Environmental disputes in Israel reflect the pervasive metanarrative of Zionism, and are frequently about friction over symbols of national identity and meaning. Currently, actors engaged in a conflict over a small forest at the margins of Jerusalem harness nationalism/Zionism, and ‘other’ their opponents, as they seek to enlist support beyond their natural constituency. Fieldwork with Green groups and an analysis of their public and internal documents show that municipal officials who are converting the area of the forest to commercial development are cast as (Arab) attackers of the city. Municipal officials also tap national tropes and a security discourse, and claim to be defending Jewish control of Jerusalem. In this paper I show that theories of space, place, and resistance must be supplemented with a contextual and rounded analysis of the master cultural narratives that form the symbolic grounds of these conflicts. It also reveals the complexity of resistance narratives, as the weak seek to benefit from discourses they share with their opponents.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AgnewJDuncanJ (Eds), 1989The Power of Place: Bringing Together Geographical and Sociological Imaginations (Unwin Hyman, Winchester, MA).
2.
AvniTFeitelsonE, 1995, “The collision between preservation of landscape and nature and roadways in Israel: Finding the source of decisions for the plans and their reasons”Horizons in Geographynumbers 42–43, pp 23–37 (in Hebrew).
3.
Ben-AriehY, 1979A City Reflected in Its Times: New Jerusalem—The Beginnings (Yad Izhak Ben-Zvi, Jerusalem) (in Hebrew).
4.
BloutJ, 1993The Colonizer's Model of the World: Geographical Diffusionism and Eurocentric History (Guilford Press, New York).
5.
CaseyE, 1997The Fate of Place: A Philosophical History (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA).
6.
CastellsM, 1983The City and the Grassroots: A Cross-cultural Theory of Urban Social Movements (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA).
7.
CohenS, 1993The Politics of Planting: Israeli—Palestinian Competition for Control of Land in the Jerusalem Periphery (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL).
8.
CohenS, 1994, “Greenbelts in London and Jerusalem”Geographical Review84 (1) 74–89.
9.
CrononW, 1983Changes in the Land: Indians, Colonists, and the Ecology of New England (Hill and Wang, New York).
10.
GolanD, 1997, Letter from the Division for Improvement of the City to Gershon Avni, Director of the Central Division, JNF, “Damage to the Jerusalem Forest”, 5 March, copy in possession of the author (in Hebrew).
11.
GonenA, 1995Between City and Suburb: Urban Residential Patterns and Processes in Israel (Avebury, Aldershot, Hants).
12.
GoodwinP, 1999, “The end of consensus? The impact of participatory initiatives on conceptions of conservation and the countryside in the United Kingdom”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space17383–401.
13.
GordinJ, 1989, “Greening Jerusalem”The Jerusalem Post 9 May, page 26.
14.
HarveyD, 1996Justice, Nature, and the Geography of Difference (Blackwell, Oxford).
15.
HassonS, 1993Urban Social Movements in Jerusalem: The Protest of the Second Generation (State University of New York Press, Albany, NY).
16.
HassonS, 1997, “Local cultures and urban protests”, in Geographies of Resistance Eds PileSKeithM (Routledge, London).
17.
HassonSLeyD, 1994Neighbourhood Organizations and the Welfare State (University of Toronto Press, Toronto).
18.
Jerusalem Institute for Israel Studies, 1997Jerusalem Yearbook 1996Jerusalem Institute for Israel Studies and the Municipality of Jerusalem, Jerusalem.
19.
Jerusalem Post1989, Special section on the Jewish National Fund, 9 May, pp 23–26.
20.
KaplanM, 1993, “The forest in the year 2000”Ecology and the Environment6(1) 25–31 (in Hebrew).
21.
KatzY, 1995, “The re-emergence of Jerusalem: New Zionist approaches in attaining political goals prior to the first World War”Political Geography14 (3) 279–293.
22.
KeithM, 1997, “A changing space and a time for change”, in Geographies of Resistance Eds PileSKeithM (Routledge, London), pp 277–286.
KimcheIReichmanSSchweidY, 1990Greater Jerusalem Region: Alternative Municipal Frameworks (Jerusalem Institute for Israel Studies, Jerusalem) (in Hebrew).
25.
KliotN, 1992, “Ideology and afforestation in Israel: Forests planted by the Jewish National Fund”, in Studies in the Geography of IsraelVolume 13Israel Exploration Society and the Department of Geography, The Hebrew University, Jerusalem (in Hebrew), pp 12–17.
26.
LefebvreA, 1991The Production of Space translated by Nicholson-SmithD (Blackwell, Oxford).
27.
LeketY, Chairman of the Directorate, Jewish National Fund, 1998, “Summary of Discussion on the Jerusalem Forest”, 6 July, copy in possession of the author (in Hebrew).
28.
LevyaY, 1997, Letter from Attorney for Adam Teva v'Din to Ilan Bari, Coordinator for Planning in the Forestry Division, Eshta'ol Office, JNF, 13 March, copy in possession of the author (in Hebrew).
29.
LippelY, 1998, “Jerusalem whispers”Newsletter of the Society for the Protection of Nature-Jerusalem January—March, number 39, 3–4.
30.
LustickI, 1993Unsettled States Disputed Lands: Britain and Ireland, France and Algeria, Israel and the West Bank—Gaza (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY).
31.
MasseyD, 1993, “Politics and space/time”, in Place and the Politics of Identity Eds KeithMPileS (Routledge, London), pp 141–161.
32.
MichaelsonJ, 1998, “A citizen's guide to Jerusalem development”The Jerusalem Post 17 July, 4–5.
33.
MishalS, 1989Speaking Stones: The Words Behind the Palestinian Intifada (Kibbutz HaMeuchad Press, Tel Aviv) (in Hebrew).
34.
MitchellD, 1992, “Iconography and locational conflict from the underside: Free speech, People's Park, and the politics of homelessness in Berkeley, California”Political Geography11 (2) 152–169.
35.
MitchellW J T, 1994, “Imperial Landscape”, in Landscape and Power Ed. MitchellW J T (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL), pp 5–34.
36.
NashR, 1967Wilderness and the American Mind (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT).
37.
OlmertE, Mayor of Jerusalem, 1998, Letter to Salah Tarif, Chairman of the Knesset Interior and Environmental Quality Committee, 3 June, copy in possession of the author (in Hebrew).
38.
PileS, 1997, “Opposition, political identities and spaces of resistance”, in Geographies of Resistance Eds PileSKeithM (Routledge, London).
39.
SchilerE, 1979The First Photographs of Jerusalem: The New City (Ariel, Jerusalem) (in Hebrew).
40.
SchnellI, 1997, “Nature and environment in the Socialist-Zionist pioneers' perceptions: A sense of desolation”Eumene4 (1) 69–85.
41.
SharkanskyI, 1998Governing Jerusalem: Again on the World's Agenda (Wayne State University Press, Detroit, MI).
42.
SharkanskyIAuerbachG, 2000, “Which Jerusalem? A consideration of concepts and borders”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space18395–409.
43.
ShiloniT, 1994The Kren Keyemet L'Yisrael as a Factor in Shaping the Colonized Landscape of Eretz Yisrael from the Time of Its Foundation to the Outbreak of World War I, 1897–1914 (Yad Itzhak Ben-Tzvi, Jerusalem) (in Hebrew).
44.
SkolnickD, 1994Jerusalem Forest Master Plan (Jewish National Fund, Jerusalem) (in Hebrew).
45.
SmollyE, 1973Anshei Be'Reshit [The founders]12th edition (Am Oved, Tel Aviv) (in Hebrew).
46.
SPNI, 1998, “For the sake of Jerusalem we shall not hold our peace”, Society for the Protection of Nature in Israel (undated document in possession of the author).
47.
TuanY, 1977Space and Place: The Perspectives of Experience (Edward Arnold, London).
48.
TwainM, 1962The Innocents Abroad; or, The New Pilgrim's Progress (Heritage Press, New York) (original publication 1869).
49.
TzabariM, 1997, Letter to Ehud Olmert, Mayor of Jerusalem, 15 June, copy in possession of the author (in Hebrew).
50.
WatermanS, 1999, “Keeping a distance—Israel at 50”Political Geography18 (2) 115–129.
51.
WeitzJ, 1970Forest and Afforestation in Israel (Massada, Israel) (in Hebrew).
52.
YavinY, 1998, “Situation report”HaAretz 13 March, page 7 (in Hebrew).
53.
YehoshuaA, 1968Mul ha Ye'arot [Facing the forests] (HaKibbutz HaMeuchad, Tel Aviv) (in Hebrew).
54.
ZerubavelY, 1996, “The forest as a national icon: Literature, politics, and the archeology of memory”Israel Studies Association1 (1) 60–99.
