Drawing on critical security studies and critical geopolitics, I examine how geopolitical discourses of danger circulate in Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan. Whereas some work in this field risks reinscribing the discursive articulation of danger as an inevitable condition of political formation, in this paper I emphasise the need to disaggregate the concept of danger carefully to highlight its operation in specific contexts. I explore these processes across a range of discursive sites from official media to popular music, contrasting findings with material from focus groups composed of socially marginalised populations. I demonstrate the role of discursive constructions of danger or safety in the production and maintenance of the political identity of the new states, and how this is inseparable from material conditions of elite power struggle. I conclude by echoing Hewitt's call for a critical geography that confronts and challenges the domestic exercise of state terror.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Aalam1999a, “Yaponiyaga jagam dep Karimovdun ‘közünö chöp salgïsï’ kelgen sayasali” [Karmonv's politics of deception, aimed at pleasing the Japanese], 15–20 October, page 3
2.
Aalam1999b, “Kïrgïzstandïn birimdigi: Mayda uluttarga avtonomiya kerekpi?” [Kyrgyzstan's unity: do the minorities need autonomy], 14–20 April
3.
Aalam1999c, “Bügün Kïrgïzstan Bar: Erteng jok bolup Ketishi mümkün?” [Kyrgyzstan: here today, gone tomorrow?], 24 February–2 March, page 1
4.
AaltoPDalbySHarleV, 2003, “The critical geopolitics of Northern Europe: identity politics unlimited”Geopolitics8(1) (special issue)
Asaba1999a, “Boevik beker jatpasïn, dayardap koyduk akchasïn” [We have got money ready for the militants so that they should not be idle], 22 October, page 2
9.
Asaba1999b, “Namangani jazgï jortuulga dayardanïp atat” [Namangani is preparing for a spring offensive], 14 December, page 1
10.
AshleyR, 1989, “Living on the border lines: man, poststructuralism, and war”, in International/Intertextual Relations Eds Der DerianJShapiroM (D C Heath, Lexington, MA) pp 259–321
BergE, 2003, “Some unintended consequences of geopolitical reasoning in Post-Soviet Estonia: texts and policy streams, maps and cartoons”Geopolitics8101–120
13.
BergEOrosS, 2000, “Writing post-Soviet Estonia on to the world map”Political Geography19601–625
14.
BichelA, 1998, “Air Force One: the cinematic erasure of Central Asia”Central Asia Monitor216–19
15.
BrownC, 2001, ‘Our side?’ Critical theory and international relations”, in Critical Theory and World Politics Ed. JonesR W (Lynne Rienner, London) pp 191–203
16.
BuzanBWæverOWildeJ D, 1998Security: A New Framework for Analysis (Lynne Rienner, Boulder, CO)
17.
CampbellD, 1998Writing Security: United States Foreign Policy and the Politics of Identity (Manchester University Press, Manchester)
18.
ChyeP SKongL, 1996, “Ideology, social commentary and resistance in popular music: a case study of Singapore”Journal of Popular Culture30215–231
19.
CollinsK, 2002, “Clans, pacts and politics in Central Asia”Journal of Democracy13137–152
20.
ConnellJGibsonC, 2003Sound Tracks: Popular Music, Identity and Place (Routledge, London)
21.
CummingsS (Ed.), 2002Power and Change in Central Asia (Routledge, London)
22.
DalbyS, 1990Creating the Second Cold War: The Discourse of Politics (Pinter, London)
23.
DalbyS, 1993a, “The ‘Kiwi disease’: geopolitical discourse in Aotearoa/New Zealand and the South Pacific”Political Geography12437–456
24.
DalbyS, 1993b, “Post-cold war security in the new Europe”, in The New Political Geography of Eastern Europe Eds O'LoughlinJvan der WustenH (Belhaven Press, London) pp 71–85
25.
DalbyS, 1997, “Contesting and essential concept: reading the dilemmas in contemporary security discourse”, in Critical Security Studies: Concepts and Cases Eds KrauseKWilliamsM (UCL Press, London) pp 3–31
26.
DalbyS, 2002Environmental Security (University of Minnesota Press, London)
27.
DalbyS, 2003a, “Geopolitics, the Bush doctrine, and war on Iraq”The Arab World Geographer67–18
28.
DalbyS, 2003b, “Calling 911: geopolitics, security and America's new war”Geopolitics861–86
29.
DijkinkG, 1996National Identity and Geopolitical Visions: Maps of Pride and Pain (Routledge, London)
30.
DoddsK, 1996, “The 1982 Falkands War and a critical geopolitical eye: Steve Bell and the If… cartoons”Political Geography15571–592
31.
DoddsK, 1997Geopolitics in Antarctica: Views from the Southern Oceanic Rim (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex)
32.
DoddsK, 1998, “Enframing Bosnia: the geopolitical iconography of Steve Bell”, in Rethinking Geopolitics Eds TuathailG ÓDalbyS (Routledge, London) pp 170–197
33.
DoddsK, 2000Geopolitics in a Changing World (Prentice-Hall, Harlow, Essex)
34.
DoddsK, 2001, “Political geography III: critical geopolitics after ten years”Progress in Human Geography25469–484
35.
DoddsK, 2003a, “Licensed to stereotype: popular geopolitics, James Bond and the spectre of Balkanism”Geopolitics8125–156
36.
DoddsK, 2003b, “Cold war geopolitics”, in A Companion to Political Geography Eds AgnewJMitchellKToalG (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 204–218
37.
DouglasM, 1992, “Risk and danger”, in Risk and Blame: Essays in Cultural Theory (Routledge, London) pp 38–54
38.
DowlerLSharpJ, 2001, “A feminist geopolitics?”Space and Polity5165–176
39.
DummT, 1993, Telefear: watching war news”, in The Politics of Everyday Fear Ed. MassumiE (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN) pp 307–321
40.
Erkin Too1999, “Prezidentterdin jolugushuusu jemishtuu body” [The meeting of the presidents was fruitful] 51(80), page 1
41.
FullerG, 1994, “Central Asia: the quest for identity”Current History93145–149
42.
GoldJRevillG, 2003, “Exploring landscapes of fear: marginality, spectacle and surveillance”Capital and Class8027–50
43.
GondolaC D, 1997, “Popular music, urban society, and changing gender relations in Kinshasha, Zaire (1950–1990)”, in Gendered Encounters: Challenging Cultural Boundaries and Social Hierarchies in Africa Eds Grosz-NgatéMKokoleO (Routledge, London) pp 65–84
44.
GordyE, 1999The Culture of Power in Serbia (Pennsylvania State University Press, University Park, PA)
45.
GossJLeinbachT, 1996, “Focus groups as alternative research practice: experience with transmigrants in Indonesia”Area28115–123
Halq So'zi1999e, “Dehqonda nima ayb?” [What is the guilt of the farmer?], 13 January, page 2
51.
Halq So'zi1999f, “Ekstremizm va terrorchilik—hurriyat kushandasi” [Extremism and terrorism are the bane of freedom], 2 March, page 2
52.
Halq So'zi1999g, “Prezidentga—halqqa—tinchlikka tajobuz” [There can be no future without memory of the past], 18 February, page 2
53.
Halq So'zi1999h, “Hushyorlikka da'vat: President Islam Karimovning O'zbekiston milliy axborot agentligi muxbirining cavollariga javoblari” [A call to vigilance: the answers of President Iolam Karimov to the questions of a journalist of Uzbekistan's national news agency], 25 June, page 1
IngoldT, 2000The Perception of the Environment: Essays in Livelihood, Dwelling, Skill (Routledge, London)
61.
JonesR W, 2001, Introduction: locating critical international relations theory”, in Critical Theory and World Politics Ed. JonesR W (Lynne Rienner, Boulder, CO) pp 1–19
62.
Jones LuongP, 2002Institutional Change and Political Continuity in Post-Soviet Central Asia: Power, Perceptions, and Pacts (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
63.
KarimovI, 1993Building the Future: Uzbekistan—Its Own Model for Transition to a Market Economy (Uzbekistan, Tashkent)
64.
KarimovI, 1995Vatan: Sajdagoh kabi Muqaddasdir [The homeland is as sacred as a place of prayer] (O'zbekistan, Tashkent)
65.
KarimovI, 1997Uzbekistan on the Threshold of the Twenty-first Century (Curzon, Richmond, Surrey)
66.
KarimovI, 1998Tarihiy Xotirasiz Kelajak Yo'q [An attack on the president the people, and peace] (Sharq, Tashkent)
67.
Kïrgïz Ruhu1999a, “Kimdin artïnda kim turat?” [Who is behind who?], 1 October, page 4
68.
Kïrgïz Ruhu1999b, “Vahabizm: diniy jana sayasiy prinsipteri” [Wahabism: its religious and political precepts], November
69.
Kïrgïz Tuusu1998, “Jibek jolynyn diplomatiyasï (Kirgïz Respublikasïnïn Prezidenti Askar Akaevdin doktrinasï)” [Silk Road diplomacy (the doctrine of the president of the Kyrgyz republic, Askar Akaev)], 27–29 October
70.
Kïrgïz Tuusu1999, “Chek aradan chïr izdegen Chuykov…” [Chuykov–the one who searches for a conflict at the border], 22–24 June
71.
KitzingerJBarbourR, 1999, “Introduction: the challenge and promise of focus groups”, in Developing Focus Group Research: Politics, Theory and Practice Eds BarbourRKitzingerJ (Sage, London) pp 1–20
72.
KlenkeK, 2001, “Eurasian grooves: popular music, identity, and politics in Uzbekistan”, unpublished paper presented at Ethnomusicological Research Seminar, Goldsmiths College, London; cited with permission, available from author at kerstin.klenke@web.de
73.
KlenkeK, forthcoming Eurasian Grooves: Popular Music, Identity and Politics in Uzbekistan PhD thesis, Department of Ethnomusicology, Cologne University, Cologne
74.
KongL, 1995, “Popular music in geographical analyses”Progress in Human Geography19183–198
KuusM, 2002, “Sovereignty for security?: the discourse of sovereignty in Estonia”Political Geography21393–412
77.
LaustsenC BWæverO, 2000, “In defence of religion: sacred referent objects for securitization”Millennium: Journal of International Studies29705–739
78.
LimbMDwyerC (Eds), 2001Qualitative Methodologies for Geographers: Issues and Debates (Arnold, London)
79.
LinklaterA, 1996, “The achievements of critical theory”, in International Theory: Positivism and Beyond Eds SmithSBoothKZalewskiM (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 279–298
80.
MacFadyenD, 2001Red Stars: Personality and the Soviet Popular Song, 1955–1991 (McGill-Queen's University Press, London)
81.
MacFadyenD, 2002Estrada?! Grand Narratives and the Philosophy of the Russian Popular Song since Perestroika (McGill-Queen's University Press, London)
82.
MccGwireM, 1991Perestroika and Soviet National Security (The Brookings Institution, Washington, DC)
83.
MaldonB, 1998, “The club: clubbing: consumption, identity and the spatial practices of every-night life”, in Cool Places: Geographies of Youth Culture Eds SkeltonTValentineG (Routledge, London) pp 266–286
84.
MarchA, 2002, “The use and abuse of history: ‘national ideology’ as transcendental object in Islam Karimov's ‘ideology of national independence’”Central Asian Survey21371–384
85.
MartinD, 2001, “Religious aspects of Uzbek nationalism”Harvard Asia Quarterly563–68
86.
MegoranN, 2000a, “Calming the Ferghana Valley experts”Central Asia Monitor 2000number 5, 20–25
MegoranN, 2002The Borders of Eternal Friendship? The Politics and Path of Nationalism and Identity along the Uzbekistan–Kyrgyzstan Ferghana Valley Boundary, 1999–2000 PhD thesis, Department of Geography, University of Cambridge, available at http://www.megoran.org
89.
MegoranN, 2004, “The critical geopolitics of the Uzbehistan–kyrgyzstan Ferghana Valley boundary dispute, 1999–2000”Political Geography23731–764
90.
MegoranN, 2005, “Preventing conflict by building civil society: post-development theory and a Central Asian–UK policy success story”Central Asian Survey2483–96
91.
MoisioS, 1998, “Finland, geopolitical image of threat, and the post-Cold War confusion”Geopolitics3104–124
92.
MueckeS, 1999, “Travelling the subterranean river of blood: philosophy and magic in Cultural Studies”Cultural Studies131–17
93.
MyersGMacnaghtenP, 1999, “Can focus groups be analysed as talk?”, in Developing Focus Group Research: Politics, Theory and Practice Eds BarbourRKitzingerJ (Sage, London) pp 173–185
94.
NashC, 2000, “Performativity in practice: some recent work in cultural geography”Progress in Human Geography24653–664
95.
NaumkinV, 1994, Conclusion”, in Central Asia and Transcaucasia: Ethnicity and Conflict Ed. NaumkinV (Greenwood Press, London) pp 201–204
96.
OlcottM B, 1993, “Central Asia on its own”Journal of Democracy492–103
O'LoughlinJ, 2001, “Geopolitical fantasies, national strategies and ordinary Russians in the Post-Communist era”Geopolitics617–48
99.
O'LoughlinJHeskeH, 1991, “From ‘geopolitik’ to ‘geopolitique’: converting a discipline for war to a discipline for peace”, in The Political Geography of Conflict and Peace Eds KliotNWatermanS (Belhaven Press, London) pp 37–59
100.
O'NeilA, 2003, “Terrorist use of weapons of mass destruction: how serious is the threat?”Australian Journal of International Affairs5799–112
101.
ÓTuathailG, 1993, “The effacement of place? US foreign policy and the spatiality of the Gulf Crisis”Antipode254–31
102.
ÓTuathailGAgnewJ, 1992, “Geopolitics and discourse: practical geopolitical reasoning in American foreign policy”Political Geography11190–204
103.
ÓTuathailGDalbyS, 1998, “Introduction: rethinking geopolitics: towards a critical geopolitics”, in Rethinking Geopolitics Eds TuathailG ODalbyS (Routledge, London) pp 1–15
104.
PaasiA, 1996Territories, Boundaries and Consciousness: The Changing Geography of the Finnish – Russian Border (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex)
105.
PainR, 2000, “Place, social relations and the fear of crime: a review”Progress in Human Geography24365–387
106.
PocockD, 1995Being There: Imagination in Human Geography OP 30, Department of Geography, University of Durham, Durham
107.
PolelleM, 1999Raising Cartographic Consciousness: The Social and Foreign Policy Vision of Geopolitics in the Twentieth Century (Lexington Books, Lanham, MD)
108.
PowerM, 2003, “The scripting, staging and projection of ‘popular’ geo-political discourse”Geopolitics8181–189
109.
RadleyA, 1995, “The elusory body and social constructionist theory”Body and Society13–23
110.
RametS P, 1994Rocking the State: Rock Music and Politics in Eastern Europe and Russia (Westview Press, Boulder, CO)
111.
RawnsleyGRawnsleyM-Y, 2001Critical Security, Democratisation and Television in Taiwan (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants)
112.
RevillG, 2000, “Music and the politics of sound: nationalism, citizenship, and auditory space”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space18597–613
113.
RichardBKrugerH, 1998, “Ravers' paradise? German youth cultures in the 1990s”, in Cool Places: Geographies of Youth Culture Eds SkeltonTValentineG (Routledge, London) pp 161–174
114.
RubinBLubinN, 1999Calming the Ferghana Valley: Development and Dialogue in the Heart of Central Asia (Century Foundation Press, New York)
115.
SharpJ, 1998, “Reel geographies of the new world order: patriotism, masculinity, and geopolitics in post-Cold War American movies”, in Rethinking Geopolitics Eds TuathailG ÓDalbyS (Routledge, London) pp 152–170
116.
SharpJ, 2000aCondensing the Cold War: Reader's Digest and American Identity (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)
ShirlowPPainR, 2003, “The geographies and politics of fear”Capital and Classnumber 80, 15–26
119.
SieversE, 2003, “Modern regression: Central Asian markets, democracy, and spoils systems”Harvard Asia Quarterly743–52
120.
SinesA, 2002, “Civilising the Middle Kingdom's wild west”Central Asian Survey215–18
121.
SkeltonTValentineG (Eds) 1998Cool Places: An Introduction to Youth Cultures (Routledge, London)
122.
SmithG, 1996, The Soviet state and nationalities policy”, in The Nationalities Question in the Post-Soviet States Ed. SmithG (Longman, Harlow, Essex) pp 2–22
123.
SmithS, 1997, “Beyond geography's visible worlds: a cultural politics of music”Progress in Human Geography21502–529
124.
SparksR, 1992Television and the Drama of Crime: Moral Tales and the Place of Crime in Public Life (Open University Press, Buckingham)
125.
ThriftN, 1996Spatial Formations (Sage, London)
126.
ThriftNDewsburyJ-D, 2000, “Dead geographies—and how to make them live”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space18411–432
127.
ToalG, 2003, “Condensing critical geopolitics: reflections on Joanne Sharp's Condensing the Cold War”Geopolitics8159–165
128.
To'lanovJ, 1998Qadriyatlar Falsafasi [The philosophy of values] (Uzbekistan, Tashkent)
129.
To'lanovJG'afuravZ, 1984Kollektiv—Qudratli Kuch [The collective is a mighty force] (Yosh Gvardiya, Tashkent)
130.
TuanY-F, 1980Landscapes of Fear (Blackwell, Oxford)
131.
TysonD, 1994, “The role of unofficial audio media in contemporary Uzbekistan”Central Asian Storey13283–294
WaltS, 1991, “The renaissance of security studies”International Studies Quarterly35211–239
134.
WeldesJLaffeyMGustersonHDuvallR, 1999, “Introduction: constructing insecurity”, in Cultures of Insecurity: States, Communities and the Production of Danger Eds WeldesJLaffeyMGustersonHDuvallR (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MD) pp 1–33
135.
YakubT, 1999, “Uzbekistan: the atmosphere of terror and violence”, report by Human Rights Society of Uzbekistan, Tashkent, 1 November, http://www.birlik.net/page-4.uk
