The logic behind land allocation for residential purposes has undergone a dramatic shift in many states with a colonial legacy in the recent decade, from an ethnonational logic that favors the ethnonational majority to a more liberal-democratic, market-based logic that disregards ethnicity. In Israel, following this shift, a new claim for biased allocation has been voiced by the ethnonational majority, politicians, and administrators, which is based on multiculturalism and recognition. According to this claim, land allocation should serve the communal needs of the majority by limiting the access of minority groups to the majority group's residential areas. In this paper I argue that, despite the decline of ethnonationalism, the discourse of multiculturalism remains a substitute discourse that rationalizes the interests of the majority group, hence contributing to the stratification of societies on the basis of ethnicity. Through an analysis of three case studies of land allocation in Israel, the paper explores the material and cultural weaknesses of a multiculturalism that has been imported from societies with a strong liberal-democratic tradition into societies with a profound ethnonational legacy.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbramsonA, 2004, “The new Zionism”Negev Time 2 April (in Hebrew)
2.
AgiusPJenkinTJarvisSHowittRWilliamsR, 2007, “(Re)asserting indigenous rights and jurisdictions within a politics of place: Transformative nature of native title negotiations in South Australia”Geographical Research45194–202
3.
Al-HajM, 2002, “Multiculturalism in deeply divided societies: The Israeli case”International Journal of Intercultural Relations26169–183
4.
AndersonK, 1991Vancouver's Chinatown: Racial Discourse in Canada, 1874–1980 (McGill-Queens University Press, Montreal)
5.
AndersonK, 1998, “Sites of difference: Beyond a cultural politics of race polarity”, in Cities of Difference Eds FincherRJacobsJ M, (Guilford Press, New York) pp 201–225
6.
AndersonK, 2000, “Thinking ‘postnationality’: Dialogue across multicultural, indigenous, and settler spaces”Annals of the Association of American Geographers90381–391
7.
BantingK G, 2005, “The multicultural welfare state: International experience and North American narratives”Social Policy and Administration39 (2) 98–115
8.
BantingK GKymlickaW, 2004, “Do multiculturalism policies erode the welfare state?”, in Cultural Diversity versus Economic Solidarity (Proceedings of the Seventh Francqui Colloquium) Ed. Van ParijsP, (De Boeck, Brussels) pp 227–284
9.
BarryB, 2002Culture and Equality: An Egalitarian Critique of Multiculturalism (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
10.
BenvenistiE, 1998, “Separate but equal in allocating state land for housing”Iyunei Mishpat (Tel-Aviv University Law Review)21769–798 (in Hebrew)
11.
Central Bureau of Statistics, 2003Local Authorities in Israel (State of Israel, Jerusalem)
12.
ColinH S, 1993, “Customs, traditions, and the politics of culture: Aboriginal self-government in Canada”, in Anthropology, Public Policy, and Native Peoples in Canada Eds DyckNWaldramJ B, (McGill-Queen's University Press, Montreal) pp 311–333
13.
Constitution, Law, and Justice Committee, 2005, “Consensual Constitution: Land and Settlement”, Protocol No. 501 (in Hebrew)
14.
DumperM, 1994Islam and Israel: Muslim and Religious Endowments and the Jewish State (Institute for Palestine Studies, Washington, DC)
15.
FincherRJacobsJ M, (Eds), 1998Cities of Difference (Guilford Press, New York) pp 1–25
16.
FormanGKedarA, 2004, “From Arab land to ‘Israel lands’: The legal dispossession of the Palestinians displaced by Israel in the wake of 1948”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space22809–830
17.
FraserN, 2003, “Social justice in the age of identity politics: Redistribution, recognition, and participation”, in Redistribution or Recognition? A Political–Philosophical Exchange Eds FraserNHonnetA, (Verso, London) pp 7–109
18.
GavisonR, 2003, “Constitutions and political reconstruction? Israel's quest for a constitution”International Sociology18 (1) 53–70
19.
GavisonRGreidi-SchwartzE, 2005, “Guidelines for discussion on the issue of land and settlement: Background material for June 14, 2005 Meeting of Constitution, Law and Justice Committee”, Israeli Parliament, Jerusalem (in Hebrew), http://www.huka.gov.il/wiki/material/data/H02-10-2005_8-56-01_hityashvut.doc
20.
HarrisC, 2004, “How did colonialism dispossess? Comments from an edge of empire”Annals of the Association of American Geographers94165–182
21.
ImbroscioD L, 2004, “Can we grant a right to place?”Politics and Society32575–609
22.
JabareenH, 2000, “Israeliness that predicts the future of the Arabs according to Jewish-Zionist time, in space that lacked Palestinian time”Law and Regime653–72 (in Hebrew)
23.
JamesonF, 1984, “Postmodernism, or the cultural logic of late capitalism”New Left Reviewnumber 146, 53–92
24.
KedarA, 2000, “First step in a difficult and sensitive road: Preliminary observations on Qaadan v Ketzir”Israel Studies Bulletin164–11
25.
KhamaissiR, 2003, “Mechanism of land control and territorial Judaization in Israel”, in In the Name of Security: Studies in Peace and War in Israel in Changing Times Eds Al-HajMBen-EliezerU, (University of Haifa Press, Haifa) pp 421–448 (in Hebrew)
26.
KhouryJ, 2004a, “New neighborhood in Carmiel for Jews only”Haaretz 30 July (in Hebrew)
27.
KhouryJ, 2004b, “ILA's ‘Jews only’ land sales challenged”Haaretz 12 October (in Hebrew)
28.
KimmerlingB, 2001The Invention and Decline of Israeliness: State, Society, and the Military (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
29.
LehaviA, 2005, “New residential communities in Israel: Between privatization and separation”Din-u-Devarim: Haifa Law Review263–140 (in Hebrew)
30.
Ministry of Justice, 2005, “Press release”, 27 January (in Hebrew)
31.
MoranA, 2002, “As Australia decolonizes: Indigenizing settler nationalism and the challenges of settler/indigenous relations”Ethnic and Racial Studies251013–1042
32.
MurphyA B, 2002, “National claims to territory in the modern state system: Geographical considerations”Geopolitics7193–214
33.
NewmanD, 2005, “From ‘Hitnachalut’ to ‘Hitnatkut’: The impact of Gush Emunim, and the Settlement Movement on Israeli society”Israel Studies10 (3) 192–224
34.
PenroseJ, 2002, “Nations, states and homelands: Territory and territoriality in nationalist thought”Nations and Nationalism8277–297
QadeerM A, 2003, “Ethnic segregation in a multicultural city: The case of Toronto, Canada”, WP 28, CERIS, Toronto
37.
QadeerM A, 2005, “Ethnic segregation in a multicultural city”, in Desegregating the City: Ghettos, Enclaves, and Inequality Ed. VaradyP D, (SUNY Press, Albany, NY) pp 49–61
38.
RamU, 2004, “The state of the nation: Contemporary challenges to Zionism in Israel”, in Israelis in Conflict: Hegemonies, Identities and Challenges Eds KempANewmanDRamUYiftachelO, (Sussex Academic Press, Brighton, Sussex) pp 305–320
39.
ReitmanM, 2006, “Uncovering the white place: Whitewashing at work”Social and Cultural Geography7267–282
40.
RinatZ, 2002, “A settlement for policemen”Ha'aretz 23 August (in Hebrew)
41.
SandercockL, 2000, “When strangers become neighbours: Managing cities of difference”Planning Theory and Practice1 (1) 13–30
42.
ShacharA, 1998, “Reshaping the map of Israel: A new national planning doctrine”Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science555209–218
43.
ShafirGPeledY, 1998, “Citizenship and stratification in an ethnic democracy”Ethnic and Racial Studies21408–427
44.
ShafirGPeledY, 2002Being Israeli: The Dynamics of Multiple Citizenship (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
45.
ShamirRZivN, 2001, “State-oriented and community-oriented lawyering for a cause: A tale of two strategies”, in Cause Lawyering and the State in a Global Era Eds SaratAScheingoldS, (Oxford University Press, New York) pp 287–304
46.
SharonA, 2000, “Land as an economic device to mold infrastructure and to reduce social inequalities”Land5010–21 (in Hebrew)
47.
ShetreetS, 2003, “On the issue of equality of separate residence in rural and communal settlements: Was the ruling in the Quadan case unavoidable?”Land: Periodical on Land Issues5627–65 (in Hebrew)
48.
ShohatEStamR, (Eds), 2003Multiculturalism, Postcoloniality, and Transnational Media (Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, NJ)
49.
State Comptroller, 2001Annual Report 51b (State of Israel, Jerusalem) (in Hebrew)
50.
State Comptroller, 2005Annual Report 55b (State of Israel, Jerusalem) (in Hebrew)
51.
StoreyD, 2001Territory: The Claiming of Space (Prentice-Hall, Harlow, Essex)
52.
TraubmanT, 2005, “8 students fund-raised 38 millions shekels”Ha'aretz 30 August (in Hebrew)
53.
TullyJ, 2000, “Struggles over recognition and distribution”Constellations7469–482
54.
TzfadiaEYacobiH, 2007, “Multiculturalism, nationalism and urban politics: The case of Ashdod”Israeli Sociology9(1) 127–148 (in Hebrew)
55.
Van KempenROzuekrenA S, 1998, “Ethnic segregation in cities: New forms and explanations in a dynamic world”Urban Studies351631–1656
56.
WilenskyH L, 1975The Welfare State and Equality: Structural and Ideological Roots of Public Expenditure (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
57.
YiftachelO, 2006Ethnocracy: Land and Identity Politics in Israel/Palestine (Penn State University Press, University Park, PA)
58.
YiftachelOYacobiH, 2003, “Urban ethnocracy: Ethnicization and the production of space in an Israeli ‘mixed city’”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space21673–693
59.
YonahY, 2005, “Toward multiculturalism in Israel: Spatial aspects”, in Memory and Meaning: The Architectural Construction of Place Eds KallusRHatukaT, (Resling, Tel Aviv) pp 137–176 (in Hebrew)
60.
YoungM I, 2005, “Self-determination as non-domination: Ideals applied to Palestine/Israel”Ethnicities5139–159
61.
Yuval-DavisN, 1997, “Ethnicity, gender relations and multiculturalism”, in Debating Cultural Hybridity: Hybridity, Multi-cultural Identities, and the Politics of Anti-racism Eds WebnerPModoodT, (Zed Books, London) pp 193–208
