Judgments of contour strength or saliency for twenty-four illusory-contour configurations were subjected to a confirmatory factor analysis. A four-factor model that posited the involvement of simultaneous contrast, linear effects (assimilation and dissimilation), depth/completion cues, and feature analyzers accounted for a substantial proportion of the variance in judgments of illusory-contour strength. The hierarchical addition of a fifth factor, diffuse illusory contours, significantly improved the overall fit of the model, but added little to the proportion of explained variance. The taxonomic approach adopted provides support for a multiprocess model of illusory-contour perception.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BachmannT, 1978“Problems of interaction and perception”Transactions of the State University of Tartu: Studies in Psychology731–60
2.
BentlerP MBonettD G, 1980“Significance tests and goodness of fit in the analysis of covariance structures”Psychological Bulletin88588–606
3.
BrignerW LGallagherM B, 1974“Subjective contour: Apparent depth or simultaneous brightness contrast?”Perceptual and Motor Skills381047–1053
4.
BrussellE MStoberS RBodingerD M, 1977“Sensory information and subjective contour”American Journal of Psychology90145–156
5.
CorenS, 1972“Subjective contours and apparent depth”Psychological Review79359–367
6.
CorenSGirgusJ, 1972“A comparison of five methods of illusion measurement”Behavioral Research Methods and Instrumentation4240–244
7.
CorenSGirgusJ S, 1978Seeing is Deceiving: The Psychology of Visual Illusions (Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates)
8.
DayR HJoryM K, 1978“Subjective contours, visual acuity, and line contrast” in Visual Psychophysics and Physiology: A Volume Dedicated to Lorrin Riggs Eds ArmingtonJ CKrauskopfJWootenB R (New York: Academic Press) pp 331–340
9.
DayR HJoryM K, 1980“A note on a second stage in the formation of illusory contours”Perception & Psychophysics2789–91
10.
DumaisS TBradleyD R, 1976“The effects of illumination level and retinal size on the apparent strength of subjective contours”Perception & Psychophysics19339–345
11.
EhrensteinW, 1941“Über Abwandlungen der L. Hermannschen Helligkeitserscheinung”Zeitschrift für Psychologie15083–91
GinsburgA P, 1975“Is the illusory triangle physical or imaginary?”Nature (London)257219–220
14.
GregoryR LHarrisJ B, 1974“Illusory contours and stereo depth”Perception & Psychophysics15411–416
15.
HalpernD F, 1981“The determinants of illusory-contour perception”Perception10199–213
16.
HalpernD FWarmJ S, 1980“The disappearance of real and subjective contours”Perception & Psychophysics28229–235
17.
JöreskogK GSörbomD, 1978LISREL IV User's Guide (Chicago, IL: National Educational Resources)
18.
JoryM KDayR H, 1979“The relationship between brightness contrast and illusory contours”Perception83–9
19.
JungRSpillmannL, 1970“Receptive-field estimation and perceptual integration in human vision” in Early Experience and Visual Information Processing in Perceptual and Reading Disorders Eds YoungF ALindsleyD B (Washington, DC: National Academy of Science) pp 181–197
20.
KanizsaG, 1955“Margini quasi-percettivi in campi con stimolazione omogenea”Rivista di Psicologia497–30
21.
KanizsaG, 1974“Contours without gradients or cognitive contours?”Italian Journal of Psychology193–113
KennedyJ M, 1975“Depth at an edge, coplanarity, slant depth, change in direction and change in brightness in the production of subjective contours”Italian Journal of Psychology2107–123
24.
KennedyJ M, 1976a“Attention, brightness, and the constructive eye” in Vision and Artifact Ed. HenleM (New York: Springer) pp 33–48
25.
KennedyJ M, 1976b“Sun figure: An illusory diffuse contour resulting from an arrangement of dots”Perception5479–481
26.
KennedyJ M, 1978“Illusory contours not due to completion”Perception7187–189
27.
LandauerA A, 1978“Subjective states and the perception of subjective contours” in Conceptual Analysis and Method in Psychology: Essays in Honour of W M O'Neil Ed. SutcliffeJ P (Sydney: (Sydney University Press)
28.
MoriG FRonchiL, 1960“On the perception of incomplete borders”Fondazione Giorgio Ronchi, Atti15357–368
29.
ParksT E, 1979“Subjective figures: Does brightness enhancement depend upon subjective boundary definition?”Perception & Psychophysics26418
30.
ParksT E, 1980“Subjective figures: Some unusual concomitant brightness effects”Perception9239–241
31.
PoracC, 1978“Depth in objective and subjective contour patterns”Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society11103–105
32.
RichardsonB L, 1979“The nonequivalence of abrupt and diffuse illusory contours”Perception8589–593
33.
RonchiLMoriG F, 1959“On the factors which affect the contrast enhancement in a figure with ‘quasi perceptive contours’ and a practical application of such a figure”Fondazione Giorgio Ronchi, Atti14495–508
34.
SambinM, 1974“Angular margins without gradient”Italian Journal of Psychology1355–361
35.
SambinM, 1975“The rule of terminal tensions in the organization of margins without gradients”Giornale Italiano di Psicologia2239–257
36.
SambinM, 1977“Contours without gradient with different phenomenal evidence”Giornale Italiano di Psicologia4121–147
37.
SchumannF, 1904“Einige Beobachtungen über die Zusammenfassung von Gesichtseindrücken zu Einheiten”Psychologische Studien11–32
38.
SmithAOverR, 1975“Tilt aftereffects with subjective contours”Nature (London)257581–582
39.
SmithA TOverR, 1976“Color-selective tilt aftereffects with subjective contours”Perception & Psychophysics20305–308
40.
SmithA TOverR, 1977“Orientation masking and the tilt illusion with subjective contours”Perception6441–447
41.
SmithA TOverR, 1979“Motion aftereffect with subjective contours”Perception & Psychophysics2595–98
42.
StadlerMDiekerJ, 1969“Margini quasi-percettivi e after-effects figurali”Rivista di Psicologia6395–104
43.
TuckerL RLewisC, 1973“A reliability coefficient for maximum likelihood factor analysis”Psychometrika381–10
44.
von GrünauM W, 1979“The involvement of illusory contours in stroboscopic motion”Perception & Psychophysics25205–208
