Infants recognise their mother's voice at birth but appear not to recognise visual-only presentations of her face until around 3 months. In a series of experiments visual discrimination by infants aged 1, 3, and 5 months of their mother's and a female stranger's face was investigated in visual-only and visual-plus-speech conditions. In the first experiment these infants' discrimination of mother's and female stranger's faces was measured by their visual-fixation-preference scores. Discrimination was found to be facilitated by the addition of speech information. In experiment 2 naive adults viewed silent videotapes of infants from experiment 1 and judged whether the mother had been presented on the infants' left or right. This added further information to the fixation-preference results of experiment 1: it was found that 1-month-olds discriminate mother's and stranger's face only in the presence of speech information, whereas 3-month-olds also do so in visual-only conditions. In experiments 3 and 4 the relative salience of lip movements and voice information in visual recognition of mother's face was investigated. In experiment 3, no significant differences in infants' visual-fixation-preference scores were obtained. However, in experiment 4 adults' ‘where is mother?’ judgments of videotapes from experiment 3 were found to be more accurate in the voice than in the lip-movements conditions, especially for the 3-month-olds and more accurate when mother rather than stranger was talking. It is concluded that young infants' visual recognition of mother is facilitated by addition of speech information, that it is primarily the voice component of speech that causes this facilitation, and that social discrimination is best indexed by a dependent variable which is sensitive to a range of facial cues provided by infants.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BahrickL EWalkerA SNeisserU, 1981“Selective looking by infants”Cognitive Psychology13377–390
2.
BahrickL E, 1988“Intermodal learning in infancy: Learning on the basis of two kinds of invariant relations in audible and visible events”Child Development59197–209
3.
BarreraM EMaurerD, 1981“Recognition of mother's photographed face by the three-month old infant”Child Development52714–716
4.
BernardJ ARameyC T, 1977“Visual regard of familiar and unfamiliar persons in the first six months of infancy”Merrill-Palmer Quarterly23121–127
5.
BertenthalB IProffittD RSpetnerN BThomasM A, 1985“The development of infant sensitivity to biomechanical motions”Child Development56531–543
6.
BigelowA, 1977“Infants' recognition of their mothers”, paper presented at the biennial meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development, New Orleans, LA, March, 1977
7.
BowerT G R, 1974Development in Infancy (San Francisco, CA: W H Freeman)
8.
BowerT G R, 1978“Perceptual development: Object and space” in Handbook of Perception volume VIII Perceptual Coding Eds CarteretteE CFriedmanM P (Orlando, FL: Academic Press) pp 83–103
9.
BredbergG, 1985“The anatomy of the developing ear” in Auditory Development in Infancy Eds TrehubS ESchneiderB (New York: Plenum) pp 3–20
10.
BroerseJPeltolaCCrassiniB, 1983“Infants' reactions to perceptual paradox during mother—infant interaction”Developmental Psychology19310–316
11.
BurnhamD K, 1987“The role of movement in object perception by infants” in Perceptual Development in Early Infancy: Problems and Issues Eds McKenzieB EDayR H (Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates) pp 143–172
12.
BurnhamD KDayR H, 1979“Detection of color in rotating objects by infants and its generalization over changes in velocity”Journal of Experimental Child Psychology28191–204
13.
BurnhamD KDoddB (to be published a) “Phonetic and phonemic factors in auditory-visual speech perception: The McGurk effect in infancy and across languages”
14.
BurnhamD KDoddB (to be published b) “Infants' auditory—visual perception of speech in familiar and foreign languages”
15.
CaronA JCaronR FMacLeanD J, 1988“Infant discrimination of naturalistic emotional expressions: The role of face and voice”Child Development59604–616
16.
CarpenterG C, 1974a“Mother's face and the newborn”New Scientist61742–744
17.
CarpenterG C, 1974b“Visual regard of moving and stationary faces in early infancy”Merrill-Palmer Quarterly20181–194
18.
CarpenterG CTecceJ JStechlerGFriedmanS, 1970“Differential visual behaviour to human and humanoid faces in early infancy”Merrill-Palmer Quarterly1691–108
19.
CernochM JPorterR H, 1985“Recognition of maternal axillary odors by infants”Child Development561593–1598
20.
CooperR PAslinR N, 1989“The language environment of the young infant: Implications for early perceptual development”Canadian Journal of Psychology43247–265
21.
CulpR E, 1974“The use of the mother's voice to control infant attending behaviour”Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development3942–51
22.
DeCasperA JFiferW P, 1980“Of human bonding: Newborns prefer their mothers' voices”Science2081174–1176
23.
DeCasperA JPrescottP A, 1984“Human newborns' perception of male voices: Preferences, discrimination, and reinforcing value”Developmental Psychobiology17481–491
24.
DeCasperA JSigafoosA D, 1983“The intrauterine heartbeat: A potent reinforcer for newborns”Infant Behavior and Development619–25
25.
DeCasperA JSpenceM, 1986“Newborns prefer a familiar story over an unfamiliar one”Infant Behavior and Development9133–150
26.
DobsonVTellerD Y, 1978“Visual acuity in human infants: A review and comparison of behavioral and electrophysiological studies”Visual Research181469–1483
27.
DoddB, 1979“Lip reading in infants: Attention to speech presented in- and out-of-synchrony”Cognitive Psychology11478–484
28.
DoddBBurnhamD, 1988“Processing speechread information”Volta Review: New Reflections on Speechreading9045–60
29.
EllsworthC PMuirD WHainsS M J, 1993“Social competence and person-object differentiation: An analysis of the still face effect”Developmental Psychology2963–73
30.
FantzR LFaganJ FIIIMirandaS B, 1975“Early visual selectivity” in Infant Perception: From Sensation to Cognition volume I Basic Visual Processes Eds CohenL BSalapatekP (Orlando, FL: Academic Press) pp 249–345
31.
FieldT M, 1979“Visual and cardiac responses to animate and inanimate faces by young term and preterm infants”Child Development50188–194
32.
FieldT MCohenDGarciaRGreenbergR, 1984“Mother—stranger face discrimination by the newborn”Infant Behavior and Development719–25
33.
FieldT MYega-LahrNScafidiFGoldsteinS, 1986“Effects of maternal unavailability on mother-infant interactions”Infant Behavior and Development9473–478
34.
FitzgeraldH E, 1968“Autonomic pupillary reflex activity during early infancy and its relation to social and non-social visual stimuli”Journal of Experimental Child Psychology6470–482
35.
FrancisP LMcCroyG, 1983“Infants' bimodal recognition of human stimulus configurations” paper presented at the biennial meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development, Detroit MI, April 1983
36.
GibsonE JOwsleyC JJohnstonJ, 1978“Perception of invariants by five-month-old infants: Differentiation of two types of motion”Developmental Psychology14407–415
37.
GibsonE JOwsleyC JWalkerAMegaw-NyceJ, 1979“Development of the perception of invariants: Substance and shape”Perception8609–619
38.
GibsonJ J, 1966The Senses Considered as Perceptual Systems (London: Allen and Unwin)
39.
GusellaJ LMuirD WTronickE Z, 1988“The effect of manipulating maternal behaviour during an interaction on 3- and 6-month-olds' affect and attention”Child Development591111–1124
40.
HaithM MBergmanTMooreM J, 1977“Eye contact and face scanning in early infancy”Science198853–855
41.
IhsenEDayR H, 1981“Infants' visual perception of moving objects at different distances” in Advances in Child Development: Theory and Research Eds NesdaleA RPrattCGrieveRFieldJIllingworthJHogbenJ (Perth, Western Australia: National Conference on Child Development)
42.
JohanssonG, 1978“Visual event perception” in Handbook of Sensory Physiology volume VIII Perception Eds HeldRLeibowitzH WTeuberH-L (Berlin: Springer) pp 675–711
43.
KaitzMShavivEGreenwaldMBlumMAuerbachJ, 1985“At what age can a baby recognize mother's face?” unpublished manuscript, Psychology Department, Hebrew University, Jerusalem, Israel
44.
KaufmannRKaufmannF, 1980“The face schema in 3- and 4-month-old infants: The role of dynamic properties of the face”Infant Behavior and Development3331–339
45.
KuhlP KMeltzoffA N, 1982“The bimodal perception of speech in infancy”Science2181138–1141
46.
KuhlP KMeltzoffA N, 1984“The intermodal representation of speech in infants”Infant Behavior and Development7361–381
47.
KurtzweilS R, 1988“Recognition of mother from multisensory interactions in early infancy”Infant Behavior and Development11235–243
48.
LambM EMorrisonD CMalkinC M, 1987“The development of infant social expectations in face-to-face interaction: A longitudinal study”Merrill-Palmer Quarterly33241–254
49.
LaubK W, 1973“Discrimination of mother from stranger by ten- and eleven-week-old infants”Dissertation Abstracts International346242–6243
50.
LaubK WMcCluskyK A, 1974“Visual discrimination of social stimuli with and without auditory cues”Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development3992–104
51.
MacKainK SStuddert-KennedyMSpiekerSSternD, 1983“Infant intermodal speech perception is a left-hemisphere function”Science2191347–1349
52.
McKenzieB EDayR H, 1972“Object distance as a determinant of visual fixation in early infancy”Science1781108–1110
53.
MasiWScottK, 1983“Recognition of mothers' faces by term and preterm infants” in Infants Born at Risk: Physiological Perception and Cognitive Processes Eds FieldTSostekA (New York: Grune and Stratton) pp 173–179
54.
MaurerDSalapatekP, 1976“Developmental changes in the scanning of faces by young infants”Child Development47523–527
55.
MehlerJBertonciniJBarriereMJassik-GerschenfeldD, 1978“Infant recognition of the mother's voice”Nature (London)7491–497
56.
MehlerJJusczykP WLambertzGHalstedNBertonciniJAmiel-TisonC, 1988“A precursor of language acquisition in young infants”Cognition29143–178
57.
MelhuishE C, 1982“Visual attention to mother's and stranger's faces and facial contrast in 1-month-old infants”Developmental Psychology18229–231
58.
MillsMMelhuishE, 1974“Recognition of mother's voice in early infancy”Nature (London)252123–124
59.
MoonCFiferW P, 1986“Newborn infants prefer the sound of mother's voice as experienced in the womb” paper presented at the International Society for Developmental Psychobiology, Annapolis, MD
60.
MuirDFieldJ, 1979“Newborn infants orient to sounds”Child Development50431–436
61.
NottleE, 1980“Visual facial discrimination of mother and female stranger by young infants” unpublished honours thesis: Department of Psychology, Monash University, Clayton, Victoria
62.
OcklefordE MVinceM ALaytonCReaderM R, 1988“Responses of neonates to parents' and others' voices”Early Human Development1827–36
63.
OlsonG M, 1981“The recognition of specific persons” in Infant Social Recognition Eds LambM ESherrodL R (Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates) pp 37–59
64.
PannetonR KDeCasperA J, 1984“Newborns prefer an intrauterine heartbeat sound to a male voice” poster presented at the International Conference on Infant Studies, New York
65.
PeeplesD RTellerD Y, 1975“Color vision and brightness discrimination in two-month-old infants”Science1891102–1103
66.
QuerleuDRenardX, 1981“Les perceptions auditives de fetus humain”Medicine and Hygiene392101–2110
67.
QuerleuDRenardXVersypFParis-DelrueLCrepinG, 1988“Fetal hearing”European Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology and Reproductive Biology29191–212
68.
SaiFBushnellI W R, 1988“The perception of faces in different poses by 1-month-olds”British Journal of Developmental Psychology635–41
69.
SalapatekP, 1975“Pattern perception in early infancy” in Infant Perception: From Sensation to CognitionVolume 1 Basic Visual Processes Eds CohenL BSalapatekP (Orlando, FL: Academic Press) pp 133–248
70.
SherrodL R, 1979“Social cognition in infants: Attention to the human face”Infant Behaviour and Development2279–294
71.
SmithermanC, 1986“Sensory primacy in the infant's discrimination of mother” paper presented at the International Conference on Infant Studies, Los Angeles, CA, April, 1986
72.
SpelkeE S, 1976“Infants' inter-modal perception of events”Cognitive Psychology8553–560
73.
SpelkeE S, 1979“Perceiving bimödally specified events in infancy”Developmental Psychology15626–636
74.
SpelkeE SOwsleyC J, 1979“Intermodal exploration and knowledge in infancy”Infant Behaviour and Development213–27
75.
TellerD YMorseRBortonRRegalD, 1974“Visual acuity for vertical and diagonal gratings in human infants”Vision Research141433–1439
76.
TronickE, 1972“Stimulus control and the growth of the infants' effective visual field”Perception & Psychophysics11373–376
77.
TronickEAlsHAdamsonLWiseSBrazeltonT B, 1978“The infant's response to entrapment between contradictory messages in face-to-face interaction”Journal of the American Academy of Child Psychiatry171–13
78.
VolkmannF CDobsonM V, 1976“Infant responses of ocular fixation to moving visual stimuli”Journal of Experimental Child Psychology2286–99
79.
WerkerJ FMcLeodP J, 1989“Infant preference for both male and female infant-directed talk: A developmental study of attentional affective responsiveness”Canadian Journal of Psychology43230–246
