Children’s incipient ability to distinguish mistakes from lies: An Italian investigation

Abstract

We report a study in which Italian children aged 3 to 5 years were given situations requiring a distinction between lies and honest mistakes. As in previous research, the children displayed an incipient grasp of the lie-mistake distinction with regard to situations involving falsehoods about edibility of a substance that had been contaminated. However, children of all ages often regarded instances of both lies and mistakes as negative rather than restricting their judgements of naughtiness to the lying alone. The results are discussed in terms of the characteristics of Italian language and culture such as the connotations of words used to indicate “mistakes” and references to anger in labelling a variety of emotional events.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Au, T.K. , Sidle, A.L. , & Rollins, K.B. (1993). Developing an intuitive understanding of conservation and contamination: Invisible particles as a plausible mechanism . Developmental Psychology, 29, 286-299 .

Hunt, E. , & Agnoli, F. (1991). The Whor” an hypothesis: A cognitive psychology perspective . Psychological Review, 98, 377-389 .

Kalish, C.W. (1996). Preschoolers’ understanding of germs as invisible mechanisms . Cognitive Development, 11, 83-106 .

Lee, K. , Cameron, C.A. , Xu, F. , Fu, G. , & Broad, J. (1997). Chinese and Canadian children’s evaluations of lying and truth-telling . Child Development, 64, 924-934 .

Marchetti, A. (1991). Un aspetto della competenza sociale: La comprensione delle emozioni. In G. Gilli & A. Marchetti (Eds.), Prospettive sociogenetiche e sviluppo cognitivo (pp. 251-291). Milan: Raffaello Cortina.

Marchetti, A. (1993). Emotional experience, labeling and social sharing of emotions. Paper presented at the Symposium on Labeling and social sharing of emotions . Xth General Meeting of the European Association of Experimental Social Psychology, Lisbon.

Marchetti, A., & Gilli G. (in press). Il bambino come ” glio: memoria familiare, soddisfazione coniugale, esperienze emotive infantili. In A. Marchetti & O. Liverta-Sempio (Eds.), Cultura e individualità. Milan: Raffaello Cortina.

Piaget, J. (1932). The moral judgement of the child. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul .

Rosen, A.B. , & Rozin, P. (1993). Now you see it... now you don’t: The preschool child’s conception of invisible particles in the context of dissolving . Developmental Psychology, 29, 300-311 .

10.

Rozin, P. (1990). Development in the food domain . Developmental Psychology, 26, 555-562 .

11.

Rozin, P. (1996). Towards a psychology of food and eating: From motivation to module to model to marker, morality, meaning, and metaphor . Psychological Science, 5, 18-24 .

12.

Siegal, M. , & Peterson, C.C. (1996). Breaking the mold: A fresh look at children’s understanding of questions about lies and mistakes . Developmental Psychology, 32, 322-334 .

13.

Siegal, M. (1995). Becoming mindful of food and conversation . Current Directions in Psychological Science, 6, 177-181 .

14.

Siegal, M. , & Peterson, C.C. (1998). Preschoolers’ understanding of the lies and innocent and negligent mistakes . Developmental Psychology, 34, 332-341 .

15.

Siegal, M. , & Share, D.L. (1990). Contamination sensitivity in young children . Developmental Psychology, 26, 455-458 .

16.

Springer, K. , & Belk, A. (1994). The role of physical contact and association in early contamination sensitivity . Developmental Psychology, 30, 864-868 .

17.

Strichartz, A.F. , & Burton, R.V. (1990). Lies and truth: A study of the development of the concept . Child Development, 61, 211-220 .

18.

Tiberi, E., & Pedrabissi, L. (1988). Caratteristiche emozionali degli italiani. Ricerca empirica sulla frequenza delle emozioni di base nella popolazione italiana. Milan: Giuffrè.

19.

Wimmer, H. , Gruber, S. , & Perner, J. (1984). Young children’s conception of lying: Lexical realism-moral subjectivism . Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 37, 1-30 .

20.

Wimmer, H. , Gruber, S. , & Perner, J. (1985). Young children’s conception of lying: Moral intuition and the denotation and connotation of “to lie” . Developmental Psychology, 21, 993-995 .