The effect of the spatial frequency (SF) of visual gratings on reaction time (RT) and temporal-order judgment (TOJ) was examined in three experiments. In experiment 1 the visual stimuli were vertical sinusoidal gratings with SFs between 2 and 8 cycles deg−1 and the comparison stimulus in the TOJ task was a 2300 Hz tone. Whereas SF had a highly significant effect on RT, it left TOJ completely unaffected. To test whether this dissociation was due to the sharp (high SF) horizontal edges of the gratings, a second experiment was carried out with circular stimuli with no sharp edges. These stimuli did produce an effect of SF on TOJ, but it was significantly smaller than was the effect on RT. In experiment 3 we confirmed that this difference was not due to differences in grating orientation between the first two experiments. These findings (a) solve discrepancies between findings reported in the literature and (b) strongly suggest that RT and TOJ cannot be regarded as converging operations for determining ‘visual latency’. This dissociation can best be accounted for by assuming that the output of early stimulus analysis can feed directly into the motor system (direct parameter specification), whereas the conscious representation that is used for TOJ is based on later integrative processes.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BarlowH BHillR MLevickW R, 1964“Retinal ganglion cells responding selectively to direction and speed of image in rabbit”Journal of Physiology173377–407
2.
BarlowH BLevickW R, 1965“The mechanism of directionally selective units in rabbit's retina”Journal of Physiology178477–504
3.
BarrM, 1983“A comparison of reaction time and temporal-order-judgment estimates of latency to sinusoidal gratings”Perception12A7
4.
BoltzR LHarwerthR SSmithE LIII, 1979“Orientation anisotropy of visual stimuli in Rhesus Monkey: A behavioral study”Science205511–513
5.
BreitmeyerB G, 1975“Simple reaction times as a measure of the temporal properties of transient and sustained channels”Vision Research151411–1412
6.
BruderG EKietzmanM L, 1973“Visual temporal integration for threshold, signal detectability, and reaction time measure”Perception & Psychophysics13293–300
7.
CampionJLattoRSmithY M, 1983“Is blindsight an effect of scattered light, spared cortex, and near-threshold vision?”The Behavioral and Brain Sciences6423–486
8.
ColesM G H, 1989“Modern mind-brain reading: Psychophysiology, physiology, and cognition”Psychophysiology26251–269
9.
CornsweetT N, 1962“The staircase-method in psychophysics”American Journal of Psychology75485–491
10.
DennettD CKinsbourneM, 1992“Time and the observer: The where and when of consciousness in the brain”The Behavioral and Brain Sciences15183–201
11.
Duncan-JohnsonC C, 1981“P300 latency: A new metric of information processing”Psychophysiology18207–215
12.
EjimaYOhtaniY, 1987“Simple reaction time to a sinusoidal grating and perceptual integration time: Contributions of perceptual and response processes”Vision Research27269–276
13.
EriksenC WSchultzD W, 1979“Information processing in visual search: A continuous flow conception and experimental results”Perception & Psychophysics25249–263
14.
GishGShulmanG LSheehyJ BLeibowitzH W, 1986“Reaction times to different spatial frequencies as a function of detectability”Vision Research26745–747
15.
GoebelR, 1990“Binding, episodic short-term memory, and selective attention, or why are PDP models poor at symbol manipulation?”, in Proceedings of the 1990 Connectionist Models Summer School Eds TouretzkyD SElmanJ LSejnowskiT JHintonG E (San Mateo, CA: Morgan Kaufman) pp 253–264
16.
GriceG R, 1968“Stimulus intensity and response evocation”Psychological Review75359–373
17.
HarwerthRLeviD, 1978“Reaction time as a measure of suprathreshold grating detection”Vision Research181579–1586
18.
JeffreysD AAxfordJ G, 1972“Source location of pattern-specific components of human visual evoked potentials. I. Component of striate cortical origin. II. Component of extrastriate cortical origin”Experimental Brain Research161–40
KlotzWWolffP, (submitted) “Impact of a masked stimulus on the motor response to the masking stimulus”
21.
LennieP, 1980“Perceptual signs of parallel pathways”Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series B29023–37
22.
LibetB, 1966“Brain stimulation and the threshold of conscious experience”, in Brain and Conscious Experience Ed. EcclesJ C (Berlin: Springer) pp 165–181
23.
LibetB, 1980“Neuronal vs. subjective timing for a conscious sensory experience” in Cerebral Correlates of Conscious Experience Eds BuserP ARougeul-BuserA (Elsevier, North-Holland: Biomedical Press) pp 69–82
24.
LuppUHauskeGWolfW, 1976“Perceptual latencies to sinusoidal gratings”Vision Research16969–972
25.
MayJ GMartinFMacCanaFLovegroveW J, 1988“The effects of spatial frequency and temporal waveform on three measures of temporal processing”The Journal of General Psychology115293–306
26.
McClellandJ L, 1979“On the time relations of mental processes: An examination of systems of processes in cascade”Psychological Review86287–330
27.
McGillW J, 1963“Stochastic latency mechanisms”, in Handbook of Mathematical PsychologyVolume 1 Eds LuceR DBushR RGalanterE (New York: John Wiley) pp 309–360
28.
MillerJ O, 1988“Discrete and continuous models of human information processing: Theoretical distinctions and empirical results”Acta Psychologica671–67
29.
MillerJRiehleARequinJ, 1992“Effects of preliminary perceptual output on neuronal activity of the primary motor cortex”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance181121–1138
30.
MusselwhiteM JJeffreysD A, 1985“The influence of spatial frequency on the reaction times and evoked potentials recorded to grating pattern stimuli”Vision Research251545–1555
31.
NakayamaK, 1985“Biological image motion processing: A review”Vision Research25625–660
32.
NeisserU, 1967Cognitive Psychology (New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts)
33.
NeumannO, 1982“Experimente zum Fehrer—Raab—Effekt und das ‘Wetterwart’-Modell der visuellen Maskierung (Experiments on the Fehrer—Raab effect and the weather station model of visual masking)”, Report No 24/1982, Department of Psychology, Cognitive Psychology Unit, Ruhr University Bochum, Germany
34.
NeumannO, 1989“Kognitive Vermittlung und direkte Parameterspezifikation. Zum Problem mentaler Repräsentation in der Wahrnehmung (Cognitive mediation and direct parameter specification: On the problem of mental representation in perception)”Sprache und Kognition832–49
35.
NeumannO, 1990“Direct parameter specification and the concept of perception”Psychological Research52207–215
36.
NeumannOEsselmannU, 1992“Visual attention, response latency, and temporal order judgment”International Journal of Psychology2713
37.
NeumannOEsselmannUKlotzW, 1993“Differential effects of visual spatial attention on response latency and temporal order judgment”Psychological Research5626–34
38.
NeumannOKlotzW, 1994“Motor responses to nonreportable, masked stimuli: Where is the limit of direct parameter specification?”, in Attention and Performance XV: Conscious and Nonconscious Information Processing Eds UmiltàCMoscovitchM (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press) pp 123–150
39.
NeumannOKochRNiepelMTappeT h, 1992“Reaktionszeit und zeitliches Reihenfolgeurteil: Übereinstimmung oder Dissoziation? (Reaction time and temporal order judgment: Correspondence or dissociation?)”Zeitschrift für experimentelle und angewandte Psychologie39621–645
40.
NeumannONiepelMTappeT hKochR, (submitted a) “Temporal order judgment and reaction time to visual and auditory stimuli of different intensities: Further evidence for a dissociation”
41.
NeumannOTappeT hNiepelM, (submitted b) “The effect of stimulus intensity and sensory modality on reaction time and temporal order judgment: A survey and an appraisal”
42.
ParkerD M, 1980“Simple reaction times to the onset, offset, and contrast reversal of sinusoidal grating stimuli”Perception & Psychophysics28365–368
43.
ParkerD MDutchS, 1987“Perceptual latency and spatial frequency”Vision Research271279–1283
44.
ParkerD MSalzenE A, 1977“Latency changes in the human visual evoked response to sinusoidal gratings”Vision Research171201–1204
45.
RoufsJ A J, 1963“Perception lag as a function of stimulus luminance”Vision Research3545–558
46.
RoufsJ A J, 1974“Dynamic properties of vision V. Perception lag and reaction time in relation to flicker and flash thresholds”Vision Research14853–869
47.
SternbergSKnollR L, 1973“The perception of temporal order: Fundamental issues and a general model”, in Attention and Performance III Ed. KornblumS (New York: Academic Press) pp 629–686
48.
SternbergSKnollR LZukofskyP, 1982“Timing by skilled musicians”, in The Psychology of Music Ed DeutschD (New York: Academic Press) pp 182–239
49.
TartaglioneAGoffD PBentonA L, 1975“Reaction time to square-wave gratings as a function of spatial frequency, complexity, and contrast”Brain Research100111–120
50.
TreismanA, 1988“Features and objects: The fourteenth Bartlett memorial lecture”Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Experimental Psychology40201–237
51.
UenoT, 1977“Reaction time as a measure of temporal summation at suprathreshold levels”Vision Research17227–232
52.
UlrichR, 1987“Threshold models of temporal-order judgments evaluated by a ternary response task”Perception & Psychophysics42224–239
53.
VassilevAManahilovVMitovD, 1983“Spatial frequency and the pattern onset-offset response”Vision Research231417–1422
54.
VassilevAMitovD, 1976“Perception time and spatial frequency”Vision Research1689–92
55.
VassilevAStomonykovV, 1987“The effect of grating spatial frequency on the early VEP-Component C1”Vision Research27727–729
56.
VassilevAStrashimirovD, 1979“On the latency of human visually evoked response to sinusoidal gratings”Vision Research19843–845
57.
WeiskrantzL, 1988“Some contributions of neuropsychology of vision and memory to the problem of consciousness”, in Consciousness in Contemporary Science Eds MarcelA JBisiachE (Oxford: Clarendon Press) pp 183–199
58.
WeiskrantzLWarringtonE KSandersM DMarshallJ, 1974“Visual capacity in the hemianoptic field following a restricted occipital ablation”Brain97709–728
59.
WilliamsonS JKaufmannLBrennerD, 1978“Latency of the neuromagnetic response of the human visual cortex”Vision Research18107–110
60.
WilsonJ T, 1987“Interaction of simultaneous visual events”Perception16375–383
61.
WilsonJ TSingerW, 1981“Simultaneous visual events show a long range spatial interaction”Perception & Psychophysics30107–113
