Interest in the concept of the polycentric urban region (PUR) has been growing among planners and policy-makers in north-west Europe. PURs are believed to offer a means of promoting regional economic competitiveness while safeguarding environmental objectives. This paper interrogates the concept and examines its relevance to the central Scotland region. Central Scotland has a polycentric physical form, but the evidence that it is a single functional region in economic terms is much more mixed. The dominant pattern of interactions suggests two separate city-regions, although links between adjoining areas seem to be growing. Despite considerable rivalry between public organisations across the region, there appears to be increasing support for the development of some kind of strategic spatial framework to inform key investment decisions and to promote closer collaboration. This would not necessarily be based on the PUR concept, since it is too broadly specified at present to guide the kinds of decision that need to be made. Further work is needed to elaborate and refine the concept.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abercrombie, P. and Matthew, R. (1949) The Clyde Valley Regional Plan 1946: A Report Prepared for the Clyde Valley Regional Planning Committee. Edinburgh : HMSO.
2.
Abercrombie, P. and Plum Stead, D. (1949) A Civic Survey and Plan for the City and Royal Burgh of Edinburgh. Edinburgh: Oliver and Boyd.
3.
Albrechts, L. (1998) The Flemish diamond: precious gem and virgin area , European Planning Studies, 6, pp. 411-424.
4.
Baa (British Airports Authority) (1999) Pax Fax Quarterly Analysis: Characteristics of Passengers using Scottish Airports . Glasgow: BAA.
5.
Bailey, N. and Turok, I. (forthcoming) Central Scotland, in: D. Ipenburg and B. Lambregts (Eds) Polycentric Urban Regions in the North Western Metropolitan Area: An Exploration of the Challenges for Strengthening Competitiveness and Quality of Life in NW Europe. Delft: Delft University Press.
6.
Bailey, N., Turok, I., Docherty, I. ET AL. (1999 ) Edinburgh and Glasgow: contrasts in competitiveness and cohesion . Department of Urban Studies, University of Glasgow.
7.
Batten, D.F. (1995) Network cities: creative urban agglomerations for the 21st century, UrbanStudies, 32, pp. 313-327.
8.
van den Berg, L., Braun, E. and van der Meer, J. (1997) The organising capacity of metropolitan regions, Environment and PlanningC, 15, 253-272.
9.
Blotevogel, H.H. (1998) The Rhine-Ruhr metropolitan region: reality and discourse, European Planning Studies, 6, pp. 395-410.
10.
Breheny, M. (1995) The compact city and transport energy consumption , Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series, 20, pp. 81-101.
11.
Cec (City Of Edinburgh Council) (2000) Info bulletin Number 2, March 2000. City Development Department, CEC, Edinburgh.
12.
Clark, W.A.V. and Kuijpers-Linde, M. (1994) Commuting in restructuring urban regions, UrbanStudies, 31, pp. 465-483.
13.
Danson, M., Fairley, J., Lloyd, M. and Turok, I. (1999) The European Structural Fund Partnerships in Scotland: new forms of governance for regional development?, Scottish Affairs, 27, pp. 23-40.
14.
Dieleman, F.M. and Faludi, A. (1998) Polynucleated metropolitan regions in Northwest Europe: theme of the Special Issue, European Planning Studies , 6, pp. 365-377.
15.
Dieleman, F.M. and Hamnett, C. (1994) Globalisation, regulation and the urban system: editors' introduction to the Special Issue, UrbanStudies , 31, pp. 357-364.
16.
European Council Of Eu Ministers Responsible For Spatial Planning (1999) European Spatial Development Perspective (ESDP). Brussels: DG Regio.
17.
Federal Ministry For Regional Planning, Building And Urban Development (1993) Guidelines for Regional Planning: General Principles for spatial Development in the Federal Republic of Germany . Bonn: Federal Ministry for Regional Planning, Building and Urban Development.
18.
Geddes, P. (1968) Cities in Evolution: an Introduction to the Town Planning Movement and to the Study of Civics. London: Ernest Benn Ltd.
19.
Gemaca (Group For European Metropolitan Areas Comparative Analysis) (1996) Northwest European Metropolitan Regions: Geographical Boundaries and Economic Structures. Paris : IAURIF.
20.
Glendinning, M. and Page, D. (1999) Clone City: Crisis and Renewal in Contemporary Scottish Architecture. Edinburgh: Polygon Press.
21.
Gordon, P., Richardson, H.W. and Wong, H. (1986) The distribution of population and employment in a polycentric city: the case of Los Angeles, Environment and Planning A, 18, pp.161-173.
22.
Hague, C. (1999) Positive planning. A paper presented at the Royal Town Planning Institute, Edinburgh , November.
23.
Hague, C. and Thomas, H. (1998) Planning capital cities: Edinburgh and Cardiff compared, in: R. MacDonald and H. Thomas (Eds) Nationality and Planning in Scotland and Wales pp. 133-145. Cardiff: University of Wales Press.
24.
Hastings, A. (1996) Unravelling the process of 'partnership' in urban regeneration policy, Urban Studies, 33, pp. 253-268.
25.
van Houtum, H. and Lagendijk, A. (1998) The role of regional identity in the shaping of new policy confzgurations for polycentric urban areas. A paper presented at the Seminar: Spatial development and policies in polycentric urban configurations, University of Amsterdam, February.
26.
Jackson, N. and Patel, D. (1996) Local sourcing by the electronics industry in Scotland, ScottishEconomic Bulletin, 52, pp. 17-29.
27.
Knapp, W. (1998) The Rhine-Ruhr area in transformation: towards a European metropolitan region?, European Planning Studies , 6, pp.379-393.
28.
Lambooy, J. (1998) Polynucleation and economic development: the Randstad , European Planning Studies, 6, pp. 457-466.
29.
Mackintosh, M. (1992) Partnerships: issues of policy and negotiation , Local Economy, 7, pp. 210-224.
30.
Maver, I. (2000) Glasgow. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
31.
Mears, F.C. (1948) A Regional Survey and Plan for Central and South-east Scotland: Prepared for the Central and South-east Scotland Regional Planning Advisory Committee. Edinburgh: Morrison and Gibb.
32.
Murphy, V. (1999) Scotland's airports in the deregulation years. Occasional Paper 2, Scottish Transport Studies Group, Edinburgh.
33.
Ons (Office For National Statistics) and Coombes, M. (1998) 1991-based Travel to Work Areas. London: ONS.
34.
Porter, M.E. (1990) The Competitive Advantage of Nations. London: Free Press.
35.
Priemus, H. (1994) Planning the Randstad: between economic growth and sustainability, UrbanStudies, 31, pp. 509-534.
36.
Priemus, H. (1998) The Randstad and the Central Netherlands Urban Ring: planners waver between two concepts, European Planning Studies, 6, pp. 443-466.
37.
Robertson, D. (1998) Pulling in opposite directions: the failure of post-war planning to regenerate Glasgow, Planning Perspectives , 13, pp. 53-67.
38.
Sassen, S. (1991) The Global City: New York, London , Tokyo. Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press.
39.
Sassen, S. (1994) Cities in a World Economy. London: Pine Forge Press.
40.
Scottish Office (1994) Local Government Reform: Structure Plan Areas—A Consultation Paper. Edinburgh: Scottish Office.
41.
Sdd (Scottish Development Department) (1963 ) Central Scotland: A Programme for Development and Growth. Cmnd. 2188. Edinburgh: HMSO.
42.
Turok, I. and Edge, N. (1999) The Jobs Gap in Britain's Cities: Employment Loss and Labour Market Consequences. Bristol: Policy Press.
43.
Vanhaverbeke, W. (1998) An economic analysis of the Flemish diamond, European Planning Studies, 6, pp. 425-442.
44.
Wannop, U.A. (1995) The Regional Imperative: Regional Planning and Governance in Britain, Europe and the United States. London : Jessica Kingsley.
45.
Webster, D. (2000) The political economy of Scotland's population decline, Fraser of Allander Institute Quarterly EconomicCommentary, 25(2), pp. 40-70.
