In this paper we discuss the apparent failure to couple together the constructs of ‘rurality’ and ‘homelessness’, and propose a critical deconstruction of this noncoupling. Three principal lines of arguments are employed. First, there are a range of physical and material reasons why rural and urban spaces have varying qualities for hiding or revealing homeless people, and why the embodied experiences of homelessness have varying geographies. Second, there are a series of obstacles that exist within the practices, thoughts, and discourses of rural dwellers themselves, which lead them to deny that homelessness exists in their place. Third, normalised conceptualisations about rurality and homelessness often serve to separate the two concepts, and contribute to the assumption that homelessness is an urban phenomenon, which is rendered invisible in rural space. In short, homelessness may be conceptualised as being ‘out-of-place’ in the purified spaces of rurality, and the imaginary geographies of rurality and homelessness become transformed into everyday practices and actions relating to what people actually do in and about rural places. This critical deconstruction will be important for any attempts to recouple homelessness and rurality in the understandings and actions of policymakers.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BarakG, 1991Gimme Shelter: A Social History of Homelessness in Contemporary America (Praeger, New York).
2.
BarnettAScrutonR, 1998, “Introduction”, in Town and Country Eds BarnettAScrutonR, (Jonathon Cape, London).
3.
BlasiG, 1990, “Social policy and social science research on homelessness”Journal of Social Issues46207–229.
4.
BourdieuP, 1979Outline of a Theory of Practice (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
5.
BourdieuP, 1989Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste (Routledge and Kegan Paul, London).
6.
BradleyTLowePWrightS, 1996, “Rural deprivation and the welfare transition”, in Deprivation and Welfare in Rural Areas Eds LowePBradleyTWrightS, (Geobooks, Norwich) pp 1–42.
7.
BramleyG, 1994Homelessness in Rural England—Statistical Update to 1992/3Rural Development Commission; now the Countryside Agency, Dacre House, 10 Dacre Street, London SW1H 0DH.
8.
BramleyGDooganKLeatherPMurieAWatsonE, 1998Homelessness and the London Housing MarketSchool for Advanced Urban Studies, University of Bristol, Bristol.
9.
BurrowsRPleaceNQuilgarsD, 1997Homeless and Social Policy (Routledge, London).
10.
ButtonE, 1992Rural Housing for YouthCentrepoint Soho, 25 Berwick Street, Soho, London W1V 3RF.
11.
ClokeP, 1995, “Rural poverty and the welfare state: A discursive transformation in Britain and the USA”Environment and Planning A271001–1016.
12.
ClokePGoodwinM, 1992, “Conceptualising countryside change: From post-fordism to rural structured coherence”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series17321–336.
13.
ClokePGoodwinM, 1993, “Rural change: Structured coherence or unstructured incoherence?”Terra105166–174.
ClokePMilbourneP, 1992, “Deprivation and lifestyles in rural Wales. II: Rurality and the cultural dimension”Journal of Rural Studies8359–372.
16.
ClokePThriftN, 1990, “Class and change in rural Britain”, in Rural Restructuring Eds MarsdenTLowePWhatmoreS, (David Fulton, London) pp 165–181.
17.
ClokePMilbournePThomasC, 1994Lifestyles in Rural EnglandRural Development Commission, now The Countryside Agency, Dacre House, 19 Dacre Street, London SW1H 0DH.
18.
ClokePGoodwinMMilbournePThomasC, 1995, “Deprivation, poverty and marginalisation in rural lifestyles in England and Wales”Journal of Rural Studies11351–366.
19.
ClokePGoodwinMMilbourneP, 1997Rural Wales: Community and Marginalisation (University of Wales Press, Cardiff).
20.
ClokePCookePCursonsJMilbournePWiddowfieldR, 2000a, “Ethics, reflexivity and research encounters with homeless people”Ethics, Place and Environment forthcoming.
21.
ClokePMilbournePWiddowfieldR, 2000b, “Partnership and policy networks in rural local governance: Homelessless in Taunton”Public Administration78111–133.
22.
ClokePMilbournePWiddowfieldR, 2000c, “The hidden and emerging spaces of rural homelessness”Environment and Planning A3277–90.
23.
CloseJBensonR, 1996, “Youth homelessness-the rural perspective” in Developing Effective Responses to Rural Homelessness Ed. RansleyS, Shelter, Kingsbourne House, High Holborn, London WC1V 7DA, pp 36–37.
24.
CresswellT, 1996In Place, Out of Place: Geography, Ideology and Transgression (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN).
25.
DalyG, 1996Homeless: Policies, Strategies and Lives on the Street (Routledge, London).
26.
DavenportJDavenportJ PNewettD, 1990, “A comparative analysis of the urban and rural homelessness”, paper presented to the 15th National Institute of Rural Social Work, New York.
27.
DearMTaylorS, 1982Not on Our Street (Pion, London).
28.
DearMWolchJ, 1987Landscapes of Despair: From Deinstitutionalisation to Homelessness (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ).
29.
de CerteauM, 1984The Practice of Everyday Life (University of California Press, Los Angeles, CA).
30.
de CerteauM, 1985, “Practices of space”, in On Signs Ed. BlonskyM, (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD) pp 122–145.
31.
DepresC, 1991, “The meaning of home—literature review and directions for future research”Journal of Architectural and Planning Research896–115.
32.
DoE, 1995Rural England: A Nation Committed to a Living Countryside Cm 3016, Department of the Environment (HMSO, London).
33.
DonohueT, 1996In the Open: Diary of a Homeless Alcoholic (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL).
34.
FabesRWorsleyLHowardM, 1983The Myth of the Rural IdyllChild Poverty Action Group, 1 Bath Street, London EC1V 9LB.
35.
FirstRRifeJToomeyB, 1994, “Homelessness in rural areas-causes, patterns and trends”Social Work3997–108.
36.
FitchenJ, 1991, “Homelessness in rural places: Perspectives from upstate New York”Urban Anthropology20177–210.
37.
FitchenJ, 1992, “On the edge of homelessness: Rural poverty and housing insecurity”Rural Sociology57173–193.
38.
HalfacreeK, 1993, “Locality and social representation: Space, discourse and alternative definitions of the rural”Journal of Rural Studies91–15.
39.
HenleyJ, 1998, “Down and out in the cold of Paris”The Guardian 28 November, page 19.
40.
HoggartK, 1990, “Let's do away with rural”Journal of Rural Studies6245–257.
41.
HoggartK, 1995, “The changing geography of council house sales in England and Wales, 1978–1990”Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie86137–149.
42.
HoggartK, 1997, “Home occupancy and rural housing problems in England”Town Planning Review68485–515.
43.
HooverGCarterM, 1991, “The invisible homeless: Non-urban homeless in Appalachian East Tennessee”Rural Sociologist113–12.
44.
HughesA, 1997, “Rurality and cultures of womanhood: Domestic identities and moral order in village life”, in Contested Countryside Cultures Eds ClokePLittleJ, (Routledge, London) pp 123–137.
45.
HutsonSLiddiardM, 1994Youth Homelessness: The Construction of a Social Issue (Macmillan, London).
JohnsonG, 1997, “Villagers buy their tramp his own wood”News of the World.
48.
LambertCJeffersSBurtonPBramleyG, 1992Homelessness in Rural AreasRural Development Commission; now The Countryside Agency Dacre House, 19 Dacre Road, London SW1H 0DH.
49.
LarkinA, 1978, “Rural housing—too dear, too few and too far”Roof315–17.
50.
LawrenceM, 1995, “Rural homelessness: A geography without a geography”Journal of Rural Studies11297–308.
51.
LawrenceM, 1997, “Heartlands or neglected geographies? Liminality, power and the hyperreal rural”Journal of Rural Studies131–18.
52.
LidstoneP, 1994, “Rationing housing to the homeless applicant”Housing Studies9459–472.
53.
LittleJAustinP, 1996, “Women and the rural idyll”Journal of Rural Studies12101–111.
MitchellD, 1997, “The annihilation of space bylaw: The roots and implications of anti-homeless laws in the United States”Antipode29303–335.
57.
MooreJCanterDStockleyDDrakeM, 1995The Faces of Homelessness in London (Dartmouth, Aldershot, Hants).
58.
MormontM, 1990, “What is rural? Or, how to be rural: Towards a sociology of the rural”, in Rural Restructuring Eds MarsdenTLowePWhatmoreS, (David Fulton, London) pp 21–44.
59.
MurdochA, 1994, “We are human too: A study of people who beg”, Crisis, 1st Floor, Challenge House, 42 Adler Street, London E1 1EE.
60.
MurdochJPrattA, 1993, “Rural studies: Modernism, post-modernism and the post-rural”Journal of Rural Studies9411–428.
61.
MurdochJPrattA, 1994, “Rural studies of power and the power of rural studies: A reply to Philo”Journal of Rural Studies1083–88.
62.
MurdochJPrattA, 1997, “From the power of topography to the topography of power: A discourse on strange ruralities”, in Contested Countryside Cultures Eds ClokePLittleJ, (Routledge, London) pp 51–69.
63.
NealeJ, 1997, “Homelessness and theory reconsidered”Housing Studies1247–61.
64.
PattonL, 1998, “The rural homeless”, in Homelessness, Health and Human Needs Ed. Committee on Health Care for Homeless People (National Academy Press, Washington, DC) pp 183–217.
65.
PhiloC, 1986, “‘The same and the other’: On geographies, madness and outsiders”, OP11, Department of Geography, Loughborough University, Loughborough, Leics.
66.
PhiloC, 1992, “Neglected rural geographies: A review”Journal of Rural Studies11351–366.
67.
PhiloC, 1993, “Post-modern rural geography? A reply to Murdoch and Pratt”Journal of Rural Studies9427–436.
68.
PhiloC, 1997, “Of other rurals?”, in Contested Countryside Cultures Eds ClokePLittleJ, (Routledge, London) pp 19–50.
69.
PrattA, 1996, “Rurality: Loose talk or social struggle?”Journal of Rural Studies1269–78.
70.
RDC, 1996Rural Needs in Local Authority Housing StrategiesRural Development Commission; now The Countryside Agency, Dacre House, 19 Dacre Road, London SW1H 0DH.
71.
RedfieldR, 1941The Folk Culture of Yucatan (Chicago University Press, Chicago, IL).
72.
RogersA, 1985, “Local claims on rural housing”Town Planning Review56367–380.
73.
RuddickS, 1996Young and Homeless in Hollywood: Mapping Social Identities (Routledge, New York).
74.
SEU, 1998Rough Sleeping Cm 4008, Social Exclusion Unit (The Stationery Office, London).
75.
ShieldsR, 1991Places on the Margin (Routledge, London).
76.
ShucksmithM, 1990House Building in Britain's Countryside (Routledge, London).
77.
SibleyD, 1995Geographies of Exclusion: Society and Difference in the West (Routledge, London).
78.
SibleyD, 1997, “Endangering the sacred: Nomads, youth cultures and the English countryside”, in Contested Countryside Cultures Eds ClokePLittleJ, (Routledge, London) pp 218–231.
79.
SimmonsM, 1993, “A house in the country?”The Guardian 28 May, page 7.
80.
SomervilleP, 1992, “Homelessness and the meaning of home—rooflessness or rootlessness”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research16529–539.
81.
SpackmanA, 1997, “A window on the countryside is opened”Financial Times 12 April, page xiv.
82.
ThomasD, 1989, “The production of homelessness”Housing Studies4253–266.
83.
TonniesF, 1957Community and Society (Harper, New York).
84.
VenessA, 1992, “Home and homelessness in the United States: Changing ideals and reality”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space10445–468.
85.
VenessA, 1994, “Designer shelters as models and makers of home: New responses to homelessness in urban America”Urban Geography15150–167.
86.
WalmerT, 1989, “Families with ‘no place to go’ on rise”USA Today 12 December.
87.
WatsonS, 1989, “Definitions of homelessness: A feminist perspective”Critical Social Policy1160–73.
88.
WatsonSAusterberryH, 1986Housing and Homelessness: A Feminist Perspective (Routledge, London).
89.
WebbS, 1994My Address is Not My Home: Hidden Homelessness and Single Women in ScotlandScottish Council for Single Homeless, 200 Cowgate, Edinburgh EH1 1NQ.
90.
WiddowfieldR, 1998, “An analysis of homelessness statistics”, working paper, School of Geographical Sciences, University of Bristol, Bristol.
91.
WhitburnV, 1996The Archers: The Changing Face of Radio's Longest Running Drama (Virgin Books, London).
92.
WilsonA, 1992The Culture of Nature (Blackwell, Oxford).
93.
WolchJGabrielS, 1984, “Development and decline of the service-dependant ghetto”Urban Geography511–129.
94.
WoodwardR, 1996, “‘Deprivation’ and ‘the rural’: An investigation into contradictory discourses”Journal of Rural Studies1255–67.
95.
WrightTVermondA, 1990, “Small dignities: Local resistances, dominant strategies of authority and homelessness”, paper presented to the Annual Meeting of the American Sociological Association, Washington, DC.
