In certain simple rotations of objects, the orientation of the axis and planes of rotation can determine whether people are able to visualize the motion or perceive it as simple and coherent. This finding affords the opportunity to investigate the spatial reference systems used to define the orientation of the axis and planes of rotation. The results of two experiments suggest that the permanent environment is the primary reference system, apart from the rotating object, used for this purpose. Subjects also were able to use a local spatial environment to determine the orientation of the motion; some subjects were particularly adept at this. The viewer perspective, in contrast, was irrelevant as a reference system in these experiments. These results argue strongly for the primacy of environmental reference systems in the perception and imagination of orientation and extend the set of findings common between the comprehension of rotational motion and orientation-sensitive form perception.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AppelleS, 1972“Perception and discrimination as a function of stimulus orientation: The oblique effect in man and animals”Psychological Bulletin78266–278.
2.
AttneaveFOlsonR K, 1967“Discriminability of stimuli varying in physical and retinal orientation”Journal of Experimental Psychology74149–157.
3.
AttneaveFReidK W, 1968“Voluntary control of frame of reference and slope equivalence under head rotation”Journal of Experimental Psychology78153–159.
4.
BiedermanI, 1987“Recognition by components: A theory of human image understanding”Psychological Review94115–147.
5.
BiedermanIGerhardsteinP C, 1993“Recognizing depth-rotated objects: Evidence and conditions for three-dimensional viewpoint invariance”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance191162–1182.
6.
CampbellF WKulikowskiJ JLevinsonJ, 1966“The effect of orientation on the visual resolution of gratings”Journal of Physiology (London)187427–436.
7.
CarletonE HShepardR N, 1990a“Psychologically simple motions as geodesic paths. I. Asymmetric objects”Journal of Mathematical Psychology34127–188.
8.
CarletonE HShepardR N, 1990b“Psychologically simple motions as geodesic paths. II. Symmetric objects”Journal of Mathematical Psychology34189–228.
9.
CorballisM C, 1988“Recognition of disoriented shapes”Psychological Review95115–123.
10.
CorballisM CRoldanC E, 1975“Detection of symmetry as a function of angular orientation”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance1221–230.
11.
CorballisM CNagourneyB AShetzerL IStefanatosG, 1978“Mental rotation under head tilt: Factors influencing the location of the subjective reference frame”Perception & Psychophysics24263–273.
12.
CorballisM CZbrodoffJRoldanC E, 1976“What's up in mental rotation?”Perception & Psychophysics19525–530.
13.
CraigJ J, 1989Introduction to Robotics: Mechanics and Control (Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley).
14.
CuttingJ EProffittD R, 1982“The minimum principle and the perception of absolute, common, and relative motions”Cognitive Psychology14211–246.
15.
DunckerK, 1950“Induced motion”, in A Source Book of Gestalt Psychology Ed. EllisW D, (Atlantic Heights, NJ: Humanities Press) pp 161–172 (Abridged translation of a paper originally published in German in 1929).
16.
FranklinNTverskyB, 1990“Searching imagined environments”Journal of Experimental Psychology: General11963–76.
17.
GassonP C, 1983The Geometry of Spatial Forms (Chichester, W Sussex: Ellis Horwood).
18.
GibsonJ JCornsweetJ, 1952“The perceived slant of visual surfaces—optical and geographical”Journal of Experimental Psychology4411–15.
19.
GildenD L, 1991“On the origins of dynamical awareness”Psychological Review98554–568.
20.
GreenB F, 1961“Figure coherence in the kinetic depth effect”Journal of Experimental Psychology62272–282.
21.
GoldmeierE, 1972“Similarity in visually perceived forms”Psychological Issues8(1) 1–135.
22.
HintonG, 1979“Some demonstrations of the effects of structural descriptions in mental imagery”Cognitive Science3231–250.
23.
HintonG EParsonsL M, 1981“Frames of reference and mental imagery”, in Attention and PerformanceVolume 9 Eds BaddeleyA DLongJ, (Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates) pp 261–277.
24.
HintonG EParsonsL M, 1988“Scene-based and viewer-centered representations for comparing shapes”Cognition301–35.
25.
HowardI P, 1982Human Visual Orientation (New York: John Wiley).
26.
HowardI P, 1986“The perception of posture, self motion, and the visual vertical”, in Handbook of Perception and Human Performance Volume 1: Sensory Processes and Perception Eds BoffK RKaufmanLThomasJ P, (New York: John Wiley) pp 18–1–18–62.
27.
HumphreysG W, 1983“Reference frames and shape perception”Cognitive Psychology15151–196.
28.
JohanssonG, 1973“Visual perception of biological motion and a model for its analysis”Perception & Psychophysics14201–211.
JustM ACarpenterP A, 1985“Cognitive coordinate systems: Accounts of mental rotation and individual differences in spatial ability”Psychological Review92137–172.
31.
KoffkaK, 1935Principles of Gestalt Psychology (New York: Harcourt, Brace and World).
32.
McAfeeE AProffittD R, 1991“Understanding the surface orientation of liquids”Cognitive Psychology23483–514.
33.
McMullenP AJolicoeurP, 1990“The spatial frame of reference in object naming and discrimination of left - right reflections”Memory and Cognition1899–115.
34.
McMullenP AJolicoeurP, 1992“Reference frame and effects of orientation on finding the tops of rotated objects”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance18807–820.
35.
MarrD, 1977“Analysis of occluding contour”Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Series B197441–475.
36.
MarrD, 1982Vision (San Francisco, CA: W H Freeman).
37.
MarrDNishiharaH K, 1978“Representation and recognition of the spatial organization of three-dimensional shapes”Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Senes B200269–294.
38.
MassironiMLuccioR, 1989“Organizational versus geometric factors in mental rotation and folding tasks”Perception18321–332.
39.
PalmerS E, 1980“What makes triangles point: Local and global effects in configuration of ambiguous triangles”Cognitive Psychology12285–305.
40.
PalmerS E, 1989“Reference frames in the perception of shape and orientation”, in Object Perception: Structure and Process Eds SheppB EBallesterosS, (Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates) pp 121–163.
41.
PalmerS EBoucherN M, 1981“Configural effects in perceived pointing of ambiguous triangles”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance788–114.
42.
PalmerS EBoucherN M, 1982“Textural effects in perceived pointing of ambiguous triangles”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance8693–708.
43.
PalmerS EHemenwayK, 1978“Orientation and symmetry: Effects of multiple, rotational, and near symmetries”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance4691–702.
44.
PaniJ R, 1989“Axis of rotation and orientation of the object in mental representation of rotation”, poster presented at the 30th meeting of the Psychonomic Society, Atlanta, GA.
45.
PaniJ R, 1993“Limits on the comprehension of rotational motion: Mental imagery of rotations with oblique components”Perception22785–808.
46.
PaniJ RDupreeD, 1990“Spatial reference frames and mental imagery of rotational motion”, poster presented at the 31st meeting of the Psychonomic Society, New Orleans, LA.
47.
PaniJ RJeffresJ AShippeyGSchwartzK, 1994“Imagining projective transformations: Aligned orientations in spatial organization” (manuscript submitted for publication).
48.
PaniJ RWilliamC TShippeyG, in press “Determinants of the perception of rotational motion: Orientation of the motion to the environment and to the object”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance.
49.
ParsonsL M, 1987“Visual discrimination of abstract mirror-reflected three-dimensional objects at many orientations”Perception & Psychophysics4249–59.
50.
RockI, 1973Orientation and Form (New York: Academic Press).
51.
RockI, 1983The Logic of Perception (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press).
52.
RockI, 1986“The description and analysis of object and event perception”, in Handbook of Perception and Human Performance Volume 2: Cognitive Processes and Performance Ed BoffK RKaufmanLThomasJ P, (New York: John Wiley) pp 33–1–33–71.
53.
RockIDaVitaJ, 1987“A case of viewer-centered object perception”Cognitive Psychology19280–293.
54.
RockIDaVitaJBarbeitoR, 1981“The effect on form perception of change of orientation in the third dimension”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance7719–732.
55.
RockIWheelerDTudorL, 1989“Can we imagine how objects look from other viewpoints?”Cognitive Psychology21185–210.
56.
SedgwickH A, 1983“Environment-centered representation of spatial layout: Available visual information from texture and perspective”, in Human and Machine Vision Eds RosenthalABeckJ, (New York: Academic Press) pp 425–458.
57.
SedgwickH A, 1986“Space perception”, in Handbook of Perception and Human Performance Volume 1: Sensory Processes and Perception Eds BoffK RKaufmanLThomasJ P, (New York: John Wiley) pp 21–1–21–57.
58.
ShiffrarM MShepardR N, 1991“Comparison of cube rotations around axes inclined relative to the environment or to the cube”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance1744–54.
59.
TakanoY, 1989“Perception of rotated forms: A theory of information types”Cognitive Psychology211–59.
60.
TarrM JPinkerS, 1989“Mental rotation and orientation dependence in shape recognition”Cognitive Psychology21233–283.
61.
ToddJ T, 1982“Visual information about rigid and nonrigid motion: A geometric analysis”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance8238–252.
62.
TverskyB, 1981“Distortions in memory for maps”Cognitive Psychology13407–433.
63.
TverskyBSchianoD J, 1989“Perceptual and conceptual factors in distortions in memory for graphs and maps”Journal of Experimental Psychology: General118387–398.
64.
WallachH, 1959“The perception of motion”Scientific American20156–60.
65.
WitkenH AGoodenoughD R, 1981Cognitive Styles: Essence and Origins (New York: International Universities Press).
