The study of illusory brightness and contour phenomena has become an important tool in modern brain research. Gestalt, cognitive, neural, and computational approaches are reviewed and their explanatory powers are discussed in the light of empirical data. Two well-known phenomena of illusory form are dealt with, the Ehrenstein illusion and the Kanizsa triangle. It is argued that the gap between the different levels of explanation, bottom—up versus top—down, creates scientific barriers which have all too often engendered unnecessary debate about who is right and who is wrong. In this review of the literature we favour an integrative approach to the question of how illusory form is derived from stimulus configurations which provide the visual system with seemingly incomplete information. The processes that can explain the emergence of these phenomena range from local feature detection to global strategies of perceptual organisation. These processes may be similar to those that help us restore partially occluded objects in everyday vision. To understand better the Ehrenstein and Kanizsa illusions, it is proposed that different levels of analysis and explanation are not mutually exclusive, but complementary. Theories of illusory contour and form perception must, therefore, take into account the underlying neurophysiological mechanisms and their possible interactions with cognitive and attentional processes.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbravanelE, 1982“Perceiving subjective contours during early childhood”Journal of Experimental Psychology33280–287
2.
AlbertM KHoffmanD D, 1995“Genericity in spatial vision”, in Geometric Representations of Perceptual Phenomena: Papers in Honor of Tarow Indow's 70th Birthday Ed. LuceD (Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates) pp 95–112
3.
BaumgartnerG, 1961“Die Reaktionen der Neurone des zentralen visuellen Systems der Katze im simultanen Helligkeitskonstrast”, in Neurophysiologie und Psychophysik des Visuellen Systems Eds JungRKornhuberH (Berlin: Springer) pp 296–313
4.
BaumgartnerG, 1962“Zur Neurophysiologie und Psychophysik des simultanen Helligkeitskontrastes”Fortschritte der Medizin80633–638
5.
BaumgartnerG, 1964“Neuronale Mechanismen des Kontrast- und Bewegungssehens”Berichte der Deutschen Ophthalmologischen Gesellschaft66111–125
6.
BeckerM FKnoppJ, 1978“Processing of visual illusions in the frequency and spatial domains”Perception & Psychophysics23521–526
7.
BertenthalB ICamposJHaithM M, 1980“Development of visual organization: The perception of subjective contours”Child Development511072–1080
8.
BloomfieldS, 1973“Implicit feature and stereoscopy”Nature (London)245256
9.
BradleyD R, 1987“Cognitive contours and perceptual organization”, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 201–212
BradleyD RDumaisS T, 1984“The effect of illumination level and retinal size on the depth stratification of subjective contour figures”Perception13155–164
BradleyD RMatesS M, 1985“Perceptual organization and apparent brightness in subjective-contour figures”Perception14645–653
14.
BradleyD RPetryH M, 1977“Organizational determinants of subjective contour: the subjective Necker cube”American Journal of Psychology90253–262
15.
BravoMBlakeRMorrisonS, 1988“Cats see subjective contours”Vision Research28861–865
16.
BressanP, 1987“Subjective rarefaction in illusory figures: The inadequacy of apparent lightness as an explanation”Perception16461–466
17.
BressanP, 1993“Neon colour spreading with and without its figural prerequisites”Perception22353–361
18.
BressanPVallortigaraG, 1986“Subjective contours can produce stereokinetic effects”Perception15409–412
19.
BrignerW LGallagherM B, 1974“Subjective contour: Apparent depth or simultaneous brightness contrast”Perceptual and Motor Skills381047–1053
20.
BrignerW LHammondJ T, 1981“Role of brightness contrast and brightness contrast-reversal in illusory contour formation”Perceptual and Motor Skills52415–424
21.
BrunoNBertaminiM, 1990“Identifying contours from occlusion events”Perception & Psychophysics48331–342
22.
BrunoNGerbinoW, 1991“Illusory figures based on kinematics”Perception20259–274
23.
BrusselE MStoberS RBodingerD M, 1977“Sensory information and subjective contour”American Journal of Psychology90145–156
24.
CarmanG JWelchL, 1992“Three-dimensional illusory contours and surfaces”Nature (London)360585–587
25.
CohenM AGrossbergS, 1984“Neural dynamics of brightness perception: features, boundaries, diffusion, and resonance”Perception & Psychophysics36428–456
26.
CorbettaMAntoniniABerlucchiGAgliotiS, 1989“Texture discrimination and illusory contour perception in normal and decorticated cats”Pflügers Archiv (European Journal of Physiology)41461
27.
CorenS, 1972“Subjective contours and apparent depth”Psychological Review79359–367
28.
CorenS, 1991“Retinal mechanisms in the perception of subjective contours: the contribution of lateral inhibition”Perception20181–191
29.
CorenSPoracC, 1983“Subjective contours and apparent depth: A direct test”Perception & Psychophysics33197–200
30.
CorenSPoracCTheodorL H, 1987“Set and subjective contour”, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 237–245
31.
CorenSTheodorL H, 1975“Subjective contour: The inadequacy of brightness contrast as an explanation”Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society687–89
32.
CorenSTheodorL H, 1977“Neural interactions and subjective contours”Perception6107–111
33.
CornsweetT NTellerD Y, 1965“Relation of increment thresholds to brightness and luminance”Journal of the Optical Society of America551303–1308
34.
DayR H, 1986“Enhancement of edges by contrast, depth and figure: The origin of illusory contours”, in Visual Neuroscience Eds PettigrewJ DSandersonK JLevickW R (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press) pp 352–364
35.
DayR H, 1987“Cues for edge and the origin of illusory contours: An alternative approach”, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 53–61
36.
DayR HDickinsonR GJoryM K, 1977“The Poggendorff illusion with subjective contours”Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology29219–226
37.
DayR HJoryM K, 1978“Subjective contours, visual acuity, and line contrast”, in Visual Psychophysics and Physiology Eds ArmingtonJ CKrauskopfJWootenB R (New York: Academic Press) pp 331–340
38.
DayR HJoryM K, 1980“A note on a second stage in the formation of illusory contours”Perception & Psychophysics2789–91
39.
DayR HKasperczykR T, 1983a“Amodal completion as a basis for illusory contours”Perception & Psychophysics33355–364
40.
DayR HKasperczykR T, 1983b“Illusory contours in line patterns with apparent depth due to either perspective or overlay”Perception12485–490
41.
DobbinsAZuckerS WCynaderM S, 1987“Endstopped neurons in the visual cortex as a substrate for calculating curvature”Nature (London)329438–441
42.
Van DoornA JKoenderinkJ J, 1982“Visibility of movement gradient”Biological Cybernetics44167–175
43.
DrespB, 1992“Local mechanisms sketch out surfaces, but do not fill them in: Evidence in the Kanizsa square”Perception & Psychophysics52562–570
44.
DrespB, 1993“Bright lines and edges facilitate the detection of small light targets”Spatial Vision7213–225
45.
DrespB, submitted, “On the biological significance of figures with illusory contours: Physiological and psychological aspects”Psychonomic Bulletin & Review
46.
DrespBBonnetC, 1991“Psychophysical evidence for low-level processing of illusory contours and surfaces in the Kanizsa square”Vision Research101813–1817
47.
DrespBBonnetC, 1993“Psychophysical measures of illusory form perception: Further evidence for local mechanisms”Vision Research33759–766
48.
DrespBBonnetC, 1995“Subthreshold summation with illusory contours”Vision Research351071–1078
49.
DrespBGrossbergS, 1995“Illusory-contour integration: From contrast summation to bipole cooperation”Perception24Supplement, 30
50.
DrespBLorenceauJBonnetC, 1990“Apparent brightness enhancement in the Kanizsa square with and without illusory contours”Perception19483–489
51.
DrespBPardieuVBonnetC (in press) “Illusory form from inducers with opposite contrast polarity: Evidence for multistage integration mechanisms”Perception & Psychophysics
52.
DumaisS TBradleyD R, 1976“The effects of illumination level and retinal size on the apparent strength of subjective contours”Perception & Psychophysics19339–345
53.
EhrensteinW, 1941“Über Abwandlungen der L. Hermannschen Helligkeitserscheinung”Zeitschrift für Psychologie15083–91 [“Modifications of the brightness phenomenon of L. Hermann”; translation by A Hogg, 1987, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 35–39]
54.
EhrensteinW, 1954Probleme der ganzheitspsychologischen Wahrnehmungslehre (Leipzig: Barth)
55.
EjimaYTakahashiS, 1988“Illusory contours induced by chromatic patterns”Vision Research281367–1377
56.
EnnsJ TRensinkR A, 1993“A model for the rapid interpretation of line drawings in early vision”, in Visual Search II: Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Visual Search Eds BroganDGaleACarrK (London: Taylor and Francis) pp 73–89
57.
EnnsJ TRensinkR A, 1994“An object completion process in early vision”, in Visual Search III: Proceedings of the Third International Conference on Visual Search Eds GaleA G (London: Taylor and Francis)
58.
Van EsenJ SNovakS, 1974“Detection thresholds within a display that manifests contour enhancement and brightness contrast”Journal of the Optical Society of America64726–729
59.
FarnéM, 1968“Alcune osservazioni con linee virtuali e margini quasi percettivi”Bollettino della Società Italiana de Biologia Sperimentale441613–1616
60.
FieldD JHayesAHessR F, 1993“Contour integration by the human visual system: evidence for a local ‘association field’”Vision Research33173–193
61.
FinkelL HEdelmanG M, 1989“Integration of distributed cortical systems by reentry: a computer simulation of interactive functionally segregated visual areas”Journal of Neuroscience93188–3208
62.
FiorentiniA, 1972“Mach band phenomena”, in Handbook of Sensory Physiology volume 7 Visual Psychophysics Eds JamesonDHurvichL M (New York: Springer) pp 188–201
FuldKO'DonnellK, 1984“Brightness matching and scaling of the Ehrenstein illusion”, in Sensory Experience, Adaptation, and Perception Eds SpillmannLWootenB (Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates) pp 461–469
68.
GalliAHochheimerW, 1934“Beobachtungen an Nachzeichnungen mehrdeutiger Feldkonturen”Zeitschrift für Psychologie132304–334
69.
GerbinoWKanizsaG, 1987“Can we see constructs?”, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 246–252
70.
GerritsH J MVendrikA J H, 1970“Simultaneous contrast filling-in process and information processing in man's visual system”Experimental Brain Research11411–430
71.
GhimH R, 1990“Evidence for perceptual organization in infants: Perception of subjective contours by young infants”Infant Behavior and Development13221–248
72.
GilbertC DWieselT N, 1985“Intrinsic connectivity and receptive field properties in the visual cortex”Vision Research25365–374
73.
GillamB, 1987“Perceptual grouping and subjective contours”, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 268–273
74.
GinsburgA P, 1975“Is the illusory triangle physical or imaginary?”Nature (London)257219–220
75.
GinsburgA P, 1982“On a filter approach to understanding the perception of visual form”, in Recognition of Pattern and Form Ed. AlbrechtD G (New York: Springer) pp 175–192
76.
GinsburgA P, 1987“The relationship between spatial filtering and subjective contours”, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 126–130
77.
GoldsteinM BWeintraubD J, 1972“The parallel-less Poggendorff: Virtual contours put the illusion down, but not out”Perception & Psychophysics11353–355
78.
GollinE S, 1960“Developmental studies of visual recognition of incomplete objects”Perceptual and Motor Skills11289–298
79.
GregoryR L, 1966Eye and Brain (London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson) (4th edition reprinted 1994, Oxford: Oxford University Press)
80.
GregoryR L, 1970The Intelligent Eye (New York: McGraw-Hill)
GregoryR LHarrisJ P, 1974“Illusory contours and stereo depth”Perception & Psychophysics15411–416
90.
GrosofD HShapleyR MHawkenM J, 1993“Macaque V1 neurons can signal illusory contours”Nature (London)365550–552
91.
GrossbergS, 1987a“Cortical dynamics of three-dimensional form, color, and brightness perception: 1. Monocular theory”Perception & Psychophysics4187–116
92.
GrossbergS, 1987b“Cortical dynamics of three-dimensional form, color, and brightness perception: II. Binocular theory”Perception & Psychophysics41117–158
93.
GrossbergS, 1994“3-D vision and figure-ground separation by visual cortex”Perception & Psychophysics5548–120
94.
GrossbergSMingollaE, 1985“Neural dynamics of form perception: Boundary completion, illusory figures, and neon color spreading”Psychological Review92173–211
95.
GrossbergSMingollaE, 1987“The role of illusory contours in visual segmentation”, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 116–125
96.
GrossbergSTodorovicD, 1988“Neural dynamics of 1-D and 2-D brightness perception: A unified model of classic and recent phenomena”Perception & Psychophysics43241–277
97.
Von GrünauM, 1979“The involvement of illusory contours in stroboscopic motion”Perception & Psychophysics25205–208
98.
GurnseyRHumphreyG KKapitanP, 1992“Parallel discrimination of subjective contours defined by offset gratings”Perception & Psychophysics52263–276
99.
HalpernD F, 1981“The determinants of illusory-contour perception”Perception10199–213
100.
HalpernD F, 1987“The functional equivalence of objective and illusory brightness enhancement”, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 171–175
101.
HalpernD FSalzmanB, 1983“The multiple determination of illusory contours: 1. A reviewPerception12281–291
102.
HalpernD FSalzmanBHarrisonWWidamanK, 1983“The multiple determination of illusory contours: 2. An empirical investigation”Perception12293–303
103.
HarrisJ PGregoryR L, 1973“Fusion and rivalry of illusory contours”Perception2235–247
104.
HaterenJ HSrinivasanM VWaitP B, 1990“Pattern recognition in bees: orientation discrimination”Journal of Comparative Physiology167649–654
105.
HeinemannE G, 1955“Simultaneous brightness induction as a function of inducing and test-field luminances”Journal of Experimental Psychology5089–96
106.
HeinemannE G, 1972“Simultaneous brightness induction”, in Handbook of Sensory Physiology volume 7 Visual Psychophysics Ed. JamesonDHurvichL M (New York: Springer) pp 146–169
107.
HeitgerFvon der HeydtR, 1993“A computational model of neural contour processing: figure-ground segregation and illusory contours”Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Computer Vision pp 32–40
108.
HeitgerFRosenthalerLvon der HeydtRPeterhansEKüblerO, 1992“Simulation of neural contour mechanisms: From simple to end-stopped cells”Vision Research32963–981
109.
HeringE, 1878Zur Lehre vom Lichtsinn (Vienna: Gerolds Söhne)
von der HeydtRPeterhansE, 1989a“Mechanisms of contour perception in monkey visual cortex. I: Lines of pattern discontinuity”Journal of Neuroscience91731–1748
112.
von der HeydtRPeterhansE, 1989b“Ehrenstein and Zöllner illusions in a neuronal theory of contour processing”, in Seeing Contour and Colour Eds KulikowskiJ JDickinsonC MMurrayI J (Oxford: Pergamon Press) pp 729–734
113.
von der HeydtRPeterhansEBaumgartnerG, 1984“Illusory contours and cortical neuron responses”Science2241260–1262
114.
HorridgeG AZhangS-WO'CarrollD, 1992“Insect perception of illusory contours”Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Series B33759–64
115.
HubelD HWieselT N, 1962“Receptive fields, binocular interaction and functional architecture in the cat's visual cortex”Journal of Physiology (London)160106–154
116.
HubelD HWieselT N, 1968“Receptive fields and functional architecture of monkey striate cortex”Journal of Physiology (London)195215–243
117.
HubelD HWieselT N, 1977“Functional architecture of macaque monkey visual cortex”Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Series B1981–59
118.
JamesonDHurvichL M, 1966The Perception of Brightness and Darkness. Contemporary Topics in Experimental Psychology (Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon)
119.
JoryM K, 1987“Increment thresholds in illusory contour line patterns”, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 183–189
120.
JoryM KDayR H, 1979“The relationship between brightness contrast and illusory contours”Perception83–9
121.
JuleszB, 1971Foundations of Cyclopean Perception (Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press)
122.
JuleszBFrisbyJ P, 1975“Some new subjective contours in random-line stereograms”Perception4145–150
123.
JungR, 1961a“Neuronal integration in the visual cortex and its significance for visual information”, in Sensory Communication Ed. RosenblithW (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press) pp 627–674
124.
JungR, 1961b“Korrelationen von Neuronentätigkeit und Sehen”, in Neurophysiologie und Psychophysik des Visuellen Systems Eds JungRKornhuberH (Berlin: Springer) pp 410–435
125.
JungR, 1964“Neuronale Grundlagen des Hell-Dunkel-Sehens und der Farbwahrnehmung”Berichte der Deutschen Ophthalmologischen Gesellschaft6669–111
126.
JungR, 1973“Visual perception and neurophysiology”, in Handbook of Sensory Physiology volume 7/3, part A Central Visual Information Ed. JungR (Berlin: Springer) pp 1–152
127.
KanizsaG, 1955“Margini quasi-percettivi in campi con stimolazione omogenea”Rivista di Psicologia497–30 [“Quasiperceptual margins in homogeneously stimulated fields”; translation by W Gerbino, 1987, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 40–49]
128.
KanizsaG, 1974“Contours without gradients or cognitive contours?”Italian Journal of Psychology193–112
KellmanP JLoukidesM G, 1987“An objective perception approach to static and kinetic subjective contours”, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 151–164
134.
KellmanP JShipleyT F, 1991“A theory of visual interpolation in object perception”Cognitive Psychology23141–221
135.
KennedyJ M, 1975“Depth at an edge, coplanarity, slant depth, change in direction and change in brightness in the production of subjective contours”Italian Journal of Psychology2107–123
136.
KennedyJ M, 1976a“Attention, brightness, and the constructive eye”, in Vision and Artifact Ed. HenleM (New York: Springer) pp 33–48
137.
KennedyJ M, 1976b“Sun figure: An illusory diffuse contour resulting from an arrangement of dots”Perception5479–481
138.
KennedyJ M, 1978a“Illusory contours not due to completion”Perception7187–189
139.
KennedyJ M, 1978b“Illusory contours and the ends of lines”Perception7605–607
140.
KennedyJ M, 1979“Subjective contours, contrast and assimilation”, in Perception and Pictorial Representation Eds NodineCFisherD F (New York: Praeger) pp 167–195
141.
KennedyJ M, 1981“Illusory brightness and the ends of petals: change in brightness without aid of stratification or assimilation effects”Perception10583–585
142.
KennedyJ M, 1988“Line endings and subjective contours”Spatial Vision3151–158
143.
KennedyJ MChattawayD, 1975“Subjective contours, binocular and movement phenomena”Italian Journal of Psychology2355–367
144.
KennedyJ MLeeH, 1976“A figure-density hypothesis and illusory contour brightness”Perception5387–392
145.
KennedyJ MWareC, 1978“Illusory contours can arise in dot figures”Perception7191–194
146.
KingdomFMouldenB, 1992“A multi-channel approach to brightness coding”Vision Research321565–1582
147.
KoffkaK, 1935Principles of Gestalt Psychology (New York: Harcourt, Brace)
148.
KöhlerW, 1940Dynamics in Psychology (New York: Liveright)
149.
KulikowskiJ JKing-SmithP E, 1973“Spatial arrangement of line, edge and grating detectors revealed by subthreshold summation”Vision Research131455–1478
150.
LammeV A FVan DijkB WSpekreijseH, 1993“Contour from motion processing occurs in primary visual cortex”Nature (London)363541–543
151.
LandauerA A, 1978“Subjective states and the perception of subjective contours”, in Conceptual Analysis and Method in Psychology: Essays in Honor of W. M. O'Neil Ed. SutcliffeJ P (Sydney: Sydney University Press) pp 142–146
152.
LawsonR BCowanEGibbsT DWhitmoreC G, 1974“Stereoscopic enhancement and erasure of subjective contours”Journal of Experimental Psychology1031142–1146
153.
LawsonR BGulickW L, 1967“Stereopsis and anomalous contour”Vision Research7271–297
154.
LegrenziP, 1988“La psicologia gestaltista del pensiero nella cultura tedesca e in quella americana”, in L'eredità della Psicologia della Gestalt Eds KanizsaGCaramelliN (Bologna: Il Mulino) pp 53–71
155.
LesherG WMingollaE, 1993“The role of edges and line-ends in illusory contour formation”Vision Research332253–2270
156.
LivingstoneMHubelD, 1988“Segregation of form, color, movement, and depth: Anatomy, physiology and perception”Science240740–749
157.
MachE, 1865–1868“Über die Wirkung der räumlichen Verteilung des Lichtreizes auf der Netzhaut”Sitzungsberichte der Wiener Akademie der Wissenschaften, Mathematisch-naturwissenschaftliche Classe, Zweite Abteilung52303–322
158.
MarrD, 1976“Early processing of visual information”Philosophical Transaction of the Royal Society of London, Series B275483–519
159.
MarrD, 1982Vision. A Computational Investigation into the Human Representation and Processing of Visual Information (San Francisco, CA: W H Freeman)
160.
MasiniRPerussiaF, 1983“Margini anomali netti e margini anomali sfumati: Un'analisi multivariata”, in Reports from the Institute of Psychology (Milan: University of Milan) pp 1–21
161.
MatherG, 1988“Temporal properties of apparent motion in subjective figures”Perception17729–736
162.
MetzgerW, 1953Gesetze des Sehens2nd edition (Frankfurt: W Kramer)
163.
MeyerG E, 1986“Interactions of subjective contours with the Ponzo, Müller-Lyer, and vertical — horizontal illusions”Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society2439–40
164.
MeyerG EDoughertyT, 1987“Effects of flicker-induced depth on chromatic subjective contours”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance13353–360
165.
MeyerG EGargesC, 1979“Subjective contours and the Poggendorff illusion”Perception & Psychophysics26302–304
166.
MeyerG EPetryS, 1987“Top-down and bottom-up. The illusory contour as a microcosm of issues in perception”, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 3–20
167.
MinguzziG F, 1982“Figure anomale: le modificazioni di chiarezza indotte da fine di linea”, report from the Institute of Psychology, Trieste
168.
MinguzziG F, 1984“La percezione di superfici anomale”, in Fenomenologia Sperimentale della Visione Ed. KanizsaG (Milan: F Angeli) pp 97–118
169.
MoriG F, 1959“Is it possible to measure the contrast enhancement of a figure with ‘quasi-perceptive contours’?”Atti della Fondazione Giorgio Ronchi14137–139
170.
MoriG FRonchiL, 1960“On the perception of incomplete borders”Atti della Fondazione Giorgio Ronchi15357–368
171.
MustilloPFoxR, 1986“The perception of illusory contours in the hypercyclopean domain”Perception & Psychophysics40362–363
172.
NakayamaKShimojoS, 1990“Toward a neural understanding of visual surface representation”, in Cold Spring Harbor Symposium on Quantitative Biology volume 40 The Brain Eds SejnowskiTKandelE RStevensC FWatsonJ D (Cold Spring Harbor, NY: Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory) pp 911–924
173.
NakayamaKShimojoS, 1992“Experiencing and perceiving visual surfaces”Science2571357–1363
174.
NakayamaKHeZ JShimojoS, 1995“Visual surface representation: A critical link between lower-level and higher-level vision”, in An Invitation to Cognitive Science volume 2 Visual Cognition Eds KosslynS MOshersonD N (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press) pp 1–70
175.
NakayamaKShimojoSRamachandranV S, 1990“Transparency: relation to depth, subjective contours, luminance, and neon color spreading”Perception19497–513
176.
OhmuraH, 1981“Effects of subjective contours in stroboscopic motion”Japanese Journal of Psychology52233–239
ParksT E, 1979“Subjective figures: Does brightness enhancement depend on subjective boundary definition?”Perception & Psychophysics26419
179.
ParksT E, 1980a“The subjective brightness of illusory figures: Is stratification a factor?”Perception9361–363
180.
ParksT E, 1980b“Letter to the Editor”Perception9723
181.
ParksT E, 1982“Brightness effects in diffuse and sharp illusory figures of similar configuration”Perception11107–110
182.
ParksT E, 1986“Illusory figures, illusory objects, and real objects”Psychological Review93207–215
183.
ParksT E, 1987“Illusory figures and pictorial objects”, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 76–80
184.
ParksT E, 1989“Illusory figure-lightness: Evidence for a two-component theory”Perception18783–788
185.
ParksT EPendergrassL, 1982“On the filtered-components approach to illusory visual contours”Perception & Psychophysics32491–493
186.
ParksT ERockIAnsonR, 1983“Illusory contour lightness: a neglected possibility”Perception1243–47
187.
PastoreN, 1971Selective History of Theories of Visual Perception 1650–1950 (New York: Oxford University Press)
188.
PeterhansEvon der HeydtR, 1989“Mechanisms of contour perception in monkey visual cortex. II: Contours bridging gaps”Journal of Neuroscience91749–1763
189.
PeterhansEvon der HeydtR, 1991“Subjective contours—bridging the gap between psychophysics and physiology”Trends in Neuroscience14112–119
190.
PeterhansEvon der HeydtR, 1993“Functional organization of area V2 in the alert monkey”European Journal of Neuroscience5509–524
191.
PeterhansEvon der HeydtRBaumgartnerG, 1986“Neuronal responses to illusory contour stimuli reveal stages of visual cortical processing”, in Visual Neuroscience Eds PettigrewJ DSandersonK JLevickW R (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press) pp 343–351
192.
PetrySGannonR, 1987“Time, motion, and objectness in illusory contours”, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 193–200
193.
PetrySMeyerG E (Eds), 1987The Perception of Illusory Contours (New York: Springer)
194.
PetrySHarbeckAConwayJLeveyJ, 1983“Stimulus determinants of brightness and distinctness of subjective contours”Perception & Psychophysics34169–174
PrandtlA, 1927“Über gleichsinnige Induktion und die Lichtverteilung in gitterartigen Mustern”Zeitschrift für Sinnesphysiologie58263–307
197.
PrazdnyK, 1983“Illusory contours are not caused by simultaneous brightness contrast”Perception & Psychophysics34403–404
198.
PrazdnyK, 1985“On the nature of inducing forms generating perceptions of illusory contours”Perception & Psychophysics37237–242
199.
PritchardW S, 1986“Reductionism versus holism: levels of explanation and the subjective contour illusion”Perception & Psychophysics39214
200.
PritchardW SWarmJ S, 1983“Attentional processing and the subjective contour illusion”Journal of Experimental Psychology: General112145–175
201.
PurghéF, 1988“The role of figural incompleteness and brightness contrast in the formation of anomalous surfaces”Perception17365
202.
PurghéF, 1991“Is amodal completion necessary to the formation of illusory figures?”Perception20623–636
203.
PurghéFCorenS, 1992“Subjective contours 1900–1990: Research trends and bibliography”Perception & Psychophysics51291–304
204.
PurghéFKatsarasP, 1991“Figural conditions affecting the formation of anomalous surfaces: An overall configuration versus a simple stimulus part”Perception20193–206
205.
RamachandranV S, 1985“Apparent motion of subjective surfaces”Perception14127–134
206.
RamachandranV S, 1986“Capture of stereopsis and apparent motion by illusory contours”Perception & Psychophysics39361–373
207.
RamachandranV S, 1987“Visual perception of surfaces: A biological theory”, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 92–108
208.
RamachandranV S, 1992“Perception: A biological perspective”, in Neural Networks for Vision Image Processing Eds CarpenterG AGrossbergS (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press) pp 45–91
RamachandranV SInadaV, 1984“Motion capture in random-dot patterns”Optics News10(5) 77
211.
RediesC, 1989“Discontinuity along lines: Psychophysics and neurophysiology”Neuroscience & Biobehavioural Reviews1317–22
212.
RediesCCrookJ MCreutzfeldtO D, 1986“Neuronal responses to borders with and without luminance gradients in cat visual cortex and dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus”Experimental Brain Research61469–481
213.
RediesCSpillmannL, 1981“The neon color effect in the Ehrenstein illusion”Perception10667–681
214.
RediesCSpillmannLKunzK, 1984“Colored neon flanks and line gap enhancement”Vision Research241301–1309
215.
ReynoldsR I, 1981“Perception of an illusory contour as a function of processing time”Perception10107–115
216.
RichardsonB L, 1979“The nonequivalence of abrupt and diffuse illusory contours”Perception8589–593
217.
RichardsonB LWuilleminD B, 1981“Illusory contours not accompanied by a brightness gradient”Italian Journal of Psychology8201–207
218.
RiethCSireteanuR, 1993“How do infants perceive subjective contours?”poster at the 4th Meeting of the Child Vision Research Society, Lyon, 11–13 July, available from R Sireteanu
219.
RockI, 1987“A problem solving approach to illusory contours”, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 62–70
220.
RockIAnsonR, 1979“Illusory contours as the solution to a problem”Perception8665–681
221.
RonchiLMoriG F, 1959“On the factors which affect the contrast enhancement in a figure with ‘quasi-perceptive contours’ and a practical application of such a figure”Atti della Fondazione Giorgio Ronchi14495–508
SalzmanBHalpernD F, 1982“Subjective towers: depth relationships in multilevel subjective contours”Perceptual and Motor Skills551247–1256
224.
SambinM, 1975“The role of terminal tensions in the organization of margins without gradients”Italian Journal of Psychology2239–257
225.
SambinM, 1977“Contours without gradient with different phenomenal evidence”Italian Journal of Psychology4121–147
226.
SambinM, 1987“A dynamic model of anomalous figures”, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 131–142
227.
SchumannF, 1900“Einige Beobachtungen über die Zusammenfassung von Gesichtseindrücken zu Einheiten”Zeitschrift für Psychologie231–32 [reprinted 1904 Psychologische Studien 11–32; translation by A Hogg, 1987, “Some observations on the combination of visual impressions into units”, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 21–34]
228.
SekulerA BPalmerS E, 1992“Perception of partly occluded objects: A microgenetic analysis”Journal of Experimental Psychology, General12195–111
229.
ShapleyRGordonJ, 1985“Nonlinearity in the perception of form”Perception & Psychophysics3784–88
230.
ShapleyRGordonJ, 1987“The existence of interpolated illusory contours depends on contrast and spatial separation”, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 109–115
231.
ShipleyT, 1965“Visual contours in homogeneous space”Science150348–350
232.
ShipleyT FKellmanP J, 1990“The role of discontinuities in the perception of subjective figures”Perception & Psychophysics48259–270
233.
ShipleyT FKellmanP J, 1992a“Perception of partly occluded objects and illusory figures: Evidence for an identity hypothesis”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance18106–120
234.
ShipleyT FKellmanP J, 1992b“Strength of visual interpolation depends on the ratio of physically specified to total edge length”Perception & Psychophysics5297–106
235.
SiegelSPetryS, 1991“Evidence for independent processing of subjective contour brightness and sharpness”Perception20233–241
236.
SigmanERockI, 1974“Stroboscopic movement based on perceptual intelligence”Perception39–28
237.
SmithA TOverR, 1975“Tilt after-effects with subjective contours”Nature (London)257581–582
238.
SmithA TOverR, 1976“Color-selective tilt aftereffects with subjective contours”Perception & Psychophysics20305–308
239.
SmithA TOverR, 1977“Orientation masking and the tilt illusion with subjective contours”Perception6441–447
240.
SmithA TOverR, 1979“Motion aftereffect with subjective contours”Perception & Psychophysics2595–98
241.
SorianoMSpillmannLBachM (in press) “The abutting grating illusion”Vision Research
242.
SoubitezM C, 1982“Perceptual development of the Ehrenstein illusion”Perception1114
243.
SpillmannL, 1975“Perceptual modification of the Ehrenstein illusion”, in Gestalttheorie in der modernen Psychologie. Festschrift für Wolfgang Metzger Eds ErtlSKemmlerLStadlerM (Darmstadt: Steinkopf) pp 210–218
244.
SpillmannL, 1977“Contrast and brightness illusions”, in Spatial Contrast Eds SpekreijseHvan der TweelL H (Amsterdam: North-Holland) pp 45–49
245.
SpillmannL, 1994“The Hermann grid illusion: A tool for studying human perceptive field organization”Perception23691–708
246.
SpillmannLFuldKGerritsH J M, 1976“Brightness contrast in the Ehrenstein illusion”Vision Research16713–719
247.
SpillmannLFuldKNeumeyerC, 1984“Brightness matching, brightness cancellation, and increment threshold in the Ehrenstein illusion”Perception13513–520
StadlerMDiekerJ, 1969“Margini quasi-percettivi e after-effects figurali”Rivista di Psicologia6395–104
250.
StadlerMDiekerJ, 1972“Untersuchungen zum Problem virtueller Konturen in der visuellen Wahrnehmung”Zeitschrift für Experimentelle und Angewandte Psychologie19325–350
251.
Van TuijlH F J M, 1975“A new visual illusion: Neonlike color spreading and complementary color induction between subjective contours”Acta Psychologica39441–445
252.
Van TuijlH F J Mde WeertC M M, 1979“Sensory conditions for the occurrence of the neon spreading illusion”Perception8211–215
253.
TylerC W1977“Is the illusory triangle physical or imaginary?”Perception6603–604
254.
TynanPSekulerR, 1975“Moving visual phantoms: A new contour completion effect”Science188951–952
255.
UllmanS, 1976“Filling-in the gaps: the shape of subjective contours and a model for their generation”Biological Cybernetics251–6
256.
UllmanS, 1984“Visual routines”Cognition1897–159
257.
VallortigaraG, 1987“The hidden face of the Kanizsa triangle: Apparent movement of subjective figures in three-dimensional space”Perception16449–452
258.
VarinD, 1971“Fenomeni di contrasto e diffusione cromatica nell'organizzazione spaziale del campo percettivo”Rivista di Psicologia65101–128
259.
VogelsROrbanG A, 1987“Illusory contour orientation discrimination”Vision Research27453–467
260.
WallachHSlaughterV, 1988“The role of memory in perceiving subjective contours”Perception & Psychophysics43101–106
261.
WareC, 1980“Coloured illusory triangles due to assimilation”Perception9103–107
262.
WareC, 1981“Subjective contours independent of subjective brightness”Perception & Psychophysics29500–504
263.
WareCKennedyJ M, 1977“Illusory line linking solid rods”Perception6601–602
264.
WareCKennedyJ M, 1978“Perception of subjective lines, surfaces and volumes in 3-dimensional constructions”Leonardo11111–114
265.
WatanabeTCavanaghP, 1991“Texture and motion spreading, the aperture problem, and transparency”Perception & Psychophysics50459–464
266.
WatanabeTCavanaghP, 1993“Surface decomposition accompanying the perception of transparency”Spatial Vision795–111
267.
WatanabeTOyamaT, 1988“Are illusory contours a cause or a consequence of apparent differences in brightness and depth in the Kanizsa square?”Perception17513–521
268.
de WeerdPVandenbusscheEde BruynBOrbanG A, 1990“Illusory contour orientation discrimination in the cat”Behavioural Brain Research391–17
269.
de WeertC M MVan KruysbergenN A W H, 1987“Subjective contour strength and perceptual superimposition: Transparency as a special case”, in The Perception of Illusory Contours Eds PetrySMeyerG E (New York: Springer) pp 165–170
270.
WeissteinNMaguireW, 1978“Computing the next step: Psychophysical measures of representation and interaction”, in Computer Vision Systems Eds HansonA RRisemanE M (New York: Academic Press) pp 243–260
