This paper challenges the widespread view that there was a rental housing supply crisis in the late 1980s in Ontario and shows that the increase in rental during that period was far greater than the number of new purpose-built rental units. Conversions and investor-owned condominiums made a major contribution. Contrary to conventional wisdom, conversions came from the relatively new stock and tenure switches unassociated with structural change were important. The importance of the conversion phenomenon is underlined by evidence that the conversion sector of the rental market was far looser in 1989 than in 1971. This suggests that the official rental vacancy rate, for large buildings, is misleading as an indicator of overall availability. The paper argues that the rise in the relative importance of conversions and investor-owned condominiums is no fluke, but rather is the consequence of the interaction of the income tax system and the high rates of inflation and capital gains of the 1970s and 1980s, as well as certain details of Ontario rent regulation. It argues that these forces have encouraged conversions of units from ownership to rental, additions of rental units in small buildings rather than in large, and non-corporate ownerships.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Baer, W.C. (1986) The shadow market in housing, Scientific American, 255, pp. 29-35.
2.
Blair, K. (1983) Net Conversions in Ontario, 1971-1981. Toronto: Ontario Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing, Corporate Planning Evaluation Branch.
3.
Bourne, L.S. (1986) Recent housing policy issues in Canada: a retreat from social housing ?, Housing Studies, 1(2), pp. 122-128.
4.
City Of Toronto Planning And Development Department (1980) Housing deconversion. Research Bulletin No. 16, City of Toronto Planning and Development Department Policy and Research Division, Toronto.
5.
City Of Toronto Planning And Development Department (1982) Toronto Condominiums, Past, Present and Future . Research Bulletin No. 19, City of Toronto PDD, Research and Information Section: Toronto.
6.
City Of Toronto Planning And Development Department (1985) Condominium Monitor '85, City of Toronto PDD, Research and Information Section: Toronto.
7.
City Of Toronto Planning And Development Department (1986) Trends in housing occupancy. Research Bulletin No. 26, City of Toronto Planning and Development Department Research and Information Section, Toronto.
8.
Clayton, Research Associates Ltd In Association With J. Hurtubise, Économiste, And City Spaces Consultants Ltd (1991) Rental Housing: A Study of Selected Local Markets. Prepared for CHMC and British Columbia Housing Management Commission. Ottawa : Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation.
9.
Crone, T.M. (1988) Changing rates of return on rental property and condominium conversions, UrbanStudies, 25, pp. 34-42.
10.
Daly, M.J. and Jung, J. (1987) The taxation of corporate investment income in Canada: an analysis of marginal investment effective tax rates, Canadian Journal of Economics, 20(3), pp. 555-587.
11.
Dennis, R. (1989) Toronto's first apartment-house boom: an historical geography, 1900-1920, Research Paper No. 177, Centre for Urban and Community Studies, University of Toronto.
12.
Doucet, M. and Weaver, J. (1991) Housing the North American City. Montreal: McGill-Queen's University Press.
13.
Ekos, Research Associates, (1985) A Study of Landlords and Rent Regulation. Research Study No. 24, Ontario Commission of Inquiry into Residential Tenancies, Toronto.
14.
Fallis, G. (1990) Housing finance and housing subsidies in Canada, UrbanStudies, 27, pp. 877-903.
15.
Fallis, G. and Smith, L.B. (1989) Tax reform and residential real estate, in: J. Mintz and J. Whalley(Eds) The Economic Impacts of Tax Reform, pp. 336-365. Toronto: Canadian Tax Foundation.
16.
Follain, J.R. and Ling, D.C. (1988) Another look at tenure choice, inflation and taxes , Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association, 16(3), pp. 207-229.
17.
Gervais-Simard, L. (1981) Method of Estimation of the Physical Housing Stock in Canada. Ottawa: Statistics Canada Housing and Building Permits Section.
18.
Gottlieb, M. (1964) Estimates of residential building in the United States, 1840-1939. Technical Paper No. 17, National Bureau of Economic Research, New York.
19.
Hamnett, C. and Randolph, B. (1986) Tenurial transformation and the flat break-up market in London: the British condo experience, in: N. Smith and P. Williams (Eds) Gentrification of the City, pp. 121-152. Boston: Allen and Unwin.
20.
Harris, R. (1986) Boom and bust: the effects of house price inflation on home-ownership patterns in Montreal, Toronto, and Vancouver, The Canadian Geographer, 30, pp. 302-315.
21.
Harris, R. and Choko, M.H. (1988) The evolution of housing tenure in Montreal and Toronto since the mid-nineteenth century. Research Paper No. 166, Centre for Urban and Community Studies, University of Toronto.
22.
Hendershott, P.H. (1980) Real user costs and the demand for single-family housing, Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 2, pp. 401-444.
23.
Hendershott, P.H. and Smith, M.T. (1988) Housing inventory change and the role of existing structures, 1961-1985, Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association, 16, pp. 364-378.
24.
Hosios, A.J. and Pesando, J.E. (1992) Monitoring price behaviour in the resale housing market: a note on measurement and implications for policy, Canadian Public Policy: Analyse de Politiques, 18, pp. 57-61.
25.
Hulchanski, J.D. (1989) Rental Housing Trends in the City of Vancouver . 'Centre for Human Settlements Research Bulletin, University of British Columbia Centre for Human Settlements, Vancouver.
26.
Krashinsky, M. and Milne, W.J. (1987) Housing prices in metropolitanToronto: an empirical analysis, Regional Science and Urban Economics, 17, pp. 289-305.
27.
Linneman, P. (1985) An economic analysis of the home-ownership decision , Journal of Urban Economics, 17, pp. 230-246.
28.
Lentz, G.H. and Fisher, J.D. (1989) Tax reform and organizational forms of holding investment real estate: corporation vs partnership, Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association, 17(3), pp. 314-337.
29.
Macnevin, A. and Gupta, A. (1986) Tax motivated business loss realizations: analysis and policy implications. Tax Analysis Technical Paper No. 2, (Department of Finance Tax Analysis Section, Ottawa.
30.
Metropolitan Toronto Planning Department ( 1987) Housing Intensification. Toronto: Metropolitan Toronto Planning Department.
31.
Miron, J.R. (1988) The Condominium Sector in Ontario. Toronto: Centre for Urban and Community Studies, University of Toronto.
32.
Miron, J.R. (1990) Security of tenure, costly tenants and rent regulation , Urban Studies, 27, 167-184.
33.
Muller, A. (1990) Rent control and vacancy rates in Canada. Paper presented to the Canadian Economics Association (Hamilton: Department of Economics, McMaster University).
34.
Northrup, D. and Murdie, R.A. (1989) The Availability of Rental Units in Owner-Occupied Dwellings in the City of Toronto and Owners' Experience in the Rental Market. Report prepared for the Planning and Development Department of theCity of Toronto, Toronto: Institute for Social Research, York University.
35.
Ontario Fair Tax Commission (1992) Working Group Report: Tax Treatment of Real Estate Gains, Toronto: Ontario Ministry of Treasury and Economics .
36.
Preston, V. , Murdie, R.A. and Fallis, G. (1989) A Profile of Rental Housing in Ontario: Trends in Renter Affordability and Physical Characteristics, Toronto: Institute for Social Research, York University .
37.
Regional Municipality Of Ottawa And Carleton ( 1988) Municipal Building Profile Program: Summary Report, Ottawa: Regional Municipality of Ottawa and Carleton .
38.
Skaburskis, A. (1988) A comparison of suburban and inner-city condominium markets, Canadian Journal of Regional Science, 11(2), pp. 29-85.
39.
Smith, L.B. (1974) A note on the price adjustment mechanism for rental housing, American Economic Review, 64, pp. 478-481.
40.
Smith, L.B. (1988a) Market adjustment, trends and the 'housing crisis', in: Home Ownership Forum Proceedings, Tab. 9, pp. 1-25. Toronto: Ontario Ministry of Housing.
41.
Smith, L.B. (1988b) Economic implications of Ontario's new housing legislation, Bills 11 and 51, Canadian Public Policy-Analyse de Politiques, 14(4), pp. 390-398.
42.
Steele, M. (1983) Construction and housing, in: F. H. Leacy (Ed.) Historical Statistics of Canada, 2nd edn. Ottawa: Statistics Canada.
43.
Steele, M. (1988) Inflation, income taxation and second generation rent regulation in Ontario, in: R. Arnott and J. Mintz (Eds) Rent Control in Ontario, pp. 67-84. Kingston: J.J. Deutsch Institute, Queen's University.
44.
Steele, M. (1991) Conversions, condominiums and capital gains: changes in the structure of the Ontario rental housing market. Research Paper No. 181, Centre for Urban and Community Studies, University of Toronto.
45.
Steele, M. (1992) Inflation, the tax system, rents and the return to home ownership, in: G. Arbuckle and H. Bartel (Eds) Readings in Canadian Real Estate, 2nd edn., pp. 119-133. York UniversityCampus, North York : Captus University Publications.
46.
Tomlinson, P. (1982) Confronting the Crisis: A Review of City Housing Policy, 1976-81. Toronto: City of Toronto Planning and Development Policy Section.
