Do we use the same neurocognitive mechanisms to spell that we do to read? There is a considerable number of conflicting findings, such that evidence has been provided to support common mechanisms for reading and spelling, while other research supports the proposal that reading and spelling utilise unique neurocognitive resources. Sensitivity to visual spatial-frequency doubling (FD) has been demonstrated to correlate with and specifically predict orthographic processing when reading; therefore, if spelling and reading share some elements of orthographic representation, sensitivity to FD should similarly correlate with, and predict, spelling ability by virtue of this shared association. A double dissociation between reading and spelling was found such that sensitivity to the FD task, as mediated by the visual dorsal stream, predicted reading ability but not spelling, while the visual control task predicted spelling but not reading ability, in poor readers/spellers. The results support a dual-orthographic model with separate orthographic representations for reading and spelling.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AmitaySBen-YehudahGBanaiKAhissarM, 2002“Disabled readers suffer from visual and auditory impairments but not from a specific magnocellular deficit”Brain1252272–2285
2.
AnsBCarbonnelSValdoisS, 1998“A connectionist multiple-trace memory model for polysyllabic word reading”Psychological Review105678–723
3.
BedfordSMaddessTRoseKJamesA, 1997“Correlations between observability of the spatial frequency doubling illusion and a multi-region electroretinogram”Australian and New Zealand Journal of Ophthalmology25S91–S93
4.
BehrmannMBubD, 1992“Surface dyslexia and dysgraphia: Dual routes, single lexicon”Cognitive Neuropsychology9209–251
5.
BenardeteE AKaplanEKnightB W, 1992“Contrast gain control in the primate retina: P cells are not X-like, some M cells are”Visual Neuroscience8483–486
6.
BosseM-LTainturierMValdoisS, 2007“Developmental dyslexia: the visual attention span hypothesis”Cognition104198–230
7.
BrunsdonRColtheartMNickelsL, 2005“Treatment of irregular word spelling in developmental surface dysgraphia”Cognitive Neuropsychology22213–251
8.
BruckMWatersG, 1988“An analysis of the spelling errors of children who differ in their reading and spelling skills”Applied Psycholinguistics977–92
9.
BruckMWatersG, 1990“Effects of reading skill on component spelling skills”Applied Psycholinguistics11425–437
10.
BuchholzJMcKoneE, 2004“Adults with dyslexia show deficits on spatial frequency doubling and visual attention tasks”Dyslexia1024–43
11.
BurtJFuryM, 2000“Spelling in adults: The role of reading skills and experience”Reading and Writing: An Interdisciplinary Journal131–30
12.
BurtJTateH, 2002“Does reading lexicon provide orthographic lexicon for spelling?”Journal of Memory and Language46518–543
13.
CallanACallanDMasakiS, 2005“When meaningless symbols become letters: Neural activity change in learning new phonograms”NeuroImage28553–562
14.
CampbellR, 1987“One or two lexicons for reading and writing words: Can misspellings shed any light?”Cognitive Neuropsychology4487–499
15.
CaramazzaA, 1988“Some aspects of language processing revealed through the analysis of acquired dysgraphia: the lexical system”Annual Review of Neuroscience11395–421
16.
CastlesAColtheartM, 1993“Varieties of developmental dyslexia”Cognition47149–180
17.
CastlesAHolmesV M, 1996“Subtypes of developmental dyslexia and lexical acquisition”The Australian Journal of Psychology48130–135
18.
ChaseCJennerA, 1993“Magnocellular processing deficits affect temporal processing of dyslexics”Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences682326–329
19.
CohenLDehaeneSNaccacheLLehéricySDehaene-LambertzGHenaffMMichelF, 2000“The visual word form area–Spatial and temporal characterization of an initial stage of reading in normal subjects and posterior split-brain patients”Brain123291–307
20.
CohenLHenryCDehaeneSMartinaudOLehéricySLemerCFerreuxS, 2004a“The patho-physiology of letter-by-letter reading”Neuropsychologia421768–1780
21.
CohenLJobertALe BihanDDehaeneS, 2004b“Distinct unimodal and multimodal regions for word processing in the left temporal cortex”NeuroImage231256–1270
22.
CohenLLehéricySChochonFLemerCRivaudSDehaeneS, 2002“Language-specific tuning of visual cortex functional properties of the visual word form area”Brain1251054–1069
23.
CohenLMartinaudOLehéricySSamsonYObadiaMSlachevskyADehaeneS, 2003“Visual word recognition in the left and right hemispheres: anatomical and functional correlates of peripheral alexias”Cerebral Cortex131313–1333
24.
ColtheartMFunnellE, 1987“Reading and writing: One lexicon or two”, in Language Perception and Production chapter 15, Eds AllportAMackayDPrinzWScheererE (London: Academic Press) pp 313–449
25.
ColtheartMLeahyJ, 1996“Assessment of lexical and non-lexical reading abilities in children: Some normative data.”Australian Journal of Psychology48136–140
26.
CornelissenP LHansenP CGilchristICormackFEssexJFrankishC, 1998a“Coherent motion detection and letter position encoding”Vision Research382181–2191
27.
CornelissenP LHansenP CHuttonJ LEvangelinouVSteinJ F, 1998b“Magnocellular visual function and children's single word reading”Vision Research38471–482
28.
CornelissenP LRichardsonAMasonAFowlerSSteinJ, 1995“Contrast sensitivity and coherent motion detection measured at photopic luminance levels in dyslexics and controls”Vision Research351483–1494
29.
CornelissenP LTarkiainenAHeleniusPSalmelinR, 2003“Cortical effects of shifting letter position in letter strings of varying length”Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience15731–746
30.
DéjerineJ, 1891“Sur un cas de cécité verbale avec agraphie, suivi d'autopsie”Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances et Mémoires de la Société de Biologie, IX Series197–201
31.
ErdemSKansuT, 1995“Alexia without either agraphia or hemianopia in temporal lobe lesions due to herpes-simplex encephalitis”Journal of Neuro-ophthalmology15102–104
32.
EverattJBradshawM FHibbardP B, 1999“Visual processing and dyslexia”Perception28243–254
33.
FriedmanRAlbertM, 1985, “Alexia”, in Clinical Neuropsychology Eds HeilmannK MValensteinE (Oxford: Oxford University Press) pp 49–73
34.
FrithU, 1980“Unexpected spelling problems”, in Cognitive Processes in Spelling chapter 22, Ed. FrithU (New York: Academic Press) pp 495–517
35.
FunnellE, 1992“On recognising misspelled words”, in Psychology, Spelling and Education Eds SterlingC MRobsonC (Bristol: Multilingual Matters) pp 87–99
36.
GreenblattS, 1973“Alexia without agraphia or hemianopia”Brain96307–316
37.
GreenblattS, 1990“Left occipital lobectomy and the preangular anatomy of reading”Brain and Language38576–595
38.
HagiliassisNPrattCJohnstonM, 2006“Orthographic and phonological processes in reading”Reading and Writing19235–263
39.
HallisA E, 1993“The role of models of language processing in rehabilitation of language impairments”Aphasiology75–26
40.
HansenP CSteinJ FOrdeS RWinterJ LTalcottJ B, 2001“Are dyslexics' visual deficits limited to measures of dorsal stream function?”Cognitive Neuroscience and Neuropsychology121527–1530
41.
HendersonVFriedmanRTengEWeinerJ, 1985“Left hemisphere pathways in reading: Inferences from pure alexia without hemianopia”Neurology35962–968
42.
HillisA E, 2001“The organization of the lexical system”, in The Handbook of Cognitive Neuropsychology: What Deficits Reveal about the Human Mind chapter 8, Ed. RappB (New York: Taylor and Francis) pp 185–210
43.
HillisAChangSBreeseEHeidlerJ, 2004“The crucial role of posterior frontal regions in modality specific components of the spelling process”NeuroCase10175–187
44.
HillisARappBCaramazzaA, 1999“When a rose is a rose in speaking, but a tulip in writing” Cortex35337–356
45.
HillisAWitykRBarkerPCaramazzaA, 2003“Neural regions essential for writing verbs”Nature Neuroscience619–20
46.
HodgsonJJohnsonG, 1993“Visual word recognition in developmental dysgraphia: One lexicon or two”Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences682354–356
47.
HolmesVCarruthersJ, 1998“The relation between reading and spelling in skilled adult readers”Journal of Memory and Language39264–289
48.
HolmesVDavisC, 2002“Orthographic representation and spelling knowledge”Language and Cognitive Processes17345–370
49.
HolmesVNgE, 1993“Word-specific knowledge, word-recognition strategies, and spelling ability”Journal of Memory and Language32230–257
50.
HulslanderJTalcottJ BWittonCDeFriesJPenningtonB FWadsworthSWillcutEOlsonR, 2004“Sensory processing, reading, IQ, and attention”Journal of Experimental Child Psychology88274–295
51.
IlesJWalshVRichardsonA, 2000“Visual search performance in dyslexia”Dyslexia6163–177
52.
JormASchoknechtC, 1981“Role of visual word-recognition checks in children's spelling”Australian Journal of Psychology33393–403
53.
JoshiR MAaronG, 1991“Developmental reading and spelling disabilities are these dissociable”, in Written Language Disorder Ed. JoskiR (Boston, London: Kluwer) pp 1–24
54.
KellyD H, 1966“Frequency doubling in visual responses”Journal of the Optical Society of America561628–1633
55.
KevanAPammerK, 2008a“Making the link between dorsal stream sensitivity and reading”NeuroReport19467–470
56.
KevanAPammerK, 2008b“Visual processing deficits in pre-readers at familial risk for dyslexia”Vision Research482835–2839
57.
McDougallSHulmeCEllisAMonkA, 1994“Learning to read: The role of short-term memory and phonological skills”Journal of Experimental Child Psychology58112–133
58.
MaddessTGoldbergIDobinsonJWineSWelshA HJamesA C, 1999“Testing for glaucoma with the spatial frequency doubling illusion”Vision Research394258–4273
59.
MaddessTHenryG H, 1992“Performance of nonlinear visual units in ocular hypertension and glaucoma”Clinical Vision Sciences7371–383
60.
MaddessTJamesA CGoldbergIWineSDobinsonJ, 2000“A spatial frequency-doubling illusion-based pattern electroretinogram for glaucoma”Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science413818–3826
61.
ManisFSeidenbergMDoiLMcBride-ChangCPetersenA, 1996“On the bases of two subtypes of developmental dyslexia”Cognition58157–195
62.
MartinFLovegroveW, 1984“The effects of filed size and luminance control on contrast sensitivity differences between specifically reading disabled and normal children”Neuropsychologia2273–77
63.
MonsellS, 1987“On the relation between lexical input and output pathways for speech”, in Language Perception and Production chapter 14, Eds AllportAMackayDPrinzWScheererE (London: Academic Press) pp 273–311
64.
MycroftRHanleyJKayJ, 2002“Preserved access to abstract letter identities despite abolished letter naming in a case of pure alexia”Journal of Neurolinguistics1599–108
65.
NationKNorburyC, 2005“Why reading comprehension fails–Insights from developmental disorders”Topics in Language Disorders2521–32
66.
NealeM D, 1999Neale Analysis of Reading Ability3rd edition (Melbourne: Australian Council for Educational Research)
67.
PammerKHansenPHollidayICornelissenP, 2006“Attentional shifting and the role of the dorsal pathway in visual word recognition”Neuropsychologia442926–2936
68.
PammerKHansenPKringlebachMHollidayIBarnesGHillebrandASinghKCornelissenP, 2004a“Visual word recognition: the first half second”NeuroImage221819–1825
69.
PammerKKevanA, 2007“The contribution of visual sensitivity, phonological processing, and nonverbal IQ to children's reading”Scientific Studies of Reading1133–53
70.
PammerKLavisRCornelissenP, 2004b“Visual encoding mechanisms and their relationship to text presentation preference”Dyslexia1077–94
71.
PammerKVidyasagarT R, 2005“Integration of the visual and auditory networks in dyslexia: a theoretical perspective”Journal of Research in Reading28320–331
72.
PammerKWheatleyC, 2001“Isolating the M(y)-cell response in dyslexia using the spatial frequency doubling illusion”Vision Research412139–2147
73.
PatchingGJordanT, 2005“Assessing the role of different spatial frequencies in word perception for good and poor readers”Memory and Cognition33961–971
74.
PattersonKKayJ, 1982“Letter-by-letter reading: Psychological descriptions of a neurological syndrome”Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology34411–441
75.
PhillipsW AGoodallW C, 1995“Lexical writing can be non-semantic and it can be fluent without practice”Cognitive Neuropsychology12149–172
76.
RapcsakSBeesonP, 2002“Neuroanatomical correlates of spelling and writing”, in Handbook of Adult Language Disorders: Integrating Cognitive Psychology, Neurology and Rehabilitation Ed. HillisA (Philadelphia, PA: Philadelphia University Press) pp 71–99
77.
RapcsakSBeesonP, 2004“The role of left posterior inferior temporal cortex in spelling”Neurology622221–2229
78.
RappB, 2005“The relationship between treatment outcomes and the underlying cognitive deficit: Evidence from the remediation of acquired dysgraphia”Aphasiology19994–1008
79.
RaymondJ ESorensenR E, 1998“Visual motion perception in children with dyslexia: Normal detection but abnormal integration”Visual Cognition5389–404
80.
RoeltgenDHeilmanK, 1985“Review of agraphia and a proposal for an anatomically-based neuropsychological model of writing”Applied Psycholinguistics6205–230
81.
RosazzaCAppollonioIIsellaVShalliceT, 2007“Quantitatively different forms of pure alexia”Cognitive Neuropsychology24393–418
82.
SakuraiYTakeuchiSTakadaTHoriuchiENakaseHSakutaM, 2000“Alexia caused by a fusiform or posterior inferior temporal lesion”Journal of Neurological Sciences17842–51
83.
SchmalzlLNickelsL, 2006“Treatment of irregular word spelling in acquired dysgraphia: Selective benefit from visual mnemonics”Neuropsychological Rehabilitation161–37
84.
SlaghuisW LRyanJ F, 1999“Spatio-temporal contrast sensitivity, coherent motion, and visible persistence in developmental dyslexia”Vision Research39651–668
85.
SteinJ, 2001“The magnocellular theory of dyslexia”Dyslexia712–36
86.
StuartG WMcAnallyK ICastlesA, 2001“Can contrast sensitivity functions in dyslexia be explained by inattention rather than a magnocellular deficit?”Vision Research413205–3211
87.
TainturierM-JRappB, 2003“Is a single graphemic buffer used in reading and spelling”Aphasiology17537–562
88.
TalcottJHansenPAssokuESteinJ, 2000a“Visual motion sensitivity in dyslexia: evidence for temporal and energy integration deficits”Neuropsychologia38935–943
89.
TalcottJWittonCMcLeanMHansenP CReesAGreenG RSteinJ F, 2000b“Dynamic sensory sensitivity and children's word decoding skills”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA972952–2957
90.
TalcottJ BWittonCHebbG SStoodleyC JWestwoodE AFranceS JHansenP CSteinJ F, 2002“On the relationship between dynamic visual and auditory processing and literacy skills; results from a large primary-school study”Dyslexia8204–225
91.
TalcottJGramAvan IngelhemMWittonCSteinJToennessenF, 2003“Impaired sensitivity to dynamic stimuli in poor readers of a regular orthography”Brain and Language87259–266
92.
TamhankarMCoslettHFisherMSuttonLLiuG, 2004“Alexia without agraphia following biopsy of a left thalamic tumor”Pediatric Neurology30140–142
93.
TraillL, 1998aSpelling Skills 4 (Melbourne: Oxford University Press)
94.
TraillL, 1998bSpelling Skills 5 (Melbourne: Oxford University Press)
95.
TraillL, 1998cSpelling Skills 6 (Melbourne: Oxford University Press)
96.
TylerC W, 1974“Observations on spatial-frequency doubling”Perception381–86
97.
TyrrellROwensA, 1988“A rapid technique to assess the resting states of the eyes and other threshold phenomena: The Modified Binary Search (MOBS)”Behavior Research Methods, Instruments, & Computers20137–141
98.
UngerleiderL GMishkinM, 1982“Two cortical visual systems”, in The Analysis of Visual Behavior Eds IngleD JMansfieldR J WGoodaleM S (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press) pp 54–86
99.
VidyasagarT R, 2001a“From attentional gating in macaque primary visual cortex to dyslexia in humans”Progress & Brain Research134298–312
100.
VidyasagarT R, 2001b“Neural underpinnings of dyslexia as a disorder of visuo-spatial attention”Clinical and Experimental Optometry874–10
101.
VidyasagarT RPammerK, 1999“Impaired visual search in dyslexia relates to the role of the magnocellular pathway in attention”NeuroReport101283–1287
102.
WeekesBColtheartM, 1996“Surface dyslexia and surface dysgraphia: Treatment studies and their theoretical implications”Cognitive Neuropsychology13277–315
103.
WilsonM D, 1988“The MRC psycholinguistic database: Machine readable dictionary, Version 2”Behavior Research Methods, Instruments, & Computers206–11
104.
WittonCTalcottJ BHansenP CRichardsonA JGriffithsT DReesASteinJ FGreenJ R, 1998“Sensitivity to dynamic auditory and visual stimuli predicts nonword reading ability in both dyslexia and normal readers”Current Biology8791–797
105.
WoodcockRMcGrewKMatherN, 2001Woodcock–Johnson III. Tests of Cognitive Ability (Itasca, IL: Riverside Publishing)
