We investigated cortical activity in response to abstract and representational paintings in artists and non-artists. Participants engaged in visual inspection of works of art and recalled them immediately afterwards through mental imagery. Meanwhile, we recorded their EEG, and calculated the power of their alpha band and theta band activity afterwards. In accordance with previous studies, theta band and alpha band power differed between artists and non-artists; these differences were found to depend, however, on the abstract or representational character of the paintings. Differences between abstract and representational art, and between inspection and imagery, occurred in alpha band power for non-artists only and in theta band power for artists. These results were taken to suggest that effects in artists reflect sustained focused attention and perceptual flexibility; in non-artists motivation and engagement with the task. The results were essentially whole-head, despite the local character of the measurement.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlexanderD MTrengoveCWrightJ JBoordP RGordonE, 2006“Measurement of phase gradients in the EEG”Journal of Neuroscience Methods156111–128
2.
ArnheimR, 1954Art and Visual Perception (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press)
3.
AsadaHFukudaYTsunodaSYamaguchiMTonoikeM, 1999“Frontal midline theta rhythms reflect alternative activation of prefrontal cortex and anterior cingulated cortex in human”Neuroscience Letters27429–32
4.
BerlyneD E, 1970“Novelty, complexity, and hedonic value”Perception & Psychophysics8279–286
5.
BerlyneD E, 1971Aesthetics and Psychobiology (New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts)
6.
BerlyneD E, 1974Studies in the New Experimental Aesthetics (New York: John Wiley)
7.
BhattacharyaJ, 2009“Increase of universality in human brain during mental imagery from visual perception”PLoS One41–11
8.
BhattacharyaJPetscheH, 2002“Shadows of artistry: Cortical synchrony during perception and imagery of visual art”Cognitive Brain Research13179–186
9.
BungeS AHazeltineEScanlonM DRosenA CGabrielJ D E, 2002“Dissociable contributions of prefrontal and parietal cortices to response selection”NeuroImage171562–1571
10.
Cela-CondeC JMartyGMaestúFOrtizTMunarEFernándezARocaMRossellóJQuesneyF, 2004“Activation of the prefrontal cortex in the human visual aesthetic perception”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA1016321–6325
11.
CupchikG CShereckLSpiegelS, 1994“The effects of textual information on artistic communication”Visual Arts Research2062–78
12.
Del CulABailletSDehaeneS, 2007“Brain dynamics underlying the nonlinear threshold for access to consciousness”PLoS Biology5e260
13.
DijkDHayesBCzeislerC, 1993“Dynamics of electroencephalographic sleep spindles and slow wave activity in men: Effect of sleep deprivation”Brain Research626190–199
14.
FairhallSIshaiA, 2008“Neural correlates of object indeterminacy in art composition”Consciousness and Cognition17923–932
15.
FechnerG T, 1876Preschool of Aesthetics (Leipzig: Breitkopf & Hartel)
FokinV AShelepinY EKharauzovA KTrufanovG ESevost'yanovA VProninS V, 2008“Location of human cortical areas activated on perception of ordered and chaotic images”Neuroscience and Behavioral Physiology38677–685
18.
FrithC DNiasD K B, 1974“What determines aesthetic preferences?”Journal of General Psychology91163–173
19.
GevinsA, 1998“The future of electroencephalography in assessing neurocognitive functioning”Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology106165–172
20.
GoodaleM AMilnerA D, 1992“Separate visual pathways for perception and action”Trends in Neurosciences1520–25
21.
GortaisB, 2003“Abstraction and art”Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series B: Biological Sciences3581241–1249
22.
Grill-SpectorKKushnirTHendlerTEdelmanSItzchakYMalachR, 1998“A sequence of object-processing stages revealed by fMRI in the human occipital lobe”Human Brain Mapping6316–328
23.
GrillonCBuchsbaumM S, 1986“Computer EEG topography of response to visual and auditory stimuli”Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology6342–53
24.
GrossJSchmitzFSchnitzlerIKesslerKShapiroKHommelBSchnitzlerA, 2004“Modulation of long-range neural synchrony reflects temporal limitations of visual attention in humans”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA10113050–13055
25.
HekkertPvan WieringenP C M, 1990“Complexity and prototypicality as determinants of the appraisal of cubist paintings”British Journal of Psychology81483–495
JasperH H, 1958“Report of the committee on methods of clinical examination in electroencephalography”Encephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology10371–375
28.
KlimeschW, 1996“Memory processes, brain oscillations and EEG synchronization”International Journal of Psychophysiology2461–100
29.
KlimeschWDoppelmayrMSchwaigerJAuingerPWinklerT, 1999“Paradoxical alpha synchronization in a memory task”Cognitive Brain Research7493–501
30.
KlimeschWSausengPHanslmayrS, 2007“EEG alpha oscillations: The inhibition timing hypothesis”Brain Research Review5363–68
31.
KubotaYSatoWToichiMMuraiTOkadaTHayashiASengokuA, 2001“Frontal midline theta rhythm is correlated with cardiac autonomic activities during the performance of an attention demanding meditation procedure”Cognitive Brain Research11281–287
32.
LaneR DReimanE MBradleyM MLangP JAhernG LDavidsonR JSchwartzG E, 1997“Neuroanatomical correlations of pleasant and unpleasant emotion”Neuropsychologia351437 – 1444
33.
LederH, 2001“Determinants of preference. When do we like what we know?”Empirical Studies of the Arts19201–211
34.
LederH, 2002Explorationen in der Bildästhetik [Explorations in visual aesthetics] (Lengerich: Pabst)
35.
LederHBelkeBOeberstAAugustinD, 2004“A model of aesthetic appreciation and aesthetic judgments”British Journal of Psychology95489–508
36.
LederHCarbonC CRipsasA, 2006“Entitling art: Influence of different types of title information on understanding and appreciation of paintings”Acta Psychologica121176–198
37.
van LeeuwenCVerstijnenI MHekkertP, 1999“Common unconscious dynamics underlie uncommon conscious effect: A case study of the iterative nature of perception and creation”, in Modeling Consciousness across the Disciplines Ed. JordanJ S, (Lanham, MD: University Press of America) pp 179–218
38.
LenggerPFischmeisterFLederHBauerH, 2007“Functional neuroanatomy of the perception of modern art”Brain Research115893–102
39.
LiYUmenoKHoriETakakuraHUrakawaSOnoTNishijoH, 2009“Global synchronization in the theta band during mental imagery of navigation in humans”Neuroscience Research6544–52
40.
LocherP J, 2003“An empirical investigation of the Visual Rightness Theory of picture perception”Acta Psychologica114147–164
41.
LuberBHabeckCTrottCFriedmanDMoellerJ, 2004“A ghost of retrieval past: A functional network of alpha EEG related to source memory in elderly humans”Cognitive Brain Research20144–155
42.
MeenanJ PMillerL A, 1994“Perceptual flexibility after frontal or temporal lobectomy”Neuropsychologia321145–1149
43.
MillisK, 2001“Making meaning brings pleasure: The influence of titles on aesthetic experiences”Emotion1320–329
44.
MusialPKublikEPaneckiSWrübelA, 1998“Transient changes of electrical activity in the rat barrel cortex during conditioning”Brain Research7861–10
45.
NakataniHvan LeeuwenC, 2005“Individual differences in perceptual switching rates; the role of occipital alpha and frontal theta band activity”Biological Cybernetics93343–354
46.
NickiR MGaleA, 1977“EEG, measures of complexity, and preference for nonrepresentational works of art”Perception6281–286
47.
PetscheH, 1996“Approaches to verbal, visual and musical creativity by EEG coherence analysis”International Journal of Psychophysiology24145–159
48.
PfurtschellerGda SilvaF H Lopes, 1999Handbook of EEG and Clinical Neurophysiology: Event-related Desynchronization (Amsterdam: Elsevier)
49.
Plato (390 BC/1982) Hippias Major translated by WoodruffPaul (1982, Indianapolis, IN: Hackett Publishing Company)
50.
RushworthM F SKramsMPassinghamR E, 2001“The attentional role of the left parietal cortex: The distinct lateralization and localization of motor attention in the human brain”Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience13698–710
51.
RussellP A, 2003“Effort after meaning and the hedonic value of paintings”British Journal of Psychology9499–110
52.
SarntheinJPetscheHRappelsbergerPShawG Lvon SteinA, 1998“Synchronization between prefrontal and posterior association cortex during human working memory”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA957092–7096
53.
SausengPKlimeschWDoppelmayrMHanslmayrSSchabusMGruberW, 2004“Theta coupling in the human electroencephalogram during a working memory task”Neuroscience Letters354123–126
54.
SausengPKlimeschWGruberWDoppelmayrMStadlerWSchabusM, 2002“The interplay between theta and alpha oscillations in the human electroencephalogram reflects the transfer of information between memory systems”Neuroscience Letters324121–124
55.
StosnikPKrishnanGO'DonnellB, 2007“The effect of selective attention on the gamma-band auditory steady-state response”Neuroscience Letters420223–228
56.
Tallon-BaudryCBertrandODelpuechCPermierJ, 1997“Oscillatory γ-band 30 – 70 Hz activity induced by a visual search task in humans”Journal of Neuroscience17722–734
57.
Tallon-BaudryCBertrandOPeronnetFPermierJ, 1998“Induced gamma-band activity during the delay of a visual short-term memory task in humans”Journal of Neuroscience184244–4254
58.
VogtS, 1999“Looking at paintings: Patterns of eye movements in artistically naïve and sophisticated subjects”Leonardo32325
59.
VogtSMagnussenS, 2005“Hemispheric specialization and recognition memory for abstract and realistic pictures: A comparison of painters and laymen”Brain & Cognition58324–333
60.
VogtSMagnussenS, 2007“Expertise in pictorial perception: Eye-movement patterns and visual memory in artists and laymen”Perception3691–100
61.
Yuval-GreenbergSTomerOKerenA SNelkenIDeouellL Y, 2008“Transient induced gamma-band response in EEG as a manifestation of miniature saccades”Neuron58429–441
62.
WundtW M, 1874Grundzüge der physiologischen Psychologie [Characteristics of physiological psychology] (Leipzig: Engelmann)
