerD P, 1985Music, Spirit and Language in the Renaissance Ed. GoukP, (Variorum Reprints, London).
76.
WegmanR C, (Ed.), 1998The Musical Quarterly82(3/4) special issue on music as heard.
77.
WoodN, 2000, “Once more with feeling: Putting emotion into geographies of music”, unpublished paper, Department of Geography, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh.
78.
YoungJ, 1988, “The concept of authentic performance”British Journal of Aesthetics28(3) 228–238.
