This paper argues against the local trap-the tendency to assume that the local scale is preferable to other scales. The local trap is an important problem in the recent explosion of research on urban democracy and citizenship. The paper highlights one strain of that literature, the work on 'the right to the city'. It is argued that the right to the city is highly susceptible to the local trap, although it is not inherently so. As we continue to search for innovative new ideas like the right to the city that can help to democratise cities, it is critical to think carefully and strategically about scale.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Agnew, J. (1997) The dramaturgy of horizons: geographical scale in the 'reconstruction of Italy' by the new Italian political parties, 1992-95 , Political Geography, 16(2), pp. 99-121.
2.
Aigner, S., Flora, C. ET AL. (2001) The premise and promise of citizenship and civil society for renewing democracies and empowering sustainable communities , Sociological Inquiry, 71(4), pp. 493-508.
3.
Amin, A. and Thrift, N. (2002) Cities: Reimagining the Urban. Cambridge: Polity Press.
4.
Axtman, R. (1996) Liberal Democracy into the Twenty-first Century: Globalization, Integration and the Nation-state. Manchester : Manchester University Press.
5.
Baiocchi, G. (2003) Participation activism and politics: the Porto Alegre experiment, in: A. Fung and E. Wright (Eds) Deepening Democracy , pp. 45-76. New York: Verso.
6.
Barber, B. (2004) Strong Democracy. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
7.
Beauregard, R. and Bounds, A. (2000) Urban citizenship, in: E. Isin (Ed.) Democracy, Citizenship and the Global City , pp. 243-256. New York: Routledge.
8.
Bender, T. (1999) Intellectuals, cities, and citizenship in the United States: the 1890s and 1990s, in: J. Holston (Ed.) Cities and Citizenship, pp. 21-41. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
9.
Benhabib, S. (1996) Toward a deliberative model of democratic legitimacy , in: S. Benhabib (Ed.) Democracy and Difference: Contesting Boundaries of the Political, pp. 67-94. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press .
10.
Berry, J., Portney, K.Et al. (1993) The Rebirth of Urban Democracy. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.
11.
Born, B. and Purcell, M. (forthcoming) Avoiding the local trap: scale and food systems in planning research, Journal of Planning Education and Research.
12.
Boudreau, J. (2003) Questioning the use of 'local democracy' as a discursive strategy for political mobilization in Los Angeles, Montreal and Toronto, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 27(4), pp. 793-811.
13.
Brenner, N. (1999) Globalisation as reterritorialisation: the rescaling of urban governance in the European Union, UrbanStudies, 36(3), pp. 431-451.
14.
Brenner, N. (2001) The limits to scale? Methodological reflections on scalar structuration, Progress in Human Geography, 25(4), pp. 591-614.
15.
Brenner, N. and Theodore, N. (2002) Cities and the geographies of 'actually existing neoliberalism', Antipode, 34(3), pp. 349-379.
16.
Brodie, J. (2000) Imagining democratic urban citizenship, in: E. Isin (Ed.) Democracy, Citizenship and the Global City, pp. 110-128. New York: Routledge.
17.
Brown, C. and Purcell, M. (2005) There's nothing inherent about scale: political ecology, the local trap, and the politics of development in the Brazilian Amazon, Geoforum, 36, pp. 607-624.
18.
Brown, M. (1997) Replacing Citizenship: AIDS Activism and Radical Democracy. New York: Guilford Press .
19.
Brownhill, S., Razzaque, K. ET AL. (1996) Local governance and the racialisation of urban policy in the UK: the case of urban development corporations, Urban Studies, 33, pp. 1337-1355.
20.
Buroni, T. (1998) A case for the right to habitat. Paper prepared for the Seminar on Urban Poverty, Rio de Janeiro.
21.
Castles, S. (2001) Globalization and citizenship: an Australian dilemma , Patterns of Prejudice, 35(1), pp. 91-109.
22.
Ceraso, K. (1999) Seattle neighborhood planning. Shelterforce Online, 108.
23.
Chaskin, R. and Abunimah, A. (1999) A view from the city: local government perspectives on neighborhood-based governance in community-building initiatives, Journal of Urban Affairs, 21(1), pp. 57-78.
24.
Cities for Human Rights (1998) Barcelona, October.
25.
CITY & SHELTER ET AL. (n.d.) The European charter for women in the city. Equal Opportunities Unit, Commission of the European Union, Brussels.
26.
Cohen, J. and Rogers, J. (1995) Associations and Democracy. London: Verso.
27.
Council Of Europe (1985) European Charter of local self-government (http://conventions.coe.int/treaty/en/treaties/html/122.htm).
28.
Cunningham, F. (2001) Theories of Democracy. New York : Routledge.
29.
Daniel, C. (2001) Participatory urban governance: the experience of Santo Andre, United Nations Chronicle Online, 38(1).
30.
Deas, I. and Ward, K. (2000) From the 'new localism' to the 'new regionalism'? The implications of regional development agencies for city-regional relations , Political Geography, 19(3), pp. 273-292.
31.
Decker, F. (2002) Governance beyond the nation-state: reflections on the democratic deficit of the European Union, Journal of European Public Policy, 9(2), pp. 256-272.
32.
Delaney, D. and Leitner, H. (1997) The political construction of scale, Political Geography, 16(2), pp. 93-97.
33.
Diers, J. (2004) Neighbor Power: Building Community the Seattle Way. Seattle: University of Washington Press.
34.
Dikec, M. (2001) Justice and the spatial imagination, Environment and Planning A, 33, pp. 1785-1805.
35.
Dryzek, J. (1996) Democracy in Capitalist Times. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
36.
Fainstein, S. and Fainstein, N. (1995) A proposal for urban policy in the 1990s, Urban Affairs Review, 30(5), pp. 630-635.
37.
Falk, R. (2000) The decline of citizenship in an era of globalization , Citizenship Studies, 4(1), pp. 5-18.
38.
Flyvbjerg, B. (1998) Rationality and Power: Democracy in Practice. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press .
39.
Friedmann, J. (1995) The right to the city, Society andNature, 1(1), pp. 71-84.
40.
Friedmann, J. (2002) City of fear or open city?, Journal of the American Planning Association, 68(3), pp. 237-243.
41.
Fung, A. (2004) Empowered Participation: Reinventing Urban Democracy . Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
42.
Fung, A. and Wright, E. (Eds) (2003a) Deepening Democracy: Institutional Innovations in Empowered Participatory Governance. New York: Verso.
43.
Fung, A. and Wright, E. (2003b) Thinking about empowered participatory governance , in: A. Fung and E. Wright (Eds) Deepening Democracy: Institutional Innovations in Empowered Participatory Governance, pp. 3-42. New York : Verso.
44.
Gill, S. (1996) Globalization, democratization, and the politics of indifference, in: J. Mittelman (Ed.) Globalization: Critical Reflections, pp. 205-228. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner.
45.
Gittell, M., Ortega-Bustamante, I. ET AL. (2000) Social capital and social change: women's community activism, Urban Affairs Review, 36(2), pp. 123-148.
46.
Goodhart, M. (2001) Democracy, globalization, and the problem of the state, Polity, 33(4), pp. 527-546.
47.
Goodman, D. (2003) The quality 'turn' and alternative food practices: reflections and agenda, Journal of Rural Studies, 19(1), pp. 1-7.
48.
Gough, J. (2002) Neoliberalism and socialisation in the contemporary city: opposites, complements and instabilities, Antipode, 34(3), pp. 405-426.
49.
Grant Building Tenants Association (2001) Grant building saved (for the moment)!Grant Building Tenants Association, San Francisco, CA.
50.
Green, G. and Haines, A. (2001) Asset Building and Community Development. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
51.
Greenberg, M. (1999) Restoring America's Neighborhoods: How Local People Make a Difference. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
52.
Hambleton, R., Savitch, H. ET Al. (Eds) (2003) Globalism and Local Democracy: Challenge and Change in Europe and North America . New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
53.
Hammar, T. (1990) Democracy and the Nation State: Aliens, Denizens, and Citizens in a World of International Migration. Brookfield, VT: Gower Publishing Co. Ltd.
54.
Hardt, M. and Negri, A. (2000) Empire. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Harvey , D. (1982) The Limits to Capital. Oxford: Blackwell.
55.
Hasselhoff, K. (2002) Motivations for the San Fernando Valley secession movement: the political dynamics of secession, Journal of Urban Affairs, 24(4), pp. 425-443.
56.
Held, D. (1995) Democracy and the Global Order. Cambridge: Polity.
57.
Herbert, S. (2005) The trapdoor of community, Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 95(4), pp. 850-865.
58.
Hipsher, P. (1996) Democratization and the decline of urban social movements in Chile and Spain, Comparative Politics, 28(3), pp. 273-297.
59.
Hoggett, P. (1987) A farewell to mass production ? Decentralization as an emergent private and public sector paradigm, in: P. HOGGETT and R. HAMBLETON Decentralization and democracy: localizing public services. School for Advanced Urban Studies, Bristol.
60.
Holston, J. (1999) Spaces of insurgent citizenship, in: J. Holston (Ed.) Cities and Citizenship, pp. 155-173. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
61.
Holston, J. and Appadurai, A. (1999) Introduction: cities and citizenship, in: J. Holston (Ed.) Cities and Citizenship , pp. 1-20. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
62.
Howitt, R. (1998) Scale as relation: musical metaphors of geographical scale, Area, 30(1), pp. 49-58.
63.
Isin, E. (1996) Global city-regions and citizenship, in: R. Keil, G. Wekerle and D. Bell (Eds) Local Places in the Age of the Global City, pp. 21-36. New York: Black Rose Books.
64.
Isin, E. (Ed.) (2000a) Democracy, Citizenship and the Global City . New York: Routledge.
65.
Isin, E. (2000b) Governing cities without government, in: E. Isin (Ed.) Democracy, Citizenship and the Global City, pp. 148-168. New York: Routledge .
66.
Isin, E. and Wood, P. (1999) Citizenship and Identity. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
67.
Jessop, B. (1997) A neo-Gramscian approach to the regulation of urban regimes: accumulation strategies, hegemonic projects, and governance, in: M. Lauria (Ed.) Reconstructing Urban Regime Theory: Regulating Urban Politics in a Global Economy, pp. 51-73. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
68.
Jessop, B. (2002) Liberalism, neoliberalism, and urban governance: a state-theoretical perspective, Antipode, 34(3), pp. 452-472.
69.
Jones, M. and Ward, K. (2002) Excavating the logic of British urban policy: neoliberalism as the 'crisis of crisis-management', Antipode, 34(3), pp. 473-494.
70.
Keating, M. (1991) Local development politics in Britain and France , Journal of Urban Affairs, 13, pp.443-459.
71.
Keil, R. (2002) 'Common-sense' neoliberalism: progressive conservative urbanism in Toronto, Canada, Antipode, 34(3), pp. 578-601.
72.
Kelly, P. (1997) Globalization, power and the politics of scale in the Philippines, Geoforum, 28(2), pp. 151-171.
73.
Kelly, P. (1999) The geographies and politics of globalization, Progress in Human Geography, 23(3), pp. 379-400.
74.
Kipfer, S. and Keil, R. (2002) Toronto Inc? Planning the competitive city in the new Toronto, Antipode, 34(2), pp. 227-264.
75.
Kofman, E. and Lebas, E. (1996) Lost in transposition: time, space, and the city , in: E. Kofman and E. Lebas (Eds) Writings on Cities, pp. 3-60. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.
76.
Laclau, E. and Mouffe, C. (1985) Hegemony and Socialist Strategy: Towards a Radical Democratic Politics. London: Verso .
77.
Larner, W. (2005) Co-constituting 'after neoliberalism': new forms of governance in Aotearoa New Zealand. Paper presented at the conference Towards a Political Economy of Scale, York University, Toronto, February.
78.
Latendresse, A. (2004) Democracy in Montreal: one step forward, two steps back, Canadian Dimension, 38(5), pp. 39-40.
79.
Lefebvre, H. (1968) Le droit à la ville. Paris: Anthopos.
80.
Lefebvre, H. (1973) Espace et politique. Paris: Anthropos.
81.
Lefebvre, H. (1991a) The Production of Space. Oxford : Blackwell.
82.
Lefebvre, H. (1991b) Les illusions de la modernite, Manières de voir, 13, pp. 14-17.
83.
Lefebvre, H. (1996) Writings on Cities. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.
84.
Lefebvre, H. (2003) The Urban Revolution. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
85.
Leitner, H. and Sheppard, E. (2002) 'The city is dead, long live the net': harnessing European interurban networks for a neoliberal agenda, Antipode , 34(3), pp. 495-518.
86.
Linklater, A. (1998) Cosmopolitan citizenship, Citizenship Studies, 2(1), pp. 23-41.
87.
Lummis, C. (1997) Radical Democracy. Ithaca, NY : Cornell University Press.
88.
Macleod, G. (2002) From urban entrepreneurial-ism to a revanchist city? On the spatial inhjustices of Glasgow's renaissance, Antipode, 34(3), pp. 602-624.
89.
MacLeod, G. and Goodwin, M. (1999) Reconstructing an urban and regional political economy: on the state, politics, scale, and explanation, Political Geography, 18(6), pp. 697-730.
90.
Madon, S. and Sahay, S. (2000) Democracy and information: a case study of new local governance structures in Bangalore, Information, Communication, and Society, 3(2), pp. 173-192.
91.
Mansbridge, J. (1983) Beyond Adversary Democracy. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
92.
Marston, S. (2000) The social construction of scale, Progress in Human Geography, 24(2), pp. 219-242.
93.
Matthews, J. (1989) Age of Democracy: The Political Economy of Post-Fordism . New York: Oxford University Press .
94.
McGuirk, P. (2001) Situating communicative planning theory: context, power, and knowledge, Environment and Planning A, 33, pp. 195-217.
95.
McNulty, R. (1999) Community empowerment manual. Partners for Livable Communities, Washington, DC.
96.
Mesch, G. and Schwirian, K. (1996) The effectiveness of neighborhood collective action , Social Problems, 43(4), pp. 467-484.
97.
Mitchell, D. (2003) The Right to the City: Social Justice and the Fight for Public Space. New York: Guilford Press.
98.
Mitchell, K. (2001) Education for democratic citizenship: transnationalism, multiculturalism, and the limits of liberalism, Harvard Educational Review, 71(1), pp. 51-78.
99.
Mohan, G. and Stokke, K. (2000) Participatory development and empowerment: the dangers of localism, Third World Quarterly, 21(2), pp. 247-268.
100.
Mouffe, C. (1999) Deliberative democracy or agonistic pluralism? , Social Research, 66(3), pp. 745-758.
101.
Mulady, K. (2004a) City's ties to Vulcan run deep, Seattle Post-Intelligencer, 25 October, p. A14.
102.
Mulady, K. (2004b) Remaking South Lake Union: Seattle is on fast track to build biotech hub, Seattle Post-Intelligencer, 20 October, p. A1.
103.
Murphy, C. (2000) Global governance: poorly done and poorly understood , International Affairs, 76(4), pp. 789-803.
104.
Murphy, P. and Cunningham, J. (2003) Organizing for Community Controlled Development: Renewing Civil Society. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
105.
Nylen, W. (2003) Participatory Democracy versus Elitist Democracy: Lessons from Brazil. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
106.
Olds, K. (1998) Urban mega-events, evictions and housing rights: the Canadian case, Current Issues in Tourism, 1(1), pp. 2-46.
107.
Parker, W. (2003) Teaching Democracy: Unity and Diversity in Public Life. New York: Teachers College Press.
108.
Pateman, C. (1970) Participation and Democratic Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
109.
Peck, J. (1998) Geographies of governance: TECs and the neo-liberalisation of 'local interests', Space &Polity, 2(1), pp. 5-31.
110.
Peck, J. (2001) Workfare States. New York: Guilford Press.
111.
Peterman, W. (1999) Neighborhood Planning and Community-based Development: The Potential and Limits of Grassroots Action. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
112.
Pratchett, L. (1999) Renewing Local Democracy ? The Modernisation Agenda in British Local Government. London: Frank Cass.
113.
Pratchett, L. (2004) Local autonomy, local democracy and the 'new localism ', Political Studies, 52, pp. 358-375.
114.
Purcell, M. (2000) The decline of the political consensus for growth: evidence from Los Angeles, Journal of Urban Affairs, 22(1), pp. 85-100.
115.
Purcell, M. (2002) Excavating Lefebvre: the right to the city and its urban politics of the inhabitant, GeoJournal, 58(2/3), pp. 99-108.
116.
Purcell, M. (2003) Citizenship and the right to the global city: reimagining the capitalist world order, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 27(3), pp. 564-590.
117.
Purcell, M. (2004) City-regions, neoliberal globalization, and democracy: a research agenda. Paper presented at the 30th Congress of the International Geographical Union, Glasgow , August.
118.
Purcell, M. and Brown, J. (2005) Against the local trap: scale and the study of environment and development, Progress in Development Studies , 5(4), pp. 279-297.
119.
Putnam, R. (1993) Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
120.
Rights to the City (1998) Conference held at York University, Toronto, June.
121.
Rights to the City (2002) Conference held in Rome, May.
122.
Rusk, D. (1995) Cities without Suburbs. Washington, DC: Woodrow Wilson Center Press.
123.
Sandercock, L. (1998) The death of modernist planning: radical praxis for a postmodern age, in: J. FRIEDMANN and M. DouGLAss (Eds) Cities for Citizens: Planning and the Rise of Civil Society in a Global Age , pp. 163-184. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
124.
Sassen, S. (2000) The global city: strategic site/ new frontier, in: E. Isin (Ed.) Democracy, Citizenship and the Global City, pp. 48-61. New York: Routledge.
125.
Scott, A. (1993) Technopolis: High-technology Industry and Regional Development in SouthernCalifornia. Los Angeles, CA: University of California Press.
126.
Secor, A. (2003) Citizenship in the city: identity, community, and rights among women migrants to Istanbul, Urban Geography, 24(2), pp. 147-168.
127.
Smith, N. (1992) Geography, difference and the politics of scale , in: J. Doherty, E. Graham and M. Malek (Eds) Postmodernism and the Social Sciences, pp. 57-79. London : Macmillan.
128.
Smith, N. (1993) Homeless/global: scaling places, in: J. Bird (Ed.) Mapping the Futures: Local Cultures Global Change, pp. 87-119. New York: Routledge .
129.
Smith, N. (2002) New globalism, new urbanism: gentrification as global urban strategy, Antipode, 34(3), pp. 427-450.
130.
Smith, S. (1995) Citizenship: all or nothing?, Political Geography, 14(2), pp. 190-193. Smock, K. (2003) Democracy in Action: Community Organizing and Urban Change. New York: Columbia University Press.
131.
Soja, E. (1996) Thirdspace: Journeys to Los Angeles and Other Real-and-imagined Places. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell .
132.
Soja, E. (2000) Postmetropolis. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
133.
Souza, M. (2001) The Brazilian way of conquering the 'right to the city', DISP, 147, pp. 25-31.
134.
Soysal, Y. (1999) Toward a postnational model of citizenship, in: G. Shafir (Ed.) The Citizenship Debates, pp. 189-217. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
135.
Speller, G. and Ravenscroft, N. (2005) Facilitating and evaluating public participation in urban parks management, Local Environment, 10(1), pp. 41-57.
136.
Staeheli, L. (1994) Restructuring citizenship in Pueblo, Colorado, Environment and Planning A, 26(6), pp. 849-871.
137.
Staeheli, L. (2003) Cities and citizenship, Urban Geography , 24(2), pp. 97-103.
138.
Swyngedouw, E. (1997a) Excluding the other: the production of scale and scaled politics, in: R. Lee and J. Wills (Eds) Geographies of Economies, pp. 167-176. London: Arnold .
139.
Swyngedouw, E. (1997b) Neither global nor local: 'glocalization' and the politics of scale, in: K. Cox (Ed.) Spaces of Globalization, pp. 137-166. New York: Guilford Press.
140.
Swyngedouw, E. (2000) Authoritarian governance, power, and the politics of rescaling, Environment and Planning D, 18(1), pp. 63-76.
141.
Swyngedouw, E., Moulaert, F. ET AL. (2002) Neoliberal urbanization in Europe: large-scale urban development projects and the new urban policy, Antipode , 34(3), pp. 542-577.
142.
Tickell, A. and Peck, J. (2003) Making global rules: globalisation or neoliberalisation? , in: J. Peck and H. Yeung (Eds) Remaking the Global Economy: Economic-geographical Perspectives, pp. 163-182. London: Sage.
143.
Turner, B. (2000) Cosmopolitan virtue: loyalty and the city, in: E. Isin (Ed.) Democracy, Citizenship and the Global City, pp. 129-147. New York: Routledge.
144.
Unchs (United Nations Centre For Human Settlements) (2001) Policy dialogue series: No. 1 Women and urban governance . UNCHS (Habitat), New York.
145.
Undesa (United Nations Department Of Economic And Social Affairs) (1992) Report of the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development. United Nations , Rio.
146.
Ward, K. (2000) A critique in search of a corpus: re-visiting governance and re-interpreting urban politics, Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 25(2), pp. 169-185.
147.
Weir, S. and Beetham, D. (1999) Political Power and Democratic Control in Britain . London: Routledge.
148.
Wells, V. (2002) Mississippi milestones: developing a comprehensive plan for a city by starting at the grass roots level isn't a new idea, Planning, 68(8), pp. 24-28.
149.
Worldwide Conference on the Right to Cities Free from Discrimination and Inequality (2002) Porto Allege, Brazil, February.
150.
Wu, F. (2002) China's changing urban governance in the transition towards a more market-oriented economy, UrbanStudies, 39(7), pp. 1071-1093.
151.
Yaghmaian, B. (1998) Globalization and the state: the political economy of global accumulation and its emerging mode of regulation, Science and Society, 62(2), pp. 241-265.
152.
Young, I. (2000) Inclusion and Democracy. New York: Oxford University Press.
153.
Yuval-Davis, N. (1997) Women, citizenship and difference, Feminist Review57, pp. 4-28.
