The perceptual-cognitive information used to support pattern-recognition skill in soccer was examined. In experiment 1, skilled players were quicker and more accurate than less-skilled players at recognising familiar and unfamiliar soccer action sequences presented on film. In experiment 2, these action sequences were converted into point-light displays, with superficial display features removed and the positions of players and the relational information between them made more salient. Skilled players were more accurate than less-skilled players in recognising sequences presented in point-light form, implying that each pattern of play can be defined by the unique relations between players. In experiment 3, various offensive and defensive players were occluded for the duration of each trial in an attempt to identify the most important sources of information underpinning successful performance. A decrease in response accuracy was observed under occluded compared with non-occluded conditions and the expertise effect was no longer observed. The relational information between certain key players, team-mates and their defensive counterparts may provide the essential information for effective pattern-recognition skill in soccer. Structural feature analysis, temporal phase relations, and knowledge-based information are effectively integrated to facilitate pattern recognition in dynamic sport tasks.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbernethyB, 1988“The effects of age and expertise upon perceptual skill development in a racquet sport”Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport59210–221
2.
AbernethyB, 1990“Expertise, visual search, and information pick-up in squash”Perception1963–77
3.
AbernethyB, 1993“Searching for the minimal essential information for skilled perception and action”Psychological Research55131–138
4.
AbernethyBGillDParksS LPackerS T, 2001“Expertise and the perception of kinematic and situational probability information”Perception30233–252
5.
AllardFGrahamSPaarsaluM L, 1980“Perception in sport: basketball”Journal of Sport Psychology214–21
6.
BarclayC DCuttingJ EKozlowskiL T, 1998“Temporal and spatial factors in gait perception that influence gender recognition”Nature259557–558
7.
BeekP JJacobsDDaffertshoferAHuysR, 2003“Views on expert performance in sport from the joint perspectives of ecological psychology and dynamical systems theory”, in Expert Performance in Sports: Advances in Research on Sport Expertise Eds StarkesJ LEricssonK A (Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics) pp 321–344
8.
BrownlowSDixonA REgbertC ARadcliffeR D, 1997“Perception of movement and dancer characteristics from point-light displays of dance”Psychological Record47411–421
9.
ChappellMHumphreysM S, 1994“An auto associative neural network for sparse representations: analysis and application to models of recognition and cued recall”Psychological Review101103–128
10.
CharnessN, 1976“Memory for chess positions: Resistance to interference”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory2641–653
11.
CharnessN, 1979“Components of skill in bridge”Canadian Journal of Psychology331–16
12.
CuttingJ EProffittD R, 1982“The minimum principle and the perception of absolute, common, and relative motions”Cognitive Psychology14211–246
13.
DidierjeanAMarmècheE, 2005“Anticipatory representation of visual basketball scenes by novice and expert players”Visual Cognition12265–283
14.
DittrichW H, 1993“Action categories and the perception of biological motion”Perception2215–22
15.
DittrichW H, 1999“Seeing biological motion: Is there a role for cognitive strategies?”, in Gesture-Based Communication in Human-Computer Interaction Eds BraffortAGherbiRGibetSRichardsonJTeilD (Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer) pp 3–22
16.
DittrichW HLeaS E, 1994“Visual perception of intentional motion”Perception23253–268
17.
EricssonK ADelaneyP F, 1999“Long-term working memory as an alternative to capacity models of working memory in everyday skilled performance”, in Models of Working Memory: Mechanisms of Active Maintenance and Executive Control Eds MiyakeAShahP (New York: Cambridge University Press) pp 257–297
18.
EricssonK AKintschW, 1995“Long-term working memory”Psychological Review102211–245
19.
GarlandD JBarryJ R, 1991“Cognitive advantage in sport: The nature of perceptual structures”American Journal of Psychology104211–228
20.
GentnerDMarkmanA B, 1998“Structure mapping in analogy and similarity”, in Mind Readings Ed. ThagardP (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press) pp 127–156
21.
GobetFSimonH A, 1998“Templates in chess memory: A mechanism for recalling several boards”Cognitive Psychology311–40
22.
GobetS E, 1998“Expert memory: A comparison of four theories”Cognition66115–152
23.
GobetS ESimonH A, 1998“Recall of rapidly presented random chess positions is a function of skill”Psychonomic Bulletin and Review3159–163
24.
HarrisL RJenkinM (Eds), 1998Vision and Action (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
25.
HendersonJ M, 2003“Human gaze control during real-world scene perception”Trends in Cognitive Sciences7498–505
26.
HolyoakK JKohK, 1987“Surface and structural similarity in analogical transfer”Memory and Cognition15332–340
27.
HuysRDaffertshoferABeekP J, 2004“The evolution of coordination during skill acquisition: the dynamical systems approach”, in Skill Acquisition in Sport: Research, Theory and Practice Eds WilliamsA MHodgesN J (London: Routledge) pp 351–373
28.
JohanssonG, 1973“Visual perception of biological motion and a model for its analysis”Perception & Psychophysics14201–211
MareyE J, 1895/1972Movement (New York: Arno Press/New York Times) [originally published in 1895]
31.
MatherGMurdochL, 1994“Gender discrimination in biological motion displays based on dynamic cues”Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B258273–279
32.
NovickL RShermanS J, 2003“On the nature of insight solutions: Evidence from skill-based differences in anagram solution”Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology A56351–382
33.
PetersonM ARhodesG (Eds), 2003Perception of Faces, Objects, and Scenes: Analytic and Holistic (Oxford: Oxford University Press)
34.
ProffittD RGildenD L, 1989“Understanding natural dynamics”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance15384–393
35.
RunesonSFrykholmG, 1981“Visual perception of lifted weight”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance4733–740
36.
ShimJCarltonL G, 1999“Anticipation of movement outcome through perception of movement kinematics”Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology21S98
37.
ShimJCarltonL GKimJ, 2004“Estimation of lifted weight and produced effort through perception of point-light display”Perception33277–291
38.
SmeetonNWardPWilliamsA M, 2004“Transfer of perceptual skill in sport”Journal of Sports Sciences19(2) 3–9
39.
WardPWilliamsA M, 2003“Perceptual and cognitive skill development in soccer: the multidimensional nature of expert performance”Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology25(1) 93–111
40.
WardPWilliamsA MBennettS J, 2002“Visual search and biological motion perception in tennis”Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport73107–112
41.
WardPWilliamsA MHancockP, in press, “Simulation for performance and training”, in Handbook of Expertise and Expert Performance Eds EricssonAHoffmanPCharnessNFeltovichP (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
42.
WilliamsA MDavidsK, 1995“Declarative knowledge in sport: a byproduct of experience or a characteristic of expertise”Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology7259–275
43.
WilliamsA MDavidsK, 1998“Visual search strategy, selective attention, and expertise in soccer”Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport69111–128
44.
WilliamsA MDavidsKBurwitzLWilliamsJ G, 1993“Cognitive knowledge and soccer performance”Perceptual and Motor Skills76579–593
45.
WilliamsA MDavidsKBurwitzLWilliamsJ G, 1994“Visual search strategies of experienced and inexperienced soccer players”Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport65127–135
46.
WilliamsA MDavidsKWilliamsJ G, 1999Visual Perception and Action in Sport (London: E&FN Spon)
47.
WilliamsA MWardPKnowlesJ MSmeetonN J, 2002“Perceptual skill in a real-world task: Training, instruction, and transfer in tennis”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied8259–270
48.
WilliamsA MWardPSmeetonN J, 2004“Perceptual and cognitive expertise in sport: implications for skill acquisition and performance enhancement”, in Skill Acquisition in Sport: Research, Theory and Practice Eds WilliamsA MHodgesN J (London: Routledge) pp 328–348
