Natural Governance and the Governance of Nature: The Hazards of Natural Law Feminism

Abstract

This article examines the precepts of natural law feminism, and in exploring the writings of two Canadian feminists, Maureen McTeer and Louise Vandelac, examines how natural law feminism is deployed in debates about how to theorize reproduction. I contend that the natural law perspective obscures many issues worthy of feminist inquiry, and, perhaps more critically, eschews a discourse that emphasizes reproductive freedom in favour of one which has at its centre a largely unproblematized view of reproduction that follows a biologically driven script of conception, gestation, childbirth and mothering as inherently and necessarily connected.

I argue that this stance is particularly evident in natural law feminist analyses of ecology and the regulation of new reproductive and genetic technologies. In both these areas, natural law feminism poses the central problem as one in which feminists must zealously protect the natural association between women and reproduction; in so doing, natural law feminists gloss over the nature of this association. I suggest a reframing of the focus of debates on reproduction from what is natural and what is socially constructed to how we demarcate the two.

Keywords

Nature new reproductive and genetic technologies natural law ecofeminism Canada reproduction

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Butler

Judith

(1990) Gender Trouble, London: Routledge.

Brown

Wendy

(1995) States of Injury, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Correa

Sonia

(1994) Population and Reproductive Rights: Feminist Perspectives from the South, London & New Jersey: Zed Books.

Cuomo

Christine

(1994) ‘Ecofeminism, deep ecology, and human population’ in Warren

Karen

(1994) editor, Ecological Feminism, London: Routledge.

Diamond

Irene

(1994) Fertile Ground: Women, Earth, and the Limits of Control, Boston, MA: Beacon Press.

Duden

Barbara

(1993) Disembodying Women, Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Franklin

Sarah

(1997) Embodied Progress, London: Routledge.

Ginsburg

Faye

, and Rapp

Rayna

(1995) Conceiving the New World Order, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

Gordon

Linda

(1974) Woman's Body Woman's Right, New York: Penguin Books.

10.

Haraway

Dona

(1997a) Modest Witness, London: Routledge.

11.

Haraway

Dona

(1997b) ‘The virtual speculum in the new world order’ Feminist Review, No. 55, spring.

12.

Jackson

Cecile

(1993) ‘Women/nature or gender/history? A critique of ecofeminist “development” The Journal of Peasant Studies Vol. 20, No. 3, April, pp. 389–419.

13.

Katz Rothman

Barbara

(1987) The Tentative Pregnancy, New York: Penguin Books.

14.

Katz Rothman

Barbara

(1989) Recreating Motherhood, New York: W.W. Norton.

15.

Laqueur

Thomas

(1990) Making Sex, Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

16.

Latour

Bruno

(1993) We Have Never Been Modern, Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

17.

Leach

Penelope

(1994) Children First, New York: Alfred Knopf.

18.

McTEER

Maureen

(1992) The Tangled Womb: The Politics of Human Reproduction, Toronto: Harper Collins Publishers.

19.

Martin

Emily

(1987) The Woman in the Body, Boston, MA: Beacon Press.

20.

Martin

Emily

(1991) ‘The egg and the sperm’ Signs, Vol. 16, No. 3, 485–501.

21.

Merchant

Caroline

(1982) The Death of Nature: Women, Ecology and the Scientific Revolution, London: Wildwood House.

22.

Mill

J.S.

(1984) ‘The subjection of women’ in Essays on Equality Law, and Education, Toronto: University of Toronto Press & Kegan Paul.

23.

Ortner

(1974) ‘Is female to male as nature is to culture?’ in Rosaldo

, and Lamphere

(1974) editors, Woman, Culture, and Society, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

24.

Pateman

Carole

(1988) The Sexual Contract, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

25.

Petchesky

Rosalind

(1984) Abortion and Woman's Choice, New York: Longman.

26.

Petchesky

Rosalind

(1995) ‘The body as property: a feminist re-vision’ in GINSBURG and RAPP (1995).

27.

Pfeffer

Naomi

(1993) The Storm and the Syringe: A Political History of Reproductive Medicine, Cambridge: Policy Press.

28.

Raymond

Janice

(1991) ‘The international traffic in women’ in Hynes

Patricia

(1991) editor, Reconstructing Babylon, Bloomington & Indianapolis: Indiana University Press.

29.

Shiva

Vandana

(1989) Staying Alive: Women, Ecology and Development, London: Zed Books.

30.

Shiva

Vandana

(1997) Biopiracy: The Plunder of Nature and Knowledge, Toronto: Between the Lines.

31.

Spallone

Patricia

(1989) Beyond Conception, Massachusetts: Bergin & Garvey Publishers.

32.

Stanworth

Michelle

(1987) editor, Reproductive Technologies, Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.

33.

Strathern

Marilyn

(1995) ‘Displacing knowledge: technology and the consequences for kinship’ in GINSBURG and RAPP (1995).

34.

Valvende

WEIN

(1997) ‘Commentary: regulating new reproductive and genetic technologies: A feminist view of recent Canadian government initiatives’ Feminist Studies, Vol. 23, No. 2, Summer, pp. 419–423.

35.

Vandelac

Louise

(1994) ‘The industrialisation of life’ in Basen, Eichler and Lippman (1994) editors, Misconceptions vol. II, Maple Pond, Prescott Ontario: Voyageur Publishers.

36.

Weir

Lorna

, and Habib

Jasmine

(1997) ‘A critical feminist analysis of the Report of the Royal Commission on New Reproductive Technologies’ Studies in Political Economy, Vol. 52, spring, pp. 137–54.