Medical Specialization,Profession,and Mediating Beliefs that Predict Stated Likelihood of Alcohol Screening and Brief Intervention: Targeting Educational Interventions
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online September, 2003
Medical Specialization,Profession,and Mediating Beliefs that Predict Stated Likelihood of Alcohol Screening and Brief Intervention: Targeting Educational Interventions
Practitioner–level educational approaches that promote screening and brief intervention (SBI) seldom consider providers’ profession and medical specialization. Strategies that consider these variables may be better equipped to affect change in beliefs and behavior. The aim of this study was to identify beliefs that predict stated likelihood of practicing SBI by specialty and health profession in order to guide the direction of educational strategies. Physicians and nurse practitioners were studied that specialized in family, internal, obstetric gynecology (ObGyn), and pediatric medicine. The results indicated that independent of amount of previous postgraduate alcohol education and knowledge, self–rated competence mediated between specialty and likelihood of practicing SBI. For instance, low self–rated competence for ObGyn was a barrier that suppressed likelihood of practicing SBI. Other findings were that role legitimacy mediated the association between profession and likelihood of SBI, so that lack of role legitimacy was a barrier for physicians but not for nurse practitioners. We suggest that targeted educational strategies for ObGyn and pediatric clinicians may prove more effective than the prevalent one–size–fits all approaches aimed at general adult populations.
US Department of Health and Human Services, National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism. 1993. Eighth special report to the US congress on alcohol and health from the secretary of health and human services, Washington, DC: US Department of Health and Human Services, National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism. Publication ADM–281–91–0003
2.
SaitzR, SullivanLM and SametJH. 2000. Training community based clinicians in screening and brief intervention for substance abuse problems: Translating evidence into practice. Subst Abuse, 21: 21–32.
3.
AdamsA, OckeneJK, WhellerEV and HurleyTG. 1998. Alcohol counseling: Physicians will do it. J Gen Intern Med, 13: 692–698.
4.
GormanDM, WernerLM, JacobsLM and DuffySW. 1990. Evaluation of an alcohol education package for non–specialist health care and social workers. Br J Addict, 85: 223–233.
5.
RowlandN, MaynardAK, KennedyPF, WintersgillW and StoneWD. 1988. Teaching doctors to take alcohol histories: A limited success story. Med Educ, 22: 539–542.
6.
Institute of Medicine. 1990. Broadening the Base of Treatment for Alcohol Problems, Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
7.
EdmundsM, FrankR, HoganM, McCartyD, Robinson–BealeR and WeisnerC, eds. 1997. Managing Managed Care: Quality Improvement in Behavioral Health, Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
8.
KitchensJM. 1994. Does this patient have an alcohol problem?. JAMA, 272: 1782–1787.
9.
MezyE. 1995. Detecting the problem drinker. Gastrointest Dis Today, 4: 19
10.
SpandorferJM, IsraelY and TurnerBJ. 1999. Primary care physicians’ views on screening and management of alcohol abuse inconsistencies with national guidelines. J Fam Pract, 48: 899–902.
11.
Center for. 2000. Substance Abuse Treatment: Primary care physicians: More training needed to diagnose substance abuse. CS AT FAX, 5: 1097
12.
El–GuebalyN, LockyerJM, DroughtJ, ParboosinghJ, JuschkaBB, WestonWA, CampbellW and ChangS. 1995. Determining priorities for family physician education in substance abuse by the use of a survey. J Addict Dis, 14: 23–31.
13.
FordDE, KlagMJ, WheltonPK, GoldsmithM and LevineED. 1994. Physician knowledge of the CAGE alcohol screening questions and its impact on practice. Alcohol Alcohol, 29: 329–336.
14.
SaitzR, MulveyKP, PloughA and SametJH. 1997. Physician unawareness of serious substance abuse. Am J Alcohol Abuse, 23: 343–354.
15.
El–GuebalyN, ToewsJ, LockyerJ, ArmstrongS and HodginsD. 2000. Medical education in substance–related disorders: Components and outcome. Addiction, 95: 949–957.
16.
LockyerJ, El–GuebalyN, SimpsonE, GromoffB, ToewsJ and JuschkaB. 1996. Standardized patients as a measure of change in the ability of family physicians to detect and manage alcohol abuse. Acad Med, 71: S1–S3.
17.
BrownRL. 1988. Evaluation of a continuing medical education program for primary care physicians on the management of alcoholism. J Med Educ, 63: 482–484.
18.
BradleyKA. 1992. Screening and diagnosis of alcoholism in the primary care setting. West J Med, 156: 166–171.
19.
FangWL, ApplegateSN, SteinRM and LohrJA. 1998. The development of substance–abuse curricular content by five North Carolina schools. Acad Med, 73: 1039–1043.
20.
Center for. 2000. Substance Abuse Treatment: Less than one–third of primary care physicians routinely screen for substance abuse. CSAT FAX, 5: 1096
21.
GottliebNH, MullenPD and McAlisterAL. 1987. Patients’ substance abuse and primary care physician: Patterns of practice. Addict Behav, 12: 23–32.
22.
SchorlingJB, KlasPT, WillemsJP and EverettAS. 1994. Addressing alcohol use among primary care patients: Differences between family medicine and internal medicine residents. J Gen Intern Med, 9: 248–254.
23.
McCradyBS, RichterSS, MorganTJ, SladeJ and PfeiferC. 1996. Involving health care workers in screening for alcohol problems. J Addict Dis, 15: 45–58.
24.
RowlandN, MaynardA, BeveridgeA, KennedyP, WintersgillW and StoneW. 1987. Doctors have no time for alcohol screening. Br J Med, 295: 95–96.
25.
AboreliusE and ThakkerKD. 1995. Why it is so difficult for general practitioners to discuss alcohol with patients?. Fam Pract, 12: 419–422.
26.
OgborneAC, RushB, EkdahlA and FondacaroR. 1986. The views of health and social service professionals regarding alcohol problems and their treatment. Int J Addict, 21: 1051–1058.
27.
MillerNS, SheppardMA, ColendaCC and MagenJ. 2001. Why physicians are unprepared to treat patients who have alcohol– and drug–related disorders. Acad Med, 76: 410–418.
28.
ChappelJN. 1992. “Attitudes toward the treatment of substance abusers”. In Comprehensive Textbook of Substance Abuse, Edited by: LowensonJ, RuizP and MillmanR. 983–996. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins.
29.
WestermyerJ, DohenyS and StoneB. 1978. An assessment of hospital care for the alcoholic patient. Alcohol Clin Exp Res, 2: 53–57.
30.
BotelhoRJ and RichmondR. 1996. Secondary prevention of excessive alcohol use: Assessing the prospects of implementation. Fam Pract, 13: 182–193.
31.
DrummondDC. 1997. Alcohol interventions: Do the best things come in small packages?. Addiction, 92: 375–379.
32.
O'ConnorPG and SchottenfeldRS. 1998. Patient with alcohol problems. N Engl J Med, 338: 592–602.
33.
RushB, BassM, StewartM, McCrackenE, LabrequeM and BondyS. 1994. Detecting, preventing, and managing patients’ alcohol problems. Can Fam Physician, 40: 1557–1566.
34.
FreidmannPD, McCulloughD, ChinMH and SaitzR. 2000. Screening and intervention for alcohol problems: A national survey of primary care physicians and psychiatrists. J Gen Intern Med, 15: 84–91.
35.
DeubanCJ. 1998. The impact of managed care on labor substitution in the health care workforce. Mich Acad, 30: 69–83.
36.
OckeneJK, AdamsA, HurleyTG, WheelerEV and HerbertJR. 1999. Brief physician– and nurse practitioner–delivered counseling for high risk drinkers. Arch Int Med, 159: 2198–2205.
37.
IsraelY, HollanderO, Sanchez–CraigM, BookerS, MillerV, GingrichR and RankinJG. 1996. Screening for problem drinking and counseling by the primary care physician–nurse team. Alcohol Clin Exp Res, 20: 1443–1450.
38.
ChickJ, LloydG and CrombieE. 1985. Counseling problem drinkers in medical wards: A control study. BMJ, 290: 965–967.
39.
KahanM, WilsonL and BeckerL. 1995. Effectiveness of physician–based interventions with problem drinkers: A review. Can Med Assoc J, 152: 851–859.
40.
FlemingMF, BarryKL, ManwellLB, JohnsonK and LondonR. 1997. Brief physician advice for problem drinkers: A randomized controlled trial in community based primary care practices. JAMA, 277: 1039–1045.
41.
WorldHealth and Organization Study Group. 1996. A cross–national trial of brief interventions with heavy drinkers. Am J Public Health, 86: 948–955.
42.
WallaceP, CutlerS and HainesA. 1988. Randomized controlled trial of general practitioner intervention in patients with excessive alcohol consumption. BMJ, 297: 663–668.
National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism. 1994. The Primary Care Setting Recognition and Care of Patients With Alcohol Problems, 18Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.
45.
ThorpJM. 1994. The obstetrician/gynecologist. Alcohol Health Res World, 18: 117–126.
46.
AdgerH and WernerMJ. 1994. The pediatrician. Alcohol Health Res World, 18: 121–126.
47.
TownesPN and HarkleyAL. 1994. Alcohol screening practices of primary care physician in eastern North Carolina. Alcohol, 11: 489–492.
48.
AjzenI. 1991. The theory of planned behavior. Organ Behav Hum Decis Process, 50: 179–211.
49.
AjzenI and MaddenTJ. 1986. Prediction of goal–directed behavior: Attitudes, intentions and perceived behavioral control. J Exp Soc Psychol, 22: 453–474.
50.
DavisJA. 1985. The Logic of Causal Order, Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
51.
WarburgMM, ClearyPD, RohmanM, BarnesHN, AronsonM and DelbancoTL. 1987. Residents’ attitudes, knowledge, and behavior regarding diagnosis and treatment of alcoholism. Journal of Medical Education, 62: 497–503.
52.
GellerG, LevineDM, MamonJA, MooreRD, BoneLR and StokesEJ. 1989. Knowledge, attitudes, and reported practices of medical students and house staff regarding the diagnosis and treatment of alcoholism. JAMA, 261: 3115–3120.
53.
EbrahimSH, LumanET, FloydRL, MurphyCC, BennettEM and BoyleCA. 1998. Alcohol consumption by pregnant women in the United States during 1988–1995. Obstet Gynecol, 92: 187–192.
54.
ChangG. 2001. Alcohol–screening instruments for pregnant women. Alcohol Health Res World, 25: 204–209.
55.
SteinMD and CyrMG. 1997. “Women and substance abuse”. In The Medical Climes of North America, Edited by: SametJH, SteinMD and O'ConnorPG. Vol. 81, 979–998. Philadelphia: Saunders.
56.
DawsonNV, DadheechG, SperoffT, SmithRL and SchubertDSP. 1992. The effect of patient gender on the prevalence and recognition of alcoholism on a general medicine inpatient service. J Gen Intern Med, 7: 38–45.
57.
CryMG and MoultonAW. 1993. The physician's role in prevention, detection, and treatment of alcohol abuse in women. Psychiatr Ann, 23: 454–462.
58.
BradleyKA, BadrinathS, BushK, Boyd–WickizerJ and AnawaltB. 1998. Medical risks for women who drink alcohol. J Gen Intern Med, 13: 627–639.
59.
National Institutes of Health, National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism. 1995. The Physicians’ Guide to Helping Patients With Alcohol Problems, Rockville, MD: The Institute. NIH Pub No. 95–3769
60.
National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism. 2002. Alcohol Alert No. 56: Screening for Alcohol Problems—An Update, Rockville, MD: The Institute.
61.
RussellM. 1994. New assessment tools for risk drinking during pregnancy. Alcohol Health Res World, 18: 55–61.
62.
AdgerH, MacdonaldDI and WengerS. 1999. Core competencies for involvement of health care providers in the care of children and adolescents in families affected by substance abuse. Pediatrics, 103: 1083–1084.
63.
SchuydowerM, FullerPG, HeymanRB, JacobsEA, PruittAW, SuttonJM and TanenbeinM. 1993. Role of the pediatrician in prevention and management of substance abuse. Pediatrics, 91: 1010–1013.
64.
FarrowJA and DeisherRA. 1986. A practical guide to the office assessment of substance abuse. Pediatr Ann, 15: 675–684.
65.
DavisDA, ThomsonMA, OxmanAD and HaynesRB. 1992. Evidence for the effectiveness of CME, A review of 50 randomized controlled trials. JAMA, 268: 1111–1117.
66.
OxmanAD, ThomsonMA, DavisDA and HaynesRB. 1995. No magic bullets: A systematic review of 102 trials of interventions to improve professional practice. Can Med Assoc J, 153: 1423–1431.
67.
O'ConnorPG. 1994. The general internist. Alcohol Health Res World, 18: 110–116.
68.
1993. Standards of Practice, Washington, DC: American Academy of Nurse Practitioners.
69.
BaborTF and Higgins–BiddleJC. 2000. Alcohol screening and brief intervention: Dissemination strategies for medical practice and public health. Addiction, 95: 677–686.
70.
SametJH, FreidmanP and SaitzR. 2001. Benefits of linking primary medical care and substance abuse services: Patient, provider, and societal perspectives. Arch of Intern Med, 161: 85–91.
