Perception of Simple and Complex Visual Stimuli: Decision Strategies and Hemispheric Differences in Same—Different Judgments

The accuracy with which observers could judge whether two visual stimuli were the same or different was measured with the rating method of detection theory. For judgments of whether two pictures referred to natural or manufactured things, the shape of the obtained receiver operating characteristic (ROC) was consistent with the observers adopting an optimal decision strategy. A similar result was found for judgments of complex but meaningless visual patterns. For judgments of whether two colours that differed along a simple sensory dimension were the same or different, however, the resulting ROC was consistent with the observers adopting a suboptimal differencing strategy. The accuracy of the judgments did not depend on the visual field to which the stimuli were presented.